Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dangerous dogs

239 replies

Poppyseed14 · 19/07/2022 17:36

My neighbours' cat was killed this week by two dogs outside our local shop. They were on a lead but being held by the owner's partner who wasn't able to control them. Think American Bully XL types. They take part in those training sessions where they are trained to attack the guy in the padded suit. Not a banned breed in the UK though larger and stronger than a pitbull. A few days ago an adult in Rotherham was killed by the same breed and her partner sustained life threatening injuries trying to get the dog off her. That was their family pet. I know it's all to do with the owners more so than the dogs themselves but I cannot get these awful situations out of my head. The death of the cat has shaken the local community as he was a well known and very much loved local character but it could so easily have been a child instead. And the owners will continue to endanger people and pets. No AIBU just venting really. Feeling so sad for my neighbours, they are understandably devastated.

OP posts:
Maves · 19/07/2022 23:36

Was saying this the other day that lbreed need banning. Think that's like the 4th death in the unkind a year by xl ab when there's that many by a single beeed you start to think mmmmm is it really the owners?
I don't know why any one would have one they aren't even nice to look at.
I have a bull breed before I'm called a hater but the breed I own has never lkilled a person.

WeeHaggisFace · 19/07/2022 23:32

I am trying to get a mental imagine here... if you have a big dog on a lead, and it manages to grab a cat... then what can you do? Pulling the lead is just pulling the dog and cat.
Only an idiot would suggest trying to pull the cat from a dog's jaws.

If they are collared/slip you would pull up rather than back.

Farmmum77 · 19/07/2022 23:15

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 18:24

You can't compare an attack on a cat with an attack on a child. I wish people would stop trying to say that dogs with prey drives are a danger to people.

As sad as it is that this cat was killed, dogs are predatory animals and will chase small furry things - it's their nature. It doesn't mean these dogs are bad or aggressive, or that they're going to go on and kill or hurt a person.

So that makes it ok?!

Feelfreetocallme · 19/07/2022 23:13

riesenrad · 19/07/2022 20:41

I wish people would stop trying to say that dogs with prey drives are a danger to people

Why not? They are. Lets never let the facts get in the way of delusion, hey?

I think people are missing the point here.
A dog that is not controlled effectively and is therefore able to act on its prey drive is a risk to children because the owners just aren’t responsible. All dogs are potentially dangerous to children and people if they don’t have responsible owners!

ABBAsnumberonefan · 19/07/2022 23:13

Of course it’s terribly sad that that happened but I agree with previous posters, the cat might have just gotten too close and at that point what can the person holding the dog do? At that point it’s too late.

I’ve never had a cat but I think rules around letting them roam so freely comes with risks and disadvantages for others too. They terrorise birds and small animals, send neighbourhood dogs crazy when they jump through gardens, one cat I know has such bad fleas they keep infecting other cats when they visit gardens 🤢 Their shit is toxic to dogs and can kill them, carries loads of horrid bacteria but Ofc it doesn’t get picked up by their owners. Imagine a small dog roaming about like that 🤔

Poppyseed14 · 19/07/2022 23:12

XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 23:03

I am trying to get a mental imagine here... if you have a big dog on a lead, and it manages to grab a cat... then what can you do? Pulling the lead is just pulling the dog and cat.
Only an idiot would suggest trying to pull the cat from a dog's jaws.

I was googling this earlier and a couple of videos on YouTube were suggesting to effectively temporarily 'choke' the dog to make it let go. They were showing an extra lead that they presumably would take with them to slip round the dog's neck and this would supposedly make the dog release in seconds. Disclaimer - I saw it on YouTube, I'm not saying I necessarily agree or disagree but just that it's a method that some suggest.

OP posts:
Discovereads · 19/07/2022 23:11

Dogs clearly find cats prey or so many wouldn’t be a danger to them.

No, that’s overly simplistic thinking, you might as well say that dogs find humans to be prey or so many (23,000 dog attacks resulting in hospitalisation in 3yrs ) wouldn’t be a danger to humans.

Danger from dogs is not always from prey drive.

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 23:06

Cherrysoup · 19/07/2022 23:00

Mine have not had the opportunity to attack cats-we have good fences-but if there was one in the garden, they would try to get it. My puppies are far from aggressive, but anything small and fluffy=prey. No idea what type of dog you have, mine are very friendly and love other dogs, regardless of size. They have a prey drive, normal, given their breed. Cats, squirrels, rabbits, birds=prey. This is my fourth go round with the same breed, all of them have chased these 4 animals. How is a dog supposed to differentiate between cats and squirrels, for example?

How is a dog supposed to differentiate between a cat and a squirrel? Are you joking? They have very good noses and the two smell wildly different. Their eyesight is also pretty decent as well. Animals are intelligent enough to know what is prey and what is another predator. For the first an attack is prey drive, for the second an attack is aggression just like when a dog attacks another dog. Don’t mistake an aggression attack for a prey drive attack.

Poppyseed14 · 19/07/2022 23:06

I'm not sure whether the dogs broke free or were still being held but I heard that the cat was sitting under a bush when they attacked him. 😔

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 23:03

WendellGeez · 19/07/2022 23:00

This is entirely the point.
We're not talking about dogs that encountered a cat while on the loose, say in a yard or garden, and the prey drive kicked in.
These dogs attacked while (presumably) being commanded not to do so by the person "in charge".
Those are dangerous dogs.

I am trying to get a mental imagine here... if you have a big dog on a lead, and it manages to grab a cat... then what can you do? Pulling the lead is just pulling the dog and cat.
Only an idiot would suggest trying to pull the cat from a dog's jaws.

EV117 · 19/07/2022 23:01

The thing that shocks me is that these dogs were on lead while the owner couldn't control them. Not sure if OP means they broke free from the owner's grasp of the lead or if they killed the cat while still being held on the lead.

Probably the latter. I’ve had my dog on a lead and a cat has not moved out the way, or they stand nearby staring at us as we walk past. I’m not a great understander of cats, but I get the impression they know what a lead is and that the dog can’t in theory get to them. My dog is a bit of a wimp - but he is quite big and I’m sure could kill a cat if he put his mind to it. They don’t seem to care. Some cats are timid but I’ve seen plenty that kind of saunter around unphased by potential dangers - I’ve even on one occasion done a sudden stop in my car and waited while a cat casually crossed my drive as I was coming out.
The owners should 100% have had their dogs under control. It’s terrible what happened. But I can imagine this cat may have sauntered by, thought nothing of the dogs fletching their teeth since they were on a lead and then didn’t get out of the way in time.

Middledazedted · 19/07/2022 23:00

Dogs clearly find cats prey or so many wouldn’t be a danger to them. Chasing a cat makes a dog no more likely to chase a child. I can’t think of a dog I have owned that wouldn’t have killed a cat given half the chance. My dogs lived with a cat and small furies but that made no difference to their out of house prey drive and being socialised not to chase or eat our cats and furries wasn’t what made them safe around children.

Cherrysoup · 19/07/2022 23:00

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 22:38

No cats are not the natural prey of dogs. No where in nature do dog species hunt cat species- ie you don’t see hyenas attacking cheetahs, or wolves hunting mountain lions. They are both predators of the same prey. The reason they do not get along unless socialised to get along, is because they are predators competing over the same prey. So if a dog attacks a cat, it is due to aggression not prey drive.

Mine have not had the opportunity to attack cats-we have good fences-but if there was one in the garden, they would try to get it. My puppies are far from aggressive, but anything small and fluffy=prey. No idea what type of dog you have, mine are very friendly and love other dogs, regardless of size. They have a prey drive, normal, given their breed. Cats, squirrels, rabbits, birds=prey. This is my fourth go round with the same breed, all of them have chased these 4 animals. How is a dog supposed to differentiate between cats and squirrels, for example?

WendellGeez · 19/07/2022 23:00

GrazingSheep · 19/07/2022 18:51

The OP says they were on leads but the person holding the leads wasn’t able to control them. Another twat. 😡
I really hope the police take action,

This is entirely the point.
We're not talking about dogs that encountered a cat while on the loose, say in a yard or garden, and the prey drive kicked in.
These dogs attacked while (presumably) being commanded not to do so by the person "in charge".
Those are dangerous dogs.

Poppyseed14 · 19/07/2022 22:59

@CaptainThe95thRifles just to give you an idea of the size and strength of these dogs, I saw on their insta that one of them is 8 stone. Even if the other one is a wee bit smaller you are probably still talking maybe 14-15 stone combined. That's a lot of dog. I wouldn't like to try to hold even one of them let alone both.

OP posts:
Feelfreetocallme · 19/07/2022 22:58

stillherenow · 19/07/2022 22:44

@Feelfreetocallme sighthounds generally don't see other dogs as prey. Mine would never go off lead as I've not had him long so he's been raced recently , but I've walked in a big group with lots of running small fluffy dogs and he's not given them a second look.

A cat in a park would probably get chased. But I think most dogs would do that !

Your dog shouldn’t be chasing anything other than it’s toy or another dog that’s it’s playing with. Other animals are not toys.

Why are people so reluctant to control their animals? I don’t understand it. You have a predatory animal bred to kill other animals. Put it on a lead. It’s not hard.

It’s the law to keep them under control. What is it people don’t get about that?

Cherrysoup · 19/07/2022 22:55

XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 22:35

I have seen a lot of bully types with cropped ears. I thought cropping ears was illegal here?
And before anyone can get in with the dog might have been a rescue from abroad.. I have seen plenty of bully puppies with cropped ears too.

Sadly common amongst back street breeders. A breeder was fined massively recently for cropping puppies, diy job, probably no anaesthetic.

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 22:54

XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 22:46

Sighthounds are bred specifically for going after small furry animals. Be that for hunting, or for chasing as part of racing.
It has been bred and trained into them for as long as the breed as been in existence.
Terrier dogs have also been bred and trained to go after small furry animals.

It does not mean they pose a danger to children!

If we switch this to humans... is a soldier, who is trained to kill, a danger to children too?

But not cats. Dogs can tell “small furry animals” apart you know. These dog breeds have never been bred by humans to hunt or chase domestic cats. In fact, humans have bred these dogs to not chase or attack cats (as cats were also part of most human households since the Neolithic). It would make no sense for humans to breed one domesticated animal to attack another domesticated animal when humans wanted or needed both of them living with them—both dog and cat around for different functions.

This is precisely why a dog attacking a cat is a red flag for a dangerous dog and a risk to children. Because by doing so it is going against nature as cats are not the natural prey of dogs and against their human breeding over thousands of years. It is an act of aggression.

ScabbersChin · 19/07/2022 22:51

stillherenow · 19/07/2022 22:44

@Feelfreetocallme sighthounds generally don't see other dogs as prey. Mine would never go off lead as I've not had him long so he's been raced recently , but I've walked in a big group with lots of running small fluffy dogs and he's not given them a second look.

A cat in a park would probably get chased. But I think most dogs would do that !

You really need to look into what is called predatory drift. Please do this before you let your sighthound run with smaller dogs.

XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 22:47

Feelfreetocallme · 19/07/2022 22:40

What? What if she saw a cat in the park? Or a small dog that looked like prey to her?

She is not interested in either... just ones in her own territory.
She rips around the park playing with the small dogs we meet in the park.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 19/07/2022 22:46

coffeecupsandfairylights · 19/07/2022 20:43

Actually, I didn't suggest the greyhound could be trained - a greyhound that chases and kills a cat may well not be trainable with cats in future. So please be more careful when reading posts, because you're accusing me of something I literally did not say or imply.

Fair enough, I misunderstood you.

I said that these dogs are dangerous in the way that a loose greyhound isn't - there are appropriate mitigations to control a greyhound - a second leashing arrangement, possibly coupled with a muzzle.

So why can't you use the same mitigations with an XL bully?

The bullies would require extensive training, which may or may not be possible, depending on owner and dogs, because their probably isn't solvable with a bit more kit.

Why not?

As I said in a previous post, any out of control dog is dangerous - whether it bites or not. Putting a muzzle on those bullies will not prevent them dragging their owner into traffic, or causing harm in other, similar ways.

But just because a dog is strong enough to pull their owner into traffic, doesn't mean it's automatically a danger. I mean, any big dog is capable of pulling their owner over or pulling the lead out of their owners hands - greyhounds included. Hell, my beagle has pulled me over chasing a rabbit before and he's only 18kg.

I suppose I just don't understand how XL bully that's muzzled, leashed and wearing appropriate gear is anymore dangerous than a greyhound that's muzzled, leashed and wearing appropriate gear?

Because, and I thought this was obvious, all my comments about the hypothetical greyhound situation involve the scenario where an otherwise under control greyhound slips its lead and kills a cat. This was the scenario outlined originally, which I responded to. It was not about a greyhound that is capable of pulling its owner over, as was the case in the OP's scenario with the bullies. In that instance, yes, the greyhound would also still be dangerous.

Obviously the mitigations for a greyhound that slips its lead are not appropriate for an XL bully that can pull its owner over. A second lead / harness would likely be completely useless for the bully, which remained on a single lead but out of control, but useful for the greyhound, which was only out of control because it slipped the lead. A muzzle alone is not sufficient in this instance either - a large dog can cause injury without biting. That is precisely why I said that there are no sufficient mitigations for the bully situation (unless you include electric collars or similar - I don't).

As I didn't make any comment about greyhounds that could pull their owner over, this is technically irrelevant, but since you bring it up, I know from experience I can hold a greyhound. I can't speak for you, or for anyone else, but it's something of which I have a lot of personal experience. Granted, not if it was on a long line and allowed to get up speed, but obviously you'd be idiotic to allow a dog to do that, in these circumstances, rather than walk it on short leash, sensibly. I don't know if I could hold a dog like those in the OP's situation, but since their owner could not control them, those dogs remain dangerous while being handled by that person, which was my original point.

I'm not going to continue to discuss this with you because you're now changing the hypothetical situation to misconstrue my comments and support your own rhetoric. You'll probably try to do the same to this post, but I presume you're just being obtuse.

XenoBitch · 19/07/2022 22:46

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 22:38

No cats are not the natural prey of dogs. No where in nature do dog species hunt cat species- ie you don’t see hyenas attacking cheetahs, or wolves hunting mountain lions. They are both predators of the same prey. The reason they do not get along unless socialised to get along, is because they are predators competing over the same prey. So if a dog attacks a cat, it is due to aggression not prey drive.

Sighthounds are bred specifically for going after small furry animals. Be that for hunting, or for chasing as part of racing.
It has been bred and trained into them for as long as the breed as been in existence.
Terrier dogs have also been bred and trained to go after small furry animals.

It does not mean they pose a danger to children!

If we switch this to humans... is a soldier, who is trained to kill, a danger to children too?

stillherenow · 19/07/2022 22:44

@Feelfreetocallme sighthounds generally don't see other dogs as prey. Mine would never go off lead as I've not had him long so he's been raced recently , but I've walked in a big group with lots of running small fluffy dogs and he's not given them a second look.

A cat in a park would probably get chased. But I think most dogs would do that !

Discovereads · 19/07/2022 22:42

Cherrysoup · 19/07/2022 22:31

Please don’t interpret my posts. I meant what I wrote.

Well so much for giving you the benefit of the doubt. You were grossly mistaken then. Many dogs do attack humans and it rarely makes the news- 23,000 hospitalisations from dog attacks in 3yrs is not “very very few”

stillherenow · 19/07/2022 22:41

@Discovereads cats are most definitely prey for my dog ! He's extremely submissive to other dogs he meets and new people (to an extreme).

Swipe left for the next trending thread