Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you be a SAHM in my position?

235 replies

ShouldibeSAHM · 19/07/2022 17:01

I am married and pregnant, living in the US.

We rent here and both work but have a home in the UK that he bought before we met, I’m not on the deeds and only contributed to bills when I lived there. I have decent savings but not a great pension (can’t contribute to UK pension much while I’m here anyway).

The Mat leave at my company is 12 weeks, majority unpaid. I really don’t think I will want to go back to work after 12 weeks (or less, unless I work right up until giving birth). I know it’s common place here and some people’s preference but I don’t want my child in nursery or with a nanny so young.

We can afford for me to be a SAHM but I worry about how it will look on my CV and my personal financial security and how hard it will be to get back into work. He has a lot of investments, savings etc from before we met. He always calls it our money, we have a joint account and I buy whatever I want within reason even though he earns a lot more.

What would you do in my position?

OP posts:
Topgub · 19/07/2022 21:43

@shesoff

Really?

I'm not jealous of sahms. I dint want to be one. I'm not a man.

I dont think the role of being a sah mum specifically has any value over any other kind of parenting

I'm not a worse parent than a sahm because I (sometimes) spend less time with my children

They're not missing out on anything

Its not hard to follow

shesoff · 19/07/2022 21:37

Sorry, that was to TopGub.

shesoff · 19/07/2022 21:36

I'm not following any of that. Can you explain the point of what you're getting at?

GeekyThings · 19/07/2022 21:36

How are you of more value to baby or child than a nanny or childcare provider? If you're not providing any more in terms of parenting than a working parent? Because the only difference between a SAHP anda working parent, as you've said yourself, is the time spent with them; and nannies and childminders do exactly the same thing.

Topgub · 19/07/2022 21:33

@shesoff

Thats quite the twist

That wasn't the question I asked.

I said sahms aren't achieving any parenting I'm not as a wp

You immediately responded with thei spend longer with their kids!!

Not, they don't put kids in child care!

You can not be a sahm and not use childcare. So that's not of value to me.

I also don't see anything wrong with using childcare so avoiding it again, not of value.

We just didn't need it. Had we needed it, we would have used it, no issue

shesoff · 19/07/2022 21:29

"So do you think sahms are better parents then? Because they spend longer with their kids?"

I didn't say that. Interesting you less to the defensive though.

Patents are parents whether they work or not. Each to their own.

But a mum (or dad) is of more 'value' to a child then a nanny or childminder, yes. That is why I'm a SAHM.

If, as you say, you and your DH shared the early years between you (with no paid childcare) then presumably you did that because you thought you were of 'more value' to your kids then a childminder or nanny. So it seems you do value SAHP.

Topgub · 19/07/2022 21:29

Also the op was sahm or not

I'm interested in the not.

Typical of a sahm to think anyone who doesn't view being a sahm as the ideal is either jealous (as if, couldn't think of anything worse] or a (shock horror) man

🤣🤣

Topgub · 19/07/2022 21:24

@shesoff

Lol.

Nice avoidance

Gender politics are fascinating.

Can you answer my questions?

shesoff · 19/07/2022 21:22

TopGub - for someone who claims to have convinced herself that SAHMs have 'no value', you don't half spend a lot of time obsessing about them.

It's all a bit 'the lady protests too much' don't you think?

If I thought something had 'no value', the last place you would find me would be on a thread about it. I'd be bored to the back teeth discussing something I thought had 'no value.'

Topgub · 19/07/2022 21:17

@shesoff and @tiggergoesbounce

So do you think sahms are better parents then? Because they spend longer with their kids?

Whats theagic number of hours required to achieve the difference?

What about kids in school? Are parents of school age kids worse parents than sahms of preschoolers kids?

What about shift workers?

tiggergoesbounce · 19/07/2022 21:12

Sahms aren't doing any parenting I'm not.

They are giving/spending more of their time with their child.

shesoff · 19/07/2022 21:10

Sahms aren't doing any parenting I'm not."

Yes that's why people pay nannies £50k per year or whatever they pay childminders. To do nothing. Because nothing happens while mums are at work. Babies and children go into suspended animation in this 'no value' time.

Topgub · 19/07/2022 21:06

@shesoff

No

Lol.

What an odd question

Topgub · 19/07/2022 21:05

@Veebees26

And no, I absolutely don't agree that the beauty of feminsm is women being able to choose inequality

shesoff · 19/07/2022 21:05

Arr you a man who wants to be a SAHD TopGub?

Topgub · 19/07/2022 21:04

@shesoff

The role.

Sahms aren't doing any parenting I'm not.

My kids aren't missing out on anything because they didn't have a sahm.

Topgub · 19/07/2022 21:03

@Veebees26

You actually haven't answered the question though

You're advising women on this thread that they can make money later and shouldn't risk missing out on their children.

You haven't answered if you advised your oh the same

Just that he didn't get the option because you wanted it.

Veebees26 · 19/07/2022 21:00

Topgub · 19/07/2022 20:50

@Veebees26

The advice that you can go back to making money at any point/can't replace the time with your children

I've addressed your question above, and I'm sure you'll agree that the beauty of equality and feminism is that as women we are free to make our own choices based on what we want (or don't want) to do.

I didn't stay off for an extended period with our child because society told me I should or because my partner didn't want to, I did it because I wanted to. If I hadn't wanted to then we would've done SPL.

shesoff · 19/07/2022 21:00

"Not seeing value in the role is not looking down on sahms"

So what would you call it then?

If you see no value in SAHMs, presumably you see no value in yourself (or your DH) when either you spend time with your kids?

Might as well just have any old person "doing childcare" 24/7 eh? No value in actual parents spending time with their kids.

GeekyThings · 19/07/2022 20:58

It's not worse by very much according to OECD stats - USA is one of the worst, at around 17%, but Finland is also 17%, and many European countries are between 12% to 16%. So not a huge difference.

The article I posted also highlights research showing it wasn't down to the length of time, as Denmark allows a year off paid leave, but they have the same gender pay gap as the USA. So it isn't the length of time, it's actually having children that is a cause of the gender pay gap.

tiggergoesbounce · 19/07/2022 20:57

You need to ensure you are as protected as you can be. But yes in your situation i would be the SAHP.

Yes men should be allowed to share/take the same amount leave as a woman does, but they cant and womens rights should not be reduced until that catches up.

A woman is more productive when she is fullfilling what she wants, she is a better mum if shes a SAHM because she wants to be and she would be a better employee being back at work, if thats what she wants to do.
She should not be belittled into deciding either.

Both are valid choices, and all the other nonsense on here is frankly ridiculous.

Do what is best for you and your family providing its an informed choice.

Yes in your situation i would opt for a year out and see how you feel after then, it really isnt that long in career terms but is a great amount of time to be with your baby (if you want to of course)

Topgub · 19/07/2022 20:50

@Veebees26

The advice that you can go back to making money at any point/can't replace the time with your children

Topgub · 19/07/2022 20:48

@Marynotsocontrary

Most women have stopped bf by 6 weeks.

I havent suggested 12 weeks as the ideal and a pp definitely said women should be with their children for the early years, which is what I responded to.

Not seeing value in the role is not looking down on sahms. And I've never said they are letting other women down

@SW1amp

See, told you you weren't actually interested

RockandRollsuicide · 19/07/2022 20:48

John Oliver did an "exposé" on maternity leave and how brutal it was on new mum's many having to work sitting on rings and pump

Veebees26 · 19/07/2022 20:47

Topgub · 19/07/2022 20:36

@Veebees26

Did you give your oh that advice?

Well it depends which part you're referring to, we discussed the option of shared parental leave but when it came down to it I wanted to be at home with our son, no shame in it.

I have a great career and the luxury of knowing it wouldn't suffer for my being away for an extended period so I went for it. I didn't want to regret going back so decided to take as long as possible.

I'm a staunch feminist as it happens, in life and especially in parenting but whichever side of the argument you're on you simply cannot argue against the fact that in the vast majority of cases the birth parent has a different type of bond with their child (maybe this changes as they become older but certainly the case for young babies) so they are more likely to be the one staying off work the baby for longer.

OP asked for opinions, I gave her mine, no reason to come at me like I'm a 50s housewife.