Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

As a parent, would you be happy with this? And teachers?

160 replies

ThrallsWife · 19/07/2022 16:49

article

So some schools in South London are now encouraged to not exclude any students "unless they pose risk to another child". In my nearly 2 decades of teaching , I have had my family threatened, racist remarks made against me, chairs thrown at me, as well as books and various other bits.

Students have had to suffer through lessons dominated by the moods of one or two children, made to sit through countless lessons where learning was impossible because the same regular students would disrupt. Sometimes, not a single student was being threatened, but a whole class had to be evacuated to protect them from the rages of others.

Do we really hold the rights of the few above the rights of the many?

"Teachers will be encouraged to try to understand the reason for bad behaviour by using a "trauma-informed" response and are being told not to take misbehaviour at "face value"."

That is a weak response by any school I've ever worked in. Sometimes the answer is just bad parenting, not trauma. And those who have had severe trauma respond much better to talking to a professional with mental health training, which many teachers don't have enough of - nor the time to invest that would be necessary.

It would stop me from ever working in any of those schools, but I fear that this is the road we will all be forced down sooner or later...

OP posts:
DockOTheBay · 19/07/2022 19:18

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 19/07/2022 18:18

This. I can’t wait to start at one of these schools and learn how to make that system work. I want to equip myself with more of the skills to de escalate behaviour and manage my classroom effectively. In the nicest way, if you don’t like it or don’t want to learn the soft skills and approaches for that environment, OP, instead of denigrating this approach, work elsewhere. There are currently hundreds of vacancies in London, your perfect school is out there!

Good luck to you!

LadyVic · 19/07/2022 19:17

Having had my son hurt physically (now scarred, sadly) by a student who has ever been diagnosed with a condition, but who's violent rages has hurt many students and teachers I have to say this concerns me.

Not all children with violent rages have a condition.
Not all children with a condition react violently
Some children have already had trauma of violence at home and now have to see it everyday at school
Many teachers have had to experience violence before and it should not happen at school. NHS staff are protected. Why not teachers.

This comes down to the same old problem. Teaching in the same way that has been done for decades, without a thought for how the world has changed.
Trying to make every child behave like every other child.
The whole system needs a change.

AntlerRose · 19/07/2022 19:15

@ThrallsWife Whilst i dont want my child shoved or sworn at, was there ever a time when people were permanently excluded for this sort of thing.

CallOnMe · 19/07/2022 19:14

I think exclusion should be the absolute last resort as some kids enjoy having time off school and many have awful homes and parents and keeping them in that environment for longer than necessary is going to make their behaviour worse.

However yet again the good kids that just keep their heads down and behave are going to suffer even further.

I used to work in mainstream and now work in an ARB with students with SEND and SEMH and it has really opened my eyes to why some of these mainstream kids behave as they do and it is more often or not because of what’s going on at home or an undiagnosed SEND.

But even in my ARB we exclude them if they are a risk to other students and there’s always a relief in the air when a particular couple aren’t there and then you feel the worry and tension when they come back, which is so unfair to the rest of the group.

UWhatNow · 19/07/2022 19:12

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Mumofsend · 19/07/2022 19:08

I've been on the other side of this.

My DD was horrendous her first few years of school. She was never once excluded. School took their time. She went through most of one year mainly outside of the classroom to limit risk and introduced back into class in baby steps. Lots of meetings with me, lots of discussion and working together.

The focus was upon us as adults understanding the issues so they could be pre-empted as well as her accepting school as a safe place via a trauma aware response.

She was not allowed to hurt others, we had maybe 4 blips in 3 years. When she did something that put herself or others at risk she was removed back out of class to help us understand why and a slow reintegration. We basically had to take full responsibility to regulate her and over the past few months we are starting to teach her the tools she needs to start to do so herself.

If a child can't recognise that funny feeling in their tummy is anxiety we can't expect them to respond correctly to it.

The problem is it takes time and patience and a lot of schools don't seem to want to invest either.

If more children at a young age had the time put in during the first few years of school rather than a cycle of exclusions, shaming and not being properly helped to learn to regulate you end up with very big kids with the same issues.

I dont think exclusions are often the answer.

LondonJax · 19/07/2022 19:07

@PeekabooAtTheZoo don't forget though, that the 'perfect school' for the kids who want to learn is also out there. So whilst you're doing all the soft skills, make sure kids like mine, who don't disrupt, who want to learn are giving the chance to do so in peace and safety. Otherwise the only kids you will have in class will be those who you're being trained to deal with. The others will have gone to the schools that value them.

ThrallsWife · 19/07/2022 18:59

Elisheva · 19/07/2022 18:54

My ds is 15, just going into year 11. He has ASD and is a sweet, kind boy. He has to daily endure the behaviour of the other children in his class disrupting his lessons to the point that he cannot learn.
They are loud, rude to the teachers, walk in and out of the lessons.
They swear at him, shove him around, steal his lunchbox, rip up his work, spray him with cleaning spray, spray deodorant in his face. All this is considered ‘low level’. He has been in the toilet with other students throwing scissors over the top of the cubicle, trying to unlock the door and taking photos - interestingly the photos got a much bigger reaction than the scissors. The class have not managed to cover the curriculum this year, and he is way behind where he should be.
Why do his needs come so far behind those of the other students?

And this is one of the issues. What is considered "a risk to other children" is laughable compared to what actual risk is.

It also doesn't teach these children how to deal with real life, where so much of their background doesn't matter and they will live a life of petty crime until it either escalates or their get chucked into prison. And then what?

Or should we all agree that our own children should see it as normal being sworn at/ having others push in line/ walk through our gardens/ steal our bags/ punch in a window and the many other things that barely raise an eyebrow anymore these days in schools?

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 19/07/2022 18:58

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 19/07/2022 18:18

This. I can’t wait to start at one of these schools and learn how to make that system work. I want to equip myself with more of the skills to de escalate behaviour and manage my classroom effectively. In the nicest way, if you don’t like it or don’t want to learn the soft skills and approaches for that environment, OP, instead of denigrating this approach, work elsewhere. There are currently hundreds of vacancies in London, your perfect school is out there!

Your naivety is shining through.

noblegiraffe · 19/07/2022 18:57

Ask the No Exclusions lot whether they would support the exclusion of a child who had raped another pupil and you'll see how little a shit they give for any victims of poor behaviour.

Elisheva · 19/07/2022 18:54

My ds is 15, just going into year 11. He has ASD and is a sweet, kind boy. He has to daily endure the behaviour of the other children in his class disrupting his lessons to the point that he cannot learn.
They are loud, rude to the teachers, walk in and out of the lessons.
They swear at him, shove him around, steal his lunchbox, rip up his work, spray him with cleaning spray, spray deodorant in his face. All this is considered ‘low level’. He has been in the toilet with other students throwing scissors over the top of the cubicle, trying to unlock the door and taking photos - interestingly the photos got a much bigger reaction than the scissors. The class have not managed to cover the curriculum this year, and he is way behind where he should be.
Why do his needs come so far behind those of the other students?

slowquickstep · 19/07/2022 18:52

Every child has the right to an education and that includes those who don't have physical and or mental health issues , or a bad home life. A solution needs to be found but allowing disruptive pupils to ruin other children's education is obviously not working and neither is it fair.

Cherrysoup · 19/07/2022 18:52

Every child is entitled to an education, but I am very sympathetic to the issue the OP describes and as a teacher, I’ve seen it in action time and time again. 2 students dominate some of their lessons and if the teacher isn’t amazing at classroom management, they can destroy multiple classes. It is really unfair on the rest of the students, particularly when it persists.

luxxlisbon · 19/07/2022 18:50

The thing is, what do exclusions achieve? If you are writing off lots of behavioural problems as “bad parenting” then what part of a school expulsions actually address that or supports the child?

5zeds · 19/07/2022 18:47

I think you’re coming at this from the wrong end of the problem. Pour money and resources into special schools. Make them fantastic happy places with enviable outcomes. Then make enough of them to accommodate ALL the children with additional needs giving them a great education. Those who can’t access the special schools can be educated for much less money/resources and achieve at least what their peers with Sen do if they work hard and apply themselves.

AntlerRose · 19/07/2022 18:44

@MsRead I completley agree the support services around a school are totally inadequete and a teacher cant be an ot, salt, ep, clinical psychologist.

But I think the long term cost of not providing those services is greater as the children will end up requiring support for life that could have been avoided and increasingly expensive interventions.

MsRead · 19/07/2022 18:36

Fully prepared for withering comments but… 20 years experience, 8 as SMT in a variety of state secondaries

How many more hats do teachers need to wear? I am a social worker ( safeguarding, ensuring children have clean uniform, are fed, regularly report concerns etc), I am supposed to have a magic wand to stop bullying, issues that occur outside school, at home, under parental jurisdiction but are dragged into school and becomes a ‘school’ problem, I am supposed to be able to speed up diagnosis of all types of emotional, behavioural distress in teenagers, whilst ensuring that students get exactly what they need while waiting 8 months for a diagnosis that doesn’t contain many answers even when it does arrive. The list is exhaustive and at the bottom of the pile, the role of teacher is forgotten.

Teachers mainly train to teach because they have an active interest in helping, supporting and teaching young people but increasingly they are in charge of every aspect of a child’s development and issues. Schools need to draw the line, teachers are leaving due to abuse ( from both kids and parents) and the idea that schools can contain, love, nurture and deal with every single behaviour, issue, special need, special parental request is unrealistic.

Many students are being robbed of their education, due to schools/ teachers being expected to deal with a vast spectrum of issues that schools have no business dealing with, and teaching suffers. Unless people are happy to pay a lot more tax to have psychologists, drug/ addiction services, mental health teams, specialists dealing in trauma, teachers cannot deal with this, it’s not what we trained for. Yes, some kids with SEND will and do miss out, but teachers cannot, should not have to deal with all issues that kids bring to school with them. I’ve seen teachers being ‘helpful’ trying to deal with issues that are not qualified to deal with and have made situations worse due to lack of knowledge/experience, they care but it’s often not enough. The answer is not to simply pack a few teachers off on a three day in service training, the complexities of child development, mental health issues are a degree subject in themselves.

Schools need to draw a line to protect staff and the majority of students, but it will not happen due to laissez faire policy and because it’s cheaper to ask schools to contain their ‘problems’. Teachers need to teach and have the appropriate specialists in schools to deal with the behaviour and extra needs.

Before all the withering comments and shouts of how special each specific child’s needs are and what schools are not doing for them, how much tax is everyone willing to pay to put the professionals around each child that will support the child and the teacher? Until there are specialists in schools a child’s education with be very dependent upon who else sits in their classroom with them, the schools will not be removing the children any time soon ( including for drug issues). The solution is not cheap, is not quick and also encompasses how we as a society are parenting our children.

We also need to address the amount of weed that is smoked by youngsters and then parents insisting the children have SEND

AntlerRose · 19/07/2022 18:35

I think some schools, perhaps due to lack of knowledge or lack of access to support, dont realise just how much they are contributing to the challenging behaviour and how much of it could be prevented with the correct support. They end up doing off the peg OT exercises, speech and language and strategies from 'tool kits' but without the thorough assessments needed to pick the right bits of the tool kit. They also arent applied as consistently and extensively as needed.

I also think they have said exclusion is ok when another child is at risk so many of your examples would still be excludeable.

ThrallsWife · 19/07/2022 18:29

Parents just like the ones you already label as bad, who FYI have already before you get the pleasure of judging them meeting them have already endured trauma levels you cannot possibly comprehend. Because you, unlike them have not only been able to choose. career, you have been afforded the privilege of pursuing it. The very system you are so angry at has failed them so monumentally that the choices you retain have been ripped from them, their families, their relationships, other siblings and yet they "cope" daily.

For one, you are assuming that none of us teachers and other school professionals have had traumatic backgrounds. Well, stuff that assumption where the sun don't shine, because I can guarentee you that you're talking out of that very behind.

I have had a childhood of being rejected by both my parents, bullyind, physical and sexual abuse throughout my childhood. I excelled despite my childhood, not because of it.

For another, you are - also wrongly - assuming that I judge all parents. I have excellent relationships with a lot of my SEND students, but, believe it or not in your bubble, bad parenting exists. I teach students who are used to going to mum or dad or grandparents who will give them whatever they want just to stay quiet and I - and many of my students - do suffer the consequences of this daily.

You also assume that we don't know the struggle of SEND parents - having fought for over 6 years so far to get one of my children the SEND help they desperately need, I know exactly where a lot of parents stand.

I am NOT talking about that.

I am talking about children with DV backgrounds being further traumatised in schools by having to witness children punch desks, walls and throw tables at best and let their aggressions out at peopple at worst.

I am talking about students with virtually no boundaries at home doing what they want in the classroom without consequences.

Yes, I am also talking about my own right to be free from abuse in my workplace, which does not even seem to be taken into consideration, as if I am not a human being.

I have been trained in MH and in SEND. I apply strategies daily. But I also see many children only for about 2 hours a week - I simply do not have the time to give them the support they need while supporting 30 others at the same time. There is a limit to my job.

Please direct your anger at the system, not me, who has concerns of how this affects others who have to suffer through this ill-thought out system.

OP posts:
DockOTheBay · 19/07/2022 18:19

titbumwillypoo · 19/07/2022 17:43

So basically you think children with disabilities such as ASD or children with terrible home lives should be excluded because of the "choices" they make? I would have thought that a teacher with 2 decades of experience should know better. You're the one who is in loco parentis, have you looked at the behaviour that you model in your classroom that contributes to the disruption?

What about the other children with disabilities and terrible home lives, who can't learn anything because of the behaviour of one individual.

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 19/07/2022 18:18

titbumwillypoo · 19/07/2022 17:43

So basically you think children with disabilities such as ASD or children with terrible home lives should be excluded because of the "choices" they make? I would have thought that a teacher with 2 decades of experience should know better. You're the one who is in loco parentis, have you looked at the behaviour that you model in your classroom that contributes to the disruption?

This. I can’t wait to start at one of these schools and learn how to make that system work. I want to equip myself with more of the skills to de escalate behaviour and manage my classroom effectively. In the nicest way, if you don’t like it or don’t want to learn the soft skills and approaches for that environment, OP, instead of denigrating this approach, work elsewhere. There are currently hundreds of vacancies in London, your perfect school is out there!

PoorMegHopkins · 19/07/2022 18:18

I don’t think anyone is saying these children don’t have needs or rights.
But when I’ve been attacked by a child I have the right to NOT have to teach that child for a few days while I work through my trauma.
Other children have the right to enjoy their education. If your daughter had been sexually assaulted by another child, you would not want her to have to face the child the next day because they have unmet needs.
It’s the funding and support that just isn’t there. It just isn’t. Until it is what do we do?

LiquidLuck · 19/07/2022 18:11

I’m not a teacher, a school governor. I understood this was potentially becoming a recommendation by the prior children’s commissioner ie. not excluding any primary school children.

Take ‘poor parenting’ and teacher aptitude to deal with behaviour out of it as that detracts from the discussion which should be child centric and is often much more complex. However, I agree it’s unreasonable some children remain in class and potentially school, for themselves and other pupils, as well as the teacher. To be clear I am not talking about SEN students.

I’ve seen the consequences of a ‘challenging’ demographic on the attainment of the whole year. I’ve also seen how often children in these situations are vulnerable and need multi/agency support well beyond the teacher. I fear it’s being pushed on schools as there is even less funding and resources at agencies that should provide that support ie. social work, ed psych etc. So the message is we can’t support/pay for those interventions so suck it up.

As an aside, I am aghast as the aggression towards teachers by the average pupil and student. Heads should be well within their rights to implement a 3 strikes and you’re out policy for ANY level of swearing or other aggression. The level of disrespect to teachers is disgusting.

For anyone feeling very vocal about this and I know there are many in MN, there is a National shortage of governors so I suggest you volunteer your time to better understand the issues and attempt to make a difference.

DoubleShotEspresso · 19/07/2022 18:09

Just a few ideas here for you....
-Incorporate proper, adequate and qualified SEN learning into all teacher training.
-FUND schools, including mainstream with adequate, proper, qualified SEND provision.
-Cease in the practice of teachers unqualified in the business of mental health, social work or parenting of making sweeping statements about a family they have likely only met in the confines of what often appears to parents as a crisis meeting.
-Provide SEN funding to facilitate consistent proper adult supervision matched to the needs clearly outlined in specialist (yes qualified ) reports, observations and recommendations.
-Stop the practice of so many SLT's , MAT'S, Mainstream settings from illegally excluding, off-rolling and intimidating SEN children and their families.
-Create provisions which include and cater towards those children currently falling under the "ghost child" umbrella. (Someting between a mainstream and a DSP/PRU/AP.
-Cease Senco's,schools, SEN Officers into wrongly and inexpertly "labelling" children as "SEMH" when they remain on the pathway for formal, medically qualified assessment. This practice is a cack-handed way of obaining short-term provision but is hugely detrimental to the child who often needs entirely different effective methods and strategies.
-Make schools accountable for failings and fraudulent use of funds.
-Make LA'S accountable for their monitoring of schools.

And finally just maybe, consider the rights of these children who though may be posing yourself and other colleagues challenges before your own. You have all benefited from the education that got you as far as teaching, perhaps consider the value of these children receiving adequate, tailored to their needs provision before not only writing them off academically, but contributing to the ill effects of exclusion and limiting the very choices that your own education has afforded you.

*I am not saying it is easy. I am not inferring your job is hideously challenging. But you are placing and directing your anger in the wrong directions.

Consider for instance the current (and doomed to be flawed following the cabinet changes) SEND consultation on the White and Green Papers. Have you taken the time to respond? Contacted your MP? Your union? Or have you perhaps thought of contacting the DFE?

Further consider the proposed (Dickensian in its' contents) Schools Bill? Parents just like the ones you already label as bad, who FYI have already before you get the pleasure of judging them meeting them have already endured trauma levels you cannot possibly comprehend. Because you, unlike them have not only been able to choose. career, you have been afforded the privilege of pursuing it. The very system you are so angry at has failed them so monumentally that the choices you retain have been ripped from them, their families, their relationships, other siblings and yet they "cope" daily. Because schools like yours simply don't. Yet when these failings are clearly identified, their "battle" really commences, as though the law is on their side, their LA often isn't..... Add to this the flavour of battle for paediatrics (it's hideous right now FYI, CAMHS (the chocolate teapot that even suicidal teens don't reach the criteria for), ASD/ADHD/PDA assessments which in some parts of the UK are currently running a 3 year waiting list, sleepless nights and the relentless emails, forms, meetings and appointments. We perhaps qualify for DLA for our children, if lucky receive £260 a month Carers- this all goes on the children and household bills as that's where the system leaves us. To obtain this absolute fortune means requiring education professionals to fill out forms outlining how challenging our children are, but we wait weeks, whilst you battle the same system from a different side of the fence to us. Yet we are grateful.

Then the audacity, the barefaced unqualified, judgemental opinions professionals like yourself freely share regarding our parenting, though you have never given us more than ten minutes of your time or even stepped into our homes. You are in receipt of 100's of emails, clearly bearing my name, but insist each time on calling me "Mum". Your tone (as in your post ) speaks loudly as "Bad Mum"..... Yet we are grateful you bothered to call at all. Because let's face it responding to our emails or calls is never a priority when it is easier to not explore a childs' needs and try to match provision towards them, it's always easier to label us "bad parents".

THIS is what is called a weak response from supposed "professionals", who in any other profession would be obliged to meet timelines and follow the law. If you genuinely consider the trauma who may have had within school is anywhere close to that of any SEN parent, I would seriously recommend you take some time to actually sit down and listen to some of them. You would be amazed I am sure.

You could consider that investing the time you have here would be identical to that of drafting an email to your MP or similar or setting up a support group within your school or LA.... Perhaps outline the racist, threatening and violent behaviours you have encountered and please o inform them whilst you're at it that many parents you deem "bad" have suffered the same relentless trauma, again from the same broken system we are all forced to share and work within.

cansu · 19/07/2022 18:03

I would not work in such a school unless they also had the staff and resources to support those children outside the class. Other kids should not have their lessons disturbed because little Johnny is standing on the table or whatever. The problem is that schools do not have the resources needed to support these kids. It is a cheap way of avoiding paying for specialist support.

Understanding a child's needs and trauma will not help when said child refuses to work and disturbs learning of self and others. We have children wandering in and out, climbing over fences, throwing chairs, screaming and kicking or hitting TAs and staff. Children with these needs are not well served in mainstream schools nor do they learn much.