Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

As a parent, would you be happy with this? And teachers?

160 replies

ThrallsWife · 19/07/2022 16:49

article

So some schools in South London are now encouraged to not exclude any students "unless they pose risk to another child". In my nearly 2 decades of teaching , I have had my family threatened, racist remarks made against me, chairs thrown at me, as well as books and various other bits.

Students have had to suffer through lessons dominated by the moods of one or two children, made to sit through countless lessons where learning was impossible because the same regular students would disrupt. Sometimes, not a single student was being threatened, but a whole class had to be evacuated to protect them from the rages of others.

Do we really hold the rights of the few above the rights of the many?

"Teachers will be encouraged to try to understand the reason for bad behaviour by using a "trauma-informed" response and are being told not to take misbehaviour at "face value"."

That is a weak response by any school I've ever worked in. Sometimes the answer is just bad parenting, not trauma. And those who have had severe trauma respond much better to talking to a professional with mental health training, which many teachers don't have enough of - nor the time to invest that would be necessary.

It would stop me from ever working in any of those schools, but I fear that this is the road we will all be forced down sooner or later...

OP posts:
Namenic · 19/07/2022 21:22

surely Exclusions to prevent violence are basic safeguarding?
Allowing a violent child in class is a danger to the other children. It is not about punishment or whether they can help it due to a condition.
It is about whether the teacher and students (including the violent student) can be kept safe. If this is not possible then the pupil should be educated in another setting.

agree with LadyVic, that NHS staff don’t have to put their own health at risk to treat a violent person. The violent patient would not be put on a ward with others (even if it was better for that patient). I think a no exclusion policy is anti-safeguarding.

rainbowmilk · 19/07/2022 21:06

Not much has changed since I went to school in the 90s. Two or three kids just terrorising entire classes, day after day after day. I was a traumatised kid with a terrible home life and my response was to freeze, to pretend it wasn’t happening, because the teachers who were supposed to protect me were getting hit or trying to diffuse the situation. It reinforced the lesson I already had learned - that adults in my life do not protect me, and cannot be relied upon.

I still have significant trauma, and I still don’t trust adults. My trauma was ignored and continues to be irrelevant as MN considers that all violence is down to SEN and that SEN takes priority. Quiet children in the classroom can’t possibly be traumatised too. They can just get on with things, as they’re posing nobody any harm or difficulty. It doesn’t matter how they turn out as adults.

The kids I’m talking about ended up assaulting a female pupil. Still didn’t get expelled, as parents made a point about it being SEN. The girl had to change schools. Presumably her trauma was irrelevant too.

YANBU OP. The answer is more funding but in lieu of that the answer isn’t to throw 29 kids under a bus on the basis of being positive about diversity.

ldontWanna · 19/07/2022 21:01

The system’s failings have been laid bare by a new report from Southwark Council’s education and business and scrutiny commission, published this month.

It reveals that children from black and ethnic minority backgrounds, those with special educational needs, and children who are eligible for free school meals, are most affected.

Nationally, permanent exclusions have risen by 71 per cent since 2012, with fixed-term exclusions also rising by nearly 54 per cent. In the 2017-18 academic year, 410,000 temporary exclusions were recorded across the country. In Southwark, exclusion rates have doubled in the same period.
Although only 0.2 per cent of children are permanently excluded in any given year, their number are disproportionately represented in the justice system, with 23 per cent of young offenders having been excluded.
And it is not just formal exclusions that are rising. Concern has also been highlighted over ‘off-rolling’ – where children are removed from the school roll and educated at home – often in the interests of the school rather than the child.
The number of children home educated in Southwark has more than doubled since 2017; from 96 to 216 aged between five to sixteen.
Advertisements
Their outcomes are particularly poor. In the 2017-18 academic year none who completed their alternative provision achieved a pass in English or maths – despite a full-time place in alternative provision costs around £24,000 per year, on average, in London.
The report outlines that Southwark Council commissions 100 places at two pupil referral unit sites – Porlock Hill and Davey Street. Shockingly, 91 per cent of children attending them receive special educational needs support.
Two academy chains are responsible for the overwhelming majority of exclusions in the borough: Ark and Harris. It has been suggested the ‘zero tolerance’ approach to behaviour is driving this trend.
The report explains Ark has been engaging with the council to analyse its exclusion rate and how this can be improved but, it notes: “Disappointingly, the Harris chain of schools did not engage with the commission’s investigation.
“Whilst we cannot identify what has driven the exceptionally high levels of exclusions in Harris Academy Peckham, we do hope that Harris schools will work closely with Southwark, and indeed with other schools to bring down rates of exclusions across all of its schools that are under-performing.”
Recommendations from the commission’s findings include a zero permanent exclusion target by 2020, a review into the disproportionate impact on ethnic minorities and children with special needs, improved alternative provision and earlier intervention at primary age, and stronger action against schools that off-roll pupils.

Basically two academy trusts have possibly racist and disablist cultures and policies, so the geniuses from the council decided to tackle it by imposing a blanket policy on everyone. Was further action and scrutiny necessary to solve the highlighted issues? Yes. Is the solution stupid,pointless,possibly detrimental to other schools and pupils? Yes. Is it the easy ,cheap option? Yes. Yes. Yes.

Smileyaxolotl1 · 19/07/2022 20:58

Bloody hell.
really glad I work in a school where exclusions are used frequently. Sometimes internal ones but often not. If a child is very rude to teachers or violent to teachers or other children a strong message needs to be sent. That message is we do not want children who cannot behave in our school.

ldontWanna · 19/07/2022 20:52
  • A 2020 report by the council found Southwark to have a higher than average exclusion rate. It also found academies would exclude more children than other schools. A separate report, also from the council, found that black students in Southwark were 1.5 times more likely to be excluded than their white counterparts.*

You missed a (quite relevant) bit from the article.

As for the policy I disagree with it, just like I disagree with any other blanket policies.

mahrezzy · 19/07/2022 20:47

DoubleShotEspresso · 19/07/2022 18:09

Just a few ideas here for you....
-Incorporate proper, adequate and qualified SEN learning into all teacher training.
-FUND schools, including mainstream with adequate, proper, qualified SEND provision.
-Cease in the practice of teachers unqualified in the business of mental health, social work or parenting of making sweeping statements about a family they have likely only met in the confines of what often appears to parents as a crisis meeting.
-Provide SEN funding to facilitate consistent proper adult supervision matched to the needs clearly outlined in specialist (yes qualified ) reports, observations and recommendations.
-Stop the practice of so many SLT's , MAT'S, Mainstream settings from illegally excluding, off-rolling and intimidating SEN children and their families.
-Create provisions which include and cater towards those children currently falling under the "ghost child" umbrella. (Someting between a mainstream and a DSP/PRU/AP.
-Cease Senco's,schools, SEN Officers into wrongly and inexpertly "labelling" children as "SEMH" when they remain on the pathway for formal, medically qualified assessment. This practice is a cack-handed way of obaining short-term provision but is hugely detrimental to the child who often needs entirely different effective methods and strategies.
-Make schools accountable for failings and fraudulent use of funds.
-Make LA'S accountable for their monitoring of schools.

And finally just maybe, consider the rights of these children who though may be posing yourself and other colleagues challenges before your own. You have all benefited from the education that got you as far as teaching, perhaps consider the value of these children receiving adequate, tailored to their needs provision before not only writing them off academically, but contributing to the ill effects of exclusion and limiting the very choices that your own education has afforded you.

*I am not saying it is easy. I am not inferring your job is hideously challenging. But you are placing and directing your anger in the wrong directions.

Consider for instance the current (and doomed to be flawed following the cabinet changes) SEND consultation on the White and Green Papers. Have you taken the time to respond? Contacted your MP? Your union? Or have you perhaps thought of contacting the DFE?

Further consider the proposed (Dickensian in its' contents) Schools Bill? Parents just like the ones you already label as bad, who FYI have already before you get the pleasure of judging them meeting them have already endured trauma levels you cannot possibly comprehend. Because you, unlike them have not only been able to choose. career, you have been afforded the privilege of pursuing it. The very system you are so angry at has failed them so monumentally that the choices you retain have been ripped from them, their families, their relationships, other siblings and yet they "cope" daily. Because schools like yours simply don't. Yet when these failings are clearly identified, their "battle" really commences, as though the law is on their side, their LA often isn't..... Add to this the flavour of battle for paediatrics (it's hideous right now FYI, CAMHS (the chocolate teapot that even suicidal teens don't reach the criteria for), ASD/ADHD/PDA assessments which in some parts of the UK are currently running a 3 year waiting list, sleepless nights and the relentless emails, forms, meetings and appointments. We perhaps qualify for DLA for our children, if lucky receive £260 a month Carers- this all goes on the children and household bills as that's where the system leaves us. To obtain this absolute fortune means requiring education professionals to fill out forms outlining how challenging our children are, but we wait weeks, whilst you battle the same system from a different side of the fence to us. Yet we are grateful.

Then the audacity, the barefaced unqualified, judgemental opinions professionals like yourself freely share regarding our parenting, though you have never given us more than ten minutes of your time or even stepped into our homes. You are in receipt of 100's of emails, clearly bearing my name, but insist each time on calling me "Mum". Your tone (as in your post ) speaks loudly as "Bad Mum"..... Yet we are grateful you bothered to call at all. Because let's face it responding to our emails or calls is never a priority when it is easier to not explore a childs' needs and try to match provision towards them, it's always easier to label us "bad parents".

THIS is what is called a weak response from supposed "professionals", who in any other profession would be obliged to meet timelines and follow the law. If you genuinely consider the trauma who may have had within school is anywhere close to that of any SEN parent, I would seriously recommend you take some time to actually sit down and listen to some of them. You would be amazed I am sure.

You could consider that investing the time you have here would be identical to that of drafting an email to your MP or similar or setting up a support group within your school or LA.... Perhaps outline the racist, threatening and violent behaviours you have encountered and please o inform them whilst you're at it that many parents you deem "bad" have suffered the same relentless trauma, again from the same broken system we are all forced to share and work within.

👏👏👏

babybythesea · 19/07/2022 20:46

Mumofsend · 19/07/2022 19:08

I've been on the other side of this.

My DD was horrendous her first few years of school. She was never once excluded. School took their time. She went through most of one year mainly outside of the classroom to limit risk and introduced back into class in baby steps. Lots of meetings with me, lots of discussion and working together.

The focus was upon us as adults understanding the issues so they could be pre-empted as well as her accepting school as a safe place via a trauma aware response.

She was not allowed to hurt others, we had maybe 4 blips in 3 years. When she did something that put herself or others at risk she was removed back out of class to help us understand why and a slow reintegration. We basically had to take full responsibility to regulate her and over the past few months we are starting to teach her the tools she needs to start to do so herself.

If a child can't recognise that funny feeling in their tummy is anxiety we can't expect them to respond correctly to it.

The problem is it takes time and patience and a lot of schools don't seem to want to invest either.

If more children at a young age had the time put in during the first few years of school rather than a cycle of exclusions, shaming and not being properly helped to learn to regulate you end up with very big kids with the same issues.

I dont think exclusions are often the answer.

Its not a case of ‘don’t want to’ but ‘can’t’ in some cases though.

I’m a TA with Y1 and 2. We don’t have enough support staff for every class in our school to have one TA each so I go and support another class once a week’ plus a number of other children who have specific needs. We had a child who had a very difficult home life and whose behaviour was extremely aggressive, particularly towards other children. However he didn’t qualify for one to one support (he behaved quite well the one morning we managed to get a professional in to assess him.) So when he was being particularly challenging I would be pulled across to be with him. That comes at a cost of the child who needed extra support with his SATS preparation not having the one to one time he needed to work something through. And the child I was supposed to do speech and language therapy with not getting it that day. And the child with suspected dyslexia not getting the in-school screening on the day she was supposed to. Not to mention all the children in class who could have done with me just sitting quietly with them to just ensure they could keep up with the work.

We invested a huge amount of time trying to work this all through, mostly with little
outside support as getting the relevant agencies involved was a nightmare. But all that time came at a massive cost to other kids who also desperately needed help
but weren’t violent so ended up sliding down our priority list because the priority had to be to stop the physical attacks.

We wanted to invest but at what point do you say “we can’t do everything. We don’t have the staff or money to employ new staff. And all these other kids pay the price because the one person we do have is always with the violent child.”

And in return for not supporting the children I was supposed to support I got headbutted, kicked and punched

KateRusby · 19/07/2022 20:44

titbumwillypoo · 19/07/2022 17:43

So basically you think children with disabilities such as ASD or children with terrible home lives should be excluded because of the "choices" they make? I would have thought that a teacher with 2 decades of experience should know better. You're the one who is in loco parentis, have you looked at the behaviour that you model in your classroom that contributes to the disruption?

Everyone needs to be taught in a place where they can thrive and for some children that isn't mainstream, or not mainstream as it is now. I wouldn't expect my 18 month old to cope in a Y4 class but that is essentially what we ask of some children - children with similar levels of understanding, emotion control and language. We are not doing the best by anyone to pretend a child who is causing, say, a Y1 class to be evacuated daily should continue to be educated in that setting. OF COURSE teachers will have looked at the behaviour they model, most will have been trying desperately to find a solution. But there is no silver bullet and at what point do the needs of one trump the needs of the remaining 29? (Some of whom will have their own SEND to contend with.)

Sherrystrull · 19/07/2022 20:38

I have seen the impact a few children can have on an entire class. As a teacher of a large class it is impossible for me to meet their needs as well as teach a full class. I would love to be able to but funding is dire. You feel like you're failing every child every day.

Sort funding out for diagnosed and undiagnosed SEND.

Tee20x · 19/07/2022 20:37

KatherineHoward · 19/07/2022 20:03

My DD use to be made to sit next to a weed smoking teenager pupil because she was well behaved. He played on his phone and talk to her non stop, she was thrilled when he use to truant.

This annoys me! I remember being in primary school and being paired with a boy who had some sort of emotionally unstable disorder & was tasked with calming him down when he was overwhelmed and helping him focus on his work.

That's what I got for being hardworking & getting on with my work - became responsible for someone else!

Tee20x · 19/07/2022 20:35

Agree with the sentiment of being trauma informed but they can do that while they have been excluded One child's experience of trauma and the way that manifests themselves in how they present at school isn't something that should disrupt the learning of 30 others and simply isn't fair.

Flopisfatteningbingforchristmas · 19/07/2022 20:31

titbumwillypoo · 19/07/2022 17:43

So basically you think children with disabilities such as ASD or children with terrible home lives should be excluded because of the "choices" they make? I would have thought that a teacher with 2 decades of experience should know better. You're the one who is in loco parentis, have you looked at the behaviour that you model in your classroom that contributes to the disruption?

As an ex teacher I entirely agree @titbumwillypoo which is why I don’t believe a busy main stream classroom is always the best place for some students.

Mumofsend · 19/07/2022 20:28

AntlerRose · 19/07/2022 20:22

Some of these issues sound like they could be dealt with by banning phones or using internal exclusion rooms over exclusion.

I absolutley relate to the children all needing different contradictory things. This happens in special schools. Asd and adhd often come together. A sl behavioural difficulties have different causes so if you have a school for behavioural needs they can still conflict.

Yes and quite often kids who need these schools can't actually cope with them. It's a nightmare.

Nolongerteaching · 19/07/2022 20:27

I think that a lot of teachers will get burnt out very quickly.

I also don’t think traumatised children are that easily placated in the classroom setting. It’s based on the assumption that there is one traumatised child in with 29 quiet, settled children. That is not the reality in many London schools. It is more like a third of children that you are trying to keep an eye on, a third you rely on to just get on with it and a third that you privately hope are ok and don’t really get to find out until it’s too late.

You have children who have just lost a parent in with children whose parents are in prison, or very sick, in with those who are refugees and then those whose whole family are very anti school/teacher. Then there children with very specific health needs (hearing, Down’s), learning needs (autism, dyscalculia). Add in speech therapy, fine motor skills therapy, extra catch up lessons and prep for tests and I really don’t think people quite get how many demands there are on your patience, resources, creativity, flexibility, etc. In the end, so many just walk away.

AntlerRose · 19/07/2022 20:22

Some of these issues sound like they could be dealt with by banning phones or using internal exclusion rooms over exclusion.

I absolutley relate to the children all needing different contradictory things. This happens in special schools. Asd and adhd often come together. A sl behavioural difficulties have different causes so if you have a school for behavioural needs they can still conflict.

Butterflymosaic · 19/07/2022 20:15

There are no lines, detentions or exclusions here in Scotland. There are however, restorative conversations and a nurture based approach. All behaviour is communication apparently! 🤔 Some days are scarier than others.

KatherineHoward · 19/07/2022 20:03

My DD use to be made to sit next to a weed smoking teenager pupil because she was well behaved. He played on his phone and talk to her non stop, she was thrilled when he use to truant.

Elisheva · 19/07/2022 19:58

And one teacher to rule them all, to paraphrase.
This
It is sometimes not possible to meet every students needs within one environment. As a very easy example, my ASD son does his exams in a smaller room because he needs a number of access arrangements to help him. For one of his recent mocks they put a student who has ADHD in the same room. He was rocking in his chair, randomly banging the table and whistling. Apparently they only have a limited amount of smaller rooms that they can staff for exams.

TheMoth · 19/07/2022 19:38

For those teachers who haven't been officially trained in trauma informed etc, I think you'll find that if you're a good teacher you're doing it anyway..

But again, one teacher, trying to get through Gove's curriculum with 30 students, cannot possibly do it all.
A theoretical classroom, not too far from reality:

1 kid has sensory issues and needs quiet
1 kid has adhd and can't cope when it's quiet.
Another kid with adhd also has tourette's and tends to shout out randomly, thus setting off other kid with adhd.
1 kid has an attachment disorder and is very reactive.
At least 2 of the kids are experiencing dv. 1 is violent. The other tends to need coaxing into each lesson.
2 kids are plain, old fashioned spoilt and entitled and like to wind others up.
Small clutch of anxious girls, who need lots of tlc.
1 kid involved in County lines. He's actually no trouble, but you've occasionally had to safeguard for signs of drug use.
1 or 2 add kids, who need lots of prompts.

And one teacher to rule them all, to paraphrase.

Curtains778 · 19/07/2022 19:33

The massive part ignored in Southwark's strategy are the other 29 children having to sit in class. Would you work with someone who said that they would kill you repeatedly? Someone who got explosively angry and threw things? What about the trauma and loss of education for those children?

Explosive anger isnt always linked to SEN. We are fastidious in watching triggers and accomodating for them and I would feel very sad if an autistic child or similar could no longer come into our school. What I wouldnt feel sad about is having a safe working environment for staff and a safe school for students.

While I do believe a trauma informed approached is vital, sometimes you get to the end of what you can actually do. Working with these students is very, very difficult and I suggest anyone at Southwark council or someone who thinks you just need the right 'approach' spend a year in a class at my school.

noblegiraffe · 19/07/2022 19:33

But the children most likely to be excluded have ASD, SEMH disabilities and attachment disorders

Are there any circumstances under which you would accept the exclusion of a child from school as necessary?

Carrieonmywaywardsun · 19/07/2022 19:28

I think it's a really interesting approach

Confrontayshunme · 19/07/2022 19:25

But the children most likely to be excluded have ASD, SEMH disabilities and attachment disorders. Surely by using a trauma informed response, you can help them stop the behavioura before they start. TIR involves de-escalation and understanding how to mitigate and calm dowm kids who don't yet have self-regulation skills. You wouldn't exclude a child who hasn't learned how to read without significant intervention, so why would you exclude a child with the behavioural age of a very young toddler.

PurpleWisteria · 19/07/2022 19:24

No teacher should have to teach a child who has attacked her.

No child should have to sit in the same classroom as a child who has assaulted her.

It is time we brought back the support for dealing with violent children and it should mean instant suspension in the first instance.

At one time teachers could refuse to teach children who has attacked them - that needs to come back.

We do a disservice to the violent/disruptive children and to the others in the class by allowing the child to remain able to behave violently. The other children are so tired of the relentlessness of such behaviour. Let's prioritise them for a change. Some of them also have special needs that go unaddressed because of the behaviour of others.

Children have a right to an education. If mainstream schools refuse to allow such children to remain then the LA will be forced to bring in better provision and more specialised schools adequately staffed.

SweetPetrichor · 19/07/2022 19:20

I don’t have children, so I have no part in this really, but my parents were both teachers who retired early cause of the downward turn in teaching and the expectations of teachers.
A teacher should simply be a teacher. If a pupil misbehaves, they should be removed from class temporarily. Repeat that behaviour and it should be made permanent. The standard classroom is not the place to deal with those children who can’t/won’t behave in the required manner.
But, there should be suitable alternatives for excluded children. Somewhere that can cater to them.