Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

As a parent, would you be happy with this? And teachers?

160 replies

ThrallsWife · 19/07/2022 16:49

article

So some schools in South London are now encouraged to not exclude any students "unless they pose risk to another child". In my nearly 2 decades of teaching , I have had my family threatened, racist remarks made against me, chairs thrown at me, as well as books and various other bits.

Students have had to suffer through lessons dominated by the moods of one or two children, made to sit through countless lessons where learning was impossible because the same regular students would disrupt. Sometimes, not a single student was being threatened, but a whole class had to be evacuated to protect them from the rages of others.

Do we really hold the rights of the few above the rights of the many?

"Teachers will be encouraged to try to understand the reason for bad behaviour by using a "trauma-informed" response and are being told not to take misbehaviour at "face value"."

That is a weak response by any school I've ever worked in. Sometimes the answer is just bad parenting, not trauma. And those who have had severe trauma respond much better to talking to a professional with mental health training, which many teachers don't have enough of - nor the time to invest that would be necessary.

It would stop me from ever working in any of those schools, but I fear that this is the road we will all be forced down sooner or later...

OP posts:
Autumnalblooms · 20/07/2022 00:08

Thereisnolight · 19/07/2022 22:18

Teachers are teachers. Not psychologists, counsellors, doctors or prison officers or security guards.

Teachers.

This is spot on .This is why any child for whatever reason be it autism , adhd or anything else will potentially fail at mainstream because teachers don't have the specialist training sen teachers do .

Autumnalblooms · 20/07/2022 00:05

DoubleShotEspresso · 19/07/2022 18:09

Just a few ideas here for you....
-Incorporate proper, adequate and qualified SEN learning into all teacher training.
-FUND schools, including mainstream with adequate, proper, qualified SEND provision.
-Cease in the practice of teachers unqualified in the business of mental health, social work or parenting of making sweeping statements about a family they have likely only met in the confines of what often appears to parents as a crisis meeting.
-Provide SEN funding to facilitate consistent proper adult supervision matched to the needs clearly outlined in specialist (yes qualified ) reports, observations and recommendations.
-Stop the practice of so many SLT's , MAT'S, Mainstream settings from illegally excluding, off-rolling and intimidating SEN children and their families.
-Create provisions which include and cater towards those children currently falling under the "ghost child" umbrella. (Someting between a mainstream and a DSP/PRU/AP.
-Cease Senco's,schools, SEN Officers into wrongly and inexpertly "labelling" children as "SEMH" when they remain on the pathway for formal, medically qualified assessment. This practice is a cack-handed way of obaining short-term provision but is hugely detrimental to the child who often needs entirely different effective methods and strategies.
-Make schools accountable for failings and fraudulent use of funds.
-Make LA'S accountable for their monitoring of schools.

And finally just maybe, consider the rights of these children who though may be posing yourself and other colleagues challenges before your own. You have all benefited from the education that got you as far as teaching, perhaps consider the value of these children receiving adequate, tailored to their needs provision before not only writing them off academically, but contributing to the ill effects of exclusion and limiting the very choices that your own education has afforded you.

*I am not saying it is easy. I am not inferring your job is hideously challenging. But you are placing and directing your anger in the wrong directions.

Consider for instance the current (and doomed to be flawed following the cabinet changes) SEND consultation on the White and Green Papers. Have you taken the time to respond? Contacted your MP? Your union? Or have you perhaps thought of contacting the DFE?

Further consider the proposed (Dickensian in its' contents) Schools Bill? Parents just like the ones you already label as bad, who FYI have already before you get the pleasure of judging them meeting them have already endured trauma levels you cannot possibly comprehend. Because you, unlike them have not only been able to choose. career, you have been afforded the privilege of pursuing it. The very system you are so angry at has failed them so monumentally that the choices you retain have been ripped from them, their families, their relationships, other siblings and yet they "cope" daily. Because schools like yours simply don't. Yet when these failings are clearly identified, their "battle" really commences, as though the law is on their side, their LA often isn't..... Add to this the flavour of battle for paediatrics (it's hideous right now FYI, CAMHS (the chocolate teapot that even suicidal teens don't reach the criteria for), ASD/ADHD/PDA assessments which in some parts of the UK are currently running a 3 year waiting list, sleepless nights and the relentless emails, forms, meetings and appointments. We perhaps qualify for DLA for our children, if lucky receive £260 a month Carers- this all goes on the children and household bills as that's where the system leaves us. To obtain this absolute fortune means requiring education professionals to fill out forms outlining how challenging our children are, but we wait weeks, whilst you battle the same system from a different side of the fence to us. Yet we are grateful.

Then the audacity, the barefaced unqualified, judgemental opinions professionals like yourself freely share regarding our parenting, though you have never given us more than ten minutes of your time or even stepped into our homes. You are in receipt of 100's of emails, clearly bearing my name, but insist each time on calling me "Mum". Your tone (as in your post ) speaks loudly as "Bad Mum"..... Yet we are grateful you bothered to call at all. Because let's face it responding to our emails or calls is never a priority when it is easier to not explore a childs' needs and try to match provision towards them, it's always easier to label us "bad parents".

THIS is what is called a weak response from supposed "professionals", who in any other profession would be obliged to meet timelines and follow the law. If you genuinely consider the trauma who may have had within school is anywhere close to that of any SEN parent, I would seriously recommend you take some time to actually sit down and listen to some of them. You would be amazed I am sure.

You could consider that investing the time you have here would be identical to that of drafting an email to your MP or similar or setting up a support group within your school or LA.... Perhaps outline the racist, threatening and violent behaviours you have encountered and please o inform them whilst you're at it that many parents you deem "bad" have suffered the same relentless trauma, again from the same broken system we are all forced to share and work within.

I am also a parent who took on the education system for a specialist placement and through sheer determination and standing my ground I got it .But seriously fully get your anger but you are also ranting at the wrong person.You took the post very personally when it wasn't even about you 🤷‍♀️.

Sherrystrull · 19/07/2022 23:58

WellThatsMeScrewed · 19/07/2022 23:54

I expect someone might explain it better.

Thank you.

WellThatsMeScrewed · 19/07/2022 23:54

I expect someone might explain it better.

WellThatsMeScrewed · 19/07/2022 23:54

Sherrystrull · 19/07/2022 23:48

What is the trauma informed response?

Responding to the cause of the dysregulation rather than the behaviour, recognising the root of the behaviour, being empathetic and accepting of the child’s emotional state, supporting them in managing the bodies state that causes behaviour (sensory support for example) and avoiding responses that cause shame in children.

WellThatsMeScrewed · 19/07/2022 23:50

Exclusion is not the answer but exposing other children (and teachers) to violence is also not the answer.

I also think there is a potentially a very dodgy lesson being given to our children, which is ‘you put up with any level of violence because of the perpetrators needs’. This is not a lesson I want either of my children to learn.

Autumnalblooms · 19/07/2022 23:49

titbumwillypoo · 19/07/2022 17:43

So basically you think children with disabilities such as ASD or children with terrible home lives should be excluded because of the "choices" they make? I would have thought that a teacher with 2 decades of experience should know better. You're the one who is in loco parentis, have you looked at the behaviour that you model in your classroom that contributes to the disruption?

To be fair to the op I don't see where they mentioned autism.Your post is pretty unfair and very angry sounding .And I say that as a parent of two high functioning autistic teenagers one of whom does attend a specialist school because they found mainstream overwhelming. I was for a while a team leader with challenging behaviour and not every badly behaved child has a horrible home life some children are just plain badly behaved and disruptive .

I agree OP there is a limit to what you can do and what disruption to the other children's education is .Mainstream is not the right place , they need a specialist schools with one to one and therapy and boundaries you can't give them that .But that will never happen because the funding will never be there so they get put in mainstream and failed badly.

Sherrystrull · 19/07/2022 23:48

What is the trauma informed response?

WellThatsMeScrewed · 19/07/2022 23:47

I am very committed to the ‘trauma informed’ approach for my line of work (not education, MH services). But I have so much sympathy for teachers. We are basically asking them to respond to pupils in a trauma informed way while also teaching and looking after 29 kids. Anyone who knows about such trauma informed practice will know that this is impossible.

I also find it very hard as a parent. One of my DC had a terrible time with one lad in his class, I knew hos family background and understood his trauma. BUT my DC was hurt by him, had his stiff damaged by him and was becoming terrified of him. Luckily he moved schools. But if he hadn’t I don’t know what we would have done.

So for every parent saying that their kids have the right to an education when they are the ones causing such disruption there are multiple parents also going ‘what about my child, who is innocent in this’. It’s an impossible situation.

Sockwomble · 19/07/2022 23:44

"Exclusion absolutely is the answer."

No the right provision ( in this case special school) being given at the right time was the answer. It should never have got to exclusion.

JudgeJ · 19/07/2022 23:28

titbumwillypoo · 19/07/2022 17:43

So basically you think children with disabilities such as ASD or children with terrible home lives should be excluded because of the "choices" they make? I would have thought that a teacher with 2 decades of experience should know better. You're the one who is in loco parentis, have you looked at the behaviour that you model in your classroom that contributes to the disruption?

What utter bollcks!
The easy leap, lets make it all about a particular group then we can pass the buck onto the teacher, sod the rest of the school, a very large majority, who are unable to learn. The pupils who are constantly disrupting the school, bullying the other pupils, abusing staff are often just plain and simply little shits with no other problems/excuses, yet they are backed up by outsiders who don't have to deal with them in a full class situation and know nothing about teaching.

Happymum12345 · 19/07/2022 23:26

For those who display such behaviours, there should be a safe place for them to receive help/education, whether because of trauma or parenting issue. This would need lots more teachers trained & qualified in psychology & trauma at a great cost. It’s so important to do though.

echt · 19/07/2022 23:22

I empathise with you but at the end of the day exclusions don't change behaviour- the same way prison does not rehabilitate for the vast majority

But it does the give the rest a break. Others need to be considered too.

echt · 19/07/2022 23:20

The schools' proposal is a weak-kneed response to a very real situation, and pushes all the responsibility back on the teacher. No change there. Hmm

Everyone gets short-changed.

A perspective from Victoria is one where privacy laws are so stringent, teachers know very little about students' backgrounds bar allergies/diet/asthma/medical/diagnosed issues in the detailed way UK teachers do. I've worked in both so I know. Just to add we don't know ethnicity, religion or languages spoke at home unless the family has chosen to give such information.

I should add that when I've spoken with students about the UK's more informed system of student information to teachers they say it's a much better idea, and I agree. It enables a far more nuanced approach to student care than an email saying "X is doing it tough right now".

In Victoria teachers deal with the behaviour, and the bottom line is, is this preventing teaching and learning from happening? We had excellent back-up from SLT if the shit hit the fan, and HOYs dealt with the more complex issues.
Background might be a reason, but never an excuse.

I know which one I prefer.

bluekostree · 19/07/2022 23:19

I empathise with you but at the end of the day exclusions don't change behaviour- the same way prison does not rehabilitate for the vast majority. I work in education and I feel great allegiance and sympathy for the stress teachers have, the funding crisis and curriculum- it all needs to change. I moved from SE England to NI and still work in education (in an overseeing role) and the issues here are much less (in terms of behaviour- and results are better). Ime there were much more difficult societal issues plus poverty at play in England which relates to Southwark (I worked in the next borough).

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 19/07/2022 23:14

Its hard my own ds year group has been a nightmare from reception my son has been hit punched kicked nipped push over by the same 5 kids in year 3 he finally snapped and has been hitting back yet he is the one who gets into trouble each time and I am the only parent contacted my ds struggles with verbal communication and has speech therapy ect so when upset ppl can't understand him so I have to write statements when he is calm at home to inform his teachers, he was attached by all 5 of these boys at the same time yet only he got into trouble and lost breaks they are all year 4 so 8 and 9 year old yet because of there home life or adhd or asd they get away with it every time, yes more help is needed for those with problems but they should also be punished for there behaviour

Sockwomble · 19/07/2022 23:13

"These sort of facilities must be funded and provided with the possibility of a return to mainstream depending on the students progress."

This child needed specialist provision for their autism but there were no special school places. It would have helped if the mainstream school had not spent a year saying that they wouldn't apply for an ehcp because they hadn't got enough evidence ( but your child can only attend part time because they need too much support).

Smileyaxolotl1 · 19/07/2022 23:10

Dancingwithhyenas

so does the trauma informed response idea only apply where children’s behaviour is trauma related? If so I can see how people I work with use it, for example keeping distance from a boy who has been assaulted previously when disciplining him and never raising the voice.
as you are aware there isn’t much training given to teachers on this.

Sockwomble · 19/07/2022 23:04

"But try changing that to:
I know a child with a severe heart condition who kept collapsing at school until the teachers felt it was unsafe to have him there. He was out of school for a year before his heart condition was finally appropriately managed by a cardiologist."

Also add in that during that year he got no medical support and his parents were left to try to sort out and manage his treatment by themselves and he only finally got medical support because his parents took the NHS to court and the law forced them to provide it.

DogsAndGin · 19/07/2022 22:59

Yep. This is how it goes. Teachers are powerless.

Smileyaxolotl1 · 19/07/2022 22:58

Isn’t it weird how kids behaved much better before all the diagnoses and people spouting things like ‘all behaviour is communication’

I don’t actually disagree with the last statement. With a lot of the kids I teach the behaviour is communicating ‘I’m a rude little shit who had never been told ‘no’ in my life’

Smileyaxolotl1 · 19/07/2022 22:54

Sockwomble

presumably if that child was excluded it’s because they were causing significant disruption/harm to the rest of the children at their school. I don’t believe that the education of 29 children should suffer for the benefit of one child. Exclusion absolutely is the answer. However the being out of school for a year was not acceptable. Children permanently excluded in my area have alternative provision to go too with smaller classes and professionals who are earned in managing children with high needs. These sort of facilities must be funded and provided with the possibility of a return to mainstream depending on the students progress.

Thereisnolight · 19/07/2022 22:53

Sockwomble · 19/07/2022 22:48

I know a 6 year old with autism and significant learning difficulties who was permanently excluded from school and was out of school for a year ( at home) before a school place was found for them. How can anyone think exclusion was the way to meet that disabled child's needs

But try changing that to:
I know a child with a severe heart condition who kept collapsing at school until the teachers felt it was unsafe to have him there. He was out of school for a year before his heart condition was finally appropriately managed by a cardiologist.

Sockwomble · 19/07/2022 22:48

I know a 6 year old with autism and significant learning difficulties who was permanently excluded from school and was out of school for a year ( at home) before a school place was found for them. How can anyone think exclusion was the way to meet that disabled child's needs

Thereisnolight · 19/07/2022 22:39

Dancingwithhyenas · 19/07/2022 22:32

I’m a teacher who has been trained in trauma informed response. I think it’s a shame you aren’t committed to it, as it has the ability to really positively impact staff and children. It does need to be really embraced rather than lip service paid, which means the right resources in place.
As a society it’s absolutely without doubt the right approach, whether in mainstream school or in nurture or specialist settings. Righting teens and children off costs us an absolute fortune in crime, mental health and prison costs. It’s madness on an economic and human/moral level.

No one says to write them off.

Would it be writing off a child with severe asthma to say that all asthma attacks should be managed by teachers at school because hospitals are overstretched? And that the other children should work by themselves while the struggling asthmatic child is being managed outside in the hall every day by the teacher?

Actually it WOULD be writing them off - because the answer would be to treat asthma where it’s SUPPOSED to be treated - by a healthcare professional in a healthcare setting. Not by teachers in a school.