Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

As a parent, would you be happy with this? And teachers?

160 replies

ThrallsWife · 19/07/2022 16:49

article

So some schools in South London are now encouraged to not exclude any students "unless they pose risk to another child". In my nearly 2 decades of teaching , I have had my family threatened, racist remarks made against me, chairs thrown at me, as well as books and various other bits.

Students have had to suffer through lessons dominated by the moods of one or two children, made to sit through countless lessons where learning was impossible because the same regular students would disrupt. Sometimes, not a single student was being threatened, but a whole class had to be evacuated to protect them from the rages of others.

Do we really hold the rights of the few above the rights of the many?

"Teachers will be encouraged to try to understand the reason for bad behaviour by using a "trauma-informed" response and are being told not to take misbehaviour at "face value"."

That is a weak response by any school I've ever worked in. Sometimes the answer is just bad parenting, not trauma. And those who have had severe trauma respond much better to talking to a professional with mental health training, which many teachers don't have enough of - nor the time to invest that would be necessary.

It would stop me from ever working in any of those schools, but I fear that this is the road we will all be forced down sooner or later...

OP posts:
Mumofsend · 20/07/2022 07:09

Olderkids · 20/07/2022 06:46

It is the attitude of people like you which has destroyed all respect and discipline in this country and typically you blame the teacher! Why should adults who take the trouble to parent properly have their efforts undermined by those who continue to have kid after kid but can’t be bothered to bring them up to be a decent human being. I taught plenty of ASD children who knew the boundaries. I have also had classes suffer due to constant low level disruption and worse and I know which children deserve the time and attention the most.

My autistic 7YO knows the boundaries, she thrives of boundaries. She gets upset when boundaries are blurred. She can't manage without a firm boundary and when she is overwhelmed by what she perceives as chaos (ie PE) she runs to hide, usually under a table or chair out of the classroom. Initially they tried to catch her and hold on to her so she lashed out. Then they learnt to let her go to her table to hide under and give her 10 minutes to stim. When they were attempting to restrain her she went into such severe flight/fight she would have zero recollection after of what had just happened.

It is nothing at all to do with not knowing boundaries. There is definitely a difference between a complete overwhelm fight/flight and just playing up but it is not good enough to say they just aren't following a boundary. It is pretty ignorant.

It was also ironic when in the very early days and school tried to blame parenting, we had early help for a few months who visited us weekly. She commented on how we have two different children, home was fine because at home I can give her the firm boundaries and adapt to her difficulties without issue (ie I wouldn't shove her in a crowded noisy hall!). We got sorted after a couple of years and she now isn't an issue at all in school either.

Elisheva · 20/07/2022 07:08

What would a trauma-informed approach actually look like in a classroom? Say a year 10, 1 hour science lesson where a couple of kids are kicking off and refusing to sit down and listen?

Sockwomble · 20/07/2022 07:00

". I taught plenty of ASD children who knew the boundaries"

It is not just about knowing boundaries. It is about forcing a child into situations that they cannot cope in and then being suprised when the child doesn't cope eg forcing them into a busy noisy dining room and then restraining them when they try to leave and being suprised that the child lashes out.

Olderkids · 20/07/2022 06:46

titbumwillypoo · 19/07/2022 17:43

So basically you think children with disabilities such as ASD or children with terrible home lives should be excluded because of the "choices" they make? I would have thought that a teacher with 2 decades of experience should know better. You're the one who is in loco parentis, have you looked at the behaviour that you model in your classroom that contributes to the disruption?

It is the attitude of people like you which has destroyed all respect and discipline in this country and typically you blame the teacher! Why should adults who take the trouble to parent properly have their efforts undermined by those who continue to have kid after kid but can’t be bothered to bring them up to be a decent human being. I taught plenty of ASD children who knew the boundaries. I have also had classes suffer due to constant low level disruption and worse and I know which children deserve the time and attention the most.

thatslow · 20/07/2022 06:43

I think it’s disgusting that adults are no longer being allowed to discipline or remove these children.
A Friends daughter sits in a separate room at school almost every day to escape bullies. She’s missing out on a proper education when it’s the bullies that should be removed. Schools seem to have lost any authority.

bigfootisreal · 20/07/2022 06:41

They will say they will come at it using a trauma informed models but the reality is they will not use a trauma informed model at all. If they label these kids as having a mental health disorder then they are not using a trauma informed model as this opposes all biological factors for mental health.

They will use a deficit model such as ACES despite it being damaging to children or they will use a biopsychosocial model, social model or biological model.

It'll be a hodge podge of models and none of which will apply to the other children who suffer as a result of the actions of these children or the staff who suffer also.

FreudayNight · 20/07/2022 06:16

DoubleShotEspresso · 19/07/2022 18:09

Just a few ideas here for you....
-Incorporate proper, adequate and qualified SEN learning into all teacher training.
-FUND schools, including mainstream with adequate, proper, qualified SEND provision.
-Cease in the practice of teachers unqualified in the business of mental health, social work or parenting of making sweeping statements about a family they have likely only met in the confines of what often appears to parents as a crisis meeting.
-Provide SEN funding to facilitate consistent proper adult supervision matched to the needs clearly outlined in specialist (yes qualified ) reports, observations and recommendations.
-Stop the practice of so many SLT's , MAT'S, Mainstream settings from illegally excluding, off-rolling and intimidating SEN children and their families.
-Create provisions which include and cater towards those children currently falling under the "ghost child" umbrella. (Someting between a mainstream and a DSP/PRU/AP.
-Cease Senco's,schools, SEN Officers into wrongly and inexpertly "labelling" children as "SEMH" when they remain on the pathway for formal, medically qualified assessment. This practice is a cack-handed way of obaining short-term provision but is hugely detrimental to the child who often needs entirely different effective methods and strategies.
-Make schools accountable for failings and fraudulent use of funds.
-Make LA'S accountable for their monitoring of schools.

And finally just maybe, consider the rights of these children who though may be posing yourself and other colleagues challenges before your own. You have all benefited from the education that got you as far as teaching, perhaps consider the value of these children receiving adequate, tailored to their needs provision before not only writing them off academically, but contributing to the ill effects of exclusion and limiting the very choices that your own education has afforded you.

*I am not saying it is easy. I am not inferring your job is hideously challenging. But you are placing and directing your anger in the wrong directions.

Consider for instance the current (and doomed to be flawed following the cabinet changes) SEND consultation on the White and Green Papers. Have you taken the time to respond? Contacted your MP? Your union? Or have you perhaps thought of contacting the DFE?

Further consider the proposed (Dickensian in its' contents) Schools Bill? Parents just like the ones you already label as bad, who FYI have already before you get the pleasure of judging them meeting them have already endured trauma levels you cannot possibly comprehend. Because you, unlike them have not only been able to choose. career, you have been afforded the privilege of pursuing it. The very system you are so angry at has failed them so monumentally that the choices you retain have been ripped from them, their families, their relationships, other siblings and yet they "cope" daily. Because schools like yours simply don't. Yet when these failings are clearly identified, their "battle" really commences, as though the law is on their side, their LA often isn't..... Add to this the flavour of battle for paediatrics (it's hideous right now FYI, CAMHS (the chocolate teapot that even suicidal teens don't reach the criteria for), ASD/ADHD/PDA assessments which in some parts of the UK are currently running a 3 year waiting list, sleepless nights and the relentless emails, forms, meetings and appointments. We perhaps qualify for DLA for our children, if lucky receive £260 a month Carers- this all goes on the children and household bills as that's where the system leaves us. To obtain this absolute fortune means requiring education professionals to fill out forms outlining how challenging our children are, but we wait weeks, whilst you battle the same system from a different side of the fence to us. Yet we are grateful.

Then the audacity, the barefaced unqualified, judgemental opinions professionals like yourself freely share regarding our parenting, though you have never given us more than ten minutes of your time or even stepped into our homes. You are in receipt of 100's of emails, clearly bearing my name, but insist each time on calling me "Mum". Your tone (as in your post ) speaks loudly as "Bad Mum"..... Yet we are grateful you bothered to call at all. Because let's face it responding to our emails or calls is never a priority when it is easier to not explore a childs' needs and try to match provision towards them, it's always easier to label us "bad parents".

THIS is what is called a weak response from supposed "professionals", who in any other profession would be obliged to meet timelines and follow the law. If you genuinely consider the trauma who may have had within school is anywhere close to that of any SEN parent, I would seriously recommend you take some time to actually sit down and listen to some of them. You would be amazed I am sure.

You could consider that investing the time you have here would be identical to that of drafting an email to your MP or similar or setting up a support group within your school or LA.... Perhaps outline the racist, threatening and violent behaviours you have encountered and please o inform them whilst you're at it that many parents you deem "bad" have suffered the same relentless trauma, again from the same broken system we are all forced to share and work within.

my child was assaulted at school, by another child who would probably fill the description and needs you are talking about.

the school completely took his side (apart from the teacher who used to be a police officer, funnily enough.) and she just had to go back into the classroom with him.

There is some really disturbing entitlement in your post. What it comes down to is you want the classroom and its resources to be focussed to the one child regardless of any impact on other children.
Already probably 30% of the classroom time is focused on the violent children, and No I’m not prepared to use only the language you permit of “lashing out” or “frustrated” because it minimises the awfulness others experience.

if your child is getting the message that the teacher is to blame if he/she wraps a chair around the teachers head, and school is responsible when he/she is violent then actually that is bad parenting, in that the minimum standards of behaviour are not being explained properly.
If your child cannot (as opposed to will not) avoid escalating to violence then they aren’t fit for a big standard classroom- it isn’t fair or appropriate on anyone.

Parkperson00 · 20/07/2022 06:13

As a mostly retired teacher I do a lot of childcare for my grandchildren. There is a Church hall soft play I often take my grandchild along to. I bumped into a former student there with his girlfriend and toddler son. My grandson was a late ish walker. It was touching to be given advice on physical development by my ex student and even more touching to see his huge pride in his family unit and his toddler son. He expressed the wish that one day his son would work with him and his dad.
I am sad that they cannot afford to live in the Borough. He had bought his family over for the day.
I was once walking home after midnight from babysitting and felt a bit anxious until a load of ex students found me and insisted on seeing me home. I certainly don't feel the fear of teenagers and young adults that so many posters seem to feel.
I really love encountering former students. There is a lovely mum of three that I talk to at the school gate when I pick up my grandchild. I used to teach her and her partner. She asked me for advice the other day on becoming a TA. She will be great.
I am so lucky to have taught in a community school and to regularly bump into these lovely adults. They love it when I recognise them ( and amazingly I do mostly) and remember them so fondly

Namenic · 20/07/2022 05:55

Teachers and pupils should not have to be in a classroom with a pupil who will cause them injury (including sexual assault). It’s basic safeguarding. A no exclusion policy will cause physical harm. Unfortunately I think the only way authorities will listen is if teachers and parents sue the school for assaults caused by such a policy. It’s not necessarily the violent child’s fault - I’m sure many have had awful lives and been abused - but I don’t think that means they should be allowed to hurt other people. This would not be allowed in many adult workplace settings - why would we put children in this type of environment? probably the answer is for the parents to sue the local authority in order to get an education for a violent child. Perhaps crowdfunding where half the money raised goes to each of those causes?

ohfook · 20/07/2022 05:55

titbumwillypoo · 19/07/2022 17:43

So basically you think children with disabilities such as ASD or children with terrible home lives should be excluded because of the "choices" they make? I would have thought that a teacher with 2 decades of experience should know better. You're the one who is in loco parentis, have you looked at the behaviour that you model in your classroom that contributes to the disruption?

Literally nobody thinks that.

Zuyi · 20/07/2022 05:41

Parkperson00 · 20/07/2022 05:01

At the risk of sounding overly hopeful, I taught for a very long time in my local secondary school. Everyday I bump into former students. For so many of them they start by apologising for bad behaviour in the classroom ( I really don't remember) and by and large they find being an adult much easier.
Many of them find work in the construction industry or with their dads and uncles. A lot of them have lovely girlfriends and perhaps children. They find adult life so much easier to manage. Having a job gives them status and real self worth. They are not going to mess up at work in the way they messed around at school. I feel so proud of them. They were always lovely but struggled in a school setting. One young Dad chased after me in Tesco's to show me his lovely daughter. His huge pride in her made me want to cry.
I have taught loads of very high achieving students as well who are always charming to bump into. It is one of the really nice things about teaching in a community comprehensive and living in the same area.
What I am trying to say is that school classrooms can be hard places to cope with and traditional teaching methods don't always work with lively restless students.
So much is asked of teachers. It can be an impossible job. Seeing them as adults with families and jobs makes me burst with pride. It may just be my experience but the majority of kids in my small part of London thrive as adults. I have never encountered aggression or hostility. They are kind and responsible and pleased to be away from school life which made them feel bad about themselves.
Yes I have taught a few that ended up at a Young Offenders institute but again the majority come through in the end.
I suppose I would wish for a far more varied and practical curriculum for those that would benefit. Too many feel rubbish about themselves and kick off in class. More money, more support for teachers and for struggling students. It has been a privilege to be involved in so many of their lives and to see them settled brings me joy

❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Parkperson00 · 20/07/2022 05:01

At the risk of sounding overly hopeful, I taught for a very long time in my local secondary school. Everyday I bump into former students. For so many of them they start by apologising for bad behaviour in the classroom ( I really don't remember) and by and large they find being an adult much easier.
Many of them find work in the construction industry or with their dads and uncles. A lot of them have lovely girlfriends and perhaps children. They find adult life so much easier to manage. Having a job gives them status and real self worth. They are not going to mess up at work in the way they messed around at school. I feel so proud of them. They were always lovely but struggled in a school setting. One young Dad chased after me in Tesco's to show me his lovely daughter. His huge pride in her made me want to cry.
I have taught loads of very high achieving students as well who are always charming to bump into. It is one of the really nice things about teaching in a community comprehensive and living in the same area.
What I am trying to say is that school classrooms can be hard places to cope with and traditional teaching methods don't always work with lively restless students.
So much is asked of teachers. It can be an impossible job. Seeing them as adults with families and jobs makes me burst with pride. It may just be my experience but the majority of kids in my small part of London thrive as adults. I have never encountered aggression or hostility. They are kind and responsible and pleased to be away from school life which made them feel bad about themselves.
Yes I have taught a few that ended up at a Young Offenders institute but again the majority come through in the end.
I suppose I would wish for a far more varied and practical curriculum for those that would benefit. Too many feel rubbish about themselves and kick off in class. More money, more support for teachers and for struggling students. It has been a privilege to be involved in so many of their lives and to see them settled brings me joy

Mumofsend · 20/07/2022 03:38

And what would realistically happen is these kids banished to home. Parent has to give up work. Poverty then becomes problematic. Meanwhile they are out of sight out of mind and forgotten about by all.

Perhaps if they are kept as everyone's problem so they can't be forgotten about then more people will push for the correct support to be available and funded.

Mumofsend · 20/07/2022 03:29

I don't think people realise how difficult it is to get a diagnosis/medical support.

By luck my youngest DC is not behaviourally problematic. He is in year R and 5yr10m. At 3yr3m he was diagnosed global development delay which is a descriptor rather than cause diagnosis. This was Jan 2020, we received 0 support due to Covid until May 2021, everything stopped. Due to backlogs when he started school the Paediatrician discharged him and asked school to re-refer if he still needed to be seen/delayed.

His EHCP was issued January 2021 and he started school with it. He is not toilet trained and open to SALT, Physiotherapy and the school nurse. It has taken 15 months and a formal complaint to access the incontinence service.

School re-referred. Referral rejected after four 4 months waiting because of a technicality (they sent EHCP rather than the individual reports). I wasn't allowed to just send in the reports, it was a start again job. He still is not on the waiting list.

In the mean time incontinence service rang, they can't do much due to his communication and the severe phobia he has developed as a result of being over forced to try and train. They have told me camhs need to work with him to unpick but if he can't communicate that will be futile. I already know camhs won't take him until paeds do their ASD assessment, he isn't even on the 18 month waiting list for it. Camhs then has about a year as things said but if he gets an ASD diagnosis then they are unlikely to accept him as its "part of having autism" even though its something specific he needs support with.

It is all well and good saying schools shouldn't be supporting pastorly/with difficult needs but when a child has been in the system for 3 years, has an EHCP and still can't see a bloody medical professional then those children are absolutely screwed.

Theoretically despite 0 behavioural incidents with no learning disability diagnosis and no ASD diagnosis the only specialist schools who would take him at behavioural schools.

My entire line of work professionally now is working with SEND families, I wish my DS was just a case gone wrong and badly affected by covid.

We will be going private in November. At £2500 for an assessment and £125 per hour of therapy the cost is prohibitive for too many families. My fear is my lovely, well behaved boy will get so upset by his communication difficulties that he will become a challenging child.

It is all well and good saying they need to go somewhere else but unless you've actually understood how difficult A) diagnosis is B) getting a place is you fail to realise thousands of children are thrown under the bus and have their futures written for them.

We should instead be screaming from the roof tops for the correct funding, training and support services.

MangyInseam · 20/07/2022 02:46

I mean, kids that are disruptive in that way are not closer to reintegration by being allowed to disrupt other kids learning.

MangyInseam · 20/07/2022 02:43

Madwife123 · 20/07/2022 01:21

I don’t think you understand how difficult it is to get a child into a special school without a diagnosis and when they are intelligent.

My current foster child would thrive in a special school as his ASD makes him struggle in busy classrooms but as he in intelligent and not behind in school they will not accept him.

It’s really not as simple as you think and these children need to be educated somewhere. Delinquent children don’t just become so overnight, there is usually a long history behind them leading to their behaviour. Why should they be denied an education and a chance at reintegration when it’s usually the adults in their lives that have failed them. We can’t punish children for the parents failings.

I'm not sure why you came to that conclusion, I didn't say anything about it being simple.

But whether it is simple or not, keeping those kinds in the general classroom doesn't help them, and it screws over everyone else as well.

I think there needs to be a whole-system rejection of the inclusion principle in terms of mainstream classes. Yes, there are kids who do much better there and those kids should be kept there. Some of them may need one on one support to manage that.

But this underlying idea that it's the blanket approach is just not realistic. It's based on a kind of ideological viewpoint that we can just makes things ok for every kid if we try hard enough and that's an eight year old POV. Politically, it makes it that much easier to ignore the need for specialist places or other approaches when they are seen as exceptional situations.

Madwife123 · 20/07/2022 01:21

MangyInseam · 20/07/2022 01:03

In a way that's not her problem, practically. Just like it's not my problem to say what should be done for a kid who makes it impossible for my daughter to learn in her class. The teachers job is to teach the class and a child that makes that impossible isn't going to be something she will be able to fix.

Some of these kids need special schools to deal with specific cognitive or mental issues. Some are delinquent and need to be treated as such in another kind of school. Some probably need to be kept in a home environment and home educated, at least for a while, while having other specialist intervention. There may be some kids who aren't going to get an education no matter what anyone does.

I don’t think you understand how difficult it is to get a child into a special school without a diagnosis and when they are intelligent.

My current foster child would thrive in a special school as his ASD makes him struggle in busy classrooms but as he in intelligent and not behind in school they will not accept him.

It’s really not as simple as you think and these children need to be educated somewhere. Delinquent children don’t just become so overnight, there is usually a long history behind them leading to their behaviour. Why should they be denied an education and a chance at reintegration when it’s usually the adults in their lives that have failed them. We can’t punish children for the parents failings.

basilmint · 20/07/2022 01:04

I have links with a wonderful AP school which was set up specifically for exactly the type if students OP is talking about. The staff have excellent training in mental health and a trauma informed approach and they have a great track record for helping these kids gain qualifications they would otherwise leave school without. However, they are nowhere near capacity because the local authority will no longer fund such places.

I teach primary school. We have children with severe additional needs in virtually every class from Reception upwards who disrupt lessons across the whole school and we have little to no training in how to deal with them. We have a five year old non-verbal pupil who spends his entire time running around the school screaming and hitting people. There are no special school places, no EP, Speech and Language or Behaviour support available. When I was first teaching 20 years ago, if you had children with specific extra needs then you would receive regular visits from LA specialist teachers to help you plan and manage specific behaviour. Now there is absolutely nothing available due to a lack of funding.

MangyInseam · 20/07/2022 01:03

Madwife123 · 20/07/2022 00:57

First of all bad parenting does lead to trauma

Secondly what do you propose happens to these children who need an education?

I am a foster carer so see my fair share of trauma and believe me if an adult went through half of what some of these children go through then they would be disruptive also. But excluding them from society doesn’t help them recover it simply moves the problem on.

In a way that's not her problem, practically. Just like it's not my problem to say what should be done for a kid who makes it impossible for my daughter to learn in her class. The teachers job is to teach the class and a child that makes that impossible isn't going to be something she will be able to fix.

Some of these kids need special schools to deal with specific cognitive or mental issues. Some are delinquent and need to be treated as such in another kind of school. Some probably need to be kept in a home environment and home educated, at least for a while, while having other specialist intervention. There may be some kids who aren't going to get an education no matter what anyone does.

Madwife123 · 20/07/2022 00:57

First of all bad parenting does lead to trauma

Secondly what do you propose happens to these children who need an education?

I am a foster carer so see my fair share of trauma and believe me if an adult went through half of what some of these children go through then they would be disruptive also. But excluding them from society doesn’t help them recover it simply moves the problem on.

Zuyi · 20/07/2022 00:48

The trauma informed response is great. However, there also needs to be strict boundaries around violence, as well as understanding the limits of a busy teacher. How can a teacher manage a trauma response while also teaching the rest of the class. Not a rhetorical question, genuinely wondering, how can they?
It's not just teachers. A lot of parents, especially mothers, are regularly experiencing violence from their children. They have to just take it, too, because what else can they do about it? It's so wrong and upsetting. Why is always women are the punching bags? I hate the rhetoric that if they were only better parents/teachers/behavioural managers, the problem would dissolve. Stop blaming the victim. If men were being regularly beaten up in the construction industry, say, the conversation would be so different.

MangyInseam · 20/07/2022 00:42

WellThatsMeScrewed · 19/07/2022 23:50

Exclusion is not the answer but exposing other children (and teachers) to violence is also not the answer.

I also think there is a potentially a very dodgy lesson being given to our children, which is ‘you put up with any level of violence because of the perpetrators needs’. This is not a lesson I want either of my children to learn.

Yes, I think the last bit is important.

While exclusions don't necessarily in and of themselves help the child excluded, there is the bigger picture where we have a standard of behaviour kids experience and expect in school.

It affects everyone, including kids with problems, when the school community is a place where violent or really disruptive behaviour is allowed to go on. It affects everyone, including the kids with problems, when the classes are calmer and there is an expectation that everyone behaves in a way that is respectful to the group.

Classes with this stuff going on are teaching the kids lessons about how to behave and how we treat other people. That's not helpful including to kids who are struggling with their own behaviour.

Sherrystrull · 20/07/2022 00:14

It's not just the training, it's the capacity. In a large class of 30+ at primary school there is a tiny snippet of individual time I can give.

I can't talk to a child on their own in a lesson if they request it without asking for cover. I eat in my classroom so I'm available for anyone who needs me but it's far from ideal as I have marking and setting up to do plus a myriad of other things.

I would love to do more to support children but how?

Smileyaxolotl1 · 20/07/2022 00:12

Autumnalblooms

Absolutely, yet the idea of inclusion in mainstream has been pushed and pushed.

Smileyaxolotl1 · 20/07/2022 00:11

Sockwomble

yes, you’re right. I probably should have said removal to a more appropriate setting rather than exclusion. However for some children who do not have additional needs exclusion is.

we are lucky that we have a number of new schools for students with autism in my area.

Swipe left for the next trending thread