Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Calling all NHS workers!!

182 replies

Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 14:23

I apologise that this isn’t an aibu.

but I really need some clarity from some ITU workers preferably consultants or anyone who has experience there.

its nearly a year since my dad died in ITU. It was harrowing. A rollercoaster of hope and despair. I’m struggling. This has been made worse by the fact my mother is insistent that they (drs)killed him, and did all in their power to make sure he died. She says they put that line into your arm and after that you’re a goner, apparently they did it to my grandmother too. I’ve told her this is nonsense. But it’s clearly psychologically impacting me as I’m having regular nightmares.

please, is this a thing? Do you have any clue what she’s talking about? I can go into detail with what happened, it’s massively outing but I don’t care, if that helps.

(im On a wait list for grief counselling btw)

OP posts:
lifechanginglemoncake · 19/07/2022 19:50

This is my grandmother OP - she's in her mid 90s and wants every intervention going. She's convinced that they didn't do everything they could to save my Dad and we should have kept care going longer. For me, having been in ICU as a relative and seen the reality, I've told my husband the opposite - please withdraw support as soon as it looks like chances of recovery are low and quality of life would be poor.

People's reactions to the trauma are so different and the narratives they use to help cope can be completely the opposite about the same patient and the same experience.

Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 19:46

Byronalso · 19/07/2022 19:38

OP I have today sat with a family for two hours whilst we tried to answer the questions they had about why their father died.

One member of the family in particular was, in the same way as your mother, convinced my staff had euthanised him.

All I can say to you is the same as I said to her, ITU do everything in their power to keep patients alive, comfortable and to give them back to their families. This is always possible, sometimes they are just too sick. In which case we make them as comfortable as possible.

That’s what my mum says and she’s made me promise that I’d fight tooth and nail to keep her on all life support and never stop treating her because they just look to euthanise to save budget.

typing that, was really traumatic

OP posts:
BlanketsBanned · 19/07/2022 19:45

Its unusual not to be given a discharge summary on any admission, or for a gp not to be ever sent one. I dont think there would have been a dozen senior doctors working under the urologist, the urologist would be the consultant and there may have been one or two Registrars in his team. His kidney function wasnt his only medical problem if he had copd and had previously had a kidney removed for cancer.

Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 19:44

BirmaBrite · 19/07/2022 19:38

Even with a grumbling appendix I had a discharge letter, printed out and emailed to my GP, but he didn’t have a discharge summary or letter on any prior hospital admissions

Do you mean nothing was sent to his GP on discharge from any of his hospital admissions ? because if true that really is odd, it can take a while for it to turn up but for nothing to be sent ever is weird !

That’s what he’d tell me and might explain why the GP wouldn’t run tests to see his creatinine or take his BP on a regular basis. What kicked start it was a huge headache and him begging to see a dr and he was in hypertensive crisis his BP was so high due to his kidney being blocked and then he was said he needed to go to a and e and he was left for 17 hrs no food no water, no medical attention, not allowing my mum in because of covid, he collapsed in the corridor and that began the first hospitalisation

OP posts:
Byronalso · 19/07/2022 19:39

*isn’t always possible.

sorry, horrible typo failure there

Byronalso · 19/07/2022 19:38

OP I have today sat with a family for two hours whilst we tried to answer the questions they had about why their father died.

One member of the family in particular was, in the same way as your mother, convinced my staff had euthanised him.

All I can say to you is the same as I said to her, ITU do everything in their power to keep patients alive, comfortable and to give them back to their families. This is always possible, sometimes they are just too sick. In which case we make them as comfortable as possible.

BirmaBrite · 19/07/2022 19:38

Even with a grumbling appendix I had a discharge letter, printed out and emailed to my GP, but he didn’t have a discharge summary or letter on any prior hospital admissions

Do you mean nothing was sent to his GP on discharge from any of his hospital admissions ? because if true that really is odd, it can take a while for it to turn up but for nothing to be sent ever is weird !

Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 19:38

BirmaBrite · 19/07/2022 19:31

I imagine he was admitted to ITU because they believed there was something reversible that possibly could be treated despite his multiple comorbidities, so an infection in his stent or something similar. So they provided his body with the intensive support it needed whilst they tried to deal with this reversible condition, to try and give him the absolute best chance of survival.
I am glad that this gave him a few days where he felt well enough to eat and drink and have a joke and see family members. I am sorry that he died before you got chance to see him at the end Flowers.
Sometimes people rally before they die, ask any healthcare professional and they will have similar stories, it's almost as though the body chucks everything it has at living for a short while and then accepts defeat. I imagine this scenario happens as often in ITU as anywhere else.
I know you said that he had no cardiac history but COPD has a huge impact on cardiac function, there is no way for one system to be severely impacted without the other one also being impacted, the two being so interlinked.
What I am really sorry about as a nurse, is your lack of answers, because there are people who will be able to give you them and give you the peace you need.

Yes this is it! It’s all coming back to me now, it was an infection in the kidney that started all of this off from the stent being blocked or moving or something.,,; it’s what kept on sending him to hospital for months. He’d be stabilised but no one ever bothered to find the route cause, they’d drain the infection and send him on his way still with creatinine through the roof, this is where I believe balls were dropped also… it’s coming back to me now.

OP posts:
Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 19:35

LIZS · 19/07/2022 19:30

He would have been given a copy , to follow up with gp.

It’s very difficult for me to say, but when I’d ask uk he was insistent he’d not been given anything and he was asking. My mother also said he was walking out of hospital empty handed, no paper no discharge or anything.

that’s also happened to me once, a discharge plan was put in place and never followed up on, I randomly got a letter years later saying there’d been an investigation into failings and this was one of them… this is just me mind, not my dad

OP posts:
Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 19:31

ITUnurse · 19/07/2022 19:22

I have now read that your father was critically unwell to the point of needing CRRT (most often used in ITU- ‘gentle dialysis’ ).

Patients in ITU are often due to their critical illness overloaded with fluid, CRRT is one way in which fluid can be taken off (not the only function of CRRT) However, often patients are so sick that they cannot tolerate fluid removal (can cause profound hypotension, arrhythmias etc - all of which can lead to cardiac arrest).

CRRT is delivered via a renal line (usually) - an invasive line prone to clotting and infection. If CRRT is not working, it is detrimental to keep it going. This is the same for all treatments in intensive care.

All decisions to withdraw care are not taken lightly - even in a very poor icu I worked in. Multiple consultants, registrars, senior nurses and staff involved - cross speciality - often ‘behind the scenes’.

Your mother thinks if he had more time his kidney could have got better. We had a family push this, we agreed to an extension of CRRT and ITU treatment of 24 hours. The patient went into AF > SVT > VT > pulseless VT on treatment 2 hours later and died - this was despite every treatment (inotropes, electrolytes optimised, albumin, anti arrhythmic infusions, DC cardio version, adenosine to same a few) and CPR and full ALS intervention. It saddens me as a planned withdrawal of treatment could’ve been much calmer and dignified for the patient. This is why we withdraw care, to avoiding suffering.

Is that the one in the leg? His dialysis line went into his leg, femoral artery i think. That was it, the balance of the dialysis, blood pressure and breathing.

OP posts:
BirmaBrite · 19/07/2022 19:31

I imagine he was admitted to ITU because they believed there was something reversible that possibly could be treated despite his multiple comorbidities, so an infection in his stent or something similar. So they provided his body with the intensive support it needed whilst they tried to deal with this reversible condition, to try and give him the absolute best chance of survival.
I am glad that this gave him a few days where he felt well enough to eat and drink and have a joke and see family members. I am sorry that he died before you got chance to see him at the end Flowers.
Sometimes people rally before they die, ask any healthcare professional and they will have similar stories, it's almost as though the body chucks everything it has at living for a short while and then accepts defeat. I imagine this scenario happens as often in ITU as anywhere else.
I know you said that he had no cardiac history but COPD has a huge impact on cardiac function, there is no way for one system to be severely impacted without the other one also being impacted, the two being so interlinked.
What I am really sorry about as a nurse, is your lack of answers, because there are people who will be able to give you them and give you the peace you need.

LIZS · 19/07/2022 19:30

He would have been given a copy , to follow up with gp.

Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 19:29

BlanketsBanned · 19/07/2022 19:23

when he was discharged from hospital each time he would have been given a discharge letter, one would have been sent to his g.p. with any advice on what the hospital doctor thought needed to be done like blood tests or blood pressure monitoring, was he admitted to a hospital ward then transferred to ITU, if so the doctors may have explained why he needed intensive care.

Apparently there was nothing, which to me rang odd and I’m cross my mother didn’t push anyone for it if this was the case. Even with a grumbling appendix I had a discharge letter, printed out and emailed to my GP, but he didn’t have a discharge summary or letter on any prior hospital admissions, just to review with his urologist when he can, but the guy was away, so nothing came of it even though there were a dozen consultants/ registrars under him

OP posts:
ITUnurse · 19/07/2022 19:25

@HeyBlaby

whilst you aren’t wrong - they should go to a ward for most EOLC. Many hospitals don’t have ward beds available for weeks - as happens regularly at mine. We have many patients receive EOLC in ITU/HDU - not just the ones for whom it is unplanned.

BlanketsBanned · 19/07/2022 19:23

when he was discharged from hospital each time he would have been given a discharge letter, one would have been sent to his g.p. with any advice on what the hospital doctor thought needed to be done like blood tests or blood pressure monitoring, was he admitted to a hospital ward then transferred to ITU, if so the doctors may have explained why he needed intensive care.

ITUnurse · 19/07/2022 19:22

I have now read that your father was critically unwell to the point of needing CRRT (most often used in ITU- ‘gentle dialysis’ ).

Patients in ITU are often due to their critical illness overloaded with fluid, CRRT is one way in which fluid can be taken off (not the only function of CRRT) However, often patients are so sick that they cannot tolerate fluid removal (can cause profound hypotension, arrhythmias etc - all of which can lead to cardiac arrest).

CRRT is delivered via a renal line (usually) - an invasive line prone to clotting and infection. If CRRT is not working, it is detrimental to keep it going. This is the same for all treatments in intensive care.

All decisions to withdraw care are not taken lightly - even in a very poor icu I worked in. Multiple consultants, registrars, senior nurses and staff involved - cross speciality - often ‘behind the scenes’.

Your mother thinks if he had more time his kidney could have got better. We had a family push this, we agreed to an extension of CRRT and ITU treatment of 24 hours. The patient went into AF > SVT > VT > pulseless VT on treatment 2 hours later and died - this was despite every treatment (inotropes, electrolytes optimised, albumin, anti arrhythmic infusions, DC cardio version, adenosine to same a few) and CPR and full ALS intervention. It saddens me as a planned withdrawal of treatment could’ve been much calmer and dignified for the patient. This is why we withdraw care, to avoiding suffering.

Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 19:17

Topgub · 19/07/2022 19:13

@Nc4post99

I'd say its the opposite

If you don't get the counselling, no amount of info will help

I know myself though, I need both and like I said I’m on the list. I’ve called the ITU again and they’re getting someone to call me back apparently (they have a clinical psychologist apparently) but I’ve been told this before by them

OP posts:
Topgub · 19/07/2022 19:13

@Nc4post99

I'd say its the opposite

If you don't get the counselling, no amount of info will help

newbiename · 19/07/2022 19:12

bridgetjonesmassivepants · 19/07/2022 14:59

A syringe driver is used at end is stage care for terminal patients who are experiencing/are likely to experience significant pain. The driver contains powerful pain relief that is self administered by the patient to make sure they are comfortable. It is programmed so that they cannot overdose. It will not have contributed to the death of your loved one but will have made sure that they were as comfortable as possible.

The medication in syringe drivers is automatically administered over 24 hours. The patient doesn't administer it.
There is a post op pump pts can use but this is a different thing.

Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 19:11

I think at this point I need to know facts around his care, because I’m 99% that ITU staff did everything they could and his kidney was shot to shit and then I need to know facts around what happened before, or no amount of counselling can help me

OP posts:
Hoowhoowho · 19/07/2022 19:10

These are good people to talk to www.avma.org.uk if lawyer costs are beyond you.

We ultimately decided not to pursue legal action or multiple layers of complaints. The hospital said they’d referred themselves to the Ombudsman and we let it go (turns out they hadn’t!) I know people who have spent years and years going though legal and complaint processes and they don’t feel any happier for it, nor do they generally ever get answers.

We’ve chosen to live with the fact that we will never know why. To seek mental health help for the PTSD. To preserve what is strong and functional in our lives. I have two other little children now and we cannot live in the past.

the truth is for very medically fragile people like your father and my daughter who are on the edge of life, there is no slack in the system and the errors stack up and lead to deaths that perhaps were preventable but perhaps were inevitable if not then, soon. These are not cases that do well in the courts because these are people who you expect to die. Those of us left behind have to work out how to live with the questions and the reality that with such fragile margins, it’s possible at one point or another we could have changed the outcome but we’ll never really know.

For those who think quality of life decisions are somehow evidence based and unbiased, I can only point to the research that suggests strongly that medics underestimate quality of life particularly for the elderly and those with disabilities (particularly learning disabilities) and are quicker to withdraw active treatment from these patients.

ITUnurse · 19/07/2022 19:08

Hello,

I’m so sorry for your loss.

I work in an intensive care unit, I’ve worked in two in my career and one as a student.

I can assure you healthcare professionals in intensive care do not kill our patients.

In intensive care patients are the sickest in the hospital, sadly this is sometimes to the point that it is incompatible with life. Despite all efforts some patients can not survive.

Was there a withdrawal of care due to futility (either Brain stem death, hypotension so profound inotropic support is unable to manage it, hypoxia despite maximum ventilator support, proning etc to name a few - often a combination of). Sadly some patients relatives - partly because of the artificial measures keeping them ‘alive’ are not able to accept futility and think a withdrawal of care (or patient death on treatment) is intentional killing by doctors and nurses. This feeling was worsened by covid as relatives weren’t able to physically see their relatives as much.

We act in the best interests of the patients, keeping a body alive with extreme measures with no prospect of recovery and likelihood of imminent death is cruel.

I hope your mother is able to work towards feeling better.

xx

Wingedharpy · 19/07/2022 19:08

www.cruse.org.uk - self refer
www.sueryder.org - on line, free counselling.

BlanketsBanned · 19/07/2022 19:05

Your mum whould get counselling too, screaming that he was murdered is very unkind on you and serves no purpose. You cannot reason with someone who is acting this way, all you can do is look after yourself and your baby.

Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 19:02

LIZS · 19/07/2022 18:56

Your gp can refer for grief counselling.

I’m waiting, been told is a 3 yr wait list

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread