Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Calling all NHS workers!!

182 replies

Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 14:23

I apologise that this isn’t an aibu.

but I really need some clarity from some ITU workers preferably consultants or anyone who has experience there.

its nearly a year since my dad died in ITU. It was harrowing. A rollercoaster of hope and despair. I’m struggling. This has been made worse by the fact my mother is insistent that they (drs)killed him, and did all in their power to make sure he died. She says they put that line into your arm and after that you’re a goner, apparently they did it to my grandmother too. I’ve told her this is nonsense. But it’s clearly psychologically impacting me as I’m having regular nightmares.

please, is this a thing? Do you have any clue what she’s talking about? I can go into detail with what happened, it’s massively outing but I don’t care, if that helps.

(im On a wait list for grief counselling btw)

OP posts:
Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 21:40

countbackfromten · 19/07/2022 21:35

No we don’t bump people off because they are old. That is really insulting to those of us who work in intensive care and work incredibly hard to care for our patients, that care includes recognising when someone is dying and caring for them at the end of their life. That will always be one of the greatest privileges of my career.

to be clear that’s not my opinion it’s what my mother has said to me, from the moment my dad was admitted that they were trying to kill him, so sorry you feel offended by that but unfortunately it’s what she thinks and to make it worse, when he was in and out of consciousness she’d be called her friends saying they were trying to kill him and euthanise him. He was out of it but still with it enough to remember conversations the next day he knew what was happening around him and he must have been so scared hearing that. I mean, I’m a rational person and after a while hearing it has affected me

OP posts:
BirmaBrite · 19/07/2022 21:36

OP, COPD is a terminal diagnosis in that there is no cure and it gets progressively worse over time until the point of death. I look after people who are described as Palliative and many have been for a couple of years, they can be absolutely fine, just a phone call required to check in and then suddenly their disease progresses and their physical health drops off a cliff and we are talking last weeks/days of life. It isn't an exact science, I suppose it could be more exact but it would entail a lot more medicalisation and intrusion into peoples lives, which those with that sort of prognosis often don't actually want.

countbackfromten · 19/07/2022 21:35

No we don’t bump people off because they are old. That is really insulting to those of us who work in intensive care and work incredibly hard to care for our patients, that care includes recognising when someone is dying and caring for them at the end of their life. That will always be one of the greatest privileges of my career.

Newmama29 · 19/07/2022 21:35

@Nc4post99 terminal doesn’t always mean cancer OP. Terminal means that they aren’t going to get better & they will eventually die from their condition. I wasn’t trying to be rude or insensitive, more that I was just meaning that the extra stress of contacting the hospital for medical records, having debrief sessions etc. can’t be good for your own mental health or grieving process. Unless you were hoping for a lawsuit, which sounds unlikely in this case, imo I couldn’t see this stress making you feel any better about your father’s death. I agree with other posters in looking into grief counselling.

Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 21:30

Newmama29 · 19/07/2022 21:04

@Nc4post99 actually OP, he was terminal. He had terminal conditions, i.e. he was not going to be cured from. He had chronic kidney failure with one kidney left, copd, low BP which is normally a side effect of cardiac issues/failure. He was a terminally ill patient in the sense that he was never going to be cured of his conditions.

OP, you are asking for medical professions advice then are very rude with your responses. We are responding with what little information you have given us in regards to his co-morbidities so we aren’t “assuming” anything, we are using our medical knowledge to put 2 & 2 together.

I’m not being rude, I’m saying he didn’t have terminal cancer, and he wasn’t terminal when going into to ITU or prior to that admission. that’s not me saying ITU killed him but no one had ever said he was a terminal patient, on end of life care, , he obviously became terminal in ITU. I’m sure you can appreciate its super emotive, there’s no tone in messages so they can be read numerous ways, rude isn’t how I’m meaning it but your initial post even though you said you didn’t mean to be insensitive came across as such, in fact it was a bit dismissive, like what does it matter, he was terminal anyway? Sure that’s not how it was intended but rather how you can’t convey everything by post, esp when you’re not medical and your definition and mine of terminal might not align because I’m a layperson

im not asking for medical advice on his cause of death, although it’s actually helpful, so thank you but the aim of my post was just basically if ITU do bump people off or not bother because they are old

again sorry to come across rude not my intention

OP posts:
Teaandcakeordeath83 · 19/07/2022 21:28

Hi OP. I'm an NHS worker, have worked on HDU (high dependency unit so a step down from ITU) and have had the experience of my grandfather dying in ITU.

What you're going through with your mother sounds very similar to what I went through with my maternal uncle when we lost my grandad at 73 (his dad). It's long so feel free to skip ...

My grandad was a very unwell man- multiple co-morbidities, obesity, hypertension, osteoarthritis and a leaking aortic valve. He had all of his faculties though. My uncle had never really bothered with him after my nan died. Anyway, my grandad was offered an aortic valve replacement. BIG operation but he was really suffering with shortness of breath and chest pains that were impacting his daily living. He decided to go for the op and myself and my mum (a nurse with years of cardio-thoracic theatres experience) supported his wishes. I have to admit neither of us we're hopeful of the outcome but he'd made the decision to try and improve his quality of life. On the day of the op his platelets were borderline low but the consultant was happy to go ahead. We weren't too impressed but again respected grandads wishes.

It was pretty obvious within about 4-5 hours of the op start time that it wasn't going well. We couldn't get an update so we went to the hospital to wait it out. They finally managed to get him into ITU after 8 hours on the table but then had to rush him back in where he spent another 10 hours. It was an incredibly long and awful night. Eventually they stabilised him and got him back to ITU over 22 hours after his op start time. He'd been on bypass for at least 17 of those hours, had been resuscitated at least 3 times and had received 12 units of blood. He was on dialysis as his kidneys had completely shut down and the catastrophic coagulopathy that had started in theatre was still not fully under control. The cardiac consultant was admittedly useless. Terrible bedside manner, dismissed the low platelets as a mere trifle and told us that the reason it had gone badly was because of the cardiomyopathy (enlarged heart) that my grandad had. If we'd have known- or my grandad had have known about the cardiomyopathy we may well have told him the surgery was even riskier but we didn't. I mention this to show there are parallels in the care received at some points.

Anyway, the ITU staff frankly were the only staff members who were remotely honest with us in terms of prognosis (we knew it was dire) and treatment pathways they could take and affects those could have. We decided as next of kin to withdraw treatment. There was no way that any quality of life should he have survived would have been remotely acceptable. I called my uncle to tell him, offered to pay the £60 taxi fare to get him there, begged him to come. Instead he decided to call me and my mum murderers, contact the solicitors to tell them we were murdering my grandfather for financial gain and has spent the last 12 years poisoning whoever he can that we actively murdered my grandfather by withdrawing treatment when he could have survived....

It leads to madness. The path your mum is taking leads to madness- grief and regret do terrible things to people. Get tough with the hospital. If you don't get that call back from the clinical psychologist then escalate it through PALs. If your mum won't submit the SAR then type it for her and present her with your phone for her to press send if you think that information will help. The likelihood is that ITU did all they could for your dad who from your descriptions sounded gravely ill. Much like in labour with the "rest and be thankful" phase, there's a similar phase with dying. I've seen it with at least 3 close relatives and with patients I've cared for.

I hope you can find some peace and I hope your mum can too. X

Newmama29 · 19/07/2022 21:04

@Nc4post99 actually OP, he was terminal. He had terminal conditions, i.e. he was not going to be cured from. He had chronic kidney failure with one kidney left, copd, low BP which is normally a side effect of cardiac issues/failure. He was a terminally ill patient in the sense that he was never going to be cured of his conditions.

OP, you are asking for medical professions advice then are very rude with your responses. We are responding with what little information you have given us in regards to his co-morbidities so we aren’t “assuming” anything, we are using our medical knowledge to put 2 & 2 together.

Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 21:04

prettymum · 19/07/2022 21:00

Unfortunately when organs start to fail at that stage, theres so much you can do.

My brother was 38 yrs old, fit and healthy and we stayed positive for 5 months hoping he'd get better. He had days where he'd start improving which would get out hopes up and then he'd deteriorate again. At the end the team did everything they could and once he started getting multiple organ failure, they just didn't haven't anything left to give him.

When we were told he was dying, we of course were completely devastated but he put up such a strong fight and it would have been wrong to keep pushing for more treatment to prolong the suffering. The main thing was that he was comfortable, pain free and had all of us around him when he finally passed.

This will take a long time to sink in and to accept, like others have said the counselling route may be best for all to talk it through with someone not connected with everything going on. I've just started the process as we went through so much the last 6 months, it needs to be let out.

I wasn’t there when he passed, my mother had dithered talking to neighbours and on the phone that morning and then the traffic jam meant we got a call to say he was gone stuck in traffic…I don’t know if that’s a good or bad thing. When my grandmother died, I saw her after and for months anytime I’d close my eyes after it would be all I saw, my mum wanted me to stay with her until they took her away (nearly 8 hrs after death) and rigour mortise had truly set in and it was horrible

OP posts:
Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 21:00

BirmaBrite · 19/07/2022 20:32

One thing to add OP, I quite often go to patients to change the outer tubing/bag/dressing on their nephrostomy and there clearly is an issue and it isn't new, but they haven't contacted anyone, even though they can ring us 24/7. Quite often they hope the issue will resolve spontaneously, without any intervention. These are people who have usually spent quite a bit of time in hospital and really don't want to go back there, understandably, it doesn't mean they are wrong to hope.

i don’t think he had one at the time of going in on his last admission

OP posts:
prettymum · 19/07/2022 21:00

Unfortunately when organs start to fail at that stage, theres so much you can do.

My brother was 38 yrs old, fit and healthy and we stayed positive for 5 months hoping he'd get better. He had days where he'd start improving which would get out hopes up and then he'd deteriorate again. At the end the team did everything they could and once he started getting multiple organ failure, they just didn't haven't anything left to give him.

When we were told he was dying, we of course were completely devastated but he put up such a strong fight and it would have been wrong to keep pushing for more treatment to prolong the suffering. The main thing was that he was comfortable, pain free and had all of us around him when he finally passed.

This will take a long time to sink in and to accept, like others have said the counselling route may be best for all to talk it through with someone not connected with everything going on. I've just started the process as we went through so much the last 6 months, it needs to be let out.

BirmaBrite · 19/07/2022 20:32

One thing to add OP, I quite often go to patients to change the outer tubing/bag/dressing on their nephrostomy and there clearly is an issue and it isn't new, but they haven't contacted anyone, even though they can ring us 24/7. Quite often they hope the issue will resolve spontaneously, without any intervention. These are people who have usually spent quite a bit of time in hospital and really don't want to go back there, understandably, it doesn't mean they are wrong to hope.

Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 20:21

Newmama29 · 19/07/2022 20:06

I don’t mean to be insensitive but would investigating this really make any difference? Your father was a terminally ill man with multiple co-morbidities that would eventually kill him sooner rather than later. A hospital would not take up an ICU bed to ultimately kill the patient off in the end, with your father’s prognosis I’m actually surprised they admitted him to ICU in the first place. You say your father had a great day 3 days before his death? I’m a nurse & this is a very common thing to happen amongst people that are dying, we call it rallying round where I work & it’s like they get this small time frame where they seem better & use up all the energy their body has left & they usually pass away within the week. What’s happened to your family is very sad & I can’t imagine it’s easy to lose a parent or spouse but looking for blame on a hospital isn’t going to make this easier for you.

He wasn’t terminal, he didn’t have a terminal diagnosis. I understand he has several grave conditions but he wasn’t terminal you can’t make comments about ‘given his prognosis’ when you Never met him as a patient.

OP posts:
cvidnurse · 19/07/2022 20:21

I think most people have covered the hows and whys. Albeit generically, but no one here has his notes and your mum obviously prefers her own narrative (whether that be through grief of personal vendetta).

Regarding your mum wanting all treatment. While that shouldn't be a decision for you and like others said she should speak to her GP. Ultimately the decision to medically treat is the decision for the doctor treating. They always take into consideration a patients requests. But it always comes down to that doctor.

I had a patient in multi organ failure, who wanted to be resuscitated and ALL attempts made. They went into cardiac arrest, we started compressions, the doctor looked at the patients history, and yes aware the patient wanted CPR, however the chance of success was next to none. Even if it had worked the patient would have had NO quality of life.

There are lots of charities that offer counselling in a 'pay what you can afford' situation. They look at your salary and make a suggestion etc but it's down to you. May be worth looking in to.

Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 20:19

It’s difficult to understand what your mum means as it’s not clear from your posts what was or wasn’t done for your Dad, or what the exact circumstances of his death were.

admitted and they called relatives saying come down not much time. The next 24 hrs are critical. He was on BP medication because it was so low and then he was on the 24 hr dialysis and some nose oxygen And some anti bitotics

they added some anti fungal anti biotics and put another nephrostemy in and then he perked up,

then it was a fine line and then they trialled removing the dialysis to see if he could pass urine and only a tiny amount came out so they put him back on, then tried again and a bit more came and his bp was stable with no meds and his oxygen was good, then they put it in again and it fell out, and then that was the start of the end

OP posts:
Newmama29 · 19/07/2022 20:06

I don’t mean to be insensitive but would investigating this really make any difference? Your father was a terminally ill man with multiple co-morbidities that would eventually kill him sooner rather than later. A hospital would not take up an ICU bed to ultimately kill the patient off in the end, with your father’s prognosis I’m actually surprised they admitted him to ICU in the first place. You say your father had a great day 3 days before his death? I’m a nurse & this is a very common thing to happen amongst people that are dying, we call it rallying round where I work & it’s like they get this small time frame where they seem better & use up all the energy their body has left & they usually pass away within the week. What’s happened to your family is very sad & I can’t imagine it’s easy to lose a parent or spouse but looking for blame on a hospital isn’t going to make this easier for you.

BEAM123 · 19/07/2022 20:05

Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 18:31

3 days before he died he has a fantastic day, i mean amazing! They were talking about discharge to ward and how they were all wrong when they called he didn’t have long the week prior.

the next day, I could hear his breathing was watery and i knew it wasn’t good.
the following day he woke up and was joking with the nurse but then got gradually more and more out of it as the day went on and didn’t wake back up, not really, in and out of consciousness I’d say. He died the next day

OP, it is a known thing that sick people may have a very good day just before the final relapse. It's like a flickering candle that burns strongly just before it goes out.

I am so sorry for your loss and how much this is torturing you. You say your mum likes drama and it sounds to me like she is now revelling in the drama and conspiracy that maybe his care wasn't right. If she thought there was something in it, presumably she would sign a SAR that you could type out for her.
Can you mentally separate yourself from your mum's thoughts? Focus on your own health, sleep, and peace of mind plus your DC.
Then in say 3 months time decide if you still want to pursue getting the records.

When you say your mum didn't call the doctors /999 over the weekend for your dad, I assume he was also able to speak and use the phone himself? Maybe he didn't want her to call anyone and didn't want to call 999 if he could wait till Monday and see GP?

BlanketsBanned · 19/07/2022 20:02

My dear relative died of copd in ITU, it can be critical and can have a knock on effect on other organs like kidneys and the heart.

WhackingPhoenix · 19/07/2022 20:02

Your Dad had a catalogue of health conditions that affected all areas of his body. COPD puts immense strain on the whole cardiovascular system, having one poorly-functioning kidney meant his body couldn’t process its waste products effectively and his BP was sky-high; sometimes when patients are that sick, we cannot treat each isolated condition without exacerbating their other conditions. Sepsis on top of that would have wracked every organ in his body, making his already-compromised organs cease functioning entirely, which is what is meant by multiple organ failure.

That might be manageable in a very limited number of cases where the patient was ordinarily well, but in a man who was already very poorly, it was sadly unsurvivable. I can assure you that he wouldn’t have been transferred to ITU if they didn’t think there was a glimmer of hope. As HCPs, we also don’t just withdraw treatment because it’s ‘too difficult’, we only withdraw it when we are certain the patient is not going to survive as such intensive treatment is so traumatic.

It’s difficult to understand what your mum means as it’s not clear from your posts what was or wasn’t done for your Dad, or what the exact circumstances of his death were. Your Mum sounds like she is very angry and searching for someone to blame, which is quite a normal response to grief. Please seek counselling for yourself and encourage her to do the same as neither of you sound like you are coping well Flowers

I’m sorry for your loss.

Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 20:01

BlanketsBanned · 19/07/2022 19:53

If you mum feels very strongly about any future treatment she wants or does not want if she becomes unable to make those decisions she needs to speak with her g.p and not put that responsibility onto your shoulders. The doctors will take decisions based on a patients condition, they will not keep someone artifically alive in ITU if there is no chance of survival and of no benefit to her.

That’s effort though and she won’t. It’s easier to put it on me. But when I was there the drs actually said the family don’t get to make judgment calls on treatment plans, it’s actually the drs, so I don’t know what she expects me to do, probably take them to court

OP posts:
Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 20:00

Everyone medical who’s put forth their expertise, you might not know it but you’ve really helped me understand what most likely went wrong, without the hysteria of my mum crying murder. I’m in finance so medicine Is a world away from mortgages and investments, and I had no idea about a lot of these things until they’ve been mentioned by you all and them suddenly it clicks. What happened, why, why decisions were made and how common it actually is.

thank you! It’s actually sent a wave of calm over me, I was frazzled today thinking about it all, the anniversary is just around the corner and truthfully I’ve been drowning.

OP posts:
Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 19:57

BirmaBrite · 19/07/2022 19:52

Nephrostomys/stents are tricky things OP , I often have to send people to hospital from the community who have one in that isn't working, as in its completely blocked, is showing signs of infection or has fallen out completely. Essentially they are a foreign body placed to try and aid the function of a bit of the body that isn't functioning properly, but as a foreign body are at the mercy of the same vagaries as the normal biological part plus some extras due to being foreign to the body and providing a rather lovely portal for infection.

Think this is what happened @BirmaBrite !

OP posts:
Wingedharpy · 19/07/2022 19:53

Oh dear.
Your Mother has a lot to answer for here.

BlanketsBanned · 19/07/2022 19:53

If you mum feels very strongly about any future treatment she wants or does not want if she becomes unable to make those decisions she needs to speak with her g.p and not put that responsibility onto your shoulders. The doctors will take decisions based on a patients condition, they will not keep someone artifically alive in ITU if there is no chance of survival and of no benefit to her.

BirmaBrite · 19/07/2022 19:52

Nephrostomys/stents are tricky things OP , I often have to send people to hospital from the community who have one in that isn't working, as in its completely blocked, is showing signs of infection or has fallen out completely. Essentially they are a foreign body placed to try and aid the function of a bit of the body that isn't functioning properly, but as a foreign body are at the mercy of the same vagaries as the normal biological part plus some extras due to being foreign to the body and providing a rather lovely portal for infection.

Nc4post99 · 19/07/2022 19:51

BlanketsBanned · 19/07/2022 19:45

Its unusual not to be given a discharge summary on any admission, or for a gp not to be ever sent one. I dont think there would have been a dozen senior doctors working under the urologist, the urologist would be the consultant and there may have been one or two Registrars in his team. His kidney function wasnt his only medical problem if he had copd and had previously had a kidney removed for cancer.

His lead consultant, was a v famous guy who worked across several hospitals and definitely had a large department (i can’t remember if he was an oncologist or urologist sorry) withseveral other clinicians under him as he got stuck abroad due to covid. My point was, that this department didn’t exactly fall on its arse because he was unavailable, there were other people my dad could have seen. Ultimately there were hideous delays, as that consultant letter with an appointment came through apologising for the delay and with an appointment for a few days after he died

it wasn’t his only medical problem, but it was his primary one. The others (whilst I wouldn’t wish them on anyone) were a more quality of life thing rather than end of life critical, although at EOL they can’t have helped.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread