Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Avoiding mortgage Early Repayment Charge

62 replies

Mumof3confused · 19/07/2022 13:46

In the process of selling house as part of divorce. We will have 2 months worth of fixed rate left and the penalty for paying off mortgage early is £9k

The actual interest due in those two months is £1k or so. We can’t remortgage/move mortgage to one of us for various reasons but I have tried that.

Has anyone successfully managed to reduce their ERC or is that a total no-go?

The mortgage is with Santander if that makes any difference.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Perple · 20/07/2022 12:06

Fos are independent independent adjudicators but they also underuse monitoring and feedback of the behaviour of financial institutions and, as such, are a part of the breeder regime of oversight of financial institutions.

ercs are liquidated damages for breaching the cost tract by leaving early. The whole point is indeed that can’t be penalties - ie the bank can’t make a profit and be in a better off position because of the early termination than it otherwise would be.

i remain surprised that a non tapered erc has been found to be acceptable. It seems to me that the bank is unlikely to suffer a loss of £9k because of a termination two months before the end date. But indeed there may be way in which the pricing for its wholesale funding that makes it so. But it does seem odd to me.

StringersBell · 20/07/2022 11:51

FOS don’t ‘oversee’ financial institutions- they’re independent arbitrators. Decisions on the legality and fairness of ERCs are long established (both there and in the courts). They aren’t penalties they are part of the pricing structure and contract of the mortgage, so they apply regardless of when redemption occurs. Again, with it them, there wouldn’t be a lower fixed period so would pay more overall.

Reasonistreason · 20/07/2022 09:28

As I said earlier, I have a Santander mortgage with a non decreasing ERC. To be fair, my mortgage broker made this very, very clear before accepting the mortgage offer. The rate on offer was very competitive at the time. Obviously no one knows how their circumstances will change so it's a bit of a gamble.

Mumof3confused · 19/07/2022 23:28

user1471548941 · 19/07/2022 22:39

So I faced this with Santander when trying to remortgage to sole mortgage in my own name due to relationship breakdown!! They would not accept me as a single lender but also wanted to charge me 5% to move to a lender who would.

Went all the way to the Ombudsman and they found in Santander’s favour.

Ironically am now taking out a different mortgage 5 years later and specifically requested one with a reducing ERC. The broker made a joke about “oh you don’t want a Santander style ERC then”, I said “funny you should say that” and basically turns out Santander have the highest and strictest ERC in the entire market. I will never borrow from them again, they are a NIGHTMARE!

sorry I can’t be more helpful, but I would definitely delay completion if you can!

This is very similar to my situation. According to my mortgage adviser they’d lend me double what I’m asking for if only my business was at least 2 years old (I have a Ltd Co). Ironically it will be 2 years old 2 months post completion and I’ve got the accountant stating on their certificate that profits so far this year are extremely healthy with an increase on the previous very successful year. Still the computer said no because the business hasn’t been established for long enough so they have discounted that income completely instead of offering me smaller mortgage that I have asked for. I will never use Santander again for sure.

OP posts:
Mumof3confused · 19/07/2022 23:11

Please could you link to this?

OP posts:
user1471548941 · 19/07/2022 22:39

So I faced this with Santander when trying to remortgage to sole mortgage in my own name due to relationship breakdown!! They would not accept me as a single lender but also wanted to charge me 5% to move to a lender who would.

Went all the way to the Ombudsman and they found in Santander’s favour.

Ironically am now taking out a different mortgage 5 years later and specifically requested one with a reducing ERC. The broker made a joke about “oh you don’t want a Santander style ERC then”, I said “funny you should say that” and basically turns out Santander have the highest and strictest ERC in the entire market. I will never borrow from them again, they are a NIGHTMARE!

sorry I can’t be more helpful, but I would definitely delay completion if you can!

PenguinLove1 · 19/07/2022 22:31

As a pp said, you have to let their complaints process complete fully which they have 8 weeks to do, before you have the right to refer to fos, their investigations can then take months so you will not get out of this before the 8 weeks going down this route, and they will know this.

Perple · 19/07/2022 22:10

Oh I’ve just had a quick look at the omb site - frankly I’m really surprised at their position. I struggle to see how these sorts of outcomes are either fair or reasonable.

although probably not that surprised. I do
think the oversight of financial bodies in the uk is very compromised.

good luck OP - sounds like no matter what happens you’re on your way out of a crappy situation!!

Micemice · 19/07/2022 22:07

What other posters have said is correct - basically ombudsman said that the charges were advertised clearly, I accept them at point of mortgage and wasn’t a test of if was fair in terms of risk / cost etc if that make sense. Good luck with it and I hope you get a different response to me, long long process also. Worth a go tho!I had solicitor sibling using all the lingo etc in my letters but ahh to no avail!

Micemice · 19/07/2022 22:00

My lender was not on a sliding scale and Also 5% and unfortunately due to many annoying and other. Dramatic reasons I had to complete a sale 15 DAYS before the end of my fixed term and I appealed to the bank and to the ombudsman and got nowhere!!!! Paid several thousand pounds for the sake of 15 days!

StringersBell · 19/07/2022 21:51

Santander (and other big banks) won’t (settle). They know the previous legal cases and ombudsmen decisions around ERCs go in their favour.

Perple · 19/07/2022 21:36

@lookleft the early termination charge IS the pre estimate of the loss of the customer breaching the contract by leaving before the minimum term. And the parties can’t agree an etc if it is not a genuine pre estimate.

it may entirely be true that it is justified because the only reason the price could be offered was because of an etc calculated at that level - but nonetheless that is the test that will be applied to assess it.

I am surprised to hear that a non tapered etc has been considered acceptable but I don’t have detailed knowledge of how mortgage rates are calculated in this situation.

I still think it’s worth going to the omb and taking it the whoLet way - often companies will settle to avoid an omb decision

deathbollywood · 19/07/2022 20:51

Please look into and quote the consumer duty when you contact Santander

lookleft · 19/07/2022 20:46

Perple · 19/07/2022 18:21

Hmmmm. I’m not persuaded on the ombudsman front. My personal view is that it a clearly from a legal perspective not a genuine estimate of loss. I’d say it’s worth at least pushing it to ombudsman decision

You're mixing up the legal tests.

"Genuine pre estimate of loss" is the old test for it a sum being claimed upon breach of contract is a penalty (and therefore unenforceable) or not.

An early termination charge for existing a contract early (which is what we have here) isn't a sum that is payable upon breach, it's just part of the pricing formula, so the penalty test is irrelevant.

Consumer law is relevant here, but the bank charges case has already clarified that a clear and upfront fee mechanism is not unfair to consumers.

Starseeking · 19/07/2022 20:37

I'm not sure if you have the same product from Santander OP, but you'll need to refer back to your mortgage offer together with the terms and conditions. I've dug my old Santander details out and screenshot these. Despite what it says, I'm still calling that number once I complete! You may as well give it a go, and talk through options.

Good luck!

Avoiding mortgage Early Repayment Charge
Avoiding mortgage Early Repayment Charge
paulmike · 19/07/2022 19:14

I was in a very similar position recently and I took out a new smaller mortgage with the same building society, as there was less than 3 months left, the early redemption fee was waived. Check if your mortgage company does the same.

Theonewiththecandles · 19/07/2022 19:12

You'd also have to raise it as a complaint to Santander first before taking it to FOS, last I knew complaints are allowed to take up to 8 weeks for a resolution and only once you've got your resolution if you are still unhappy you can take it to FOS. By which point your mortgage rate has run its course anyway!

FudgeSundae · 19/07/2022 19:12

We went to the ombudsman over no reduction in ERC (I.e. charge at 1yr same as 4yrs) and lost. Can’t you just wait 2 months?

Starseeking · 19/07/2022 19:08

WinterMusings · 19/07/2022 17:06

@Starseeking

good luck!!! I hope they do that for you!!

I'll come back and update the thread with the outcome.

To be honest, I'm looking at that money as lost, and a bonus if I get it back. The annoying thing is I was planning to spend it on a new bathroom with the house that got away, and now this new house is smaller, needs a new bathroom and I have no money left for it!

StringersBell · 19/07/2022 18:26

Honestly, read all the previously published decisions by omndudsmen on the accepted legality and reasonableness of ERCs (bar v occasional circumstances as I said). They aren’t like bank charges and not treated as such. They aren’t considered ‘unfair’ even if they’re not tiered. As said it’s about the forward rates purchased to ‘fund’ the low rates during the ERC period.

Perple · 19/07/2022 18:24

The issue is what loss the bank suffers now because the op terminates two month earlier - which would no way be £9kive just look at the Dow website - there’s a page on erc that is worth a look - good luck!

Perple · 19/07/2022 18:21

Hmmmm. I’m not persuaded on the ombudsman front. My personal view is that it a clearly from a legal perspective not a genuine estimate of loss. I’d say it’s worth at least pushing it to ombudsman decision

StringersBell · 19/07/2022 17:40

Some bad advice on here re FOS. They don’t hold ERCs as unfair if they were clearly disclosed etc - only times they will, is if they deem you’re unfairly trapped in the mortgage (eg can’t move because of age and bank has erred in that decision). They won’t uphold just because you want to redeem the mortgage earlier, no matter how reasonable OPs case sounds on paper (if I’m wrong, please link the actual decision , they’re all published on their site).

And their queues are nuts at the moment so you won’t get a decision fast enough anyway (Santander will push for an actual Ombudsman decision, they won’t accept first stage Investigator decision if goes in OPs favour as they know the above). It may seem high but the ERCs are calculated based on the cost to the bank when it bought the funds to fix the low rate. ERCs suck but without them, wouldn’t get the low rate in first place!

napody · 19/07/2022 17:27

Wow I didn't know this about santander. Will make sure I avoid them when I remortgage.

Riverlee · 19/07/2022 17:23

We looked into paying off the mortgage early.

I did look to see if we could leave a nominal amount in the account, and have a very cheap mortgage, but we weren’t allowed to, and could only pay a certain amount as a lump sum.