Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Going on holiday with in-laws sounds like hell on earth

162 replies

WilsonMilson · 19/07/2022 12:23

Inspired by some threads I’ve read recently, I’m struck by how many people seem to take holidays with extended family, parents, in-laws, siblings and their families.

This is my idea of absolute hell.

I could just about stretch to going with my parents for a short break, but even then I’d rather not. There is no way I would entertain going abroad with my in-laws or siblings / in law siblings and their kids to a villa. Absolutely no way.

Now that I think of it, this goes for house guests too. We had my aunt and uncle to stay for a few days recently, I love them to bits but couldn’t wait for them to go so I could get my space back and my house clean and tidy again and not have to be constant hostess catering to every whim.

Is it just me? Am I just an anti social old fun sucker for enjoying DH and DS company. I love seeing family and friends, but the last thing I want is to be on holiday with them or having enforced extended inescapable contact.

OP posts:
mackthepony · 19/07/2022 13:59

Y at totally NBU.

I've had holidays with in-laws and DH family and honestly it's nothing but hard peddle. Excel spreadsheets to divide up the costs of everything, cooking for 14 people etc etc ad nauseum

Overrated

Delatron · 19/07/2022 13:57

i don’t think it makes you antisocial to not want to go in holiday with your in-laws.

We had to once as we were going to a wedding. Worst holiday of my life. I had a baby and a toddler. Yet MIL would huff and puff if the house wasn’t tidy and someone (me) hasn’t started dinner by 7.30.
She was the biggest martyr. She would sweep the outside porch!! Again huffing and puffing.

Just awful

We go with friends from time to time but I have to admit I do love just pleasing ourselves.
Not unusual I think.

Hotcrossbunnowplease · 19/07/2022 13:50

We do it with my siblings and parents, lots of similar aged cousins running around together which is very sweet. The key is to allow everyone freedom to set their own schedule, and also to agree to some basic rules in advance. For example, the siblings are in charge of kids tea, we take turns to cook it and clear up etc. Parents cook the adult meal while kids are taken upstairs for bed. But if one family bailed and went out for dinner by themselves no one would care.

FawnFrenchieMum · 19/07/2022 13:47

I'm very on the fence about it, we have a select couple of friends who we are comfortable to go away with but we always agree that we don't have to be tied at the hip. They tend to work on the same principles / timescales etc as us so it works well. We have other friends / family who we love to bits but would never dream of going away with them. Too different in styles.

We have been away with the IL's a couple of times, they had never been abroad before so probably would never have experienced it had we not have invited them. It worked really well as there was no expectations on each others times or plans once we arrived. It was just a case of we are going to do xyz at x time, they would either join us or not and same the other way.

This year we went with my parents and I've said never again, even though they go abroad several times a year alone they almost turned into children, expecting me to know / sort everything out, eg where's the toilets, what times dinner, what we doing tomorrow. Definitely not a break for me! I found this really bizarre as at home I'd much rather spend time with my mum then MIL.

Indoctro · 19/07/2022 13:43

My in laws are toxic no way on this earth would I go on holiday with them ..

Blurp · 19/07/2022 13:38

We've been on holiday with my parents and siblings (and families) and it's good because we all do separate things a lot of the time, but also take it in turns to babysit so the individual couples actually get out for lunch or dinner in peace, which is lovely.

We've also been on holiday with my ILs (DH's parents, siblings and their families) and it's not so good because they insist on everyone doing everything together, so there's a constant schedule (which often doesn't work for the younger DC) and no time alone. I don't enjoy that at all.

BuenaVistaAntisocialClub · 19/07/2022 13:38

I agree OP. I generally like people and enjoy spending time with them. But for a matter of hours not days. After socialising with people for a few hours I simply can’t do it anymore. I feel myself glazing over and just have no interest in having any more conversation. It’s like I’m ‘full up’ on people.

Going on holiday with extended family would be an endurance test - which I’d fail at miserably - rather than an enjoyable experience.

WokingOrNot · 19/07/2022 13:35

I'm about to go on holiday with my in-laws and I can't wait. And they don't even help with childcare. They're my family and holidays in my opinion are more fun in a bigger group. But the key is not to spend every minute together. We have some plans together and some separately.

Essie274 · 19/07/2022 13:35

Oh wow, I grew up going on holiday with my grandparents/aunts/uncles/cousins and they were the best holidays. I can only think of one summer holiday we took when I was a child when it was just my nuclear family. Now my cousins and I are adults and have our own children there are too many of us to make going on holiday all together very simple (or affordable), but we try to every couple of years. You've reminded me to send out a message about a trip next September.

I'd rather bathe in shit than holiday with my in-laws, though.

zafferana · 19/07/2022 13:32

YANBU to feel that way, but many of us do it out of a sense of duty. If you marry someone, you also marry their family, unless they are estranged. And part of that is often sucking up spending time with the in-laws, even if you have little/nothing in common and would prefer not to.

I've just had my in-laws to stay for 10 days and we took them to France for part of that. It was extremely hard work and I can't say that I enjoyed most of it, but I consider it to be part and parcel of being part of an extended family. On Saturday we go away with my family for five days, so DH also sucks that up.

VickyEadieofThigh · 19/07/2022 13:32

I feel the same way, OP. I can count on the fingers of two fingers the friends I would countenance going on holiday these days (others have been great friends otherwise, but not so good as holiday companions) and there are no family with whom it would occur these days.

This bit also caught my attention: "Now that I think of it, this goes for house guests too. We had my aunt and uncle to stay for a few days recently, I love them to bits but couldn’t wait for them to go so I could get my space back and my house clean and tidy again and not have to be constant hostess catering to every whim." ABSOLUTELY. We occasionally have close friends to stay but by the 3rd day I want them gone!

Mischance · 19/07/2022 13:29

Oh yes - and the gang of cousins all rampaging about and having a lovely time is just a joy to see!

The other factor is that I have a very full life on my own and so I hope none of my family feel obliged to ask me as I am so needy!

Angelinflipflops · 19/07/2022 13:28

Knottingneedles, no-one forced you to do all that work, just don't do it and relax

Angelinflipflops · 19/07/2022 13:27

I'm happy to holiday with inlaws or parents, they won't be around for ever!

UniBallEye · 19/07/2022 13:26

No way in HELL would I holiday with my parents or my-laws.
I would be miserable. And cranky. We have radically different views of what makes a good holiday.

I wish it was different or that we all gelled better as a group but it is what it is and I recognise it as so and have learnt not to try to force things.

I could do a weekend in a hotel with either side but would have enough after that.

I don't feel dd has particularly missed out but not going on 2 week holidays in a huge family gang.

We do big gatherings for in-laws a couple of times a year and it's a day long thing.

We visit mine (further away) and sometimes still make it a day trip or 1 night at most. After that we all need our own space

Mischance · 19/07/2022 13:23

Well.... I am the in-law!!!

When my DD first asked me to join them on a family holiday I accepted happily, but made it very clear that this was not setting a precedent and that I would not go into a decline if not asked again! It all went very well and we have done it a few times - but they have also holidayed on their own - indeed at the same place - knowing that I would not be miffed, but just wish them well.

On the whole we did not live in each other's pockets - mostly they would go out for the day and I would lounge about the pool, or fetch in some nice food and cook them a meal for when they returned. And sometimes I would child sit at the accommodation while DD and her OH had a jaunt on their own. So it worked fine.

This year I am treating the whole family - 14 of us - to a holiday abroad - my OH has died and a little bit of money came my way, which I am spending on the holiday as a sort of gift in memory of Dad/Grandpa.

I think these holidays can work as long as everyone's different needs are respected. I have limited mobility so big walks/jaunts are not a possibility (boo hoo), but I like to read and paint and cook and swim so I will be very content. There may be one outing that I might join, and I know that help will be forthcoming for me from all the family, but in no way would I expect them to include me in everything - it is just not appropriate. I will love to be around the family and that will be a big treat for me to be with them all.

We have made it work before and I am sure all will be well this time - I am also sure it will be total chaos!

PeanutButterOnToad · 19/07/2022 13:21

Maybe it depends on what is on offer. My son is very happy to holiday with his in-laws, they are really lovely people and the fact that they pay for business class flights and five star resorts probably doesn’t make it too much of a hardship. We can only offer an annual long weekend for the family in a nice villa in wine country with some great food but I don’t think DIL hates the weekend.

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 19/07/2022 13:20

luxxlisbon · 19/07/2022 12:54

On mumsnet people hate socialising, houseguests or holidays with anyone. In the real world people like their family, enjoy spending time with their friends and even maintain those relationships.

Exactly this

JaninaDuszejko · 19/07/2022 13:20

If we didn't have holidays with our families we'd never see them, we don't live near to them so only see them if someone hosts or we go away together. We've found going away together works best with my family because there are fewer arguments if no-one is the host (Mum gets stressed when she has guests but is a very critical guest herself), but with MIL I like her to come and visit, she's an easy house guest.

Rishiscreditcard · 19/07/2022 13:18

I agree OP, nothing I'd hate more!

Dinoteeth · 19/07/2022 13:17

I think it depends, an all inclusive hotel or a caravan park with each group having their own space meeting up doing stuff would be fine.

ILs, Bil & Sil, Sil & Bil & baby, DH & Me & Toddler. In a big house was hell on earth never to be repeated.

MIL & SIL organised it I'm sure they had dreams of one big happy family like a John Lewis Christmas advert.

SIL wanted her baby in bed before dinner, which meant dinner was far too late for my toddler. Except there was no communication that was what they were doing.
We went out to dinner one night, I said book it for 6ish - they booked the back of six - really is 6.50 the back of six ?
Then her baby cried all the way through dinner, and mine was grumpy because dinner was too late.

Never again!

JellyBellyNelly · 19/07/2022 13:15

user1487194234 · 19/07/2022 13:11

Each to their own
we have various holidays each year and one is with my parents and my siblings and their families
we love it and it means the cousins are close

My lot refer to their cousin gang.

Goodnewsday · 19/07/2022 13:14

Also the baby thing with everyone needing to take their parents, presumably for a break from the baby.. Our baby is particularly easy going I’d say but I’d still far rather go ourselves and have to push him about sleeping in a buggy at night while we have a drink than have to tie in with parents everywhere we went 🙈 it might be different if it was a bigger group of people and less intense but nah, it’s a no from me

AnnaMagnani · 19/07/2022 13:14

We used to do it when I was a child with my mum's parents.

All I can say is that my dad was an exceptionally tolerant man which was probably the only reason it worked, but even as the child being spoiled by the grandparents, after a week we'd all had enough.

Grissini50 · 19/07/2022 13:14

We are doing this this summer with in laws. I am absolutely dreading it and will likely be a mixture of enraged and bored the whole two weeks. Yes two weeks. FIL is paying and DH can't say no to him. I wasn't going to go but my daughter has guilted me into it (also I would otherwise have no holiday as this has used up our holiday budget as although FIL is paying for villa and flights we have had to pay an extortionate amount for car hire, hotel at the airport, parking, and apparently are paying for all the food). I go on holiday to get away from people. I don't get on with in laws. They bore me to tears. And have different rhythms. One SIL and her kids are very fussy eaters. The other BIL never shuts up and talks only about himself. DD will have cousins to play with but they are all boys so she gets left out. DH gets very irritated by the talkative BIL and by FIL who is stubborn and very very difficult to talk to. It is an absolute disaster waiting to happen. We managed to put it off last year due to covid but have to get it over with now. And it will never be happening again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread