Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Going on holiday with in-laws sounds like hell on earth

162 replies

WilsonMilson · 19/07/2022 12:23

Inspired by some threads I’ve read recently, I’m struck by how many people seem to take holidays with extended family, parents, in-laws, siblings and their families.

This is my idea of absolute hell.

I could just about stretch to going with my parents for a short break, but even then I’d rather not. There is no way I would entertain going abroad with my in-laws or siblings / in law siblings and their kids to a villa. Absolutely no way.

Now that I think of it, this goes for house guests too. We had my aunt and uncle to stay for a few days recently, I love them to bits but couldn’t wait for them to go so I could get my space back and my house clean and tidy again and not have to be constant hostess catering to every whim.

Is it just me? Am I just an anti social old fun sucker for enjoying DH and DS company. I love seeing family and friends, but the last thing I want is to be on holiday with them or having enforced extended inescapable contact.

OP posts:
TuxedoJunction · 19/07/2022 16:05

For me, the only way this works well is going with family/friends to an all inclusive resort. So no one needs to; shop, cook, clean, pick up after each other - everyone gets a holiday this way.

Plus you have your own space to retire to at the end of the day, or whenever you feel like it. And maybe most importantly there’s no wondering how to split bills, especially when eating out, paying for a food shop etc. These things have a tendency to get messy and people feel restful if others aren’t pulling their weight both financially and effort wise.

xogossipgirlxo · 19/07/2022 16:03

sunshineandshowers40 · 19/07/2022 15:51

Each to their own. We have been away with in-laws for special occasions a couple of times usually only 2 nights and it has been fine (they have paid). I wouldn't want to go for any longer with my family or the in laws. We like a very chilled holiday and really don't do much, given the choice I would rather it was just us especially if it was our only holiday of the year but it can't really be a surprise that some people enjoy going away with their in-laws/ parents.

I agree. I actually, would really like to like spending time with my family. I tried so many times, but I just can't do it. I saw my family in September and I have enough until 2024. I know my mum would want us to go on big family getaway, but I don't think my sister&I would want to do it. Both of us feel resentful towards mum, so I am always stressed when I have to visit her and then I recover for a long time. I know my sister feels the same, because she always texts me about insensitive things mum said to her and how upset she is.

sunshineandshowers40 · 19/07/2022 15:51

Each to their own. We have been away with in-laws for special occasions a couple of times usually only 2 nights and it has been fine (they have paid). I wouldn't want to go for any longer with my family or the in laws. We like a very chilled holiday and really don't do much, given the choice I would rather it was just us especially if it was our only holiday of the year but it can't really be a surprise that some people enjoy going away with their in-laws/ parents.

Katyrosebug · 19/07/2022 15:51

We go on holiday with BIL and SIL, they are the same ages roughly, we're all TTC, no kids yet unfortunately 😭, I'd not want to go with anyone else to be honest, it'd only because we're all so close in age ans have very similar interests that we do it

BiddyPop · 19/07/2022 15:51

YANBU

Ask me how I know that....actually, no, there is a chance it could be outing for certain family members...just believe me when I say

Y A D N B U

Proudboomer · 19/07/2022 15:43

I am on holiday with family, in-laws and extended family now. We have a 4 bed villa for 7 adults and 1 5 year old. To make it even more confusing 2 members of our party have very limited English and two of us don’t speak their language. But we are having a lovely time and only have a few days left before some of us fly home and the others will be driving back to their home country. The only slight problem is that our villa is half way up a mountain so to get anywhere we must all go in the car so it hadn’t been possible to have afternoon or evening away from the group.

twilightcafe · 19/07/2022 15:37

I've been on several breaks with PIL and had a great time.

I've been on enough holidays with BIL and SIL to know that I never want to put myself through that again. They don't like me. I've tried to get on with them but it was a waste of time.

Hbh17 · 19/07/2022 15:37

I have never and would never go on holiday with my family or in laws - and I quite like(d) my in laws (my own family are horrible).
We do holiday with one friend quite often, but a week is enough, even tho we have been best friends for 40 years. I need headspace on holiday, so even when I am on holiday with Him Indoors I try to get some time alone. For me, holidays are an important opportunity to get away from people to recharge the batteries. I also love trips away by myself - no conversation for days - total bliss!

HarlanPepper · 19/07/2022 15:35

@BiasedBinding yes! exactly. (I am a bit grumpy today)

Snog · 19/07/2022 15:31

I like holidaying with family generally but not if I end up doing the lion's share of organisation or grunt work.

BiasedBinding · 19/07/2022 15:30

HarlanPepper · 19/07/2022 15:23

Oh great, another thread where OP reassures themselves they aren't the only person not to like a thing, and argues with people who do like the thing, except it's not really a proper argument, it's just people going "i like the thing" "well, I don't like the thing" until someone leaves or dies.

It’s always framed as “am I a super special freak or is everyone else lying and really they feel the same way that I do” when actually no, it’s just normal variations of tastes and experiences

Allthegoodusernamesareused · 19/07/2022 15:30

YANBU... we've been holiday with FIL a couple of times in recent years. He has health conditions that affect his mobility and lives alone so struggles to go abroad, and we are his only family. I have a great relationship with him, but dear lord, two weeks of constantly having to wait for him to get ready, of him not wanting to do any of the same things as us (but also not wanting to be left alone) drove me nuts! We're going abroad without him this summer and he has made us feel very guilty but we need a break where we can relax.

I also do a short UK break every year with a friend and her children. They wouldn't get any sort of holiday otherwise, so i feel i have to continue, but it is exhausting as she does not 'adult' at all if there is anyone else there to do everything. Maddening.

Eeksteek · 19/07/2022 15:29

Depends on the holiday. Went on a canal boat once with BIL. It was awful. I had no desire to drive the bloody thing, but was happy to cook. They thought we should all take turns at everything. DH and I wanted to meander from pub to pub, with nice walks and stops to sunbathe and read. They wanted to drive, drove, drive and do lock staircases and to motor as far and fast as possible from where we started. DSIL complained that she was stuck with all the driving (but was the one who wanted to go such a long way)
Nobody was happy. The following year we went skiing. Ate out all the time, they got up early and went adventuring on all day black runs.
I wandered out later to ski school and joined them for the odd red. I simply declined anything I didn’t want to do and sometimes even spent afternoons in the spa.
Of course, they were miffed because obviously only they knew how to have a good time, but they couldn’t make me go and I didn’t.
DH sometimes went with them and sometimes with me. Everybody was happy (they are all better skiers than me. What’s fun for them is hard work and often painful for me. They thought I should work harder to get better. I said ‘fuck off, I’m on holiday’. DH enjoyed the challenges with them. I was totally happy dipping in and out)

OTOH I love going to festivals with people and piggybacking on their good taste in and enthusiasm for music, as left to my devices I’ve never heard of anyone and just wander around getting lost and missing anything good. Absolutely love camping with family, but also refuse to do things that don’t work for us now. They like to take their boys to a pub to watch the rugby. Taking toddler (at the time) DD to a pub where she will neither eat nor drink (only drinks water!) I can’t drink because I’m on my own and always have to drive and entertaining her for 80 minutes of rugby neither of us are interested in a pub is no fun at all. They also liked paid activities that got their kids out of their hair, but mine is younger and needs more help, so it was not fun for me having to them with her, if she was allowed. They’d pitch in, to be fair to them, but it’s not the same. I had to go swimming.
They’d just chuck the kids in and open the wine poolside. Whereas mine was happy playing in a stream with a stick.

Parents are another matter. Mum lives abroad and I don’t visit now. I don’t love her country, and she lives in the middle of nowhere with nowhere to go and nothing to do in a completely un-child friendly building site on the side of a mountain with no heating. If we go she drags us round endless smoky bars with awful food and her equally awful friends. It’s too far to drive, given that I don’t want to go anyway, and if I fly, her husband has to drive us everywhere and he drinks and then expects to drive us home. The first time I went they had a land rover with only two seats and expected us to travel with no seats, let alone belts, in the back!
She’s got no toys or kid equipment so something like the beach is a nightmare. They won’t pay for anything like umberellas and think you can just chill in a café in the shade during the hottest part of the day (with a toddler). They think I should just smack DD if she can’t cope with their very adult lifestyle, and won’t make any accommodations. The second time I went (she bought us tickets for Christmas) she did hire a car and I could drive (and never drink!) It still sucked. If she comes here she treats the place like a hotel and just books tons of appointments and social things, with hardly any time for us, DD is massively wound up and then disappointed (in term time. She won’t come in the holidays, as the flights are more expensive) expects lifts to and from the airport in the middle of the night (I’m a single parent FFS!) and it’s hugely disruptive to our routine, which is a struggle for us anyway. She borrows my car all the time, leaves her washing and gets billions of parcels delivered weeks beforehand (not just little things. I once had a fucking trailer arrive!). It makes me feel like I’m parenting them, and I’m not up for it. In future she will be welcome to stay as long as she likes. In school holidays. In fairness, I have not yet had this conversation. I would like to approach it tactfully and proactively and invite her for specific activities or holidays here, but I’m too broke atm. In practice she will likely push the boundaries until I put my foot down. She’s like that. There no malice in her, she just has no boundaries and assumes no one else does either.

LuckySantangelo35 · 19/07/2022 15:29

@WilsonMilson

“Am I just an anti social old fun sucker for enjoying DH and DS company”

yes. Yes you are

very boring

also remember that one day your ds will be grown and have his own life and/or your DH could die or leave you. You should try and learn to enjoy other people’s company as well as theirs

HarlanPepper · 19/07/2022 15:23

Oh great, another thread where OP reassures themselves they aren't the only person not to like a thing, and argues with people who do like the thing, except it's not really a proper argument, it's just people going "i like the thing" "well, I don't like the thing" until someone leaves or dies.

xogossipgirlxo · 19/07/2022 15:22

No, it's not just you. I would never agree to go on holidays with my parents, sister or in-laws etc. Never. They are family, so obviously I keep in touch with them, visit them, but mostly because I have to (because tHeYr'E fAmIlY🤐), not because I enjoy it.

balalake · 19/07/2022 15:22

Depends on the holiday in my opinion. A city break in autumn or winter is very different from two weeks on a Spanish or Greek beach.

BiasedBinding · 19/07/2022 15:15

TheGraceFace · 19/07/2022 15:13

I know a few families who always go away together. I’m wondering if it’s because they’re afraid to go it alone. Or some couples can’t cope with each other, so they need this. I’ve been with siblings in the past but it wasn’t enjoyable as they thought we had to do everything they wanted to do, & spend every minute of the day together. It’s my worst mare, I go on holiday to get away from everyone.

No it
isnt about being afraid to go alone. Have you not read the thread? Some people have families where it works well, others don’t. Clearly it doesn’t work for you. I think you’re completely normal so why don’t you think people who do things differently might be doing so out of genuine enjoyment?

TheGraceFace · 19/07/2022 15:13

I know a few families who always go away together. I’m wondering if it’s because they’re afraid to go it alone. Or some couples can’t cope with each other, so they need this. I’ve been with siblings in the past but it wasn’t enjoyable as they thought we had to do everything they wanted to do, & spend every minute of the day together. It’s my worst mare, I go on holiday to get away from everyone.

OceanbreezeSun · 19/07/2022 15:11

We have been on a couple of big family holidays abroad (around 12 people!) including young kids. We stayed in a big villa and it was great because we did our own thing during the day, some of us went to the beach, others went exploring the local town. We didn’t have to do everything together but it was lovely spending time with everyone, big breakfasts and evening dinners /bbqs sat out in the garden. Lots of good memories.
Dh, Dd and I also go on short camping breaks with my parents (in the UK) a couple of times a year, which are always fun. Dd is happy with a big field to play in!

I wouldn’t enjoy going on holiday with mil or dhs stepdad because they are the type of people who would expect to do everything together & mil would think something was wrong if we wanted to do something separately. We get on fine, but I definitely don’t want to go on holiday with them & fortunately it’s never come up in all the years we’ve been together.

Arthursmom · 19/07/2022 15:10

We did this. It was great for childcare. Everyone had their own space and did our own thing. We had a few dinners together and gps watched the kids

LadyApplejack · 19/07/2022 15:10

We've been with my parents and siblings twice. Parents paid for a big villa with private pool/games etc, and everyone mucked in with my kids to allow DH and I a break. We're close so it was very fun and chilled! I wouldn't choose to do it for every holiday though.

Id never go with in-laws. It'd feel far too guarded/polite/formal. We're nowhere near close enough to be half naked sunbathing and waking up under one roof all week! It'd be a totally stressful, giant chore. And they wouldn't have the kids, so we'd be with them constantly in return for no quality time with DH. Literally no benefit!

aSofaNearYou · 19/07/2022 15:09

I love going on holiday with my family, but being honest I wouldn't be overly keen on going with my DPs.

But they don't really seem to do it much, anyway, whereas mine do.

Allthegoodnamestakken · 19/07/2022 15:08

I semi agree with you and semi agree with some pp posters. It is only manageable if you all have enough space and nobody is insisting everyone has to do everything. That is the key, if somebody fancies a walk they go on one, others can read by the pool, some people may head to a local attraction etc. usually we would all meet up for dinner in the evening but even that is flexible with the exception of a few nights when a baby sitter has been booked along with a fancy local restaurant.
If everyone is able to come and go and enjoy each others company as they please it works great. I couldn't cope with the described holidays where theirs a schedule of who's cooking what, where you're going that day etc.

Amybelle88 · 19/07/2022 15:03

I would rather shit in my hands and clap, but that's including one side of my family, too.

My mum has been away with us a few times and we enjoy that, so does she - she's so much fun, kids love her. We are lucky. I've got some cousins who I'd love to go away with, but my in laws bar my brother and law and nieces, absolutely not. The thought makes me shiver 😂🤦🏻‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread