Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New Job and annual leave help me decide

34 replies

appls · 19/07/2022 01:09

Please help me decide what is reasonable.

I worked in a job (job A) which I hated for 20,500 a year (frontline and dangerous job with rubbish management). I was headhunted and seconded to a role in the same company for a year which I loved and paid 22,300 and was able to mostly WFH.

Secondment is now ending and I do not want to return to job A.

I have now been offered a new job (Job B) in a different company with a salary of 26500. To start mid august. It is a more senior position and has more job progression. Less flexibility as no WFH. I have accepted this job.

However. I realised today.

Annual leave in my current job runs from 1 April - 31 March. I get 35 days. I have used 30 already due to child illness and a family bereavement as well as normal time off for things such as in the school holidays.

Therefore when I leave on 12 August I will actually owe the company money and not get paid. The new job won't pay me til end September as I miss their payroll date when I start.

So my choice is this:

Return to job A until early next year so that I don't owe them anything. This means losing almost 2k a year and I will struggle to pay my bills each month. There is a small chance of other teams in the company recruiting and I may be able to switch roles but it will be the same or very similar salary.

Take the new job and have no money at all in august and potentially owe hundreds to my old employer. I will ultimately end up better off once this is repaid as the salary is 6k higher than what I'd get by staying.

There's no option of a loan or credit of any kind as my credit score is in the bin (husband was mentally unwell. Took out a lot of debt and then ended his life, the debt was in his name but some in mine and some in ours, all defaulted etc)

No family or friends who can loan me money. Nothing to sell. No chance of working extra as I'd be paying childcare (I don't have family. Friends live too far away)

So essentially no money until end sept apart from tax credits which is £400 a month (low due to overpayment that I disputed but that's another story) This wouldn't even cover the mortgage.

Any advice?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
appls · 19/07/2022 14:08

I only get tax credits so unfortunately can't get any bridging loans or anything. Not eligible for anything else, as I earn too much (which is ridiculous as I don't earn a lot!)

OP posts:
123becauseicouldntthinkofone · 19/07/2022 14:03

If you claim benefits do they not do bridging loans or hardship loans anymore where you can pay back over time? i know they used to but maybe worthwhile at least looking into

appls · 19/07/2022 14:03

Also in terms of annual leave, we can use it whenever we want which is how this problem occurred!

I took 11 days in April as my daughter had covid, I took 8 days in june for a bereavement as I had to travel abroad, I took 2 days in July when my eldest was unwell and then 9 days in May which I think was for a holiday. So that's 30, and I have 5 remaining until April

We do get a lot of annual leave in that job. But now I'm in this position!

OP posts:
appls · 19/07/2022 13:59

Thanks everyone. I found our pay day in the new job is the 25th, so I'm not sure when they do payroll?

Old job payday is 19th. I get paid on the 19th for the entire month (so technically paid 2 weeks in advance)

I will mention to HR about paying back in installments as I think they will definitely take it from August's salary without asking (it is in the contract they can do this)

I have kept up with the mortgage as it's a lot smaller due to moving house after husband died. He died 5 years ago today, so things are very settled but equally very difficult- I don't have any family. So childcare is just me Lol.

I also feel bad as holiday club is 8-4 and my working hours are 830-430 and it's a 30 min drive, so I will have to ask my employer to leave an hour early until DD goes back to school in September. I feel like they will think I'm too awkward to employ?

Thank you for the mortgage payment holiday idea, I will call them now

OP posts:
ThreeLittleDots · 19/07/2022 13:28

Ah sorry - didn't read properly - there's no break. Agree with PPs to take new job and let the bills slide on this one occasion. You can ask for a mortgage payment break and agree terms with your utilities suppliers and council tax.

ThreeLittleDots · 19/07/2022 13:26

Option B (new job) and do temping work in the meantime.

FinallyHere · 19/07/2022 13:23

And negotiate paying existing company back for the holiday you have already taken. Worth a try.

FinallyHere · 19/07/2022 13:22

Congratulations on the new better job. Another vote for going for it and talking to them about an advance on pay. Totally standard.

Plexie · 19/07/2022 11:22

OP is due to leave current job on 12 August, so won't accrue much (if any) leave entitlement for August. Her entitlement for April-end July is probably around 11.5 days, so she owes around 18.5 days, almost a month's salary.

Depending on when she resigned and when her current employers run their payroll, she might get nothing in August and be due to pay back money, or they may deduct the whole amount across July and August's salary payments.

If you can afford the gap between salary payments and go with Job B, do as others have suggested and ask current employer if you can pay back at a later date or in instalments. Ask new employer if they can make an out-of-cycle payment to cover you for work done in August. You don't have to go into detail - just explain that you've leaving current employer at the beginning of August and it will be financially difficult to be without income until the end of September. It's not an uncommon request. In my experience payroll are reluctant if it's a short period (eg 1 week) but in your case it will be 2.5 weeks so they be more amenable.

Assuming their payroll cycle is a calendar month, you probably won't get the one-off payment until early September (they'll probably wait until you've actually worked the days in August).

Welshrarebitontoast · 19/07/2022 10:51

Job B, and I'd make it work.

How often do opportunities come up and how much would you regret not going for it?

Insidelaurashead · 19/07/2022 10:04

Agree with ring mortgage company and ask for a couple of months payment holiday. Ring utilities too and ask for the same, especially if in credit anyway. Go through cupboards, fridge and freezer, work out as many meals as you can with the food you already have in. Do you have a slow cooker? I've made a veg soup using two bags of frozen veg, it's done 10 meals for about 2 quid so potentially you could do a couple of things like that to really push you through the few weeks of being skint?

TheTeenageYears · 19/07/2022 07:45

I would ask new company if they can organise a one off payment at the end of August. Presuming you start on 15th August you must only just miss their payroll cut off date and will still work more days in the month than not. I would also try and negotiate the used holiday entitlement at current company down and repay over several months.

RhymesWithAntelope · 19/07/2022 07:43

I'd keep the request quite vague rather than saying you've used 6 weeks holiday in 15/16 weeks.

I agree with pp that you should do a double pronged approach - ask your current employer for time to pay back.

figmaofmyimagination · 19/07/2022 07:34

sorryiasked · 19/07/2022 06:28

Stick with job B. Ask them if it would be possible to be paid an advance due to payroll date issue.
Ask current job if you can pay back owed holiday pay in three instalments starting September, rather than having it deducted.
If you explain re hardship I would hope that both employers would try and assist.

This.

Jessbow · 19/07/2022 07:31

How will you manage the new job if its less flexible? Alreadyyou have needed to take ( i would say) an extreme ammount of time off in 4 months.

BarbaraofSeville · 19/07/2022 07:27

Oh dear, you've had a hard time up to now Flowers

Take job B. Ask for an advance of some money to tide you over for essentials until you get paid. That's very standard, don't worry about that and don't over explain.

Make an arrangement to pay back what you owe with job A over as long a period as possible. Short of with holding what pay they do owe you, they probably can't do much to recover money you owe them, short of taking you to court, and they probably wouldn't do that.

Cancel any non essential direct debits you can get away with not paying, ie not mortgage or council tax. I don't suppose you are in credit in your energy account and can ask for the money to be returned?

No Nectar points or similar floating around that you can use to buy food?
As an aside, have you had help dealing with the debt, from an independent non profit organisation like Stepchange or Christians Against Poverty? Is it all currently still defaulted, ie not settled?

But have you managed to keep up with the mortgage throughout all this? Did he have life insurance? Have you done a new benefit check as a widowed parent and did you claim widowed parents allowance? Sorry, so many questions, but it's one of those things where there's lots to consider and things that might be able to be done to make things easier for you.

Ontomatopea · 19/07/2022 07:01

Take new job. Ask for mortgage holiday of one month.

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 19/07/2022 06:58

I would be a little wary of highlighting the amount of holiday time over-taken and poor credit history to a potential employer. Good first imprssions and all that

The salaries involved suggest that the OP isn't applying for a high level management position where negotiation is expected

Santorini22 · 19/07/2022 06:55

What is your plan regarding the less flexibility of job B?

BalloonsAndWhistles · 19/07/2022 06:54

Ouch. Just a quick question, how much better off are you actually going to be with the higher paid job? You’re going to have to pay some sort of childcare I assume/your tax credits will reduce/fuel or train/bus to get to work. If the numbers work then go for the higher paid job. If you aren’t any better off, or only better off by a couple of quid a month, I’d stay put until the kids are older.

BackInMarch2020PreCovid · 19/07/2022 06:54

Occasionally, if you’re new company really want you, you may be able to negotiate a “hello” package to pay off what you owe.

if you express the situation to the hiring manager that you may have to decline the offer, and they really really want you, they should do something to ease the situation, be that pay for the holiday you’ve overtaken, or previous poster said, do an additional BACS run and pay you early.

Ask the question and then make a decision. I would personally always go for the higher paid job, but word of advice for the future, never accept the first offer - negotiate negotiate negotiate - salary, holiday, benefits, hours etc.

DogDaysNeverEnd · 19/07/2022 06:48

Are there no other opportunities in the first company? You'd be amazed what turns up when you say you have an offer elsewhere, so worth asking if you have a good reputation where you are.

Have you taken tax and ni into account working out the difference between the new and old job? Put the gross amount into an online calculator to get the take-home. The increase might not be as big as it looks, but the job progression opportunities are worth something, but so is flexibility. Tough call, I hope you can make it work for you.

Plastichanger · 19/07/2022 06:47

Check your contract and company handbook etc to see whether there is a specific clause in writing allowing them to claw back and holiday pay when you leave - they can only take most of it off your final pay if it is in writing.

if they can take it back then ask if you can pay them back in instalments and ask new employer for an advance on pay in august.

Northe · 19/07/2022 06:46

You may not be able to get credit per se but if you call your mortgage lender and ask for a payment holiday, it would not be uncommon for them to allow 1-3 months break in payments added to the mortgage value. Call and explain - they would likely rather this than for you to be unable to pay in an unplanned way.

SafelySoftly · 19/07/2022 06:39

Your current employer seems very understanding. It’s not normal
to allow someone to use up so much leave (appreciate you have extenuating circumstances) but any idea on new employer B will be the same? Worth considering - if you have goodwill from employer A that can be worth lots of £££.

Swipe left for the next trending thread