Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you'd do when hurt & let down by brothers?

61 replies

buckeejit · 18/07/2022 21:31

Background - I come from a family of 3 brothers & me. A staunch Presbyterian upbringing means imo all the brothers are repressed, (I probably am somewhat also, but am basically the black sheep that went off the rails a little)

We don’t have a lot in common but exchange birthday cards & usually the same amount of money gets put in an envelope & passed round for each sibling & spouse’s birthday.

Our mum was diagnosed with a brain tumour a year ago & died at the end of the year. Everyone pitched in somewhat with caring for her at home until she died, (the boys didn’t do any personal care or cooking-the wives helped with that).

2.5 months ago my dd (was 8-just turned 9), was diagnosed with a chronic illness. She is often in a lot of pain & now on a ton of meds with a lot of awful side effects. It’s been really traumatic for me to come to try to come to terms with this diagnosis & am very anxious about her future & grieving the easy & normal childhood I had hoped for her.

My dad communicated the diagnosis to the brothers & their wives & has since updated them on the struggles since.

Eldest & youngest brothers have no dc & I don’t expect them to know much about the illness. Both them & the wives are very churchy people & often fall over themselves to help other people in need. None of them have made the simple effort in all this time to even text to say ‘sorry to hear about the diagnosis/thinking of you/how are you/dd’. I’ve seen them all in person since - at a family funeral & one other time separately since-no mention of dd. Middle brother & wife (with dc), has made contact & shown some concern.

I really cannot understand what kind of thought process someone has to just ignore this issue. Surely you don't need dc to understand that this would be a difficult time?

I don’t know whether to make contact to say how hurt I am or just to cut what little contact we have. I have a lot of other stuff going on atm but this issue is taking up a monumental amount of headspace & I’m not sure what to do about it so would appreciate any advice.

Thanks for reading this ramble.

OP posts:
Itsbackagain · 20/07/2022 15:18

I would assume hearing the news second hand that you didn't want to talk about it so I wouldn't mention it either. Maybe speak to them yourself and let them know it's ok to ask. I wouldn't tell them you're hurt in case they've assumed as I would - that makes it into an issue it actually might not be.

Ahnobother · 20/07/2022 14:59

Hi OP,
Hope your daughter is doing ok - I have a girl the same age.
I'm from similar background although my parents were the ones who left the church behind. I think it's a world that can be all consuming and unfortunately that can leave out others even if they are family.
I'd take onboard the advice others have given you on removing bits of your text but I would add early on 'this has been a shock to DD and us because of the discomfort and potential complications she now has to manage for the rest of her life'. (Apologies if that isn't quite the right wording as I don't have a total understanding of UC apart from knowing a friend who has it). This might help them see it more from your perspective.
Wishing you good luck.

buckeejit · 20/07/2022 14:47

I meant leave out the bit about not knowing why they haven't asked. I can just remove the supportive friends bit-just wanted to add something positive & clutching at straws

OP posts:
nca · 20/07/2022 14:45

If you want to find out what's going on tbh you'd be better ringing them or seeing them face to face. Tone doesn't translate well to text

buckeejit · 20/07/2022 14:45

I guess I could leave it out & then add it back in to my next message depending on their responses

OP posts:
nca · 20/07/2022 14:44

I agree it's a bit passive aggressive.

The bit about being grateful for having supportive friends would make me go "well that's me told. She doesn't want anything to do with me"

buckeejit · 20/07/2022 14:43

Thanks @MRex. I'll remove the last bit about not sending further updates but why they haven't asked is really important for me to understand so I want to leave that or something like it in.

Agree my dad is minimising. We were brought up in a 'don't make a fuss' house I guess. When we were ending the call last night he felt the need to say 'remember it's not about you or your siblings it's about dd'. Like my feelings should be dismissed.

OP posts:
Gymnopedie · 20/07/2022 14:41

On the whole it's fine. Detailed enough for them to see what's going on, but not a blow by blow account of her symptoms and treatment.

But leave out this bit: I’m not sure what your reasons are for not asking after her since the diagnosis but thought I’d give you an update anyway. Without that it just sounds quite friendly and assumes they're interested and would want to know. Then make a judgement call based on their response or lack of.

MRex · 20/07/2022 14:23

It does sound a bit angry, bits like "I’m not sure what your reasons are for not asking after her since the diagnosis but thought I’d give you an update anyway." and "I won’t send further updates but"' are passive aggressive. Remove those and you are giving them an update assuming that they care. It's much easier for them to them respond positively to you than if you push them onto the back foot with digs. However much you feel it's justified, that would more likely push them away.

Your dad sounds a bit defensive, I'd lay bets he's minimised the severity significantly. They may believe it is mild and under control. Go gently and hopefully they will understand more so that they step up to help you.

buckeejit · 20/07/2022 13:02

Thanks all. Having slept on it, I definitely don't want anyone else saying anything to them. My dad called straight after my counselling session last night & I unintentionally blurted it all out to him, although he was already somewhat aware. He couldn't quite articulate his reasons why he thought they hadn't reached out. The closest he got was 'they're maybe embarrassed, but not embarrassed....'

Anyway I've drafted this text to send them later & would appreciate opinions on whether the words & tone come across as ok. I've left out feeling hurt for now as I understand that them viewing it as an attack of sorts won't contribute to useful discourse.

Hope you’re both well. Just thought I’d update you on Dd. I’m not sure what your reasons are for not asking after her since the diagnosis but thought I’d give you an update anyway. She’s doing ok at the minute though up & down. Not sure how much you know about ulcerative colitis, (we knew/know very little), but it’s a complicated lifelong illness that is unpredictable & often painful. She’s on some medications to hopefully get her into remission, (where the inflammation in her gut is under control & symptoms of the disease improve). It can take months or years to find the right combination of medications & most of them can have unpleasant side effects, as well as making her immunocompromised, which is an additional worry for us.
We’re hopeful that the latest meds will work & we’re grateful that she is being a real trooper with everything & to have supportive friends. Just wanted to make sure you were aware of what’s going on. I won’t send further updates but please do shout if you’ve any questions. Take care now.

I think I'm better just to send to the brothers & leave sil out of it. Any advice appreciated-I'm already feeling better about

OP posts:
Jenny70 · 20/07/2022 06:51

Can you talk to middle brother (or wife) to say that you are hurt that neither brother A or Z have shown any care or offered support, not been in touch at all... maybe even ask if he has heard whether they are OK, as seems so inconsiderate to show absolutely no interest or care that maybe they are engulfed by some other personal drama?

nca · 20/07/2022 05:53

buckeejit · 19/07/2022 23:27

Ah I see, thanks.

No, I can be sure my dad has no desire to control the narrative, will just pass on information on how dd has been. He's a peacekeeper though & wants to keep everyone upbeat so may add in that she's keeping upbeat or similar, but only after passing on the bare facts.

I know what you mean about Presbyterian women controlling the narrative though!

It's still not the same as you talking to them directly. It puts a distance

paisley256 · 20/07/2022 00:05

K8Shrop I know a few people like that, where they fall over themselves to help those in need, when they've an audience. But are never there for those closest to them. It's a real shame.

Yes, I do too. And it's this that really hurts. Like they can turn on the empathy when it suits them.

If they do know the facts, and it appears they do as your dad told them, then it's a huge let down that they've not reached out to you.

If you feel able, then I'd tell them you're disappointed that they haven't asked after your daughter, especially as they are always keen to help others.

It might not change anything but it might make you feel better, even in a small way.

Whatalovelydaffodil · 19/07/2022 23:53

nca · 19/07/2022 12:35

Can you talk to your brothers directly rather than through your dad?

Yes. They might think that you don't want to talk about it as you let/asked your dad tell them.

K8Shrop · 19/07/2022 23:43

I know a few people like that, where they fall over themselves to help those in need, when they've an audience. But are never there for those closest to them. It's a real shame.

It may be harsh, but tbh to me I think it's a sign of narcissism. They want to help, but they want to help on their terms, and get the credit for it. As you're their sister, they can't just help and get praise, they'd need to continuously be there, with you and your child being the main focus, and not so much any focus on their actions. So they just don't bother. They don't get anything out of helping you - gives them no satisfaction and they can't use it to make themselves feel better about themselves, too much hard work in your case as it wouldn't be an easy fix eg, organising a fundraiser, food collection and drop offs, etc etc.

Perhaps I am too much of a negative Nancy but that's just my thoughts based on the people I know who would do similar. It's a real shame. Sorry it has upset you, try to just focus all your energy on your daughter. They don't deserve an ounce of your time.

buckeejit · 19/07/2022 23:27

Ah I see, thanks.

No, I can be sure my dad has no desire to control the narrative, will just pass on information on how dd has been. He's a peacekeeper though & wants to keep everyone upbeat so may add in that she's keeping upbeat or similar, but only after passing on the bare facts.

I know what you mean about Presbyterian women controlling the narrative though!

OP posts:
nca · 19/07/2022 22:47

Just. You don't know what your brothers have been told and how it's been put across to them. Until you've had an actual conversation with them directly I wouldn't get into hurt or not hurt you know? You don't know what they think you want - I just know what my mum was like for wanting to control the narrative and it causes issues for me with my brothers that we don't have at all now that we communicate directly.

buckeejit · 19/07/2022 22:35

@nca just reflecting on this & wondering from your perspective why you wouldn't say you were hurt? Has the Presbyterian angle got an influence?

OP posts:
Meraas · 19/07/2022 13:30

I think you should absolutely tell your brothers how hurt you are and how much you would appreciate their support.

If they don't step up, then step back from them.

buckeejit · 19/07/2022 13:25

Thanks - that's good responses & plenty for me to think about.

I know what you mean about interpreting things, although I do know sil well enough to know that's what she meant & dad confirmed it when he said he replied 'well I don't really know, I suppose we just have to trust the experts'

Having said this I don't think either that they're completely uncaring. I'm just baffled. Will certainly think about these different viewpoints before deciding what to do.

OP posts:
Fenella123 · 19/07/2022 13:23

My take is that them messaging you to say how sorry they are just takes precious time away from your day when you need all your time and energy to devote to your DC.

Question. Is there practical help that you could or would reasonably ask them for?
If yes, contact them, say you don't know how much detail your Dad passed on, but, here is the situation, and you are asking for help, namely (whatever).
If not - tbh it doesn't matter what they think or do, does it? Worrying about not getting a "sorry this has happened" from brothers you're not at all close with, is "hoovering behind the wardrobe" - a way of thinking about anything but the real issue, which is your DD's poor health. And there have GOT to better and less upsetting distraction techniques than that!

Mally100 · 19/07/2022 13:21

Your brothers are a product of their upbringing and you all don't seem close at all, why do you expect more from them. Sometimes it is easier to avoid the very link or connection to an unhappy childhood (each other) and function normally with everyone else. Nothing you say will make them suddenly change, you can't force something that's not there in the first place.

bluebell34567 · 19/07/2022 13:14

whether to make contact to say how hurt I am i would definitely do that.

MRex · 19/07/2022 13:10

I don't think asking what medications are for implies that they aren't needed, more like just asking for details; to understand if it should fix a condition, or relieve pain, or prevent it getting worse etc. It's a bit confusing why you're getting annoyed about supposed responses to your dad, when you weren't there and are just interpreting. I don't think it will help to jump into conversations being hurt and annoyed, how about just letting them know the real situation with "I don't know how much dad has said" at the start. If they don't care when they hear she is in pain, then it makes sense to cut contact and you have clear reasons. If there's specific support you want, then ask for it, rather than assuming they'll figure it out. If they let you down when you've been clear, then again you'll know where you stand.

nca · 19/07/2022 12:59

I wouldn't say you were hurt.

I'm just thinking about my own relationship with my brothers (also Presbyterian) and weirdly how much it's improved since my mum died and we communicate directly with each other.