Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy a yoghurt maker?

32 replies

User280905 · 18/07/2022 18:34

While walking round an air-conditioned supermarket today I was thinking about what changes I could make.
We eat lots of yoghurt. Lots of plastic pots and lids, often wrapped in packs of 6 for extra plastic.
WIBU to try to make my own? Would I just be buying another gadget that would end up unused in our cupboard? Would the kids eat home-made yoghurt? They do eat natural yoghurt, sometimes with honey in, so it doesn't have to be fancy fruity yougurts or anything.
Pleae tell me your yoghurt making experiences before I buy something pointless.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
bushtailadventures · 04/09/2022 11:13

I have a cheap electric pressure cooker that I use just for yoghurt, but we are a family of adults so I make 5 litres a time. Just put in a couple of tablespoons of live yoghurt, 5 cartons of UHT milk and a couple of tablespoons of milk powder, use the yoghurt program on the pressure cooker, and then I put the inner pot straight into the fridge. I strain mine because I like it thick, but other people spoon it straight out of the pot. I make a couple of pots a week, dread to think ow much it would cost me if I was buying that much.

Saltyandvinegar · 04/09/2022 10:56

Love my homemade yoghurt in my ninja foodi. So easy. I use really good full fat milk. If you prefer greek yoghurt you only have to strain the yoghurt using a tea towel in a colander.

User478 · 04/09/2022 10:47

If you do it in your instant pot you need to change the seal and super clean the pot and lid or your yogurt tastes like cumin.

Treaclemine · 04/09/2022 10:36

I have made it using a pint wide mouthed thermos or similar. Pour in the contents of a tin of evaporated milk and top up with boiled water. Add a tablespoon of bought starter, put the lid on and leave overnight , or for long enough. Then refrigerate.

Gatekeeper · 04/09/2022 10:03

I make ours in the slow cooker using a 2l bottle of whole milk and store it afterwards in 1l glass container. Its fab and has improved my guts no end

ErrolTheDragon · 04/09/2022 10:00

I was making yogurt all through lockdown. The only reason I'm not doing it now is that DH is the main yogurt eater and he prefers Greek.

We have a simple yogurt maker bought from Lakeland years ago (not the 'easi Yo' or whatever it is they sell with expensive kits).

Use UHT milk, basically they've done the boiling for you, and freeze dried culture.
If you want yogurt of a decent thickness without straining it, add some dried milk powder - more if you're using skimmed milk, less if it's whole milk.

I'd warm it up a bit just by putting the inner pot in the microwave for a minute.
Couldn't be much easier really.

Having made a batch using the starter culture, we would then save 4 tiny sealed pots of about 2 tablespoons each in the fridge to use as starter, and start the next batch using 2 tablespoons straight from the pot. This cuts the cost of the culture, and these batches don't take so long to mature - probably more organisms in them than the pinch of powder from a sachet I guess.

You could make further generations I suppose but there's a risk of introducing something you don't want

If you want to make 'Greek' yogurt you can strain it through a muslin but this significantly reduces the yield and is a bit of a faff.

WeRateSquirrels · 04/09/2022 09:56

We do ours in our Instant Pot. Very easy. Only problem is that we have to make sure we don’t run out because the shop bought stuff is horrid in comparison.

DoodlePug · 04/09/2022 09:49

It's a great way to get good bacteria and cut down on plastic.

I bought one from lake land, followed the instructions unsuccessfully 3 times and nearly gave up but thought I'd try UHT and it's amazing.

UHT doesn't taste like it used to!

Now I use maybe 4 tbsp yoghurt plus a carton of UHT from the cupboard, 8 hours later perfect yoghurt.

If the kids want fruit yoghurt you can mix in jam/compote or make them a fruit corner by simmering frozen fruit with a little sugar.

CatherinedeBourgh · 04/09/2022 09:41

Brefugee · 04/09/2022 09:33

I have some 1 litre jars that I've knitted cosies for that I put them into.

that sounds great! I currently have a kind of styrofoam thing that the jars go into but if ever that breaks or i can't use it I'll make a quilted cover.

Used to wrap them in tea towels, but ds1 is a compulsive tea towel user and i got fed up of hunting for available ones! Took me less than half an hour to do one...

freeandfierce · 04/09/2022 09:37

BorisJohnsonsHair · 04/09/2022 09:32

Boil milk, cool to body temperature. Stir in 2 spoons of live yoghurt.

Put it in a food flask/yoghurt maker, anywhere it will keep warm for a few hours.

I have a cheap yoghurt maker that I use, but it's only to keep it warm.

Don't get sucked into Easy Yo or whatever, just make plain yoghurt then stir in honey/passion fruit/coulis whatever to flavour it.

You can also add dried skimmed milk when you add the yoghurt to the milk to make it extra creamy.

Agree about easy yo, I use the yoghurt maker which is essentially a flask but don't use the packs. Really expensive and I've had mixed results with them.

JennyForeigner · 04/09/2022 09:37

JennyForeigner · 04/09/2022 09:31

Oo! Tell us more!

Happy to Google, but any useful tips v welcome.

Rats. We don't have that NF.

Back to the old yoghurt maker it is.

Brefugee · 04/09/2022 09:33

I have some 1 litre jars that I've knitted cosies for that I put them into.

that sounds great! I currently have a kind of styrofoam thing that the jars go into but if ever that breaks or i can't use it I'll make a quilted cover.

AnnaMagnani · 04/09/2022 09:33

I have made yoghurt the @Brefugee method. Heated milk in heavy bottomed casserole dish, added live yoghurt when it seemed warm, wrapped casserole dish in towel and left it.

Pros: it was incredibly easy and the yoghurt was great
Cons: it was obvious I was not going to do this every week, gadget or no gadget

BorisJohnsonsHair · 04/09/2022 09:32

Boil milk, cool to body temperature. Stir in 2 spoons of live yoghurt.

Put it in a food flask/yoghurt maker, anywhere it will keep warm for a few hours.

I have a cheap yoghurt maker that I use, but it's only to keep it warm.

Don't get sucked into Easy Yo or whatever, just make plain yoghurt then stir in honey/passion fruit/coulis whatever to flavour it.

You can also add dried skimmed milk when you add the yoghurt to the milk to make it extra creamy.

JennyForeigner · 04/09/2022 09:31

Handsnotwands · 18/07/2022 18:45

I make yogurt in my ninja foodi. It is delicious. I’ll never go back to bought

Oo! Tell us more!

Happy to Google, but any useful tips v welcome.

CatherinedeBourgh · 04/09/2022 09:31

I do the same as brefugee but don't boil it for 10 minutes, just heat up to just before boiling.

I have some 1 litre jars that I've knitted cosies for that I put them into.

So heat to boil, leave for 30 mins, pour into cosied jars which have a spoonful of yoghurt in them and leave for a few hours.

Brefugee · 04/09/2022 09:28

i used to have a yoghurt maker, with 6 little glass pots (square in section to fit on the base plate) which was also an egg boiler (so German Grin) it was easy enough and i made sure that when i'd eaten the 4th pot i made new yoghurt right away - but then you have to decant the yoghurt so you have enough pots.
I use 1 litre glass jars and i have 3 of them so i can always "leapfrog" the production process. But then. I eat a LOT of yoghurt :)

C8H10N4O2 · 04/09/2022 09:24

I use same method as @Brefugee

Its not a faff - basically its boil milk in pan or microwave, cool, stir in yogurt, leave for 8 hours.

If you use an instant pot its boil milk in instant pot, cool, stir in yogurt, leave for 8 hours.

Same amount of work either way.

I would suggest you try the non gadget method first to see what length of fermentation you like and because its easier to tweak things.

boobashka · 04/09/2022 09:22

👍 @5foot5
Looking forward to trying this.

5foot5 · 04/09/2022 09:20

boobashka · 04/09/2022 09:10

Thanks for that suggestion @5foot5 . I have the lakeland yogurt maker - always heated my uht milk but such a faff getting it to the right temperature. I'll give your method a go as we get through so much yogurt every week 😋

@boobashka UHT is at room temperature when I use it as it doesn't need to be kept in fridge.

boobashka · 04/09/2022 09:19

Yes @Tropicalsunshine , that's what we do. And then recycle the big pots.

5foot5 · 04/09/2022 09:18

Tunus · 04/09/2022 08:39

I’ve been wanting to make yoghurt in my instant pot for a while to cut down on plastic but am worried it’s going to end up costing a lot more than shop bought. How much yoghurt do you get from say 1l of milk? Also if you do it with uht does it have that horrible uht taste?

From 1 litre of milk you get 1 litre of yoghurt!

No you don't get the horrible UHT taste. I can't stand the taste of UHT in drinks. We tried it once when we ran out of fresh milk as I always have a stash of UHT in for yoghurt. Bleugh! But the yoghurt tastes of yoghurt

Tropicalsunshine · 04/09/2022 09:15

Middle ground is to just stop buying small pots and buy the largest size of natural or Greek yogurt. Tesco do a 1kg size. It's a bit more expensive than buying the milk but not much.

boobashka · 04/09/2022 09:10

Thanks for that suggestion @5foot5 . I have the lakeland yogurt maker - always heated my uht milk but such a faff getting it to the right temperature. I'll give your method a go as we get through so much yogurt every week 😋

Brefugee · 04/09/2022 09:10

Also if you vary the amount of time you leave it before you put it in the fridge (I do it all in German so I'm not sure - it's called the "ripening" stage? maybe fermenting?) you can get really thick yoghurt without straining.

It's one reason i make sure to boil my (not UHT) milk for around 10 minutes then cool down. It makes the yoghurt really thick without an extra stage.