Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Making accommodations isn't always 'kind' (uni)

543 replies

Jourdain11 · 18/07/2022 18:20

I'm interested in knowing general opinions on this. I would accept that the last few years have been tough for students, and UG finalists in particular have had their full course horribly disrupted. But I am struck by how the accommodations made for students have really not helped them, in a large proportion of cases. I work in a uni (London Russell Group, competitive and highly-rated) and the number of students who have requested deferrals and so on for MH reasons is huge. In my role, I pushed back a bit and said that we shouldn't be advocating this as a way of dealing with any level of pressure and anxiety. In some cases it was absolutely necessary, but in others I felt that it was just becoming a pattern or a way of buying more time.

Ultimately, in the careers many of these graduates will go on to have, they will have to work to deadlines and deal with pressure, and part of the uni experience is providing preparation for that.

We now have students who are very upset because they cannot graduate with their peers, who are very anxious because they've deferred half their year's assessments to a one-werk resits period and feel they will not cope, or who are just disappointed that they haven't completed the year and have uncertainty as regards progression. Plus those who have now come to see assessment as an absolutely terrifying and insurmountable thing because we have agreed that they clearly weren't capable of sitting their exams, when they probably were.

Overall, I feel that we need to be encouraging coping strategies and empowering students, rather than encouraging them to opt out on the most tenuous rationale. But some of my colleagues would consider this to be virtually heresy and I'm not sure how we're going to get out of this place we have found ourselves in.

OP posts:
theclangersarecoming · 19/07/2022 17:07

user1497207191 · 19/07/2022 17:01

Why wouldn't you give the online students access to the recordings of the in person lectures? As for seminars and tutorial groups, they're small groups anyway, so you'd have a mix of some groups F2F and other groups online, so again, no extra staffing needed. Obviously the exams have to be different - or do they? - "online" students could attend Uni for in person exams or other pre-arranged necessary in person meetings/group activities etc rather than a default assumption of them being there all the time. My DS was certainly surprised at the sheer number of students in his exam hall this year, most of whom he'd never seen before, who presumably were working from home rather than attending campus!

Thatit really what we actually did, but you seem not to understand that! And yes, it is a lot of extra work for staff. You can’t just duplicate in person and online without it involving extra work. For one thing, you can’t do lecture capture properly in in-person lectures as if you’re on Zoom. It’s done via different software, like Panopto, which requires giving the lecture once for lecture capture and then again in person.

antelopevalley · 19/07/2022 17:06

@Bibbetybobbity I think there will be an increasing backlash by employers. This will probably be reported in the media and some parents will take the issue on board.

Bibbetybobbity · 19/07/2022 17:03

I hear you @user1497207191 and I did say, it shouldn’t be a cold experience or whatever, the fun side of uni does matter. I certainly enjoyed it and would be churlish not to recognise that’s part of the experience, of course it is. But the question is whether the current/existing support measures in place (in some unis) are proportionate or even helping, given where we are now? We can’t go back, and fwiw I agree that students were short changed, but going forwards is there a resilience problem and what can be done about it, because realistically life and the word of work isn’t able to accommodate finding green pens triggering, or being unable to meet any deadlines (again: no one is saying this is all students/uni leavers, but it does sound like a growing %).

theclangersarecoming · 19/07/2022 17:02

But you’re missing the point entirely - the government instructed that universities close at certain points during lockdown. At others as many efforts were made to provide essential teaching as possible, including online. Many staff had to be furloughed or lose their jobs. They were not available for non-essential work like “astronomy clubs”, which in any case contravened the regulations regarding bubble mixing, number of people in rooms and so on.

antelopevalley · 19/07/2022 17:02

I agree that the usp of Open University is distance and online learning. It is also cheaper. If you want that kind of learning why not go there?

user1497207191 · 19/07/2022 17:01

theclangersarecoming · 19/07/2022 16:53

Re attendance, there's clearly two groups, those that want in person and those that want online. Why don't Unis offer that choice? I.e. why don't they make clear which are in person (and then there should be an expectation of it properly being in person, both from the teaching side and student side), and other options which are specifically online for those who don't want face to face? This trend of weasel wording "blended learning" or "face to face where possible" does no one any favours as it's not clear and is basically misleading students.

For the obvious simple reason that duplicating all teaching online and in person requires either employing twice the number of lecturers or halving the students’ contact time.

Why wouldn't you give the online students access to the recordings of the in person lectures? As for seminars and tutorial groups, they're small groups anyway, so you'd have a mix of some groups F2F and other groups online, so again, no extra staffing needed. Obviously the exams have to be different - or do they? - "online" students could attend Uni for in person exams or other pre-arranged necessary in person meetings/group activities etc rather than a default assumption of them being there all the time. My DS was certainly surprised at the sheer number of students in his exam hall this year, most of whom he'd never seen before, who presumably were working from home rather than attending campus!

FlySwimmer · 19/07/2022 17:00

@user1497207191 There were lots of last-minute cancellations because staff were still catching Covid. Or had to stay home with a child who had covid. Or who was required to isolate, until that requirement was dropped. Universities were still trying to provide in-person. As the airports and other services have shown recently, people are still getting sick and so can’t come to work. In the case of universities, that meant some adjustments, and but doesn’t mean they weren’t trying to provide in-person.

As @theclangersarecoming has said, having both online & in-person is unworkable without doubling staff or doubling their workload. And it would fundamentally change the nature of most universities. If you want online learning, the OU is absolutely fantastic at it. Meanwhile, we’ll be back on-campus come September, just as we were last September, and tried to be throughout the year as much as circumstances would allow.

user1497207191 · 19/07/2022 16:57

theclangersarecoming · 19/07/2022 16:38

If Unis are providing common rooms, gyms, cafes/bars/shops, libraries, and other facilities, then they should ensure they remain available when allowed and not just shut everything down for protracted periods for their convenience/cost savings

And by this you mean during a time everyone was advised to work from home wherever possible? Universities should have kept everything open, at the direct cost of older staff who might not want to risk their health? Remember students are in an age group very unlikely to die from Covid. But our maintenance and caretaker and library and kitchen and security and cleaning staff are often much older, some for example men and women in their 60s with health issues; and they are not, overwhelmingly, middle-class. But they are meant to be jumping to it to keep things open for a few fit young 20 year olds? Okay. Those priorities are telling ones.

Not to mention that, like any other business, we could only avoid mass redundancies by closing down and furloughing nearly all non-academic staff. Huge amounts of rental, conference and grant income simply disappeared. Furlough kept things afloat, as with large parts of the entire economy.

The point was indeed work from home "where possible". If you work in a place where it's not possible, then you go to work! Closing everything down was fair enough during the lockdowns themselves, but there was no reason for the widespread shutdown between lockdowns!

If Unis made the decision to close down their premises, then that should have extended to their student accommodation. It was grossly unfair and almost criminal to promise blended learning, "normal as much as possible", etc to "encourage" students to sign up for campus accommodation, and then shut everything down for the full year, so there was no benefit/need in them being on campus! Yes, I know they needed the student accommodation fees, but that's the Uni's problem to finance itself, not fleecing their students for accommodation fees and then in a lot of cases, refusing to refund when the student realises nothing is going on and decides to return home!

theclangersarecoming · 19/07/2022 16:53

Re attendance, there's clearly two groups, those that want in person and those that want online. Why don't Unis offer that choice? I.e. why don't they make clear which are in person (and then there should be an expectation of it properly being in person, both from the teaching side and student side), and other options which are specifically online for those who don't want face to face? This trend of weasel wording "blended learning" or "face to face where possible" does no one any favours as it's not clear and is basically misleading students.

For the obvious simple reason that duplicating all teaching online and in person requires either employing twice the number of lecturers or halving the students’ contact time.

theclangersarecoming · 19/07/2022 16:51

user1497207191 · 19/07/2022 16:33

But they need approval/facilities provided by the Uni. If you need a lecture theatre, and the Uni won't give you permission "due to covid", then the society can't run, likewise access to the observatory for the astronomy club, etc.

So middle class! “Why didn’t the university ensure Mr Hourly-Paid Building Caretaker, age 60, should be on site to open up the astronomy observatory for student clubs, during a nationwide pandemic where 1,000 older people were dying a day? Scandalous.”

user1497207191 · 19/07/2022 16:48

FlySwimmer · 19/07/2022 16:26

@user1497207191 But did his classes run in-person? My experience is the vast majority of unis were back teaching in-person this year. The only exception in our place was very large lecture groups, which remained online.

The extracurricular disappointment is highly regrettable and I understand it does impact students’ experience. But for the core of their experience, aka the education, most would have been offered in-person this year. As I said before, many did not attend when it was available. Then complain about lack of support.

Not really, no. For 4 modules, there were no F2F lectures, they were all online (for 1 they were all pre-recorded rather than "live" and for others, there was a mix of live and last year's recorded lectures). For the other 4, they were all supposed to be in person, but there were lots of last minute cancellations where they were online instead.

Re attendance, there's clearly two groups, those that want in person and those that want online. Why don't Unis offer that choice? I.e. why don't they make clear which are in person (and then there should be an expectation of it properly being in person, both from the teaching side and student side), and other options which are specifically online for those who don't want face to face? This trend of weasel wording "blended learning" or "face to face where possible" does no one any favours as it's not clear and is basically misleading students.

Unfortunately, technology has led us to this issue. There was a time when missing a lecture was detrimental to the student, but during the past decade or so, recording lectures has become the norm, so that means students can easily catch up if they miss one. It also feeds into the mindset of getting accustomed to just watching them online afterwards if they don't benefit from the "in person" aspect due to poor lecturers etc.

There is a further issue of time-table clashing, especially with, again, a more modern trend for "mix and match" subjects, i.e. Natural science or Maths with Physics, etc etc., where timetable clashes are inevitable so students will have no option but to choose which lecture they attend when there is a clash or overlap. Yes, for some modules, the lectures are duplicated due to very high numbers, but for others, it's just one lecture!

I'm sure there are students who are too lazy to attend, but it's likewise very lazy for lecturers to whinge about the entire cohort, when many do attend or others have valid reasons for not attending! Also, with these past two years affected by covid (though not sure why the last year was so badly affected!), there'll be lots of students who've had protracted periods back home, so they'd have expected to be on campus, but in reality, weren't there as much as they expected, especially when a number of their modules were online. Not much point staying on campus for 1 or 2 lectures per week when all the others are online!

antelopevalley · 19/07/2022 16:47

Eeksteek · 19/07/2022 16:40

@antelopevalley I agree, if you got on the property ladder right out of the gate and weathered the 2008 crash ok, 44 isn’t bad. No, we’ve not got golden pensions (that’s ok if you’ve got equity) and we don’t have jobs for life (but are often youngish, have some skills/expertise and corporate savvy enough to jump around and not take shitty jobs from shitty companies). If you didn’t get on the property ladder, or you got burned in 08, it could be pretty crappy. There’s variation. Covid was a more uniform impact. Also, absorbing that impact as an adult, with fully developed brain and adequate resilience and coping systems (or at least adequate so far) is vastly different to an immature adult. Especially as they traditionally rely on one another for support and don’t live together and are not supported by parents in the sane way younger children are. I do think they are more vulnerable that we are allowing them, because it looked cushy. But their coping resources were severely impacted when they should have been forming.

But we’re the hirers. If, for you, it’s as good as it gets in living memory, and you’re hiring a generation where it’s a shitty as it gets in living memory, empathy is not free flowing and you’re going to have conflict. I think that is as much the issue as the impact itself.

Trust me now is not as good as it gets in living memory. I look back to the Olympics of 2012 and years before as the best time nationally.
The impression I get is that young adults now get a lot of support and practical help from parents for quite a number of years. I had nothing after I left home at 18. I am not arguing for that, but all I had was friends to help. And that was tough at times.
I am not denying the pandemic caused issues for young people. But I think the victim mentality of the generation who have had it worse than anyone ever is not true, and more importantly does not help them.

Eeksteek · 19/07/2022 16:43

antelopevalley · 19/07/2022 16:27

If marketing pushed that university was all about fun, then the marketing was wrong. Students can have a lot of fun at university, but the point of going is to study.

It didn’t used to be. Many graduates don’t use their degree in their work. Graduates used to denote a level of application, maturity, research ability and transferable skill that non-graduates didn’t have. I don’t think that’s the case any more. Especially at the moment.

antelopevalley · 19/07/2022 16:41

@user1497207191 you can not have an astronomy club, but some clubs can still operate or new ones set up.
But I do find in general young people are not interested in setting things up, instead talking about what they wish existed.

Eeksteek · 19/07/2022 16:40

@antelopevalley I agree, if you got on the property ladder right out of the gate and weathered the 2008 crash ok, 44 isn’t bad. No, we’ve not got golden pensions (that’s ok if you’ve got equity) and we don’t have jobs for life (but are often youngish, have some skills/expertise and corporate savvy enough to jump around and not take shitty jobs from shitty companies). If you didn’t get on the property ladder, or you got burned in 08, it could be pretty crappy. There’s variation. Covid was a more uniform impact. Also, absorbing that impact as an adult, with fully developed brain and adequate resilience and coping systems (or at least adequate so far) is vastly different to an immature adult. Especially as they traditionally rely on one another for support and don’t live together and are not supported by parents in the sane way younger children are. I do think they are more vulnerable that we are allowing them, because it looked cushy. But their coping resources were severely impacted when they should have been forming.

But we’re the hirers. If, for you, it’s as good as it gets in living memory, and you’re hiring a generation where it’s a shitty as it gets in living memory, empathy is not free flowing and you’re going to have conflict. I think that is as much the issue as the impact itself.

theclangersarecoming · 19/07/2022 16:38

If Unis are providing common rooms, gyms, cafes/bars/shops, libraries, and other facilities, then they should ensure they remain available when allowed and not just shut everything down for protracted periods for their convenience/cost savings

And by this you mean during a time everyone was advised to work from home wherever possible? Universities should have kept everything open, at the direct cost of older staff who might not want to risk their health? Remember students are in an age group very unlikely to die from Covid. But our maintenance and caretaker and library and kitchen and security and cleaning staff are often much older, some for example men and women in their 60s with health issues; and they are not, overwhelmingly, middle-class. But they are meant to be jumping to it to keep things open for a few fit young 20 year olds? Okay. Those priorities are telling ones.

Not to mention that, like any other business, we could only avoid mass redundancies by closing down and furloughing nearly all non-academic staff. Huge amounts of rental, conference and grant income simply disappeared. Furlough kept things afloat, as with large parts of the entire economy.

user1497207191 · 19/07/2022 16:33

antelopevalley · 19/07/2022 16:25

Clubs and societies are organised by the students.

But they need approval/facilities provided by the Uni. If you need a lecture theatre, and the Uni won't give you permission "due to covid", then the society can't run, likewise access to the observatory for the astronomy club, etc.

antelopevalley · 19/07/2022 16:27

If marketing pushed that university was all about fun, then the marketing was wrong. Students can have a lot of fun at university, but the point of going is to study.

FlySwimmer · 19/07/2022 16:26

@user1497207191 But did his classes run in-person? My experience is the vast majority of unis were back teaching in-person this year. The only exception in our place was very large lecture groups, which remained online.

The extracurricular disappointment is highly regrettable and I understand it does impact students’ experience. But for the core of their experience, aka the education, most would have been offered in-person this year. As I said before, many did not attend when it was available. Then complain about lack of support.

antelopevalley · 19/07/2022 16:25

Clubs and societies are organised by the students.

user1497207191 · 19/07/2022 16:22

Bibbetybobbity · 19/07/2022 15:38

@MySonFury but the uni staff on this thread aren’t describing tight deadlines or demanding hours. They’re saying that students are pushing back on ANY deadlines, ANY demands (with of course exceptions, no one is saying it’s every kid).

Uni isn’t for well-being. Of course there should be clarity about what’s on offer, and I agree with PP that students were shortchanged when they paid for accom and then unis had to close, but setting that aside. Is it really realistic to expect that unis, whose primary purpose is surely research and education to provide wrap around care too? I don’t mean that it should be a cruel or cold experience, but what’s the expectation?

Unis heavily push the "fun" side of it, as part of their marketing.

If Unis are providing common rooms, gyms, cafes/bars/shops, libraries, and other facilities, then they should ensure they remain available when allowed and not just shut everything down for protracted periods for their convenience/cost savings, nor should they make their own rules over and above the covid restrictions in place at that time.

Like a previous PP, my son was at one of the Unis who didn't do well with covid and it was a bleak and miserable experience for him, worsened by the actions of the Uni.

As for a previous PP saying they're back to normal, no they're not. At my son's very few clubs & societies operated this last year due to rooms not being made available to them by the uni and due to them disbanding the year before as there is no one to carry them on. The few which operated were mostly online in the first place, or were those where "meetings" could be held in other places, such as on the lawns on fine days, on the sports pitches, etc. DS wanted to join the astronomy club, but "due to covid", they weren't allowed access to the observatory throughout this last year when there weren't any covid restrictions!

antelopevalley · 19/07/2022 16:22

Covid affected everyone, but for many even most it is just a blip in their lives.

Eeksteek · 19/07/2022 16:17

GoodThinkingMax · 19/07/2022 12:12

No generation HAS lived though anything remotely like this.

Sorry but that statement is just so historically inaccurate that it’s almost offensive in the ignorance and/or lack of imagination it demonstrates.

My father lost his father in WW2; my grandmother’s generation lost a host of family and friends in WW1

I also think of the 100s of thousands of young gay men who lost their lives to an unknown virus in the 1980s, largely ignored because it was seen as a “gay disease.”

In the globally coordinated battle against the Corona virus, we had pretty effective vaccines within a year.

To clarify, I meant alive today. I’m aware there are people who remember the war alive today. However, they are sadly ever fewer and farther between, are not, by and large, working and were (mostly now) not adults during the war and not dealing with the issues. I don’t wish to trivialise anything here)

I do not think covid is comparable in severity, as I said. But in terms of affecting a whole generation. I don’t think we have seen that universal impact since. As I said, I don’t think it’s a very helpful comparison. But neither is the 80’s/70s etc etc. I was alive during some of those things. I barely even knew about the AIDS epidemic. It was no more relevant to me personally than the famine in Ethiopia. That doesn’t mean it wasn’t awful, but that it didn’t affect me at all. It affected comparatively few people devastatingly. Covid affected everyone. Everyone. In quite dramatic everyday ways. That’s all I’m saying. I don’t think comparing trauma competitively is helpful, even generationally, as this is showing. Personal experience is too varied.

Ormally · 19/07/2022 16:09

Until earlier this year, I was part of the 'we' and the 'us' for more than 10 years so don't need the background. I'm meaning the blind spots, so to speak, on this thread - not necessarily in any one workplace as, even with common features, selling points, student levels of productivity, and pandemic strategies, they are all different.

moksorineouimoksori · 19/07/2022 16:09

MySonFury · 19/07/2022 15:30

I feel that we need to be encouraging coping strategies and empowering students

I'd bet solid money that you're not bothering to do this though. You can't have your cake and eat it too. Law firms and investment banks and accountancy firms get away with demanding hours and tight deadlines because they (investment banks to a much lesser extent) provide actual well-being provisions, access to healthcare and genuine support and guidance. When universities step-up and offer decent provision for students then they can expect the same level of resilience. You cannot reasonably expect anyone to have resilience without well-being, they're completely intertwined.

Good point, and the quality of pastoral services in universities vary greatly. Equally, healthcare is struggling at the moment and MH healthcare was never particularly amazing in the first place.

Also, at work, you're also being paid to be there and withstand whatever stressors - not quite the case at university, in fact rather the other way around!