Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Making accommodations isn't always 'kind' (uni)

543 replies

Jourdain11 · 18/07/2022 18:20

I'm interested in knowing general opinions on this. I would accept that the last few years have been tough for students, and UG finalists in particular have had their full course horribly disrupted. But I am struck by how the accommodations made for students have really not helped them, in a large proportion of cases. I work in a uni (London Russell Group, competitive and highly-rated) and the number of students who have requested deferrals and so on for MH reasons is huge. In my role, I pushed back a bit and said that we shouldn't be advocating this as a way of dealing with any level of pressure and anxiety. In some cases it was absolutely necessary, but in others I felt that it was just becoming a pattern or a way of buying more time.

Ultimately, in the careers many of these graduates will go on to have, they will have to work to deadlines and deal with pressure, and part of the uni experience is providing preparation for that.

We now have students who are very upset because they cannot graduate with their peers, who are very anxious because they've deferred half their year's assessments to a one-werk resits period and feel they will not cope, or who are just disappointed that they haven't completed the year and have uncertainty as regards progression. Plus those who have now come to see assessment as an absolutely terrifying and insurmountable thing because we have agreed that they clearly weren't capable of sitting their exams, when they probably were.

Overall, I feel that we need to be encouraging coping strategies and empowering students, rather than encouraging them to opt out on the most tenuous rationale. But some of my colleagues would consider this to be virtually heresy and I'm not sure how we're going to get out of this place we have found ourselves in.

OP posts:
theclangersarecoming · 19/07/2022 19:09

No-one has said there hasn’t been an impact (though I can tell you the impact is much greater on primary age and disadvantaged children compared to university students). But does that mean that a whole year later students can’t be expected to hand in a dissertation or project on time?

TullyApplebottom · 19/07/2022 18:57

theclangersarecoming · 19/07/2022 18:47

If we’re talking about developing life skills, @TullyApplebottom , why were all my students sitting at home telling me that at least they were getting meals cooked for them by mum and dad? I didn’t hear a single one say: “Well, I’m here and mum and dad are working from home, so I’ve learned how to cook a few meals so I can look after mum and dad while they work”. Or even, I’m helping homeschool my siblings which is a good skill to learn? Or helping with community efforts at food hubs, delivering help to housebound people and so on, like many people in my village were doing? They all told me they were bored at home being looked after!

Neither did most of them stop socialising - in fact lots told me that it was nice being at home because they were getting a lot of time to spend with old friends from school. Several went on holiday.

That’s all anecdotal, so maybe there were tons of students doing all of those things (none of which are beyond the wit of a late teenager). But certainly none of mine were.
And all of those things would have offered the experience and life skills you talk about. (And not getting the full middle class uni experience for a year is hardly great privation. It’s not like they were fleeing a war zone or being shelled by Russian troops.)

Do you think you might be taking some throwaway remarks a little too seriously?
you seem quite resentful of the students you teach. No one was going on holiday or socialising with school friends during lockdown unless they were breaking the law. Those who were able to go to university had highly abnormal, restricted experiences. I do wonder if some resentment here isn’t getting in the way of acknowledging that yes, this might have had an impact.

theclangersarecoming · 19/07/2022 18:47

If we’re talking about developing life skills, @TullyApplebottom , why were all my students sitting at home telling me that at least they were getting meals cooked for them by mum and dad? I didn’t hear a single one say: “Well, I’m here and mum and dad are working from home, so I’ve learned how to cook a few meals so I can look after mum and dad while they work”. Or even, I’m helping homeschool my siblings which is a good skill to learn? Or helping with community efforts at food hubs, delivering help to housebound people and so on, like many people in my village were doing? They all told me they were bored at home being looked after!

Neither did most of them stop socialising - in fact lots told me that it was nice being at home because they were getting a lot of time to spend with old friends from school. Several went on holiday.

That’s all anecdotal, so maybe there were tons of students doing all of those things (none of which are beyond the wit of a late teenager). But certainly none of mine were.
And all of those things would have offered the experience and life skills you talk about. (And not getting the full middle class uni experience for a year is hardly great privation. It’s not like they were fleeing a war zone or being shelled by Russian troops.)

TullyApplebottom · 19/07/2022 18:42

goldfinchonthelawn · 19/07/2022 14:16

But @antelopevalley I think that poster was just listing their own experiences of how to mature. If you work from age 16 you are faced with endless opportunities and struggles which enable you to mature - tough customers or bosses, work schedules, commutes etc. You learn resilience. Uni is one way, work is another. But being housebound and desocialised for two years during lockdown, at one of the most formative times of a human life, neurologically, must be incredibly debilitating to their development.

Quite. Some people here are being wilfully very stupid.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 19/07/2022 18:41

Could we just acknowledge here that the academic staff in departments were not the ones making decisions about accommodation, extra-curricular activities etc? The senior management of the universities had to do that, at great speed when the first lockdown was declared halfway through one academic year, and then had to try to plan ahead for the next academic year at a point when the future was extremely unclear. It's hardly surprising they got it wrong in some cases. The leadership from the government was far from stellar, as we all know.

I used to work as a lowly administrator in a university. It was abundantly clear that most students (and their families too, I expect) had no grasp of university financing, and why should they? They were unaware that decades ago the government provided most university funding from taxes, supplemented by tuition fees paid by LEAs for undergraduates out of the rates. The LEAs also paid maintenance grants to undergrads which were easily enough to live on if you were sensible, without any need to take on a part-time job (this was my experience, anyway), so you could concentrate on your academic work. All of this was affordable because the number of students going onto higher education was tiny. At this point some students might have graduated with a small overdraft, but nothing like the huge paper debts they have now.

Then New Labour decreed that 50% of the population should go to university and instead of a massive increase in taxes/borrowing to pay for it they decided to make the students pay, but to give them low-cost loans to do it.

And lo and behold, within a very few years, almost all central government funding for universities had vanished. I believe there's a block grant for their capital funding for STEM courses, and some funding for NHS-related courses, and that's about it. Students and their families have to cough up or take out loans for both tuition fees and maintenance costs. Students far more often have to work alongside their studies. The loans aren't all that cheap any more. You start repaying on a lower salary than of yore. Etc etc.

It's not universities' fault that going to university is so expensive now, nor that jobs you used to be able to secure with a handful of O levels or CSEs now require a degree. It's also not their fault that successive governments have failed to beef up our vocational education and training so it's a really good and rigorous alternative to an academic route. There are some excellent apprenticeship schemes but there aren't nearly enough of them.

Students and their families see themselves as consumers, as customers, and we all know the customer is always right, so feedback and league tables have taken on a ludicrous amount of importance for university management.

I also think the government has utterly failed to explain to students and their families WHY they thought it would be beneficial for more students to go to university. It wasn't so they could have a terrific time for three years playing sport and using the bar, gym and so on. It was so they could carry on with their education and develop all sorts of transferable skills that they could then take into their working lives and benefit the economy.

We used to have a higher education system that was the envy of the world. I'm not sure that's the case any more.

TullyApplebottom · 19/07/2022 18:39

antelopevalley · 19/07/2022 14:12

@TullyApplebottom It was a serious question.
"did drama and sport with friends, did exams, got a job, went on holiday, went to university where I met and socialised with a wide group of people, did drama, politics and sport, did my work.."

So do people who do not have those experiences have a poorly developed brain? I ask because when I was young most working-class kids left school at 16. Some did exams like me, but not everyone. No university. No holidays abroad. No drama, politics and sport was only for sporty young people.
I did none of those things except get a job and see friends.

You are talking about a specific middle-class western experience of life that meant people generationally and around the world have never experienced.

I know some undergraduates had a hard time, especially during the first lockdown. But stating all these things such as university, holidays, sport and drama are necessary for brain development is simply hyperbole.

Working class children might not have done those things; they would have had the life experiences available to them. Which may well have included study and work and leisure pursuits.
what they wouldn’t have had is complete and sudden cessation of all the experiences and interactions that had been an intégral part of their lives to date, which provided them with the chance to develop life skills, networks, connections, resilience.
im really surprised at the stubbornness of the refusal to engage with the impact this has had on teenagers and adolescents. It feels like guilt. If we acknowledge we have to feel responsible and we don’t want that. So, we blame them. Rather unpleasant

GoodThinkingMax · 19/07/2022 18:30

I went from a happy outgoing teen to miserable, lonely, drinking huge amounts of alcohol because I was constantly being handed free drinks (and making terrible decisions as a result).

Seriously @CharlotteOH just what do you think academics should do with a student who makes stupid choices and suffers the consequences?

What would have helped you then? And - hand on heart - would you have followed through on the advice? For example, would you have practiced "think the drink through" each time you were offered a free drink? Would you have established a pattern of sleep hygiene and physical & mental health self-care? Exercising properly each day, setting a regular sleep pattern, eating well to fuel & nurture your body?

I am there to teach my subject (in which I'm a leading expert internationally). My skill is in taking my research and re-presenting it to engage students, to facilitate their learning about this specific aspect of my broader discipline, to introduce them to new ideas, and to help them think their own new ideas.

I'm not there to therapise them!

cormorant5 · 19/07/2022 18:26

So far I am on P9, sorry, had to prioritise work.
Let me make random comments. MN regulars even get snide anti Thatcher reference in here.
I would suggest that the miners led by Arthur Scargill were early Snowflakes. They only wanted to have jobs in an industry that was unprofitable produced a product that could easily be replaced that ensured they didn't have to go to another town or re-skill.
Comparisons with WW2, as difficult as it was many of the survivors were able to build friendships through the adversity they suffered. That was denied during covid. They developed resilience which helped them to start businesses
Those born after about 1960 were the first generation who did not almost automatically do better than their parents. In my family 4 generations from servant to artisan to house owner to me house owner and business owner. DC nurse and soldier.

GoodThinkingMax · 19/07/2022 18:24

@Jourdain11 For me, I think the 2nd full lockdown in January 2021 was the hardest teaching term of my entire career. It was announced so suddenly, with only a few days' notice, and we were all looking forward to going back into the seminar rooms and lecture theatres.

Depths of winter, and a government that clearly had no idea what it was doing. And angry anxious students who took it out on us teaching staff.

wouldithelpme · 19/07/2022 18:22

I’m another who disagrees .

My mother was diagnosed with frontotemproal dementia last month, moved into a home .

My dad’s moved 2000 miles abroad .

My gran died last week .

My uni are phoning me daily Mon-Fri, have helped me to defer a year and have given me endless support pastoral, academic and financial - I’d be bloody lost without them .

GoodThinkingMax · 19/07/2022 18:20

Some Unis went over and above the legal restrictions and made life a lot harder for their students than it needed to have been.

I live on the edge of a big student house (privately rented) area in my town. I KNOW from the noise of loud music until 2am and my observations of groups of students outside their houses throughout lockdowns that students were breaking the government laid out COVID rules about socialising.

Added to which, the weekly university email to all staff & students repeatedly emphasised the government rules about mixing households. I heard (from the inside) that the University Registrar was getting merry hell from all the public health people in the town about the ways that students mixing were spreading C-19 in a town which otherwise had ver low levels of infection.

It's why, when given the choice before I was vaccinated, as someone over 60, with a couple of underlying health conditions, I taught online. I wasn't going to trust my health to the actions of possibly quite irresponsible students.

Jourdain11 · 19/07/2022 18:07

GoodThinkingMax · 19/07/2022 18:01

Now there are plenty of people on the thread saying we aren’t sympathetic enough, and it’s like they think we have never had any mental health issues ourselves or any experience with this. I’ve been teaching and doing pastoral support for students for about twenty years now, and I’m more than familiar with helping support students with serious mental health and pastoral issues. And this new culture isn’t like that at all. It’s something very different, and really concerning. I know I sound like I’m just complaining, but it’s dismaying to me that despite every effort to support students it’s like that’s actually counterproductive, and I think we should be changing tack on this soon before the culture gets even more entrenched. It isn’t doing this cohort any favours at all.

Yes, @theclangersarecoming I think your post is really perceptive.

And I would also point out to the parents saying we're unsympathetic on this thread, that during the pandemic, we had to absorb all the student anxiety, listen to students complaining about being online (it was the bloody LAW, what do you think we should have done?) and I had one student swearing at me and telling me I didn't know what I was doing.

But there was NO pastoral care or back up support for teaching staff. My university gave us an extra 'rest day' once, but didn't actually remove a day's work from our workloads! It was a joke.

In my discipline, we had to re-conceive our modules & courses from scratch, in order to convert a part lab-based course into online offerings which still met our approved learning outcomes. We had family worries, our own health at risk (for the last 2 years I was not certain I would see my mother alive again - I know others who lost parents - whatever age you lose a parent it's very tough).

But certainly in my Department (and throughout most of my highly-regarded Russel Group university) we soldiered on. And unlike our students, didn't mention our concerns or take out our worries on the students.

I know from colleagues that lockdown 1 was absolutely horrendous, the workload was unreal and the hours put in were beyond reasonable. I was having chemo so was not working, and it sounds like I had a positive holiday by comparison 😅 Certainly I returned to the workplace in a better state than some of my colleagues!

OP posts:
GoodThinkingMax · 19/07/2022 18:01

Now there are plenty of people on the thread saying we aren’t sympathetic enough, and it’s like they think we have never had any mental health issues ourselves or any experience with this. I’ve been teaching and doing pastoral support for students for about twenty years now, and I’m more than familiar with helping support students with serious mental health and pastoral issues. And this new culture isn’t like that at all. It’s something very different, and really concerning. I know I sound like I’m just complaining, but it’s dismaying to me that despite every effort to support students it’s like that’s actually counterproductive, and I think we should be changing tack on this soon before the culture gets even more entrenched. It isn’t doing this cohort any favours at all.

Yes, @theclangersarecoming I think your post is really perceptive.

And I would also point out to the parents saying we're unsympathetic on this thread, that during the pandemic, we had to absorb all the student anxiety, listen to students complaining about being online (it was the bloody LAW, what do you think we should have done?) and I had one student swearing at me and telling me I didn't know what I was doing.

But there was NO pastoral care or back up support for teaching staff. My university gave us an extra 'rest day' once, but didn't actually remove a day's work from our workloads! It was a joke.

In my discipline, we had to re-conceive our modules & courses from scratch, in order to convert a part lab-based course into online offerings which still met our approved learning outcomes. We had family worries, our own health at risk (for the last 2 years I was not certain I would see my mother alive again - I know others who lost parents - whatever age you lose a parent it's very tough).

But certainly in my Department (and throughout most of my highly-regarded Russel Group university) we soldiered on. And unlike our students, didn't mention our concerns or take out our worries on the students.

CharlotteOH · 19/07/2022 18:00

Totally agree.

In general I think uni is terrible for mental health and that most of the staff don’t care / understand the causes. I went from a happy outgoing teen to miserable, lonely, drinking huge amounts of alcohol because I was constantly being handed free drinks (and making terrible decisions as a result).

I wish more people had a year out, or that our culture wasn’t so contemptuous of the idea of going to a local uni while living at home. Or failing that, I wish that staff had better training on mental health.

Jourdain11 · 19/07/2022 17:51

Our student newspaper is like a complaints column! It's a pity it isn't more representative. Very dominated by a small group of voices.

OP posts:
GoodThinkingMax · 19/07/2022 17:48

How about getting back to fully face to face lectures, seminars, working groups, etc which is what the majority of students want? Or does it only work one way?

We've been teaching in person since last September. My department is a lab-based subject so in fact we were face to face from last May - as soon as we were ALLOWED to by government legilsation.

Predictably, the student newspaper (not The Tab, which s a rag worse than the Sun) ran a front page article about how utterly AWFUL it was that lectures were back to in person, because they had to get out of bed to go to 8:30am classes, and couldn't participate at their own convenience, and all sorts of other made-up reasons.

I'm not sure how far the student newspaper reflected the views of my students: they seemed overjoyed to be in live seminars, even though we were still masking up at the time. They were utterly lovely, actually.

But I thought the student newspaper front page complaints article was really telling of current student tendencies as a cohort to thrash about to find stuff to complain about.

FlySwimmer · 19/07/2022 17:47

As for seminars and tutorial groups, they're small groups anyway, so you'd have a mix of some groups F2F and other groups online, so again, no extra staffing needed.

Others have already addressed the problem of specialised teaching where there’s only one group.

But, this year and last we had an online group and in-person groups for large modules. Students were to declare which they wanted at the start of the semester; the online group was intended for CEV students, and a tiny number of international students still affected by travel restrictions. The great majority were expected to attend in person.

By halfway through the semester the online group was overwhelmed with requests to transfer into it, as students decided they didn’t want to have to travel in. It maps perfectly onto the declining attendance we saw pre-covid as the semesters progressed. And they were pissed when told they couldn’t transfer halfway through. Students want it both ways but universities can’t cope with that.

Hawkins001 · 19/07/2022 17:46

Jourdain11 · 19/07/2022 17:20

We actually had a lot of complaints about online lecturing and lecturers overwhelmingly reported that engagement was less than when they lectures/taught in person. I think it is not so simple as "some want in person, some want online". It is easy, if they have been basically doing online for a year and a half, to feel that this is what they want, but when they actually have to attend in-person, realising they get 100% more out of it, it's more social, it's more participatory...

A learning experience for me has been that starting a MN thread is very bad for my work output, as I've been drawn back to it like a moth to the flame! Tomorrow I have an interview for a senior post, in which I shall talk disingenuously about my work ethic and ability to focus 😂

All the best and positivity

theclangersarecoming · 19/07/2022 17:22

Ah, good luck @Jourdain11 !!

Jourdain11 · 19/07/2022 17:20

We actually had a lot of complaints about online lecturing and lecturers overwhelmingly reported that engagement was less than when they lectures/taught in person. I think it is not so simple as "some want in person, some want online". It is easy, if they have been basically doing online for a year and a half, to feel that this is what they want, but when they actually have to attend in-person, realising they get 100% more out of it, it's more social, it's more participatory...

A learning experience for me has been that starting a MN thread is very bad for my work output, as I've been drawn back to it like a moth to the flame! Tomorrow I have an interview for a senior post, in which I shall talk disingenuously about my work ethic and ability to focus 😂

OP posts:
theclangersarecoming · 19/07/2022 17:18

GCAcademic · 19/07/2022 17:09

Why wouldn't you give the online students access to the recordings of the in person lectures? As for seminars and tutorial groups, they're small groups anyway, so you'd have a mix of some groups F2F and other groups online, so again, no extra staffing needed.

Many modules have just one seminar group and — when you get to Year 2 and beyond — are sufficiently specialised that only one member of staff can teach it. A recording of a live lecture is also going to be a poor quality experience. It’s acceptable in extremis but not as the basis for an actual online course.

Yes - if I’m teaching one final year 2hrs/week seminar (on, say, the Frankfurt School, or death in early modern Europe, or Postcolonial Australian film or whatever), with 20 students, if half want to do it online and half in person then that’s four hours a week not two. Who else is supposed to be stepping in to help out? Or am I just expected to double my workload… seems like parents think so.

XingMing · 19/07/2022 17:17

DS is studying a practical, creative and tech-heavy subject at an arts university. In first year 20/21, lockdown meant there were no opportunities for hands-on training in the use of big film and TV cameras, sound equipment and edit suites. Last year's first year cohort have had close to the full experience. He's a bit jaundiced that he paid full fees and accommodation costs for a poor facsimile of the course. But having spent a couple of years working while he decided on his course of study, he's fairly scathing about the work ethic of many of his (younger) peer group.

JangolinaPitt · 19/07/2022 17:10

Completely agree OP. I am a teacher and gave a 6th form tutor group and really feel we go pupils and students no favours by medicalising every setback and making excuses and extending deadlines instead of helping them with strategies to meet the deadlines, or coping with the fallout from not meeting them. A friend and I were discussing the emergency services response to a n incident here today and how they could not simply pleased that they need ‘extra time’ they had to deal with the situation professionally without excuses, and wondering how done of our pupils would cope in real jobs with inflexible time constraints.

GCAcademic · 19/07/2022 17:09

Why wouldn't you give the online students access to the recordings of the in person lectures? As for seminars and tutorial groups, they're small groups anyway, so you'd have a mix of some groups F2F and other groups online, so again, no extra staffing needed.

Many modules have just one seminar group and — when you get to Year 2 and beyond — are sufficiently specialised that only one member of staff can teach it. A recording of a live lecture is also going to be a poor quality experience. It’s acceptable in extremis but not as the basis for an actual online course.

WillMcAvoy · 19/07/2022 17:08

TheWayoftheLeaf · 19/07/2022 13:25

I was at uni before Covid (grad 2017) and saw regular uni destroy some people utterly. Horrific mental health issues. They could not cope. I hate to think how many are even worse now.

Why? What was so utterly horrific about university in the early 2010's? Because I never saw people destroyed by university...there were always a few who didn't cope well the pressure, wih prexisting issues etc, but they were rare.

Swipe left for the next trending thread