Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Making accommodations isn't always 'kind' (uni)

543 replies

Jourdain11 · 18/07/2022 18:20

I'm interested in knowing general opinions on this. I would accept that the last few years have been tough for students, and UG finalists in particular have had their full course horribly disrupted. But I am struck by how the accommodations made for students have really not helped them, in a large proportion of cases. I work in a uni (London Russell Group, competitive and highly-rated) and the number of students who have requested deferrals and so on for MH reasons is huge. In my role, I pushed back a bit and said that we shouldn't be advocating this as a way of dealing with any level of pressure and anxiety. In some cases it was absolutely necessary, but in others I felt that it was just becoming a pattern or a way of buying more time.

Ultimately, in the careers many of these graduates will go on to have, they will have to work to deadlines and deal with pressure, and part of the uni experience is providing preparation for that.

We now have students who are very upset because they cannot graduate with their peers, who are very anxious because they've deferred half their year's assessments to a one-werk resits period and feel they will not cope, or who are just disappointed that they haven't completed the year and have uncertainty as regards progression. Plus those who have now come to see assessment as an absolutely terrifying and insurmountable thing because we have agreed that they clearly weren't capable of sitting their exams, when they probably were.

Overall, I feel that we need to be encouraging coping strategies and empowering students, rather than encouraging them to opt out on the most tenuous rationale. But some of my colleagues would consider this to be virtually heresy and I'm not sure how we're going to get out of this place we have found ourselves in.

OP posts:
Phineyj · 20/07/2022 09:18

As an A-level teacher, I'm beginning to think that the students I teach aren't really suited to an "advanced" course at 16 any more. They don't have/yet have the independence of mind or ability to absorb material from texts and comment on it critically, with a few exceptions. And I provide masses of scaffolding. I received very little myself. It may be a cohort effect due to Covid of course. But it's not surprising these students experience difficulties at university.

Interestingly, I studied in North America in the 1990s where the students were much more spoon fed and everything was more market-driven and the academics just loved the three of us British exchange students as we'd been taught to read and write critically. We were good students but by no means top of our classes back in the UK.

ludocris · 20/07/2022 08:51

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/07/2022 21:46

We’re not doctors or mental health nurses or counsellors or their parents

Neither was l. But l did whatever l could to help and support. You seem to be implying that too much leeway is being given to students with problems. But l think it will get worse before it gets better. Maybe you need to adjust your mindset.

I think the issue is that people want the support and help to be given to the students who DO have problems, not just anyone who is a bit stressed or disorganised.

ludocris · 20/07/2022 08:50

CallmeMrsPricklepants · 20/07/2022 06:35

I think the NSS had a lot to answer for. Departments are so scared of upsetting students by not meeting their every whim that there are no clear expectations set, no boundaries.

This is very true

AtomicBlondeRose · 20/07/2022 08:40

In sixth form I’ve always observed that it takes a while to get into a college mindset - the freedom sends them a bit giddy at first for a start, and then coming to terms with the fact that teachers aren’t your enemies, that you’re on the course of your own free will and can leave if you want, therefore you shouldn’t spend your time railing against perceived authority but rather realise teachers are there to help and guide you. So when we set work it’s for your own benefit rather than as some kind of punishment to make you lose your free time!

This commonly takes until about Christmas for the majority. Some have it straight away but it’s normal to need a transition period. But this year’s Y12 have taken a very very long time to settle. Some are still squarely in “school mode” - arguing with teachers, not handing stuff in etc. There’s also an odd thing that one of the PPs mentioned where they will spend a LONG time on work. Way longer than needed or asked for. And yet the work is still often of noticeably poorer quality than previous years. This happens even when I try to give guidance such as telling them how
long to spend on something (never needed to do this before as most tasks are self-limiting), giving them numbered lists with the order they should do things and so on. And yet when I look at what they’re doing they’ve gone back to a piece I’ve told them was fine and are wasting hours faffing with that instead of doing new work. Like I say, this is after explicitly being told “you need to do X, Y and Z in this order and this is what they should look like when they’re done”.

This is also very frustrating and demotivating for the students who did it all when they were asked to and then have to sit for weeks while the rest of the class laboriously catch up. There’s only so much extra stuff you can give students to do on their own, especially when ideally you’d be moving the whole class on.

ApplesandBunions · 20/07/2022 07:59

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/07/2022 22:00

Significant numbers of young people are struggling. There’s no mental health support for most of them.

Im hoping that by the time they get to mid 20’s or so they may have thrown off the shackles of lockdown and be like previous generations. But they may not. I don’t have an answer apart from much greater investment in adolescent and young adult mental health. Imo they are all about 2 years behind socially and mentally.

My friend is pastoral support in a 6th form and has said the exact same thing, that socially they're more like kids in Year 10 or 11. I suppose it's to be expected. Like you I am concerned and don't have an answer.

Paq · 20/07/2022 06:52

I agree with so much on this thread. As a parent of a teen, a university employee (not an academic) and as a part-time master's student who just handed in two assignments. Yes, it is stressful but dealing with the stress is part of the training.

I think the conversation needs to move from "how do we support young people?" to "how can young people become more resilient?". They, and their parents, need to take responsibility for this themselves and we needs to design schools and universities to help.

CallmeMrsPricklepants · 20/07/2022 06:35

I think the NSS had a lot to answer for. Departments are so scared of upsetting students by not meeting their every whim that there are no clear expectations set, no boundaries.

MangyInseam · 20/07/2022 01:31

I was just considering why so many of them have so suddenly become incapable.

It's been a leap, but not totally, things were already headed in that direction.

But I think it's a consequence of the same things happening at schools - many kids haven't been given structure and have had accommodation, they've never had to cope with hard deadlines.

They've not developed normal levels of independence for young adults in other areas of their lives.

They haven't had to face their anxieties or be stressed, so they really believe they can't manage these feelings.

Then on top of it for two years they have never had to face the real tests that other teens had to like exams or getting themselves to class. And they don't think they can or should. They feel they've been empowered to just balk.

I've really started to feel like disempowerment - not letting people feel they are responsible for their own decisions and the consequences, like their actions won't make a difference - is a much larger issue than we've recognized and that it's consequences, especially in the teen years, are significant and sometimes long lasting.

sparkysdream · 20/07/2022 00:00

This is a really interesting discussion and reminded me of this article by Kathleen Stock kathleenstock.substack.com/p/the-parent-trap

goldfinchonthelawn · 19/07/2022 23:54

GCAcademic · 19/07/2022 15:26

Universities are back to normal teaching and societies in full operation, and most have been for the past academic year. A few may not have been, but that is far from the norm.

Are we supposed to throw our hands up in the air and say “young people had a shit time for a couple of terms and so must never be expected to work to a deadline, or encounter stress or difficulties again, and must forevermore have the path smoothed for whatever (they think) makes them happy?” Should they also now have assessments of the kind they prefer )and which were only meant to be a temporary measure) even if that means allowing them to cheat, and turn a blind eye to that?

Or should we be attempting to restore processes that allowed them to benefit from university-level learning and to enter the workforce with the ability to forge the kind of career that they presumably hoped to embark on when they signed up for a degree course? It seems that this is not the preferred route of university administrators, or some parents on here, not to mention some of the students themselves, but we are failing them (in some cases literally) if we do otherwise.

I don't think we should make extra allowances forever - I agree with you on how to help them get resilient and start maturing. I was just considering why so many of them have so suddenly become incapable.

RampantIvy · 19/07/2022 22:59

But I can't help but feel like taking an exam in your house is completely different than taking one in an exam hall.

Of course it is.

DD said she preferred doing in person exams to open book ones. She said that getting an exam out of the way in three hours or so was far less stressful than writing what was essentially an assignment complete with referncing, that she would normally be given two weeks to do, in 24 or 48 hours.

Genderargh · 19/07/2022 22:39

I think it’s interesting as in my experience there has been an enormous shift very quickly. I’m 29 and I’ve seen such big differences in attitude (e.g people calling in sick for nothing or taking a whole day off for a telephone GP appointment). It’s really shocked me. I’ve also had some annoying health issues this year and people keep telling me to take extensions or defer etc (in postgraduate education) but It’s far bettter for my mental health to crack on!

NothingIsWrong · 19/07/2022 22:14

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/07/2022 22:01

A d allowances do have to be made at work under the disabilities act.

Reasonable adjustments under the Equality Act 2010 have to be considered. If there isn't an adjustment that can be made to make the job possible then it can't be done, taking into account cost, business needs and impact on other staff. For example, reception staff can't work from home however much they would wish so.

I work in a field where it isn't possible to make adjustments for many people so they simply can't do the job.

googoogagaaa · 19/07/2022 22:13

I do feel for recent graduates. But I can't help but feel like taking an exam in your house is completely different than taking one in an exam hall.

RollingInTheCreek · 19/07/2022 22:12

I also think that in the case of your daughter @ArseInTheCoOpWindow all the other factors would be considered in where best for her to study and what course given her struggles. The difference in support from family for students 300 miles away in halls compared to living at home is huge. A mostly small group delivered course with a small cohort size is completely different to a large cohort in large group lectures and 50% online. Those things need to be considered too as the University can make some adjustments but has no control over other circumstances

moksorineouimoksori · 19/07/2022 22:12

What does ability to engage with normal life mean to you?

Can't perform normal daily tasks like hygiene activities, can't feed themselves properly. Insomnia or excessive sleeping. Cognitive dysfunction. Ignoring commitments despite being aware of the consequences of doing so. Excessive escapism and avoidant behaviour. Many different things could apply.

theclangersarecoming · 19/07/2022 22:04

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/07/2022 21:46

We’re not doctors or mental health nurses or counsellors or their parents

Neither was l. But l did whatever l could to help and support. You seem to be implying that too much leeway is being given to students with problems. But l think it will get worse before it gets better. Maybe you need to adjust your mindset.

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow I’ve been supporting students like your DD for twenty years. So when all the the students who don’t have her issues say they also must have all the support and accommodations she gets, and they use this to just not hand the work in on time, am I supposed to let them, just because lockdown was a bit depressing? Would your DD be happy to get less support because everyone else wants it too and there’s not enough left to go round?

Plenty of posters have pointed out on the thread that a general culture of allowing any extension or allowance for no real reason actually takes support away from students like your DD. And it doesn’t help the students who really don’t have severe anxiety or migraines, but are pathologising normal nerves and normal social, academic and developmental experiences.

We aren’t teachers. We don’t have the statutory safeguarding duties teachers have; our employers don’t employ us to do that kind of job. I happen to know my students really well because if the system I’m in; lots of other university lecturers hardly meet their students and know little about them depending on the course and institution. If necessary, we refer students who need support to tutors, pastoral and mental health support. (I’ve seen plenty of well-meaning interventions by academics into student mental health support not go well.) That doesn’t mean we are unsympathetic. But does being sympathetic mean we allow any student who wants it essentially not to do the required work? That’s not what a university degree is, or what our job is.

poetryandwine · 19/07/2022 22:02

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow , people aren’t talking about your DD or other students with well documented conditions. I’ve sat on endless Mit Circs panels and whilst we always follow due process, it is clear who is in genuine distress, who is trying it on, and who is in this new category combining a sort of subclinical but possibly genuine malaise with a variable degree of entitlement.

But with the best will in the world there is only so much your DD’s uni will be able to do for her, and she will presumably need to finish her degree within the constraints of her loan. Every year about dozen well supported, academically able students in my own School, at a guess, fail to meet this challenge for reasons of MH. I am a harsh critic when support is lacking, but not in these cases. What would you have us do?

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/07/2022 22:01

A d allowances do have to be made at work under the disabilities act.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/07/2022 22:00

Significant numbers of young people are struggling. There’s no mental health support for most of them.

Im hoping that by the time they get to mid 20’s or so they may have thrown off the shackles of lockdown and be like previous generations. But they may not. I don’t have an answer apart from much greater investment in adolescent and young adult mental health. Imo they are all about 2 years behind socially and mentally.

antelopevalley · 19/07/2022 21:54

What does ability to engage with normal life mean to you?

RollingInTheCreek · 19/07/2022 21:53

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/07/2022 21:22

I find the op’s attitude appalling. It really got me. Get ready for the ones coming through. My gp says they’ve had so many teens and young adults affected by it. She told me it’s endless, and incomparable.

So looks like you might need to cultivate a better attitude because you’re only dealing with the start of it imo. I’d be furious if someone was like that about my dd.

l was a secondary teacher for 27 years. All sorts of kids had problems. I never sneered behind their backs.

I completely appreciate that and feel so sad for all the young people affected.

Not being goady but what is the solution? If we are talking significant percentages of young people struggling- what do we do when that generation are our GPs, nurses, bus drivers, bin men, scientists and they can’t cope with pressure or stress? The world will grind to a halt or be carried on the backs of those who are mentally well but the pressure will eventually get to them too.

Unless as young people who present with mental health problems we guide them down career pathways that reduce stress and don’t challenge them to the extent others would but then do they reach their full potential? Achieve their dreams or just what’s deemed suitable? As an adult in work allowances can’t always be made- you need to be reliable and dependable.

Chouetted · 19/07/2022 21:53

Jourdain11 · 19/07/2022 21:41

My concern is that we grant these endless extensions, deferrals, etc. on tenuous grounds, not on a legitimate basis but as a tick box exercise. We've been 'considerate', we can say that we've made adjustments, but it doesn't actually help the students in the long run. In fact, it presents them with a bigger source of stress at this point in the year.

It is also profoundly problematic in relation to EDI, because we're essentially nullifying the adjustments which we offer to students with documented disabilities/health concerns/MH issues and they're therefore no longer on a level playing field.

The thing I don't quite understand is that, IIRC, the difference in results between disadvantaged students and, for want of a better word, "normal" students closed significantly during the "safety net" times. Isn't that a win for EDI?

moksorineouimoksori · 19/07/2022 21:51

Even those who cite anxiety when it's probably more like natural nerves, concern or pressure they're putting on themselves - I wouldn't say they are making it up. More that they're misinterpreting a natural response as being somehow 'abnormal'.

Are they diagnosed?
If anxiety is affecting their ability to engage with normal life, then it is abnormal.
I think many young people and students have been sold the idea that MH is no longer a taboo and will be taken seriously through awareness programs etc, so they feel they can be open.
Unfortunately, attitudes don't shift overnight, even if people pay lip service.

GCAcademic · 19/07/2022 21:49

You seem to be implying that too much leeway is being given to students with problems

That isn’t what the OP, or other academics on here, are saying. Rather the opposite, in fact.

Swipe left for the next trending thread