Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Making accommodations isn't always 'kind' (uni)

543 replies

Jourdain11 · 18/07/2022 18:20

I'm interested in knowing general opinions on this. I would accept that the last few years have been tough for students, and UG finalists in particular have had their full course horribly disrupted. But I am struck by how the accommodations made for students have really not helped them, in a large proportion of cases. I work in a uni (London Russell Group, competitive and highly-rated) and the number of students who have requested deferrals and so on for MH reasons is huge. In my role, I pushed back a bit and said that we shouldn't be advocating this as a way of dealing with any level of pressure and anxiety. In some cases it was absolutely necessary, but in others I felt that it was just becoming a pattern or a way of buying more time.

Ultimately, in the careers many of these graduates will go on to have, they will have to work to deadlines and deal with pressure, and part of the uni experience is providing preparation for that.

We now have students who are very upset because they cannot graduate with their peers, who are very anxious because they've deferred half their year's assessments to a one-werk resits period and feel they will not cope, or who are just disappointed that they haven't completed the year and have uncertainty as regards progression. Plus those who have now come to see assessment as an absolutely terrifying and insurmountable thing because we have agreed that they clearly weren't capable of sitting their exams, when they probably were.

Overall, I feel that we need to be encouraging coping strategies and empowering students, rather than encouraging them to opt out on the most tenuous rationale. But some of my colleagues would consider this to be virtually heresy and I'm not sure how we're going to get out of this place we have found ourselves in.

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 21/07/2022 11:03

antelopevalley · 20/07/2022 18:24

Except they did not spend two years without friends or socialising.

You do realise that not all students are drug taking, alcoholic party animals don't you? It's quite insulting to the large proportion of students who aren't interested in that lifestyle!

My son only made friends with only a handful of flat mates in campus accommodation in the worst affected covid year 20/21. In that year, for his course, there wasn't a single "in person" lecture, tutorial or seminar and his college common room was kept locked and in darkness - even during the periods between lockdowns, where limited socialising was allowed! They weren't allowed to sit together in the library as desks/tables were separated and adjoining ones were covered in "do not use" notices and hazard tape! He did a couple of "group" tasks but the others in his group weren't on campus (two weren't even in the country) so no "real life" friends from that either!

Yes, there were other students wandering around the campus, but literally the only "get togethers" were based around alcohol, which just isn't his scene. Yes, some students went to pubs/bars (when allowed), and yes, some would "socialise" in eachothers' flats.

But I get quite annoyed at the narrative that suggests all students are obsessed with partying. My son doesn't drink, and luckily a couple of his flat mates weren't "party" animals either, so his flat remained pretty "quiet" throughout the first year.

Luckily, although he's absolutely hated his Uni experience so far, he's kept his sanity and has knuckled down and done the work, and not expected any extensions nor concessions. He's not happy about things, but knows it's a means to an end, and is grateful that he's now done 2 years and only has 1 year left. He certainly won't be looking back with misty eyes and thinking it's been the best years of his life, and hasn't made life long friends!

poetryandwine · 21/07/2022 08:10

@goldfinchonthelawn I apologise. I should have started a new paragraph to disassociate that comment from you. The comparison was attempted some while back.

I agree we can be empathetic without infantilising students, also. @TomPinch is right that encouraging students to wallow (and making too many concessions, although my standard for that is not on the strict side) is disempowering.

goldfinchonthelawn · 21/07/2022 07:53

@poetryandwine - I didn't compare Covid to the war experience? Was that a refernece to another post in a paragraph that tagged me?

I also think it is possible to be empathetic about their experience and to try ands grasp the impact it has had on their generation without infantilising them in the process.

TomPinch · 21/07/2022 07:33

TullyApplebottom · 20/07/2022 18:26

I literally cannot believe the determination to argue that teenagers and young people have not been put through a highly abnormal period. It just seems mad. Would a shred of empathy cost too much?

I see a lot of empathy on this thread. What everyone here wants is for students to succeed and thrive. Encouraging them to feel really bad isn't true empathy at all: it's disempowerment, irresponsible, and potentially quite horrible in its effects.

There are some earlier comments (not, I think, from you) about how it's not surprising that university students know they have bleak prospects. Well, in an inversion of that over-used comment by Aristotle about young people's poor morals, it's also true that the young of every generation think they have it uniquely bad compared to their elders. The truth is that every generation has its own unique challenges. Furthermore, every generation has to make its own way in the world, and it does look daunting at the start.

I think it's helpful for anyone who is having a bad time to remember that anyone around them of any age may have their own bad stuff going on, and while we should also treat eachother with kindness, we also have to take courage and continue.

Keep calm and carry on, if you like, but I think the UK began to repudiate that way of being years ago.

TomPinch · 21/07/2022 07:16

There’s also an odd thing that one of the PPs mentioned where they will spend a LONG time on work. Way longer than needed or asked for. And yet the work is still often of noticeably poorer quality than previous years

Flicking over to social media? But on the other hand that must have been an enormous time-waster for a decade now.

Phineyj · 20/07/2022 22:20

MarchingFrogs, imagine what it's like for teachers!

Haudyourwheesht · 20/07/2022 21:27

poetryandwine · 20/07/2022 18:59

@maryso and others, sometimes students with the greatest MH needs are the most reluctant to access help. This becomes really difficult for everyone.

@TullyApplebottom I don’t see anyone denying that today’s student’s have been through very bad times. My uni is not alone in having let them down. But this sits side by side with the fact that staff during those times were on their knees from overwork. This thread hasn’t acknowledged that. The idea that academic staff let students down is largely wrong. Mostly lapsed infrastructure, poor central planning, etc were the culprits. Also just an impossible situation. @CoffeeWithCheese posted pretty typical experiences.

@goldfinchonthelawn makes an excellent point about the developing brain and how it may link to resilience. The brain is very sensitive in the late teen years. But comparing Covid to a war experience is obscene. PTSD, amputation and other life changing injuries, starvation and violent death on a large scale, anyone? (Obviously we had deaths, but violent ones are a different category.)

But, you know, they got to travel so they were better off than young people during Covid.

Never mind that they never came home from their 'travels'.

MarchingFrogs · 20/07/2022 20:08

...or taking a whole day off for a telephone GP appointment

Sorry, just diverting back to this for a moment. Early last year, when schools were only open physically to key workers' and vulnerable DC, DS2 got himself a telephone GP appointment. When he just said 'It's on Wednesday the week after next', I naïvely thought that he had forgotten at what time. But no, 'Wednesday the week after next' was literally his appointment. So had he actually been in school, his phone could have rung when he was in transit there or back (discuss your medical issues at the side of a busy road, anyone?), or in a lesson (assuming that the teachers would have agreed for him to keep his phone on - probably, to be fair - and that he had remembered to ask and not just turned it off automatically), or - as it eventually did, at 6.45 in the evening.

(Previous appointments - the old-fashioned, tip up to the waiting room a few minutes early, get called in at some time usually fairly close to the arranged one, speak to someone in the flesh for a few minutes variety - on a school day had involved being a little late in, leaving a little early, or walking / being taken to the surgery at some point after coming home...).

Armed with that experience, had he needed to make another appointment once he was back in school, I might well have suggested that he took the day off for it.

poetryandwine · 20/07/2022 18:59

@maryso and others, sometimes students with the greatest MH needs are the most reluctant to access help. This becomes really difficult for everyone.

@TullyApplebottom I don’t see anyone denying that today’s student’s have been through very bad times. My uni is not alone in having let them down. But this sits side by side with the fact that staff during those times were on their knees from overwork. This thread hasn’t acknowledged that. The idea that academic staff let students down is largely wrong. Mostly lapsed infrastructure, poor central planning, etc were the culprits. Also just an impossible situation. @CoffeeWithCheese posted pretty typical experiences.

@goldfinchonthelawn makes an excellent point about the developing brain and how it may link to resilience. The brain is very sensitive in the late teen years. But comparing Covid to a war experience is obscene. PTSD, amputation and other life changing injuries, starvation and violent death on a large scale, anyone? (Obviously we had deaths, but violent ones are a different category.)

maryso · 20/07/2022 18:31

@goldfinchonthelawn I haven't read the whole thread, and the points you make seem fair. The system is there for students genuinely in need, and rightly so. However other students who also faced the same world can easily distinguish the malingers from the ones who need support. And they're the same age. And @antelopevalley is right, they didn't spend the last 2 years without friends or socialising, there's a tendency from certain tribes to play the system, and they also tend to be disruptive during the course, so there is little sympathy for them, and are called out in course chats. There's no shortage of camaraderie for those genuinely in need.

RampantIvy · 20/07/2022 18:30

Well said @goldfinchonthelawn.

I'm surprised that so many university tutors and lecturers are expected to nursemaid the students so much.

Although DD did request a couple of PECs, which were refused (IMO asking for an extra week for a dissertation when she was laid very low with covid for a week and unable to do any work at all was not unreasonable) and even her dissertation tutor said she should have been granted one, she managed to get her dissertation over the line before the deadline (just).

It seems that DD's university take a much stricter line on marking. She knows some engineering students who scored very badly in one of their third year exams. One student scored 0% and one scored 5%.

So, not all universities give into pressure from the students.

TullyApplebottom · 20/07/2022 18:26

I literally cannot believe the determination to argue that teenagers and young people have not been put through a highly abnormal period. It just seems mad. Would a shred of empathy cost too much?

antelopevalley · 20/07/2022 18:24

Except they did not spend two years without friends or socialising.

goldfinchonthelawn · 20/07/2022 18:20

I came on this thread to agree with OP that overall, we need to stop pathologising teen distress and stress and showing them that it is normal and they can cope and it will pass. But I think some people om this thread are a bit too dismissive of the impact Covid has had. If you are 20, and the first two of your uni years were interrupted by Covid, that's 10% of your entire life and life experience. Or 19 and sat no A levels, had no goodbyes with friends, no celebrations when results came out, arrived at a uni to sit alone in a bedsit and log onto yet another screen, for all tutorials and lectures, with no bar or library to go to, no societies open, it's going to impact heavily on your ability to socialise.

These - late teens, early twenties - are the years when the brain is primed to soak up new experience, learn from mistakes, take risks etc. Instead all teen brains were seriously understimulated for months on end, reliant on dopamine-addictive screen time for hours a day and little else. We may be more resilient because our brains got that stimulation at that crucial time in life, and lockdown was a far tinier percentage of our time on earth - we had loads more experience to draw on.

bruffin · 20/07/2022 17:59

ludocris · 20/07/2022 08:50

This is very true

My sister works for a uni and says exactly the same!

maryso · 20/07/2022 17:49

My DCs have always said that from the start of a course, you can see various tribes forming, and from their priorities, can predict those who will be disruptive/ nerdy/ etc, will be asking for extensions, will be very vocally negative in group comments. This from some courses that are competitive enough to involve surviving interviews that require significant life experiences and skills to even get offered a place. DCs question if they learned to fake how rational adults behave under stress, or had identical siblings who tested or interviewed? Because they sure as hell aren't making good choices in their lives.

Qualifications have to be earned. Perhaps the kindest and best option all round is that they fail, or at least have to resit out of cohort, and decide whether they should do something else? Coping with stressful demands by pleading MH rather than tackling the work just piles up the work, and vicious cycle. The genuinely ill are easily spotted. Many who are ill but not debilitatingly so, press on and get past, heal afterwards. Risky, but self awareness is part of adulthood. I think that the student perspective (party without work tribe excluded) is about the same as the staff one.

antelopevalley · 20/07/2022 17:16

I have no idea if the KS article is true or not. But through personal knowledge of working with them I know one university who has terrible practices that are often illegal. I would not be surprised if they were taken to court.

poetryandwine · 20/07/2022 15:40

The more I learn about Kathleen Stock the more ambivalently I view her. But I agree that the article @sparkysdream links to on p12 is good, and thought provoking. (The article in The Critic that KS links to is full of cheap shots and claims of bad practice that I can’t imagine IRL, if only because they would leave the uni open to lawsuits.)

CoffeeWithCheese · 20/07/2022 14:55

Our uni was very clear from the start - lecturers could give a 2 week extension within some limits - otherwise you had to go through the formal deferral process. I think staff were lovely and helpful with students getting through that if there were legitimate reasons, but I don't think the process was as straightforward if it was someone trying it on shall we say?!

FlySwimmer · 20/07/2022 13:33

@CoffeeWithCheese Well done on getting through all that and coming out with your degree! I’d personally ban 69%… it’s either 68 or 70, 69 just feels personal somehow Grin

One thing I note from your posts though is how you sat with key people & made plans for work, and then clearly actually did it (leaving aside Covid hell!). I’ve lost count of the number of students I’ve done that with, creating a roadmap for their work & how they’ll get it done, from research to writing to editing and submission. And then, so many of them just… don’t do it? And it all gets kicked to the next assessment period, and then the next. That’s one aspect I really don’t understand, I’ll admit. How do you help further in that scenario? I don’t have endless time to have meetings with students to plan work, which then never gets done. (Not aimed at you specifically @CoffeeWithCheese, more of a general point.)

CoffeeWithCheese · 20/07/2022 11:09

poetryandwine · 20/07/2022 10:45

For the info of MNetters, @CoffeeWithCheese had some genuinely shit experiences at uni. On a different thread she asked for advice and several of us responded, essentially, ‘I seldom advise students to appeal, but I think you should appeal.’

Thanks for that @poetryandwine - I was typing kind of quickly as I had to go out somewhere! I have appealed - not expecting it to bring results but it's more me living with myself knowing I gave it everything through the course.

That bloody NSS though - it's like impossible to avoid them - I tried a fair few times and then they blooming rang me up about 3 times to catch me!

Genuinely good to "see" you though @Jourdain11 - hope all is going well for you.

poetryandwine · 20/07/2022 10:45

For the info of MNetters, @CoffeeWithCheese had some genuinely shit experiences at uni. On a different thread she asked for advice and several of us responded, essentially, ‘I seldom advise students to appeal, but I think you should appeal.’

CoffeeWithCheese · 20/07/2022 09:49

As for online exams. Hate.
Trying to get my house quiet with guaranteed stable wi-fi.
Then one of our big online ones was phonetics - video clip would be made available for the exam duration, we had to transcribe, photograph our transcription (typing phonetic characters sucks) and email it within a given time... video didn't become available at the right time - and it really threw me into a panic attack, so I was trying to fight the technology, transcribe (and phonetics is usually one which really stresses every SALT student out as it's just such a different skill and our mark requirements are so high for it), panic and get all of that done. In a normal year we would have gone into a room, with our usual lecturer delivering the exercises in a way we were used to, transcribed it and left our transcriptions to be marked. It was awful. I still passed with an incredibly high mark (I'm fucking GOOD at phonetics and linguistics) so that's not me freaking out from a lack of preparation or skill - it was just horrid.

CoffeeWithCheese · 20/07/2022 09:44

I've skimmed and I'll pop back later and read fully because I need to go out. I've just finished a degree as a mature student - with healthcare placement elements in it so you can imagine how wonderfully disrupted that one's been in the current circumstances! Cannot fault my department staff though - they've been brilliant. They're fucking brutal in terms of how tough they can be on us with assessments - but come out high on satisfaction every year because of how close-knit the course is with small numbers and everyone being noticed if they're starting to struggle and disengage.

I've deferred elements through it though - I had to, because my mental health just disintegrated completely with the pandemic and combining trying to do the degree with my own kids' home learning and them mentally really struggling - so I sat with my tutor and we planned moving some assessments to the summer period so I could basically focus on the kids and just keep uni ticking over until the school year was done - was supported by the staff.

I think I had a two week extension on an assignment this year as well - the kids had covid, then the husband had man-covid and then I got absolutely flattened with it for a good week - so yep, no matter how well I'd planned my schedules out and workload, and had all the prep reading done for it - there was no way that one was getting submitted on time!

I actually have mentoring funded by DSA as I've got a history of shocking mental health (now I have an autism diagnosis which explains a lot of the times in life I've struggled to cope) - have rarely needed it in terms of planning out workload, but it's been used a lot this year to offload and discuss mental coping strategies as it's been absolutely brutal going through university on a healthcare course with Covid hitting at the end of the first year. It's not fair to dismiss the massive toll that it's taken on students though - it has been horrendous - and yes, there are a few on my course who've cried anxiety whenever it didn't suit them, and I'm currently bloody pissed off as I ended up on 69% but didn't get upgraded to a first, but our chief anxiety queen got 69% and DID get a first and is currently gloating all over social media about it all!

In hindsight, part of me wishes I'd suspended for a year, but graduating and staying with my cohort was important to me - and I feared if I stopped then I wouldn't restart. We have lost a LOT of students this year - ones who took peak lockdown year out and dropped back a year, ones who've had placements fall through through no fault of their own because of Covid hitting and had to fall back a year to re-take placements, and people who've just hit the wall of disengagement and had enough.

Second year online was awful - our recorded stuff was all uploaded by 4pm on a Thursday. By 4.01pm the online learning platform had inevitably keeled over as the entire university all tried to log on to see what they had to get through. Then it was log on every morning - slog through a couple of hours of recorded lectures with no interaction (my course is very small so there's not normally this lecture/seminar division and everything is very interactive), connect to the odd scheduled thing for the day - not get to choose who you were placed with or working with for group tasks (and as an autistic - that screen going black before you go into random breakout groups is fucking awful on the anxiety), pray you ended up with a group where people were still actually engaged with the task - go back into the main room... then we would usually lose about 15 minutes while staff battled to get videos or sound clips to play - at one point we ended up being asked to analyse someone's speech sample with the lecturer playing it on his phone holding it up to the microphone on his laptop, or connections would go shitty and you ended up with seminars being conducted solely via the lecturer painfully typing with two fingers. Then trying to do assignments with only e-books available as the library was still on lockdown - and one of the e-book platforms doesn't work well with Mac laptops which made things harder for a lot of people... and my dyslexia makes reading on-screen quite tricky - I need to annotate things and highlight to process text. I loved my subject and my course - but god it drained all the enjoyment out of it. If I had been 18-19 and expecting to have fun at uni, then dropped into this without a perception of the long-term stakes in terms of student debt, future employment etc - I would have given up.

DrBlackbird · 20/07/2022 09:19

CallmeMrsPricklepants · 20/07/2022 06:35

I think the NSS had a lot to answer for. Departments are so scared of upsetting students by not meeting their every whim that there are no clear expectations set, no boundaries.

This comment resonates with my experience of the NSS. Asking students about fairness in relation to their marks is insane. As if any student receiving a lower than expected mark will feel it’s fair.

Coupled with the evidence that lower performing students tend to have a poor ability to evaluate the quality of their work. Yet the NSS guides so much of our central admin thinking and initiatives.

Marking and assessment has been fair

www.officeforstudents.org.uk/media/703530d2-1c8f-48fc-a62d-23b278b8b799/nss-2021-core-questionnaire-optional-banks.pdf

Swipe left for the next trending thread