Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Making accommodations isn't always 'kind' (uni)

543 replies

Jourdain11 · 18/07/2022 18:20

I'm interested in knowing general opinions on this. I would accept that the last few years have been tough for students, and UG finalists in particular have had their full course horribly disrupted. But I am struck by how the accommodations made for students have really not helped them, in a large proportion of cases. I work in a uni (London Russell Group, competitive and highly-rated) and the number of students who have requested deferrals and so on for MH reasons is huge. In my role, I pushed back a bit and said that we shouldn't be advocating this as a way of dealing with any level of pressure and anxiety. In some cases it was absolutely necessary, but in others I felt that it was just becoming a pattern or a way of buying more time.

Ultimately, in the careers many of these graduates will go on to have, they will have to work to deadlines and deal with pressure, and part of the uni experience is providing preparation for that.

We now have students who are very upset because they cannot graduate with their peers, who are very anxious because they've deferred half their year's assessments to a one-werk resits period and feel they will not cope, or who are just disappointed that they haven't completed the year and have uncertainty as regards progression. Plus those who have now come to see assessment as an absolutely terrifying and insurmountable thing because we have agreed that they clearly weren't capable of sitting their exams, when they probably were.

Overall, I feel that we need to be encouraging coping strategies and empowering students, rather than encouraging them to opt out on the most tenuous rationale. But some of my colleagues would consider this to be virtually heresy and I'm not sure how we're going to get out of this place we have found ourselves in.

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 23/07/2022 19:11

The reality is that pre the internet, we simply couldn't have had lockdowns on the scale that we did. There's no way that Universities could have continued operating at all if lecturers/students weren't on campuses without an alternative method (albeit very flawed) of delivering the tuition online. Likewise no way we could have closed down so many other workplaces, i.e. offices, banks, etc without the internet. I think it's now obvious that the internet is a double edged sword as it facilitates crazy things like lockdowns, but at least now that the resultant damage can be seen, we can only hope that they're never happen again and some more sensible alternative measures are planned to deal with future pandemics.

ApplesandBunions · 23/07/2022 16:49

Exactly, there were no national lockdowns and so the experience of them is something new and specific. It's immaterial to this discussion what the reason for that was.

antelopevalley · 23/07/2022 16:39

@ApplesandBunions There were no national lockdowns because people in the recent past did not travel much. It could take many months for an infection to spread across the country. So of course the response was more localised. It would have been ridiculous to have a national lockdown for a part of the country that may not have a polio outbreak until six months later.

ApplesandBunions · 23/07/2022 16:26

antelopevalley · 23/07/2022 16:00

Polio outbreaks as recent in the fifties led in some places to school closures, swimming pool and library closures and people avoiding shops. Work continued though.

What you describe here is not a lockdown as practiced in the UK during this pandemic. Some regional school closures and work continuing is not the same as nationally decreed closures of schools and whole economic sectors, and it didn't involve people being subjected to significant restrictions on leaving their homes.

antelopevalley · 23/07/2022 16:00

Polio outbreaks as recent in the fifties led in some places to school closures, swimming pool and library closures and people avoiding shops. Work continued though.

antelopevalley · 23/07/2022 15:59

Not true. Lockdowns happened for polio outbreaks.

ApplesandBunions · 23/07/2022 15:55

Yes, lockdown and quarantine are two very different things. Quarantine is ancient. Lockdown as practiced in the UK during this pandemic is brand new.

TullyApplebottom · 23/07/2022 15:21

JennieTheZebra · 23/07/2022 11:24

@TullyApplebottom
That’s not quite true. Lockdowns and quarantine have been pretty common in history during times of plague. I know that we haven’t had a significant disease outbreak in living memory, so it felt “new”, but social distancing was mandated during the Spanish Flu, for example, (see this article www.nationalgeographic.com/history/article/how-cities-flattened-curve-1918-spanish-flu-pandemic-coronavirus which explains how that worked) . Even the word “quarantine” derives from a specific period of mandated social isolation-the 40 days (“quaranta”) a ship had to spend in harbour before the inhabitants were allowed ashore, to try and stop the spread of bubonic plague.
The main differences between this generation and the ones in the past are that a) unlike in the past, a big epidemic was unexpected and the subsequent public health responses frightening and unfamiliar
b) they had access to the internet.
In theory having access to the internet should have made this easier but, as social media is such a strange phenomenon anyway, in some ways the internet seems almost to have made it worse. To what extent there should be continued accommodations is a difficult question and it is one I don’t really have an answer to. I just wanted to correct the misconception that this experience was particularly historically unique; public health quarantines were the norm for a very long time, just not recently.

I am well aware of all that, thank you. The measures undertaken to combat Spanish flu were not comparable in scale to the national lockdowns we have just experienced. If you have to reach back to the time of plague for a parallel I think that reinforces the point that the period we have just been through is truly extraordinary. It is simply not reasonable to expect it not yo have affected young people adversely.

JennieTheZebra · 23/07/2022 11:24

@TullyApplebottom
That’s not quite true. Lockdowns and quarantine have been pretty common in history during times of plague. I know that we haven’t had a significant disease outbreak in living memory, so it felt “new”, but social distancing was mandated during the Spanish Flu, for example, (see this article www.nationalgeographic.com/history/article/how-cities-flattened-curve-1918-spanish-flu-pandemic-coronavirus which explains how that worked) . Even the word “quarantine” derives from a specific period of mandated social isolation-the 40 days (“quaranta”) a ship had to spend in harbour before the inhabitants were allowed ashore, to try and stop the spread of bubonic plague.
The main differences between this generation and the ones in the past are that a) unlike in the past, a big epidemic was unexpected and the subsequent public health responses frightening and unfamiliar
b) they had access to the internet.
In theory having access to the internet should have made this easier but, as social media is such a strange phenomenon anyway, in some ways the internet seems almost to have made it worse. To what extent there should be continued accommodations is a difficult question and it is one I don’t really have an answer to. I just wanted to correct the misconception that this experience was particularly historically unique; public health quarantines were the norm for a very long time, just not recently.

ApplesandBunions · 23/07/2022 09:14

TullyApplebottom · 23/07/2022 07:31

We also, of course, indulged ourselves in a lot of rhetoric about how the young had a responsibility to those older than them to protect them and should therefore comply, as potential vectors of disease. Which we certainly could have chosen not to do. That may also have an effect.

True.

TullyApplebottom · 23/07/2022 07:31

We also, of course, indulged ourselves in a lot of rhetoric about how the young had a responsibility to those older than them to protect them and should therefore comply, as potential vectors of disease. Which we certainly could have chosen not to do. That may also have an effect.

TullyApplebottom · 23/07/2022 07:27

I’m afraid the statement that no generation has been through an experience like lockdown is actually true (it’s probably necessary for this audience to spell out that that is not the same as saying that no generation has been through anything as bad). I cannot think of a time when inaction and isolation has been forced on the population on this scale. It was a psychological experiment on all of us and we do not yet understand what all the impacts have been, especially on the young.
i am not suggesting we should tell them they have been damaged but as the adults in the room who let this happen - indeed in many cases bayed and shrieked for it to happen - we should acknowledge our responsibility and have empathy and compassion.

TomPinch · 22/07/2022 22:44

I disagree with a lot of what Tullyapplebottom had said, but I agree that the WW2 comparison is unhelpful - for different reasons though.

How the British behaved during WW2 has become something of a national myth, and makes for a belief (which I think is no longer true) that the British tend to tough things out by paying insufficient attention to their mental health. The result is an overreaction to feeling bad about stuff in a way that I don't see happening in my adopted country.

But it's worth remembering that the reason why the WW2 comparison was raised on this thread - because of the allegation that no generation had been through what this one had. That allegation strikes me as either not capable of any meaningful comparison and therefore meaningless, or it is hyperbolic. And hyperbole is going to distort a person's view of what they've gone though in a very unhelpful way. A person's perception of their own suffering can be a very suggestible, malleable thing.

TullyApplebottom · 22/07/2022 16:49

poetryandwine · 22/07/2022 16:42

@TullyApplebottom , even amongst soldiers, the nostalgic idea of war building resilience is true only for the lucky. According to www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2089086/,
15% of British soldiers were discharged from WW1 with shell shock, about 1/3 of the Allied casualties in the 1943 Tunisian campaign were neuropsychiatric, and about 25% of soldiers in the early years of the Korean conflict suffered neuropsychiatric diseases.

In the recent article militaryhealth.bmj.com/content/early/2022/01/17/bmjmilitary-2021-002045
the authors report that in a large, comprehensive search of NHS records in a certain area of the UK, 38% of veterans sought MH care between 1985 and 2021. This is significantly higher than the general population.

I am not prejudiced against soldiers. My adored grandfather's family had a long military tradition. He was the somewhat indulged baby of a large family; WW2 was the making of him and he went on to a successful military career. I just think resilience is built only for the lucky ones. These data would appear to support my hypothesis, as there is surely a large grey area between 'resilient' and a psychiatric diagnosis.

But again, I was not making a point about active combat. Of course that can impact mental health, but Most people in this country did not see active combat.
the point is really quite a simple one; the comparison between the wartime generation and the covid generation is inapt, because their experiences are not comparable. The comparison does not afford a basis for concluding, as some here have done, that the covid generation’s current behaviour is evidence of inherent defects in their character or upbringing.

poetryandwine · 22/07/2022 16:42

@TullyApplebottom , even amongst soldiers, the nostalgic idea of war building resilience is true only for the lucky. According to www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2089086/,
15% of British soldiers were discharged from WW1 with shell shock, about 1/3 of the Allied casualties in the 1943 Tunisian campaign were neuropsychiatric, and about 25% of soldiers in the early years of the Korean conflict suffered neuropsychiatric diseases.

In the recent article militaryhealth.bmj.com/content/early/2022/01/17/bmjmilitary-2021-002045
the authors report that in a large, comprehensive search of NHS records in a certain area of the UK, 38% of veterans sought MH care between 1985 and 2021. This is significantly higher than the general population.

I am not prejudiced against soldiers. My adored grandfather's family had a long military tradition. He was the somewhat indulged baby of a large family; WW2 was the making of him and he went on to a successful military career. I just think resilience is built only for the lucky ones. These data would appear to support my hypothesis, as there is surely a large grey area between 'resilient' and a psychiatric diagnosis.

Kazzyhoward · 22/07/2022 13:49

FlySwimmer · 22/07/2022 13:02

A lot of people are ignoring that this was a problem before Covid. It’s not a case of returning to how things were before the pandemic, as things were pretty bad then too. Covid just increased it. This is a longer-term and deeper problem among this generation of students. So acknowledging they’ve had it tough (and no, not tougher than their lecturers, as a PP suggested) won’t get us anywhere near solving the problem, as it’s more deep-seated than Covid alone.

Well yes, there is a bigger issue in society around all kinds of "reasonable adjustments" for lots of reasons which some would call "dumbing down".

Look at entry requirements for say the police or fire service where physical abilities has been massively watered down. There was a time when you couldn't get in the police if you wore glasses or couldn't run the specified length in the specified time, but no longer. Likewise there used to be a weight lifting requirement for the fire service which has been massively watered down. There are now even hoists and lifting equipment on fire appliances to get, say, the portable pump off the appliance, whereas in the past, it would just take a couple of burly blokes to carry it off!

And then there is dyslexia and dyscalculia where pupils at all stages can be awarded "accommodations" but where such people would really struggle in a workplace, i.e. someone with dyscalculia really, really, shouldn't be working in a numerical job such as book-keeping or accounting or tax, and someone with dyslexia shouldn't be a book editor or proof reader!

But that is a problem for society in general. Not sure why it's fine and dandy for someone with a recognised disorder to get extra exam time, a scribe, deadline extensions, but someone whose been severely affected by covid restrictions, but has no MH diagnosis doesn't deserve any accommodations at all?

FlySwimmer · 22/07/2022 13:02

A lot of people are ignoring that this was a problem before Covid. It’s not a case of returning to how things were before the pandemic, as things were pretty bad then too. Covid just increased it. This is a longer-term and deeper problem among this generation of students. So acknowledging they’ve had it tough (and no, not tougher than their lecturers, as a PP suggested) won’t get us anywhere near solving the problem, as it’s more deep-seated than Covid alone.

CoffeeWithCheese · 22/07/2022 12:20

I was horrified by how students were treated during the pandemic - the students in Manchester literally fenced into their accommodation blocks at points, the ones in my city being blamed for social gatherings and causing us to move up a covid tier - when the uni had covid tested anything that moved and the social gatherings in question were waiting at a tram stop to travel onto campus... and healthcare students had a really really crappy time of it with the ever-changing rules and placement stop-gos.

Yes, there are some entitled babied idiots out there - I can think of a couple of my course, but they were in the minority and most of the cohort I was with really did knuckle down, get on with it, find workarounds for as much as they could do and slog on through changed assessments, screwed up placements and the whole debacle. Even the ones who were awestruck by the initial experience of how a washing machine worked have come out the other side of it with heads screwed on - and through it all they took all the shit hurled at young people being blamed for all the covid tiers and eternal Leicester lockdown, followed all the rules (except the one spoilt princess one who caused chaos and pissed off an entire house-share of half the bloody course) and really really tried to do the right thing.

I think the pisstake contingent was always there but in the past they would have drifted into jobs post-school and kind of muddled along - but now they HAVE to go to university and some of the more consumer-savvy universities who have to actively push for numbers DO tend to bend over too far backwards to keep them on-board. Mind you I think it's probably one half of the ex-polys as you sure as hell aren't going to be allowed to doss about on a vocational healthcare course!

Kazzyhoward · 22/07/2022 12:18

TullyApplebottom · 22/07/2022 11:29

This seems bang on to me. It’s easier for management to default to « remove the demands » mode. Students ask for that because that’s what they’ve learned to do. Teaching staff caught in the middle, a generation of young people unable to cope with any rigour at all. It’s no good.

Surely the aim is for things to get back closer to pre covid "normal" over time?

Accommodations needed to be made, virtually without question/argument during the worst affected years, but as things improve, with new cohorts coming through, then things need tightening up again, slowly, over time.

Just like in virtually every other walk in life, where changes and flexibility had to be invoked just for things to continue moving at all, and where mostly, those changes have now been reversed and we're heading back to normal.

TullyApplebottom · 22/07/2022 11:31

WillMcAvoy · 22/07/2022 11:27

Yes it is quite telling that you are determined to make all young adults into sad victims riddled with mental health difficulties. They aren't, and you are not helping them at all. Why are you pretending asif they were all locked into cages for 2 years, when that is far far from the case?
It is no wonder these young adults can't cope with even an essay, you have schooled them to be pathetic.

TF mine and most I know are nothing like this.

I am not saying that at all. I am saying they have been through a highly abnormal experience which has compromised their resilience and development and those around them need to bear that in mind. Outside the rather odd little world of MN I doubt you would find many people who would argue with that, tbh

TullyApplebottom · 22/07/2022 11:29

GCAcademic · 22/07/2022 09:51

There should be a general appreciation from the teaching staff that students have had a very tough time and a level of flexibility is needed, not just for those with a written diagnosis. There's a hell of a lot of middle ground between rigid adherence to the strict rules of pre-covid and a complete free for all where extensions are given on demand.

But we’re nowhere near the middle ground, that’s the whole point of this thread. It’s absolutely a free for all, and some universities (including mine) are talking about continuing with self-granted extensions indefinitely. The middle ground is where we want to be, but it’s proving very hard to get there because there’s a mindset from university management and students that we’re to go back to “normal” in every respect except in asking students to complete work on time.

This seems bang on to me. It’s easier for management to default to « remove the demands » mode. Students ask for that because that’s what they’ve learned to do. Teaching staff caught in the middle, a generation of young people unable to cope with any rigour at all. It’s no good.

WillMcAvoy · 22/07/2022 11:27

Yes it is quite telling that you are determined to make all young adults into sad victims riddled with mental health difficulties. They aren't, and you are not helping them at all. Why are you pretending asif they were all locked into cages for 2 years, when that is far far from the case?
It is no wonder these young adults can't cope with even an essay, you have schooled them to be pathetic.

TF mine and most I know are nothing like this.

TullyApplebottom · 22/07/2022 11:25

Oh and also castigating their parents. That’s very important.
this is prejudice talking, not reason.

TullyApplebottom · 22/07/2022 11:24

WillMcAvoy · 22/07/2022 09:01

You're still wrong. For a great many, war involved forced removal of social contact. Do you think it was harder to be a child sent away for up to 6 years from your entire family and everything you know, not knowing if any of you would survive it, or was it watching netflix in your dorm room unable to socialise for a while as you had the whole world available to you online and the ability to go home any time you choose?

And WHY did it make those, who suffered much more, so resilient while a comparable much easier situation made modern youngsters so depressed and anxious? Is it because they have a learned victim mentality where every norma emotion is pathologised and labelled as a disorder? Is it because they are babied and mollycoddled?

You are absolutely right to point out the problems caused to very young children by removal from home, but that is not the age group we are talking about here (nor is it the same thing as lockdown, but never mind that for now).
you seem determined to make the response of our young people to lockdown the result of them being inferior to the wartime generation in different ways - but it seems equally possible that the difference in response is due to the experiences being qualitatively different (which they are, and I have pointed out some of the more obvious differences). The resistance to accepting possible explanations not rooted in defects in young people is quite telling.

goldfinchonthelawn · 22/07/2022 11:16

WillMcAvoy · 22/07/2022 10:53

There should be a general appreciation from the teaching staff that students have had a very tough time

But they haven't, most of them. You telling them they have is part of the problem.

I don't agree @WillMcAvoy . Admitting things have been tough is not what makes them incapable. Downplaying tough times causes a separate set of problems.

To create resilience, the best way forward (imo) is to say: it has been reallyu tough on your generation - all your normal milestones and opportunities to make new friendships, to get starter jobs and internships were put on hold for two years. So it's not surprising you feel like this. However, you can't let it hold you back. Now you must...

I'm getting otugh on my DC. Last summer I didn't fund DS1. He had to find a job and eventually did, at minimum wage, getting up at 6 am. He admits it was good for him. Doing the same to DS2 this year. Just nodding and saying, yep, it's tough isn't it? How do you plan to keep going?

But minimising what they have experienced versus what they grew up expecting to experience is just dismissivem and that's neither helpful nor necessary. Empathy doesn't make people soft. Infantilising does. They are not the same thing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread