Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Making accommodations isn't always 'kind' (uni)

543 replies

Jourdain11 · 18/07/2022 18:20

I'm interested in knowing general opinions on this. I would accept that the last few years have been tough for students, and UG finalists in particular have had their full course horribly disrupted. But I am struck by how the accommodations made for students have really not helped them, in a large proportion of cases. I work in a uni (London Russell Group, competitive and highly-rated) and the number of students who have requested deferrals and so on for MH reasons is huge. In my role, I pushed back a bit and said that we shouldn't be advocating this as a way of dealing with any level of pressure and anxiety. In some cases it was absolutely necessary, but in others I felt that it was just becoming a pattern or a way of buying more time.

Ultimately, in the careers many of these graduates will go on to have, they will have to work to deadlines and deal with pressure, and part of the uni experience is providing preparation for that.

We now have students who are very upset because they cannot graduate with their peers, who are very anxious because they've deferred half their year's assessments to a one-werk resits period and feel they will not cope, or who are just disappointed that they haven't completed the year and have uncertainty as regards progression. Plus those who have now come to see assessment as an absolutely terrifying and insurmountable thing because we have agreed that they clearly weren't capable of sitting their exams, when they probably were.

Overall, I feel that we need to be encouraging coping strategies and empowering students, rather than encouraging them to opt out on the most tenuous rationale. But some of my colleagues would consider this to be virtually heresy and I'm not sure how we're going to get out of this place we have found ourselves in.

OP posts:
reallypuzzledoverthis · 24/07/2022 18:21

Just a few figures here from my course which I graduated from last week -
67 started
1 committed suicide
3 attempted suicide, removed from course
2 removed for sexual assault
3 removed for breaching confidentiality
2 removed as unfit to practice
8 had fitness to practice hearings in addition
16 left quoting stress and study/life balance
which left 32 to graduate

which hopefully shows why student support and mental health services is essential

aridapricot · 24/07/2022 17:47

user1497207191 · 24/07/2022 17:02

It's not just extensions either. There seems to be a lot of "scaling" in the marking of the exam papers.

My son had a exam with basically two questions of identical marks (choice of 2 out of 4). He only did one, but spent all the time on it, and he was expecting a very high mark for it, (into the 90's as he says himself he made a perfect attempt at it). I won't go into why he didn't do any others but afterwards he found out most of his cohort didn't either!

So, basically, he was aiming for an overage %age score on that paper of maybe 47/48% which he'd have been very happy with he thought his scores on other papers were high enough to compensate.

On results day, he was astonished to see he'd been awarded 78% on that paper - so he actually got more marks than possible for the 1 question that he did. There was a lot of speculation in that module's group chat that so few people had done any of the other 3 questions that they changed the weighting to give more weighting to the question that it turned out, they'd nearly all done, just so that the target x% of students would have been in the usual split of scores at each level.

Obviously delighted for DS!

I'm regulary astonished at how far marking criteria can be stretched to avoid failing a student, or to avoid a significant percentage of the cohort getting a low/very low pass...

For example: essay question is on class in Dickens' "Great expectations", student writes an essay on gender in Austen's "Emma". In the university system I studied in, this would be an automatic fail. In my department, there would be a lot of "but akshally the essay is well-written, and one of the marking criteria is "good writing", and even though there is no engagement with class you could argue that gender is also an important topic", all in the interests of get them to a Pass.

user1497207191 · 24/07/2022 17:02

It's not just extensions either. There seems to be a lot of "scaling" in the marking of the exam papers.

My son had a exam with basically two questions of identical marks (choice of 2 out of 4). He only did one, but spent all the time on it, and he was expecting a very high mark for it, (into the 90's as he says himself he made a perfect attempt at it). I won't go into why he didn't do any others but afterwards he found out most of his cohort didn't either!

So, basically, he was aiming for an overage %age score on that paper of maybe 47/48% which he'd have been very happy with he thought his scores on other papers were high enough to compensate.

On results day, he was astonished to see he'd been awarded 78% on that paper - so he actually got more marks than possible for the 1 question that he did. There was a lot of speculation in that module's group chat that so few people had done any of the other 3 questions that they changed the weighting to give more weighting to the question that it turned out, they'd nearly all done, just so that the target x% of students would have been in the usual split of scores at each level.

Obviously delighted for DS!

RampantIvy · 24/07/2022 16:51

To my mind giving extensions is pointless unless the student has been too ill to work during the few days before the deadline.

DD asked for an extension for her dissertation because she lost a week to covid when she was too ill to do anything at all. It was refused. Even her dissertation tutor was horrified that it was refused.

However, DD did manage to get it over the line in time, but it knocked a lot out of her.

user1497207191 · 24/07/2022 15:41

@aridapricot

There's no concept of planning for the unexpected, which we all have to do.

That isn't just students though. Lots of adults are also incapable of planning for the unexpected!

TullyApplebottom · 24/07/2022 15:01

Ps you might want to take your interesting points to the medical and educational experts I hear frequently on my radio explaining quite how significant they think the impacts on children and young people have been. They clearly need you to tell them how wrong they are.

TullyApplebottom · 24/07/2022 14:59

antelopevalley · 24/07/2022 13:56

So they did happen, but not to the same scale. Rather than never happened before.
I remember talking to a friend at the beginning of the pandemic who said she was used to lockdowns as the village she came from abroad, had a lockdown whenever a serious infectious disease came to the village.

I’m not quite sure what point you think you’re making here. The point I’m making is that there isn’t anything comparable in scale and potential effect in our past. What you’ve just said doesn’t contradict that.
id be very interested to know where your friend is from though. Never heard of anywhere in the modern world relying on repeated lockdowns to combat infectious disease as a long term strategy. But even if such a place exists, I don’t think that disproves the assertion that lockdowns are wholly exceptional in this society, and might be expected to affect children and young people.

antelopevalley · 24/07/2022 13:56

TullyApplebottom · 23/07/2022 15:21

I am well aware of all that, thank you. The measures undertaken to combat Spanish flu were not comparable in scale to the national lockdowns we have just experienced. If you have to reach back to the time of plague for a parallel I think that reinforces the point that the period we have just been through is truly extraordinary. It is simply not reasonable to expect it not yo have affected young people adversely.

So they did happen, but not to the same scale. Rather than never happened before.
I remember talking to a friend at the beginning of the pandemic who said she was used to lockdowns as the village she came from abroad, had a lockdown whenever a serious infectious disease came to the village.

Toddlerteaplease · 24/07/2022 13:05

My last faunal year student Nurse made absolutely no effort to start he dissertation, but the university gave her extension after extension. She did eventually hand it in. But we'd have never been allowed such leniency.

aridapricot · 24/07/2022 12:58

To my mind giving extensions is pointless unless the student has been too ill to work during the few days before the deadline.

Yes, when being asked for extensions I've noticed that some students work under the assumption: ok, I need 5 days to complete the assignment, 2 days to do the reading, 2 to write the thing, 1 to proofread, then submit. So they don't start working on it until 5 days before the deadline, and then a very short-term illness, or something like the tutor not replying to their requests for clarification about the brief (perhaps because it's the weekend??), will complete derail their plans. There's no concept of planning for the unexpected, which we all have to do. And I agree there's a generational change as well: I studied in another country, but I can well imagine that if me or my fellow students bombed an essay by what was objectively bad planning on our part, we'd just bite the bullet and maybe learn the lesson for the next time.

SnackSizeRaisin · 24/07/2022 12:42

To my mind giving extensions is pointless unless the student has been too ill to work during the few days before the deadline.
I am not really recognising this idea that it's the academic study of an undergraduate degree that is causing all these mental health problems. When I was a student in the early 2000s I was never aware of anyone getting overly worried about studying. Most people did the bare minimum during the first year before possibly trying a bit harder later on. If you failed you did a resit and if you failed that you resat the year. It really wasn't this huge cause of distress. A very few had some tragic personal circumstances that meant they had mitigating circumstances, usually close family bereavement.
For others any stress was more likely due to the usual homesickness or boyfriend trouble. You didn't expect to get any special treatment for that . Certainly no one would have been telling academic staff about that type of thing.
The pandemic was awful for a lot of people and I really feel for young people and students however granting extensions and making the degree easier isn't going to bring back the lost socialising opportunities etc. If anything it just creates more problems.

aridapricot · 24/07/2022 11:07

All of you say is absolutely true @GCAcademic. Every year, term obligation seem to finish later and start earlier (re-sit boards and the like). And it's absolutely true re Teams and Zoom. In the past I used to work one or two days a week from home - on research, but also on other tasks that I feel I can accomplish best if I have several hours of uninterrupted time. If someone wanted to schedule a meeting you could always say "I'm not going to be on campus that day". Obviously now this is gone...

GCAcademic · 24/07/2022 11:03

Oh, and the fact that universities discovered Teams and Zoom during the pandemic hasn’t helped either. People sticking all sorts of online meetings in your diary with no regard for the fact that the periods between terms used to be when we could get our research time and annual leave slotted in. Now you’re expected to duck out of the archive or library (which we’ve only managed to get back to after two years) to join some bloody meeting.

GCAcademic · 24/07/2022 10:58

On the other hand, I have been an author in several edited collections and all of them have had massive delays - like 6 or 7 years from invitation to actual publication, due to authors who feel it is ok to submit their chapter one year late with no explanation. I think it is incredibly disrespectful of the work of the editors and also of the other authors (who might be waiting for their chapter to appear in print for the purposes of REF or promotion, which do have strict deadlines). Sometimes I feel that if academics aren't able to stick to deadlines then what hope is there for students...

One of the reasons that academics are failing to meet publication deadlines, though, is related to the issue we’re discussing, the utter erosion of research time with no clear end to term-time, with marking, meetings and other teaching admin filling the weeks between terms. Our exam boards used to be at the end of term but are now pushed into the so-called vacation because we need to allow time for all the the late submissions. Research is supposed to account for 40% of our time, but (and I admit my case is unusual as I’m a HoD), I’ve managed three days this academic year. Yet again, I’ve booked annual leave in August just to carve out some space for research.

aridapricot · 24/07/2022 10:34

@user1497207191 I completely see what you mean, as I said in a previous post I think the culture of online always 24/7 has a lot to answer for it, in that it distorts our perception of time and its cycles. And I must say that academics are also culprits of it. I have recently edited two edited collections, and I was quite lucky in that most of my contributors were very respectful of deadlines. Me and my co-editors were also very clear that not meeting a certain deadline could mean that your chapter wouldn't make it into the collection (as it indeed happened in one case).
On the other hand, I have been an author in several edited collections and all of them have had massive delays - like 6 or 7 years from invitation to actual publication, due to authors who feel it is ok to submit their chapter one year late with no explanation. I think it is incredibly disrespectful of the work of the editors and also of the other authors (who might be waiting for their chapter to appear in print for the purposes of REF or promotion, which do have strict deadlines). Sometimes I feel that if academics aren't able to stick to deadlines then what hope is there for students...

aridapricot · 24/07/2022 09:43

@Jourdain11 whatever the solution is, it requires that academic and support staff stick together and sing from the same book. I hear in my institution there's a desire to go back to the pre-Covid situation, but this isn't possible if I follow the rules and tell a student "no, I cannot give you an extension because your computer crashed, you need to plan in advance and use the library computers if necessary", and then they say "oh but your colleague gave me an extension for exactly the same reason earlier today".

user1497207191 · 24/07/2022 08:33

But people "abuse" deadlines in all walks of life. There's nothing particularly special or unusual about the student/lecturer relationship.

I'm an accountant. Every sodding year, people will try to hand over large piles/boxes of paperwork at lunchtime on 31 January and expect us to have worked through it and filed their tax return by midnight that day! It's happened at every single firm I've worked at, and any kind of client can be the culprit, including professionals and academics! That's after a sequence of reminders throughout the TEN MONTHS they had to get the paperwork together to give to us! They think it's fine that they've had 10 months to basically put a load of paperwork in a pile and drive it over to us, but we only need a few hours - they clearly think we don't have any other clients! Any accountant/tax adviser will tell you the same.

Like your University management, HMRC don't help! During covid, we burst a gut to get tax returns submitted on time, hassling clients constantly in the final few months, only at the last minute, for HMRC to extend the deadline, which makes us look fools, not to mention our wasted weekends and evenings to help disorganised clients which turned out to be unnecessary. It sends a VERY poor message to taxpayers who'll then have an unrealistic expectation that deadlines will be pushed back again in the future!

It's not just accountants, I know solicitors who tear their hair out when their clients leave it to the last possible minute ahead of completion day or a court hearing, when they could have sent the info/documents needed weeks earlier. I know shop workers who are constantly harassed by customers expecting to be able to walk into a shop at 1 minute before closing time and then wonder around aimlessly filling a trolley!

Rather than whingeing about students, I think you have to accept that the population at large are becoming very poor at personal responsibility in lots of different ways, and the "nanny state" is facilitating it with all manner of extensions, exemptions and turning a blind eye to rules etc.

Phineyj · 24/07/2022 08:12

It does sound like university managements have been very unreasonable. I remember the departmental secretary on my degree course (1990s) having one of those signs that said Poor Planning on Your Part Doesn't Mean an Automatic Emergency on Mine...but she could say that, as it wasn't being normalised by her institution.

My school did essentially give teachers extensions in these situations but the issue for us is that then there are knock on effects, viz: cancel student homework for a week because it's PHSE 'kind week' or some such twaddle x repeat this regularly = get to the end of the academic year and surprise surprise, find the course hasn't been covered...students find endless excuses for not doing tests, essays and exams because reasons = poor UCAS prediction as no evidence = can't apply for the courses they want. Teacher then pressurised to organise endless resits which generally show same level of achievement...argh!

I am sometimes nostalgia for the 1990s when if you failed something it was on you.

FlySwimmer · 24/07/2022 07:56

@aridapricot Agreed.

@Trivium4all I agree here too. The lack of staff support from many institutions makes it even worse. Students get a two-week extension, but there’s no extension to the marking deadline. Impossible when half the cohort in some cases are receiving extensions.

Trivium4all · 24/07/2022 00:37

Whatever the nuances of the situation, this thread has made me, as an academic, feel a bit less alone. It's easy, as a lecturer, to feel just a wee bit of resentment at undergrads going partying for New Year's when I still couldn't see friends/family after a year, yet at the same time be expected to accept any and all excuses and explanations for extensions, while not being given the same courtesy by my institution...my tag-line throughout has been, "At least it's not 1350", meaning that at least most of us had a decent hope of making it out the other end alive and with most of our loved ones alive. You do have to be alive, in order to profit from mental health of any sort...

...that said, it's sucked.

Jourdain11 · 23/07/2022 23:43

Sorry for disappearing from my own thread. I hope no one has started AWOL procedures with threat of deregistration😃Have been too busy with work stuff and end of school term etc. 😬

I guess my overall feeling is that - regardless of disagreements on Covid and lockdown impact and whether or not it was right to make allowances at the time - how do we move forward from this? I feel that, at this point, it's more important to find a solution that we can work with going forward. It seems clear that reverting to 'situation normal' isn't going to be successful because students are unable/unwilling to adhere to this. But neither do I feel that having a total free-for-all is the answer. Over this past academic year we seem to have swung between those two and it's clear there is a need to find some middle ground.

OP posts:
theclangersarecoming · 23/07/2022 22:24

@aridapricot yep — I frequently encounter students these days who will send me a draft or paper by email at 9, 10 or 11pm - or even in the middle of the night, 3 or 4am! - then are genuinely surprised and annoyed that I haven’t marked it for a meeting at 9am or 10am.

Obviously I don’t need to get up, have breakfast, have a shower, drive to work, etc., but am just in suspended animation in my office ready and waiting for The Essay to arrive. 😂

aridapricot · 23/07/2022 20:50

I do agree with the OP. What I find is that the younger generations seem to have a mindset where they expect everyone and everything to be available 24/7 while at the same time having a very short "plan-ahead" window. I think this is primarily caused by them having been practically born with social media and web 2.0, but I think it has also been exacerbated by the pandemic when most of our lives were online.
For example many students will be surprised if you tell them that if our deadline to post grades is 15th June at noon, no they cannot submit their dissertation on the 14th at 8pm. It's as if it never occurred to them that the dissertation will be marked by a real person (rather 2) who needs to sleep and eat and possibly have a family life too, and there are other various administrative processes (external boards etc.) that need to be followed.
I've also encountered students who seem to operate under the assumption that if they've been e.g. off 1 week with Covid then all of their assignments, right until the very end of the term, need to be moved back by 1 week... I feel that every class I have to point them to the assignment briefs and remind them "with what we've covered so far in class, you should have enough to answer question 4".
On the other hand, if you want to stick to the university's rules for extensions and mitigating circumstances, in the hope that this will maybe teach the students some time management skills and make your life a bit easier (without extensions and m.c. becoming a "free for all"), you are out of look if you have "kind" colleagues who the students know they can turn to and who will insist that you grant a (non-permitted) extension or waive late days. And they get to be the kind cool guys while you're the witch.

ZandathePanda · 23/07/2022 20:43

I think there’s a pressure/anxiety that comes from being up to 50k ‘in debt’ at the end of your degree that I certainly didn’t have. And the ‘waste’ of money on the lost seminars, contact time and experiences.

My Dd had to live in just one very warm, small room for 2 weeks solidly as everyone else in her house had covid fairly early on, pre-vaccinations. Students either side were vomiting and leaning out their windows coughing so she didn’t even have the window open until she guessed they were in bed. Dd couldn’t come home as her younger sister was medically vulnerable and couldn’t visit her sister who was rushed in hospital several times for serious problems. It was stressful (for all of us) when she did occasionally come home, thinking she could infect us and the consequences. So she became a volunteer at the vaccination centre in her Uni city and got a lot of satisfaction from that.

When Dd finally did get covid she was on her own in the house, hours away from us. At least by now she was vaccinated and she could move around the damp flat freely. But she couldn’t breathe easily and was starting to hallucinate with a high temperature, which again is pretty stressful for anyone on their own. And, may I say, for a mum on the phone at 3am who can’t just drive several hours and pick her up.

It was the lack of physical face-to-face contact, that is so vital for us as primates, that has been so difficult. Leave most primates isolated (with the exception of adult orangutans) and their mental health suffers.

Dd managed remarkably well mentally but it was not a nice experience at times for her. She has just graduated with a first and is very ready to work hard.

As for war comparisons, I remember the phrase ‘don’t mention the war’ when I was little. And our town didn’t let off any loud fireworks as the older people still got very upset. And this was decades after the war.

My 93 year old uncle reckons the war was easier than the pandemic. However, he obviously was too young to fight.

ApplesandBunions · 23/07/2022 19:19

Oh yeah, I don't see how it could've happened until well into the 2010s. Even in the late 00s things were just so much less internet-ised.

Swipe left for the next trending thread