Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Making accommodations isn't always 'kind' (uni)

543 replies

Jourdain11 · 18/07/2022 18:20

I'm interested in knowing general opinions on this. I would accept that the last few years have been tough for students, and UG finalists in particular have had their full course horribly disrupted. But I am struck by how the accommodations made for students have really not helped them, in a large proportion of cases. I work in a uni (London Russell Group, competitive and highly-rated) and the number of students who have requested deferrals and so on for MH reasons is huge. In my role, I pushed back a bit and said that we shouldn't be advocating this as a way of dealing with any level of pressure and anxiety. In some cases it was absolutely necessary, but in others I felt that it was just becoming a pattern or a way of buying more time.

Ultimately, in the careers many of these graduates will go on to have, they will have to work to deadlines and deal with pressure, and part of the uni experience is providing preparation for that.

We now have students who are very upset because they cannot graduate with their peers, who are very anxious because they've deferred half their year's assessments to a one-werk resits period and feel they will not cope, or who are just disappointed that they haven't completed the year and have uncertainty as regards progression. Plus those who have now come to see assessment as an absolutely terrifying and insurmountable thing because we have agreed that they clearly weren't capable of sitting their exams, when they probably were.

Overall, I feel that we need to be encouraging coping strategies and empowering students, rather than encouraging them to opt out on the most tenuous rationale. But some of my colleagues would consider this to be virtually heresy and I'm not sure how we're going to get out of this place we have found ourselves in.

OP posts:
Bibbetybobbity · 19/07/2022 13:44

I think the comparisons between the war and the pandemic slightly miss the point. We can probably agree it’s been crap, varying degrees of crap. But for me the most interesting part of this thread is how we best support this generation to rebuild their resilience and whether large scale adjustments/extensions/ shift in expectations to an unrealistic level actually help in the short, medium or long term. And I do think it’s clear that teenagers and young adults who genuinely are facing huge challenges are (and will) find it harder to access proper support because a substantial majority consider their needs equally as urgent, when they simply aren’t.

TullyApplebottom · 19/07/2022 13:44

antelopevalley · 19/07/2022 13:02

Bloody hell I think the wartime generation had it worse, especially if they were adults.
I knew a number of men who had pain or problems as a result of wartime injuries or torture. And many had nightmares for decades. The current generation could not cope with what they went through. And it is beyond ridiculous to suggest they did not have it harder than the current generation.

As I said I think quite clearly, it is not about « better » or « worse ». It is about the experiences not being comparable. One involved deprivation of developmental opportunities. One did not. I hope that is now clear.

WinterDeWinter · 19/07/2022 13:41

theclangersarecoming · 19/07/2022 13:15

Should academics and universities as institutions declare that a core responsibility is to toughen young humans up to withstand a brutal work life which rewards only those it has not manage to break? Or should they be protesting that brutality, encouraging young people (all of us, in fact) to stand against a systemic machine-for-profit which exists to extract everything it can from its resources before moving on to the next harvest?

This is frankly ridiculous. You really do need to give your head a wobble as the kids say, if you think that expecting a 20-year old to be able to read a nice novel and write an essay on it in one week - perhaps also reading a couple of short online articles too - is “extracting everything from them before moving on to the next harvest.”

Geez, I’m a Marxist by training, and even I think some people do need to sit their bums down and do what is objectively not exactly hard factory labour.

I really didn't say that. I was responding to the idea, expressed many times on the thread, that Finals /immovable deadlines are functionally brutal in order to toughen up young people for corporate careers.

One poster said effectively 'Absent this, how can an employer trust that graduate employees won't break at a critical point, when it's too late to prevent the damage (to the corporate!).' They said (paraphrasing) 'Work doesn;t care that your grandmother died.' Most have come at it less sociopathically, taking as given their moral responsibility to the students themselves to prepare them for Work, and then debating whether understanding and acoommodation actually acquits that responsibility. No-one has suggested that Work, as it is currently constructed, and the economic system which constructs it, might be the problem.

Jourdain11 · 19/07/2022 13:39

Why is a degree only valid if complete in an arbitrary 3-year window?
I would absolutely argue that it isn't, but often in these cases, interruption is a better option than deferral.

I would also agree that students' campus lockdown experience was fairly dreadful, but we as staff were in a difficult position. If the Government said that we weren't to do campus teaching, etc., we couldn't do it. In my institution there was some disparity between departments - definitely some HoDs who were very Covid-cautious and moved slower. I would say the majority of students want an in-person experience, but those who do not are a noisy minority.

OP posts:
Morred · 19/07/2022 13:35

At the uni where I work (RG) there seems to be a total unwillingness (from the university and the students) to accept that university is meant to be a bit difficult. Not overwhelmingly difficult, but harder than school - for all sorts of reasons.

This leads to problems at both ends of the mental health spectrum. We are incredibly unwilling to tell students that they are simply too ill (mentally or physically) to study and we keep offering 'accommodations' that don't actually help. (As pp have said, if you have crippling anxiety, or ongoing depression, or you're so ill from long covid you can't concentrate on reading a text, it won't much help you to assessments in August rather than May.) On the other end of the spectrum, we end up giving lots of 'mental health support' to students who would honestly do better with (more) study skills advice, more guidance on structuring revision, working out how to do two pieces of coursework that have the same deadline, etc. Being worried about that and unsure you can do it to the best of your ability is not the same as diagnosed anxiety and counselling probably won't help you through it either. But because we're not supposed to admit that assessments are inherently a bit stressful and difficult (they're supposed to be a test!), anyone who is finding them stressful must need some sort of accommodation or MH support.

bruffin · 19/07/2022 13:29

antelopevalley · 19/07/2022 12:59

They involved trauma. Seeing your friends die in horrible ways and risk being killed or injured.
Soldiers did see other countries. But young adults then generally had more responsibility than young people now.

agree @antelopevalley My FIL was in Burma during WW11
He died of skin cancer as did many soldiers who were in Burma. I never met him and my children never knew their grandfather.
Apparently he never talked about his experiences and ended up an alcoholic which affected my DH's childhood.

TheWayoftheLeaf · 19/07/2022 13:25

I was at uni before Covid (grad 2017) and saw regular uni destroy some people utterly. Horrific mental health issues. They could not cope. I hate to think how many are even worse now.

WinterDeWinter · 19/07/2022 13:24

It actually annoys me that many middle class people did not give a shit about these issues until it started affecting their own offspring. Most had no issue when it just affected the plebs.

I think this is fair @antelopevalley and I'm ashamed of my own class and, to the extent that I've been complicit (though always left, and always with a Marxist-lite analysis of power through the axis of Class/Race/Sex), of myself.

In my defence, I now feel compelled to look well beyond the collapse of the middle-class quid pro quo (and to alienate my own class by saying it all out loud, creating... awkwardness ;-)

RockinHorseShit · 19/07/2022 13:22

I'm glad to see you being open about this as it gives me hope for change.

My DD has a disability & can genuinely struggle badly, but she's very bloody minded & pushes on regardless, which isn't always in her best interests tbh. She postponed Uni due to the pandemic & took a local college course to fill her time. She hit a lot of problems there & asked for help, that just was never forthcoming as they were just snowed under dealing with other young people making more fuss than she could muster as she was genuinely bloody struggling. She refused help from us & ended up dropping out as a result. Thankfully it wasn't an important course for her, but it worries me for upcoming Uni

Badbadbunny · 19/07/2022 13:17

theclangersarecoming · 19/07/2022 13:06

Yes, that’s undoubtedly true. For example, during the pandemic if students in our halls had to isolate, the university paid for three meals a day to be delivered to the students’ rooms free of charge. The kitchen staff doing the delivering were hourly-paid young people, often the same age as the students, who if they had to isolate at home just didn’t get paid. And they couldn’t afford not to work and they came into work anyway despite the risk of getting Covid themselves. And our students complained bitterly about how there were not enough satisfactory vegan options in the free food delivered by low paid kitchen staff.

Obviously no-one said anything to them about this, and every effort was made to get them exactly what they wanted. Same with extensions and adjustments and everything else - we just get them exactly what they want because the customer is always right. We don’t say any of this to their faces!

But despite some posters on this thread suggesting that we are terrible people not fit to teach young adults, we aren’t nannies or mental health nurses or counsellors. We’re employees doing a job and seeing that the things we’re asked to give students aren’t actually helping them in the long run.

When my DS and his flat mates had to isolate due to one of the flat mates having covid, their flat only got a packet of bog rolls provided by the Uni. That was it. Nothing else. They had to make their own arrangements for food deliveries. Not allowed out of the flat. No Uni staff made any attempt to contact them to see if they needed anything. So making out all Unis made a lot of effort to help their students during covid is simply untrue. I'm sure some did, but some provided no help at all (other than a pack of bog roll, which is very strange!).

theclangersarecoming · 19/07/2022 13:15

Should academics and universities as institutions declare that a core responsibility is to toughen young humans up to withstand a brutal work life which rewards only those it has not manage to break? Or should they be protesting that brutality, encouraging young people (all of us, in fact) to stand against a systemic machine-for-profit which exists to extract everything it can from its resources before moving on to the next harvest?

This is frankly ridiculous. You really do need to give your head a wobble as the kids say, if you think that expecting a 20-year old to be able to read a nice novel and write an essay on it in one week - perhaps also reading a couple of short online articles too - is “extracting everything from them before moving on to the next harvest.”

Geez, I’m a Marxist by training, and even I think some people do need to sit their bums down and do what is objectively not exactly hard factory labour.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 19/07/2022 13:14

Interesting thread. I would say that people who were children or in their teens during the war lost out on a lot of developmental opportunities, for all the obvious reasons. Many of the things now deemed necessary for optimal development were impossible for the majority of young people until very recently, and still are for the majority around the globe.

Anyway, the point I want to make, tentatively, is that leaving aside lockdown, the obvious difference between people under and over 25 now is 24-hour a day access to the internet and the arrival of social media. I'm not surprised some young people claim to be constantly anxious. I'm not on Facebook but some of the stuff I've seen on Twitter is worrying. There are some very vocal young people who seem to be online almost all the time. Minimal time spent exercising, engaging with the natural world, reading a book, watching a film (with full attention), talking to real people face to face, and so on. Lots and lots of people agreeing with anyone expressing a minor worry that this is a mental health crisis. Lots of talk of 'hate' describing normal disagreement. It's not healthy.

GCAcademic · 19/07/2022 13:14

Fair enough. How about getting back to fully face to face lectures, seminars, working groups, etc which is what the majority of students want? Or does it only work one way?

We have done, the minute the government allowed us to to that. My students only had one term and one week of online teaching, after the government locked us down in December 2020. The rest of the time we’ve been in classrooms or offices for lectures, seminars and tutorials, wearing masks, until last term when the mask requirement was removed.

Though going by the attendance rate this academic year, (20-30% amongst our first year cohort) I’m not even sure that this is what a majority of students want.

moksorineouimoksori · 19/07/2022 13:12

You are being very dishonest now. No-one is saying that appraisal methods don’t change, they are saying that failing to comply with them now as they currently are is a problem.
Do you have an actual point to add here or are you just trying to ruin a decent thread by pretending not to understand the points that people are making?

There's no need for dramatics - I'm not trying to ruin anything. I was mainly responding to the call for exams to go back offline, but deferments, extensions etc are a part of the appraisal methods. There's no less worth in a degree because someone with extenuating circumstances took a longer time to complete it. Why is a degree only valid if complete in an arbitrary 3-year window? And I do somewhat accept the point about cheating, although just like anything else universities have to adapt to the times and possibly even change the definition of what cheating is.

antelopevalley · 19/07/2022 13:12

@WinterDeWinter I do not recognise the clear path you had. But I come from a different class.
What is really happening is that the middle class is shrinking fast. So there are still opportunities for high-paid jobs with good career progression and pensions, but there are fewer of them.
You want to change the economic system? I would support that. But it won't because it benefits people like you. What needs to happen is:


  • the government need to stop artificially inflating house prices

  • increase protection for renters

  • allow local authorities to put limits on percentage/number of second and holiday homes

  • seriously tackle climate change

  • improve workers rights, especially those in the gig economy

  • build social housing

But it won't happen because it would reduce house prices, increase costs of services many middle-class people use, and reduce income from rents.

It actually annoys me that many middle class people did not give a shit about these issues until it started affecting their own offspring. Most had no issue when it just affected the plebs.

theclangersarecoming · 19/07/2022 13:06

GCAcademic · 19/07/2022 12:38

I think there is something in this and it does make me very uncomfortable that we, in universities, are effectively entrenching middle class privilege by mollycoddling students and protecting them from things that their peers who don’t go to university have to either get with or face the consequences. Similarly, the supposed mental health crisis in universities, of which much has been made in the media, is never discussed in the context of that age group as a whole, for which there is a higher suicide rate amongst 18-21 year olds not at university. There is a lot of classism and privilege about the university system that goes beyond the provision of education itself.

Yes, that’s undoubtedly true. For example, during the pandemic if students in our halls had to isolate, the university paid for three meals a day to be delivered to the students’ rooms free of charge. The kitchen staff doing the delivering were hourly-paid young people, often the same age as the students, who if they had to isolate at home just didn’t get paid. And they couldn’t afford not to work and they came into work anyway despite the risk of getting Covid themselves. And our students complained bitterly about how there were not enough satisfactory vegan options in the free food delivered by low paid kitchen staff.

Obviously no-one said anything to them about this, and every effort was made to get them exactly what they wanted. Same with extensions and adjustments and everything else - we just get them exactly what they want because the customer is always right. We don’t say any of this to their faces!

But despite some posters on this thread suggesting that we are terrible people not fit to teach young adults, we aren’t nannies or mental health nurses or counsellors. We’re employees doing a job and seeing that the things we’re asked to give students aren’t actually helping them in the long run.

WinterDeWinter · 19/07/2022 13:05

@antelopevalley Totally disagree with this. There are assessment tools mental health professionals use to assess who is at risk of suicide.

I know - that's my whole point. The people who are making the decisions on accommodations are not mental health professionals able to carefully interrogate the nature and extent of the suffering - they are academics and pastoral staff who have perhaps done a short counselling course.

I am so interested in why so many here are unwilling to consider whether it is the system itself which is no longer fit for purpose, - instead insisting that children suck it up because our own generation managed to do so.

Our children exist in a totally different reality Many feel constitutionally hopeless - you must see the nihilism in culture? They do so not because we've told them to - Christ why would we do that? - but because they have eyes. At a global level, at a national level, there is real despair. They start to see it as pre-teens and then they can't un-see it.

Meanwhile the pressures to be compliant, to compete for an ever-shrinking pot, intensifies year by year - while the quid pro quo for being 'good kids' which existed for us (stimulating work, financial security, sense of achievement, clear path, home ownership, a family of your own) no longer pertains (though cruelly, we encourage those children least primed to see through the lie - working class kids, non-white kids) that it does if you only want it badly enough, piling side-hustle onto side-hustle.

Is the function of universities to provide global corporates (or any employer)with a broken-in human resource, with the cost born by the product ? Should academics and universities as institutions declare that a core responsibility is to toughen young humans up to withstand a brutal work life which rewards only those it has not manage to break? Or should they be protesting that brutality, encouraging young people (all of us, in fact) to stand against a systemic machine-for-profit which exists to extract everything it can from its resources before moving on to the next harvest?

Why should we churn out children resilient to an economic system which treats them like meat and which no longer offers much of anything in return? Why should we do all we can to keep this creaking, inherently unfair economic machine powering on at such human cost? Why are universities so bloody keen to be complicit in a system which all of us know in our heart of hearts is antithetical to humanity?

I think we all know that part of the answer is that their own livelihoods depend on the Ponzi scheme continuing to pull greater quantities of raw product in, and push more refined product out. I say that with real sympathy, at an individual level - I don't expect any academic to risk her own family's security.

But I do find it really odd - quite shocking in fact - that a class which purports to value enquiry, analysis, freedom, truth cannot look itself in the eye and see that it is the handmaiden at best, executioner at worst, of an inhumane economic ideology which has - sitting here in my study in 40 degree heat - already destroyed the hope of a progressively better world for our children.

I know that academics have themselves been victims , and that the world you thought you were going into has changed. But whataboutery - in this case, the assertion that individual damage is not damage if it is universal, or if previous generations suffered different kinds of damage - is exactly what the machine requires to grind on unimpeded.

To paraphrase Bob Crowe (and risk undermining my argument through literalism - I do not in fact believe that any mainstream Left position has grasped that the system cannot be reformed; that reform is itself the means of its reproduction): "Don't rail against the RMT for fighting for what all humans deserve - get a better fucking union."

WillMcAvoy · 19/07/2022 13:05

TullyApplebottom · 19/07/2022 13:00

Some people did lose their lives, yes; most didn’t and continued to live active lives during wartime.
the point isn’t about which was worse and which was better; the point is the experiences, for this age group, are not comparable. So saying « wartime generation had it worse » is a daft argument. The point for the covid generation is they have been deprived of developmental opportunities. It is not surprising therefore if they gave not developed optimally.

Yes, perfectly active lives with the constant fear of death, rationing, conscription and loss of all normal ways of living.
Yes it is comparable and in not one single way was the Covid era worse. Your privilege is shocking. Deprived of developmental opportunities? Give your head a wobble.

MsFrenchie · 19/07/2022 13:05

TullyApplebottom · 19/07/2022 13:00

Some people did lose their lives, yes; most didn’t and continued to live active lives during wartime.
the point isn’t about which was worse and which was better; the point is the experiences, for this age group, are not comparable. So saying « wartime generation had it worse » is a daft argument. The point for the covid generation is they have been deprived of developmental opportunities. It is not surprising therefore if they gave not developed optimally.

It’s hard to understand the insanity of some posts on here. Yours in particular.

To claim that having to do some of your studying at home and not see your friends is so not worse than being forced to leave home, get into a troop ship, and then get out to kill or be killed as you fight your way across a foreign country far from everyone and everything you love while your family back home are bombed or starved is imbecilic.

Badbadbunny · 19/07/2022 13:04

GCAcademic · 19/07/2022 12:54

Yes, you do have to DO them, that's not what I said. The methods change. I don't think 100 years ago people would have sat online coursework for a degree! ;)

The reason that many academics want to return to traditional exams is because the online assessments (which were never set up because they were pedagogically sound, but from necessity during the pandemic) have resulted in high levels of cheating which it is all but impossible for us to circumvent. Traditional exams may pose a rather artificial scenario but they have the advantage that your native-speaking mother can’t sit your language test for you, or you can’t use an essay mill, or collude with your classmates or get someone who took the module last year to help you.

Fair enough. How about getting back to fully face to face lectures, seminars, working groups, etc which is what the majority of students want? Or does it only work one way?

antelopevalley · 19/07/2022 13:02

Bloody hell I think the wartime generation had it worse, especially if they were adults.
I knew a number of men who had pain or problems as a result of wartime injuries or torture. And many had nightmares for decades. The current generation could not cope with what they went through. And it is beyond ridiculous to suggest they did not have it harder than the current generation.

TullyApplebottom · 19/07/2022 13:00

WillMcAvoy · 19/07/2022 12:52

But the salient point is that whatever the hardships of war, they did not generally involve deprivation of important developmental experience. And lockdown did

They involved the actual deprivation of LIFE ITSELF, which is more of a big deal than your kidnot getting freshers week.

These posts are insane

Some people did lose their lives, yes; most didn’t and continued to live active lives during wartime.
the point isn’t about which was worse and which was better; the point is the experiences, for this age group, are not comparable. So saying « wartime generation had it worse » is a daft argument. The point for the covid generation is they have been deprived of developmental opportunities. It is not surprising therefore if they gave not developed optimally.

GoodThinkingMax · 19/07/2022 12:59

Agree, not Andy! My phone hates me!

antelopevalley · 19/07/2022 12:59

TullyApplebottom · 19/07/2022 12:48

So, your final sentence isn’t true. For young people who joined the services, they had access to opportunities and responsibility well beyond what young people of their age would have had in normal times. I had such people in my family and you probably did too. But the salient point is that whatever the hardships of war, they did not generally involve deprivation of important developmental experience. And lockdown did.

They involved trauma. Seeing your friends die in horrible ways and risk being killed or injured.
Soldiers did see other countries. But young adults then generally had more responsibility than young people now.

GoodThinkingMax · 19/07/2022 12:59

bruffin · 19/07/2022 11:51

"People are constantly comparing covid to the war. To have even been born during it you’d need to be over 78. To have been an adult during it you’d need to be 96. I’m fairly sure than few of those people are still in the workforce, and as a generational voice they are now few in number. I don’t think it’s a helpful comparison usually, but I DO think it demonstrates universal impact, well. So no, no generation has lived through anything like this in living memory. I don’t think it’s fair to minimise that."
But its not helpful for this generation to think they had it worse,when they didnt.
My DD is 24 both her grandparents lived through the war and she knows about their lives
This generation dont even know how lucky it is to get to go to university in the first place. As said above my MIL education stopped at 12 because of the war, I was talking to my friend whose mother is in her 80s and had a similar story, there is a generation of women who had no education because of WW11
My Father who lived in Cyprus left school at 12.
I was born in the early 60s , very few of my school friends took A levels let alone went to university.

Andy, @bruffin

I’m always interested in how the effects of both world wars still filter down the generations. And especially for women.

And I was a teenager when equal pay for women was finally legislated(not that we have it). There are a lot of things about working and social arrange which are far far better for this generation of graduates than they were for me, or my mother’s and grandmother’s generations.

Im technically a baby boomer although I was born right at the end of the 50s. But opportunities and wealth etc were/are still a matter of class and also geographic location. A lot of the filthy lucre of the swinging sixties never made it north of London and certainly not into the north west were I was brought up. Quite reverse - it was an area of de-industrialisation even before Thatchers deliberate policies to wreak havoc on the North.

Swipe left for the next trending thread