Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Making accommodations isn't always 'kind' (uni)

543 replies

Jourdain11 · 18/07/2022 18:20

I'm interested in knowing general opinions on this. I would accept that the last few years have been tough for students, and UG finalists in particular have had their full course horribly disrupted. But I am struck by how the accommodations made for students have really not helped them, in a large proportion of cases. I work in a uni (London Russell Group, competitive and highly-rated) and the number of students who have requested deferrals and so on for MH reasons is huge. In my role, I pushed back a bit and said that we shouldn't be advocating this as a way of dealing with any level of pressure and anxiety. In some cases it was absolutely necessary, but in others I felt that it was just becoming a pattern or a way of buying more time.

Ultimately, in the careers many of these graduates will go on to have, they will have to work to deadlines and deal with pressure, and part of the uni experience is providing preparation for that.

We now have students who are very upset because they cannot graduate with their peers, who are very anxious because they've deferred half their year's assessments to a one-werk resits period and feel they will not cope, or who are just disappointed that they haven't completed the year and have uncertainty as regards progression. Plus those who have now come to see assessment as an absolutely terrifying and insurmountable thing because we have agreed that they clearly weren't capable of sitting their exams, when they probably were.

Overall, I feel that we need to be encouraging coping strategies and empowering students, rather than encouraging them to opt out on the most tenuous rationale. But some of my colleagues would consider this to be virtually heresy and I'm not sure how we're going to get out of this place we have found ourselves in.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jourdain11 · 19/01/2023 23:17

I was thinking back to this thread today. We've just had exams and the issues I mentioned have continued to present themselves. We've had a lot of heavy discussion in meetings this week about whether we're supporting and preparing students adequately and fairly, and the perception seems to be that we are doing too much fire-fighting and not enough prevention, but also that students' expectations are not necessarily reasonable.

My worry is that the fact that we're constantly giving out mitigations means that the students who really need them are not being treated equitably. The fact that we've gone back to an evidenced-based system hasn't led to fewer requests and it is just NEVER ENDING. I don't think I've finished work earlier than 7pm since the start of the year - and even then I am still behind. It's a bit grim!

OP posts:
Chouetted · 28/07/2022 17:03

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 28/07/2022 15:39

Yes, if there are no issues of hand-eye co-ordination or dyslexia or other cognitive/physical reasons for poor handwriting. I've always thought written exams are tough on people who for whatever reason can't write fast. I suppose the same applies in online exams to those who can't get the knack of typing fast either.

I write so little now with pen or pencil that I find I have to concentrate very hard on it or I miss out penstrokes. Blush

You can get extra time if you have unusually slow handwriting. I got it for being assessed as twice as slow as average, which explained why I always ran out of time in exams before then. There isn't much room in maths for cutting corners.

Which probably feels unfair if you're slow, but not quite that slow.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 28/07/2022 15:39

Yes, if there are no issues of hand-eye co-ordination or dyslexia or other cognitive/physical reasons for poor handwriting. I've always thought written exams are tough on people who for whatever reason can't write fast. I suppose the same applies in online exams to those who can't get the knack of typing fast either.

I write so little now with pen or pencil that I find I have to concentrate very hard on it or I miss out penstrokes. Blush

GoodThinkingMax · 28/07/2022 14:24

Surely, legible hand writing is just good manners ie. consideration for others?

Phineyj · 28/07/2022 10:01

When I started teaching I was unhappy with my handwriting (it hadn't been an issue in my previous career due to my good touch typing - which I taught myself after a frustrating experience at a university in North America in the 1990s - UK university expected handwritten submissions - overseas one only accepted typed).

So I bought a book recommended by the Campaign for Handwriting and some better pens.

Of all the knotty problems identified on this thread, this one is rather solvable!

goldfinchonthelawn · 28/07/2022 07:52

antelopevalley · 28/07/2022 01:22

It has changed. In the pasy students were told if examiners could not read their handwriting, then tough.

Yes. I remember a friend failing her degree due to her handwriting. They gave her a chance to resubmit some essays in a better state but her handwriting hadn't imrpoved and she just failed.

I think it's good that we've moved on from that time. She should have been judged on what she knew not her handwriting, but computers weren't available in those days.

antelopevalley · 28/07/2022 01:22

It has changed. In the pasy students were told if examiners could not read their handwriting, then tough.

TomPinch · 28/07/2022 01:16

I took a degree as a mature student here. One of my fellow students had the worst handwriting I ever saw and I asked him whether he was disadvantaging himself. He said no: the university gave his paper to a transcriber!

I was a bit surprised but actually it makes sense. Leaving aside resourcing issues for the university (Auckland - at the time a highly ranked one) it doesn't seem right to me that one student ought to get a better mark just because they have nicer handwriting.

GoodThinkingMax · 28/07/2022 00:45

I can see how it might be a problem in exams but they have 'drunk spider' interpreters for that.

Not sure what that means! I have never ever - in 30 years of university teaching in 3 countries - had an interpreter (or even been offered such assistance) for reading execrable hand writing. If I can't read an exam paper clearly, then that paper will be marked accordingly.

The bottom line for young people - which parents may want to suggest - is that if they want other people to engage with, understand and value their ideas and arguments, they need to communicate in ways which articulate their ideas and arguments clearly and in ways in which their readers or interlocutors (in speech, online, wherever) might enjoy!

TomPinch · 28/07/2022 00:23

It sounds like a fad to me.

I'm in NZ where the schools are definitely more relaxed and there is a big emphasis on BYOD. My DCs were taught handwriting but I don't remember it being a particular emphasis after year 2. One of my DCs' handwriting got worse and worse and is now pretty awful but no teacher has raised it as an issue. She's now in her senior year.

I can see how it might be a problem in exams but they have 'drunk spider' interpreters for that.

ZenNudist · 28/07/2022 00:23

Is this not further extension of "student as customer"? Paying so much for a degree puts too much pressure on.

theclangersarecoming · 28/07/2022 00:14

Interestingly, handwriting is getting a lot of emphasis in primary at the moment —especially teaching them to write in “correct” cursive (and in some schools teaching cursive from the outset and bypassing print entirely…)

TomPinch · 28/07/2022 00:12

My understanding is that schools aren't so strict on handwriting now because in the age of computers good handwriting just isn't very important.

AtomicBlondeRose · 27/07/2022 14:05

Well, as a sixth form teacher, the amount of influence I have over handwriting is basically zero. If I can read it - and thanks to years of experience I can read almost anything - I have no reason to enforce handwriting improvement. What could I do? Refuse to mark something when I can read it perfectly well? I will comment on handwriting of course and students with the poorest writing get to use a computer for the real exams but I will still make them write at length in class to get the practice. But I’m not a handwriting teacher and we have no support available for that level of teaching. None. We don’t even have enough support for the students who are supposed to have 1-1s.

By GCSE level a student knows if they have bad handwriting and it’s only within their ability to improve it if they want to. Anyone with a problem that stops them from improving it can use a computer, and anyone else can do drills or buy handwriting books to help themselves get better. There are plenty of girls (and a few boys) spending a large amount of time on getting beautiful handwriting so it’s really not an abnormal thing to do.

Phineyj · 27/07/2022 13:33

If universities would move to a post results application system, I think it would help a great deal.

Students would apply knowing their grades, eliminating the current stressful, ridiculous, predicted grades process at a stroke.

It would also put a bit more slack in the system to address students' mental health and study skill needs before they take a big step like committing to a 3 or 4 year academic course.

Maybe degree apprenticeships could be expanded and more access courses offered, with progression to year 1 or 2 of the degree dependent on results (I believe that's what the French do?)

So much of sixth form is taken up arguing with students and increasingly, their parents, about why they can't be predicted As they're nowhere near, testing and retesting, that there's barely time to teach the course, never mind do lots more study skills.

I did the most study skills with year 12 this year I've ever done (concerned anout the lack of proper GCSEs) and they moaned and moaned and moaned. It was thoroughly depressing.

Kazzyhoward · 27/07/2022 11:29

RampantIvy · 27/07/2022 08:10

I know I said this upthread, but having been reading the WIWIKAU Facebook page I feel that there are far too many young people going to university, especially ones a long way from home, who maybe shouldn't have gone as they are entirely unsuited to higher education or just not ready. It is as if university is the default option these days.

How many of the students who request extensions are at university because they received an unconditional offer and took their foot off the pedal for A levels?

It does seem that schools are just ignoring issues and assuming/hoping that "someone else" will address them. My son's issue is pretty minor in the big scheme of things, but I can well imagine other more serious issues have been ignored for other people.

My DS's handwriting has been abysmal ever since primary school. We kept mentioning it at parent's evenings every year, but the succession of teachers just glibly said things like "Oh, he's not that bad, you should see some of the others!".

We tried to address it ourselves, giving him handwriting practice books, but he always kicked back saying it's not a problem, teachers are happy etc.

Same at secondary school, we mentioned it at parents' evenings, same glib attitude from teachers. Then in sixth form, the same.

At Uni, first year was 100% online so he did most things on word processor and just did graphs etc freehand which he scanned and uploaded. No negative feedback.

Just done his first "proper" in person exams since 2018, and he's had negative feedback from lecturers/teaching staff after the results day, saying he really needs to improve his handwriting! First time in 15 years of education that anyone at all has given him that feedback. I've refrained from telling him "I told you so!" Now, he's suddenly decided to take it on board and has started to practice being neater!

RampantIvy · 27/07/2022 08:10

I know I said this upthread, but having been reading the WIWIKAU Facebook page I feel that there are far too many young people going to university, especially ones a long way from home, who maybe shouldn't have gone as they are entirely unsuited to higher education or just not ready. It is as if university is the default option these days.

How many of the students who request extensions are at university because they received an unconditional offer and took their foot off the pedal for A levels?

GoodThinkingMax · 27/07/2022 00:57

But I think increasingly universities are going to have to be more proactive in dealing with these problems.

Alternatively, schools could prepare their pupils better, by doing this sort of thing - teaching young people to manage & structure their time. Schools work more closely with groups of students on a consistent basis. I may see a cohort for 3 hours a week in one term; a school will see pupils across a timetable 9am to 3pm.

ThomasinaGallico · 26/07/2022 22:34

GCAcademic · 18/07/2022 19:56

No one is saying that students shouldn’t be given support. Of course they should. It’s the nature of the “support” that we’re calling into question. And, while these particular forms of “support” may have served a purpose during lockdowns, they have now become inappropriately normalised and are detrimental to students’ ability to move into the workplace or even complete their degrees,

I agree with this. I speak as someone who sabotaged my own degree grade a few decades ago by handing in assessed essays two weeks late and messing up my attendance and essay completion for most of my final year.

This is a complex problem but not to be solved by endlessly stretching deadlines. Some of these students simply do not have what it takes, and their anxiety comes from knowing this deep down. It would be a kindness to remove them from the course. Many are bright and capable but incapable of managing their time; still others are putting themselves under extreme pressure to gain top grades.There may be a few who have real additional needs like ADHD or undiagnosed dyslexia.

I often think I would have benefited from something like a procrastinator’s boot camp, led by a psychologist and one of the tutors, using social support and breaking down assignments into manageable sections. Such interventions take funding and resources, of course, and RG unis of the time prided themselves on their hands-off approach, so would have turned their noses up at them. But I think increasingly universities are going to have to be more proactive in dealing with these problems.

user1745 · 26/07/2022 22:27

I think you are probably right. I also think, with younger teenagers, that "mental health" seems to have become a bit of an excuse to not do things that make you feel bad/anxious/stressed etc. As in, "sorry I couldn't do the favour I said I'd do for my friend for mental health reasons". I say that not to dismiss genuine struggles nor to imply that they're making their feelings up, but I think they are genuinely incapable of distinguishing normal unpleasant feelings from mental illness. There's also an excessive avoidance of pressure or negative feelings.

CashmereMutt · 26/07/2022 22:03

reallypuzzledoverthis · 24/07/2022 18:21

Just a few figures here from my course which I graduated from last week -
67 started
1 committed suicide
3 attempted suicide, removed from course
2 removed for sexual assault
3 removed for breaching confidentiality
2 removed as unfit to practice
8 had fitness to practice hearings in addition
16 left quoting stress and study/life balance
which left 32 to graduate

which hopefully shows why student support and mental health services is essential

How did you get to know these details?

Jourdain11 · 24/07/2022 22:16

Also, lecturers are not MH professionals and it can actually be profoundly unhelpful to the student for them to try to take on that role. To an extent it falls more within my remit, but I'm also not qualified to diagnose or treat students' health conditions, mental or physical. Of course university staff should be mindful of potential concerns and flag up/signpost/make adjustments as necessary. But if it comes to the point where the student is unable to fulfil the requirements of the course then that's a different conversation. As I've said previously, I don't think that interrupting studies should be looked down on, and in some circs it is the most helpful and appropriate option.

There are other students, however (and I'd say this is a larger group) where they are coming to realise that using certain language will entitle them to leniency and extensions, which they may feel will help them at the time, but which they might regret further down the line. My thoughts about this 'culture' going too far are more in relation to that group than for those who are in genuine crisis.

Of course, there is another group where there might be a short-term or unexpected issue, crisis or health concern, where a week-long extension or deferral of an assessment till August is exactly what is needed, and that's where it is really appropriate to use those mechanisms.

OP posts:
Phineyj · 24/07/2022 22:07

I haven't seen anyone be glib about poor student mental health on this thread. Lecturers and teachers are people too. We can't do our jobs if we've got to wonder if every conversation about a deadline might send someone fragile over the edge. That's quite different to reporting concerns if a student discloses something, of course.

Word soon gets about if deadlines aren't real deadlines (like the tax example above).

user1497207191 · 24/07/2022 20:17

@reallypuzzledoverthis

which hopefully shows why student support and mental health services is essential

Exactly. Whether lecturers think mental health issues, depression, etc is real or not, the reality is that IT IS REAL for the students suffering it, and glib comments about resilience, "stiff upper lip" and other such crap don't help prevent suicide attempts and dropping out. AN unhelpful or unpleasant remark from a lecturer (or anyone else) minimising a student's suffering can be enough to push them over the edge. It really doesn't matter who's right and who's wrong when a student's life is on a knife edge!

reallypuzzledoverthis · 24/07/2022 18:22

Just to add the 8 who had hearings removed themselves possibly before the uni did that for them