Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this holiday plan is just a bit shit for a family with young children?

308 replies

Holidayplanisshit · 18/07/2022 18:08

Background - we’re saving money for a holiday next autumn with twins; not massively expensive (under £2000 for 2 week cruise) but, as a low income family, it will take a bit of discipline to save a regular amount rather than spend on extras for the children. We’ve set an amount to save each month which will pay for the cruise and also give us spending money.

Now for my AIBU…….. DH wants to go away for a holiday this year as well and thinks 10 days to 2 weeks staying with his DF in rural Wales will be “perfect” - for that read free accommodation and he will, no doubt, love spending the evenings in his dad’s garden drinking beers and chatting guy crap!! Meanwhile, the cottage his DF lives in isn’t child friendly - think no proper kitchen or bathroom (he’s been saying for years that he’s going to swap them round or refit both but all he’s done is rip stuff out and cobble working parts together) the stairs are in the middle of the living space and aren’t childproof plus no way to stop toddlers going up or down meaning I’ll have to watch them like hawks. The garden is full of junk and not safe for kids to play in, there’s no boundary fencing and there’s a stream across the Lane which they could easily fall into.

There’s nothing locally for us to do as a family without having to drive miles each way even to a play park! Even the ‘local’ beach is over an hour’s drive away - for context, we live 20 miles from beautiful beaches that people actively seek out to visit for holidays!!

DFiL is lovely but doesn’t really interact with the children when he stays with us and, as an older man, is quite set in his ways so follows quite a rigid routine of wanting his daily paper, having a few drinks in the evening and a couple of smokes in the garden later in the evening. DH readily admits his dad won’t help out with the children and that his home isn’t ideal but he just sees the idea of a free holiday. I see 10 days to 2 weeks of
him having a whale of a time doing nothing as he won’t be at work while I am watching the children, keeping them safe and entertained and making sure they’re fed regularly (not helped by them being fussy eaters so I can’t just give them what my DFiL would usually cook as they won’t eat curries, fish, veg or things).

AIBU for wanting a holiday that gives me as well as DH a chance to kick back & relax; where our kids can play safely, have something to do walking distance away to entertain them a bit either during the day or in the early evening; a pub or restaurant where we can eat sometimes during the holiday so I don’t have to cook every single day. Basically I don’t want my precious holiday time spend being a spare wheel to DH & SFiL having a great catch up while I manage young children in a totally unsuitable environment!!

OP posts:
bruffin · 20/07/2022 19:34

xippo · 20/07/2022 19:24

we're going for a week in a caravan, £1200.
we've just been for a week, 2 of us, to Cyprus, £2200
I don't know where you could holiday for less than 2k for 4 people. did you go on honeymoon in 1960?

10 days in centerparcs in Netherlands easily comes in around £1500 . We used to do this last week of August every year, dc loved it there. Getting there make cost a little extra atm.
Activities really cheap compared to UK. Also Duinrell with free entry to water park and themepark as well as forest and seaside to walk or bike to.

newfriend05 · 20/07/2022 19:28

I mean that's a lot of money if on a low income

newfriend05 · 20/07/2022 19:27

@NeverFlyCoach I never low income families cant go on holiday I said a £2000 holiday Cruise holiday ..

xippo · 20/07/2022 19:24

surreygirl1987 · 18/07/2022 18:41

YANBU... but also, a £2k holiday?! Is this really what people spend? The only holiday I've ever taken that cost anything like that was my honeymoon. And I would consider us to be at least a medium income household (combined income £100k+). Is this what people typically spend on a holiday?

we're going for a week in a caravan, £1200.
we've just been for a week, 2 of us, to Cyprus, £2200
I don't know where you could holiday for less than 2k for 4 people. did you go on honeymoon in 1960?

Sallybates · 20/07/2022 19:06

Enjoy family time! Compromise- go for 5 days. Spend time with the old fella and let bonding happen. Life’s too short for missed opportunities. I remember great times in a hard up period of our lives. Kids love attention. Look forward to other trips and negotiate some time away for yourself on your own later.

Jack80 · 20/07/2022 19:04

Have a week without him so he can have a break at his dads or you both go for the weekend or you have a week away with friends/family when he is back.

aSofaNearYou · 20/07/2022 19:00

Hmm1234 · 20/07/2022 18:24

There’s so much to do in WALES with kids especially if you drive. Just being out in the countryside is good for the children you are being unreasonable and selfish tbh

How on earth is she being selfish?

Ortega888 · 20/07/2022 18:56

As always the men get away with doing sod all whilst it’s left to the women to do absolutely everything. I would let your husband go and you could stay at home with the children and just go out locally. It’s sounds as if your like a single parent and your husband is like a big child which most of them are. It will be no fun for you as it’s hardly a holiday or a proper break. I really feel for you as you will have all the responsibilities on your shoulders whilst your husband just does nothing but have beers all evening. You will be exhausted try and get friends and family to call up to your home and they can help with the kids whilst hubby does his own thing. Let us know how you get on.

Surreytodorset · 20/07/2022 18:41

It’s a no from me. Swerve it if you can

Hmm1234 · 20/07/2022 18:24

There’s so much to do in WALES with kids especially if you drive. Just being out in the countryside is good for the children you are being unreasonable and selfish tbh

Highover · 20/07/2022 18:09

missing the point of the thread but cruises are fab holidays with little kids. We’ve taken ours since they were knee high. And, you can get amazing bargains if you can travel outside school holiday time. We go with P&O too. They have a two week cruise inAugust round Scandinavia and the Baltic £3000 for a family of four in one cabin. Full board - loads of entertainment- kids club thrown in - normal pub prices in the bars- what’s not to like? There is a lot of snobbery around cruising, but once you’ve tried it, it’s very difficult to find anything comparable. OP enjoy your cruise in Oct 23!

SunscreenCentral · 19/07/2022 14:42

No. That sounds like a recipe for disaster. Holidays with small children can be a nightmare at the best of times and the thought of being miles and miles from activities or attractions (distractions) in an unsafe ramshackle environment whilst slaving away doing the lion's share of work whilst he's chilling in the garden with his dad & beers ??

no fucking way

ninjafoodienovice · 19/07/2022 14:27

Sounds like same shit but in a different more difficult place.
I only had one toddler and this would have been an utter nightmare for me and DH would have tag teamed with me.

Say hell no now but be prepared to compromise on a weekend (which will be equally shit)

Cyclebabble · 19/07/2022 14:23

I would see this as visit rather than a holiday. For me that means I would limit to four days tops (inc travel), and I would be very clear that I would expect all childcare, cooking/cleaning etc to be jointly done. Too often a family holiday is actually more work for the woman not less.

GretaVanFleet · 19/07/2022 14:09

Plus he dropped into the conversation that DFiL has a cat living at his - and he’s worried he’ll spend the holiday sneezing/eyes streaming as he’s allergic to cats!! He thought I wanted to go as well which was why he didn’t mention the cat!!

Yeah right, he was thinking of you the whole time!
The only reason he’s agreeing with you now is because he’s found out about or just remembered the cat and that he’s allergic.

Thinkingblonde · 19/07/2022 13:47

I missed the updates by OP. Having seen them I think she’s right in not wanting to go, she knows her partner than any of us here.
I know I wouldn’t want to go either.,
Cruise holidays are great, they do early meal sittings for kids, the food is varied and plentiful, kids entertainment on board,. Stairs…not a problem, they have lifts!
Plus, unless you really want to stay on board you’re not on the ship all day long. Day trips to explore the countries the ships are docked at.
Boating holidays are great too, we’ve done three with our kids, starting at roughly the same age as ops would be by September ‘23. They loved it, Life jackets on when out on deck if we were moored up, if we were moving they stayed inside mostly, we’d sometimes let sit outside at the pointy end where the seating was lower down, with life jackets on obs. it wasn’t a problem, they went inside when coming into moor up, DH was steering. I was stood outside on the side of the boat with a moor rope ready to jump off as he pulled up as close as possible. The Kids watching out of the widow waiting for me to fall in( I never did) if ai was lucky a fellow boater would shout ‘Chuck it’ I’d throw him the rope and he’d moor up for me. Job done.
We gave them little jobs to do, mopping the deck, tidying the rope up. Paying the man who pumped the toilet out.
We let them have go at steering and as they grew older they were doing the jumping off and mooring up. And they never fell in, one lost a shoe once but that was the only mishap.

We met families with babies, they took collapsible playpens for tricky times. But you both have to do it together..

Holidayplanisshit · 19/07/2022 13:09

Spoken to DH this morning and said I’m not happy going and listed all the issues with DFiL’s home, lack of things for twins to do, how it won’t be much of a holiday for me if I’m constantly worrying about what they’re getting into or that they’re wandering off towards the lane and the stream.

He appears to be listening as he’s admitted it would far more of a break for him than me and that the twins will probably be bored as anything. Plus he dropped into the conversation that DFiL has a cat living at his - and he’s worried he’ll spend the holiday sneezing/eyes streaming as he’s allergic to cats!! He thought I wanted to go as well which was why he didn’t mention the cat!!

So the plan now is to look for a week’s holiday in a caravan or holiday park and see what the cost would be then take it from there either to go away or just do days out. DDiL is always invited to stay - DH mentions coming down for a few days every time he speaks to him on the phone!

And, for those saying being able to afford a £2,000 holiday (booked 18 months in advance which allows us time to save) doesn’t class us as a low income family - DH earns under £20,000 and I don’t work so I wouldn’t say we’re even a middle income family!!

OP posts:
Goldbar · 19/07/2022 11:49

@Orangello . There are definitely shades of 'Better drowned than duffers' about some of these responses 😂. Two little urchins wandering around the Welsh countryside with blackberry juice trickling down their cheeks...the picture of happy childhood. While the OP, clad in a flowered apron, whips a cut and come again cake out of the oven just as the little cherubs wander in from their unsupervised explorations past their dad and grandad snoozing in deck chairs in the garden. What could possibly go wrong?

Newestname002 · 19/07/2022 11:40

He obviously wants to see his dad which is perfectly fine and you say FIL is lovely so could you compromise and go five days up to a week?

There's nothing stopping him going on his own, with a bit of organisation (by him) and planning with his father. The fact is he doesn't want to do anything which doesn't involve effort by his wife.

Additionally, together with other PP, I can't see why he can't invite his father to their family home, which OP is open to. That has the added advantage that the children would be in a safe and comfortable environment with plenty of things to do much closer than FIL's deathtrap sounding home.

OP I hope you've made your feelings abundantly clear and are sticking to your position. Having something for free which is of no value (the opposite) is no inducement to do something you really do not want to do. 🌹

NeverFlyCoach · 19/07/2022 11:39

newfriend05 · 19/07/2022 11:20

You definitely not a low income family if your planning a cruise holiday🤦🏻‍♀️

Low income families can still go on holiday. It’s allowed 😂

Orangello · 19/07/2022 11:35

Goldbar
LOL this just reminded me of this old thread where OP wondered why some people were complaining about credit crunch and not enough money for food, when they could just go pick blackberries..

KangFang · 19/07/2022 11:27

Tell him you're not going, for all the same reasons you said above.

I agree with you.
This will not be a holiday for you and you're supposed to be a team, so he should not be going and leaving all the grunt work to you.

Goldbar · 19/07/2022 11:22

Oh, just push them out the door in the direction of the stream, OP, and then settle down with a good book in the garden while your husband and FIL have a natter! You're unreasonable to be so uptight about water safety and if they fall through the bannister and bash their heads...well, survival of the fittest, isn't it?

Don't worry about catering/food, either. Not your problem. Just take a few things for you and if the twins get hungry wandering about in the wilds, I'm sure a kindly farmer will teach them how to trap a rabbit or two or his wife will invite them in for seed cake and ginger beer. And there's bound to be plenty of blackberries about if they learn to avoid the prickles.

No doubt it will be absolutely idyllic.

newfriend05 · 19/07/2022 11:20

You definitely not a low income family if your planning a cruise holiday🤦🏻‍♀️

G5000 · 19/07/2022 11:19

Have people who are saying how unsuitable and generally horrible cruises are, actually been on one? You're not "stuck on a boat for 2 weeks without seeing anything" - on this particular cruise OP has booked, they will get to visit Madeira, Gran Canaria, Tenerife, Lanzarote, Fuerteventura, Cadiz and Lisbon, full day at pretty much each location, just going back for dinner and sleeping. Plenty of time to do sightseeing, if you have toddlers. There will be tons of suitable food options for picky toddlers on the ship, plus entertainment and babysitting.

Holidays with toddlers are obviously not the same than when you were childless, but honestly cruises are pretty much as good as it gets. Certainly beats a death-trap house in the middle of nowhere, where other adults won't even consider adjusting their cooking preferences so DC can eat as well.