Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Go on fess up, who’s eating all the good graduates?

634 replies

Whatsyournameandwheredyoucomefrom · 18/07/2022 17:17

I am currently interviewing grads for an entry level role in the marketing industry and SWEETMARYANDJOSEPH it’s tough going.

I’ve been taking in cohorts of grads for 10 years and in past years they were always keen to learn, chatty, determined to show the best of themselves and keen to know more about the industry. I’ve found graduate hiring to be a really
lovely thing; starting people off on their careers is something I love to do.

This year is bloody horrendous. I’ve done 23 interviews so far (5 roles available) and bar 2, without exception there’s zero enthusiasm or ‘self selling’, it’s more like I’m asking them to do a household chore and they’re getting pocket money in return - it’s ‘well if I really must do this job, what’s in it for me’. For example today a 21 year old cut me off mid sentence as I was talking about possible career progression through the industry and said ‘yeah I’m probably not thinking about that right now, I’m just figuring out what industry I want to get into right now you know? Like what is it about XXXX (that industry I’ve been in my entire career) that you think is worth pursuing because I could do basically anything and be fine you know?’ - very nearly snapped ‘this is an interview not a careers fair’ but held my tongue. Another told me £22k was basically slavery (her exact words) and she couldn’t work for less than £30k - not even graduated yet ffs. Also, oop norf so no London premium either.

I’m not expecting gratitude for the interview, I don’t even expect them to know anything about the industry and I’ll pay them £22k for the privilege of being fairly useless for a year while they learn. They can be earning £30k in 2 years with the training they get at the early stages through this role and I’ve had some go one to £50k+ in that time and yet almost without exception, none of the grads this year have turned up to the interview with any indication that they actually want the job.

What is this?? Is someone sweeping up all the driven, good candidates and paying them megabucks? Or are universities setting mad expectations on salary and not teaching interview skills?

I’m 35 so it’s not like I’m totally out of touch and feel a bit daft saying it but is this a generational thing? Covid?? WHAT IS HAPPENING?

OP posts:
50mg · 19/07/2022 06:18

Yorkshirelass04 · 18/07/2022 23:20

The alternative is that the employer ditches the graduate scheme and graduate jobs altogether - they are pretty resource intensive - and focuses on professional hires for £40-50k to contribute more straight away.

I'm not sure it always makes commercial sense to hire grads or inexperienced people, it isn't really a cheaper option what with the training and supervision needed.

And this is how a nation ends up with a skills shortage.

maddiemookins16mum · 19/07/2022 05:51

Maybe try non Grads, people who actually want a job and not entitled shits who think they are better than everyone else just because they went to Uni.

CourtneeLuv · 19/07/2022 05:49

InChocolateWeTrust · 18/07/2022 17:25

I think (trigger: unpopular opinion) a combo of Covid, social media and parenting/education styles that are very much "child led" or child centred, is leading to very entitled young people who think the world owes them everything.

This.

Open it up to non grads and you'll likely find people that will bite your hand off.

YouCantSpellAmericaWithoutErica · 19/07/2022 05:41

I don’t know the answer to most of your questions OP, but my partner lectures in university, mainly those in their final year and he’s said similar to you about a fair few of them. The arrogance seems to piss him off most. Not just towards him, but the insinuation that anyone who employs them would be lucky to have them. This often the attitude before their grades are given to them. I’d like to say receiving a 2:2 or below would knock that attitude out of them but it doesn’t seem to 🤷‍♀️

Oblomov22 · 19/07/2022 05:21

Interesting thread. Loads of different issues. I have quite strong views. I like the millennial job interview sketch video, where he sacks her! Yet I agree with sinek on things. My closest friend who is an employment lawyer says she worked hours and days for years, things that new lawyers just won't do. The balance between graduate with no experience versus apprentice is a good question. Ds1 interviewed for top accounting apprenticeships but turned then down, choosing a linked degree which will have regular work experience across the years. Whether that's a good option I hope so!

AsTreesWalking · 19/07/2022 05:05

Offer £26-28 as a starting wage with fewer benefits, look for people 40+ who have been stuck on term time only contracts in schools or admin in the NHS for years, treat breaks as sacrosanct and she'd get intelligent, adaptable, practically bulletproof employees who won't bugger off halfway round the world after two years or leave for a competitor at the first opportunity.

This.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 19/07/2022 01:08

MangyInseam · 19/07/2022 00:41

I think hiring non-grands, or reentries to the workforce, is the future in these kinds of jobs where a degree isn't actually useful in and of itself.

The degree in anything is just a cost that means the individuals are going to need a higher salary as they will likely have loan payments.

It's basically an apprenticeship, you could take anyone looking to get into the industry if they seem capable and talented.

Offer £26-28 as a starting wage with fewer benefits, look for people 40+ who have been stuck on term time only contracts in schools or admin in the NHS for years, treat breaks as sacrosanct and she'd get intelligent, adaptable, practically bulletproof employees who won't bugger off halfway round the world after two years or leave for a competitor at the first opportunity.

MangyInseam · 19/07/2022 00:41

I think hiring non-grands, or reentries to the workforce, is the future in these kinds of jobs where a degree isn't actually useful in and of itself.

The degree in anything is just a cost that means the individuals are going to need a higher salary as they will likely have loan payments.

It's basically an apprenticeship, you could take anyone looking to get into the industry if they seem capable and talented.

Entwifery · 19/07/2022 00:29

GrowlingManchego · 18/07/2022 23:53

I’m currently hiring for a charity role and I was discussing this with a friend’s teen daughter. The gist of her opinion was that most marketing jobs are ‘bullshit jobs’, which are promoting the consumerism that is wrecking the planet. She said that she would want a bigger salary than if she were in a more socially meaningful role, such as working for a cause she believed in.

If she's going to go down that route, the vast vast majority of jobs are "bullshit jobs" at the end of the day.

LouisRenault · 19/07/2022 00:01

The gist of her opinion was that most marketing jobs are ‘bullshit jobs’, which are promoting the consumerism that is wrecking the planet. She said that she would want a bigger salary than if she were in a more socially meaningful role, such as working for a cause she believed in.

Does she think that charities and other 'socially meaningful' causes don't spend a lot of money on engage in marketing?

maincrop · 18/07/2022 23:56

Echoing other posters, £22k just isn't enough to get someone good nowadays.

Yorkshirelass04 · 18/07/2022 23:54

GrowlingManchego · 18/07/2022 23:53

I’m currently hiring for a charity role and I was discussing this with a friend’s teen daughter. The gist of her opinion was that most marketing jobs are ‘bullshit jobs’, which are promoting the consumerism that is wrecking the planet. She said that she would want a bigger salary than if she were in a more socially meaningful role, such as working for a cause she believed in.

So she'll do a consumerist job for more money?

GrowlingManchego · 18/07/2022 23:53

I’m currently hiring for a charity role and I was discussing this with a friend’s teen daughter. The gist of her opinion was that most marketing jobs are ‘bullshit jobs’, which are promoting the consumerism that is wrecking the planet. She said that she would want a bigger salary than if she were in a more socially meaningful role, such as working for a cause she believed in.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 18/07/2022 23:50

TuftyMarmoset · 18/07/2022 23:49

And yet school leavers would?

Well, no. That’s the point. They’re all on a pretty even playing field. There’s not enough between them to warrant a huge pay disparity.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 18/07/2022 23:49

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime I feel like I'm going mad here. Either that or you and the other one are having a separate conversation to the one I've been in. I'll leave you to it... Best of luck getting good candidates.

TuftyMarmoset · 18/07/2022 23:49

Yorkshirelass04 · 18/07/2022 23:45

Many of them don't have the skills or fortitude for the workplace.
I speak as someone who didn't!!!

And yet school leavers would?

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 18/07/2022 23:49

TuftyMarmoset · 18/07/2022 23:44

So you think graduates develop literally zero skills during their degrees?

I would say, not especially more skilled than someone who has worked for three years. Obviously with some courses and professions excluded.

Yorkshirelass04 · 18/07/2022 23:45

Many of them don't have the skills or fortitude for the workplace.
I speak as someone who didn't!!!

TuftyMarmoset · 18/07/2022 23:44

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 18/07/2022 23:36

We do! We’re saying the average graduate (who hasn’t done voluntary work or internships) isn’t any more equipped to the job than an 18 year old fresh from A-Levels or a 21 year old who went into work instead of university. There are a few degrees and professions this is not true for, but on the whole, it’s a pretty fair assumption.
Now, if you’ve got a certain amount of money to put into the training and salary of one of these young people to enter to working environment, why would you pay a lot more salary for someone who isn’t any better equipped to do the job?

So you think graduates develop literally zero skills during their degrees?

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 18/07/2022 23:43

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 18/07/2022 23:39

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime Well no, that isn't the point we've been discussing at all. Grads vs non-grads-without-experience is a completely different topic. What you've been repeatedly saying is that the OP is doing these grads a favour by being willing to give them a job if they show suitable gratitude at interview. That's what I disagree with.

That’s EXACTLY what this thread is about! So much so that OP has even had a meeting with her management team to open up the role to non-graduates i.e getting rid of the graduate scheme. OP’s company was doing the graduates a favour by giving them the opportunity to interview for a job they have no experience in before anyone else.

Yorkshirelass04 · 18/07/2022 23:40

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 18/07/2022 23:39

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime Well no, that isn't the point we've been discussing at all. Grads vs non-grads-without-experience is a completely different topic. What you've been repeatedly saying is that the OP is doing these grads a favour by being willing to give them a job if they show suitable gratitude at interview. That's what I disagree with.

But you haven't said why.

Yorkshirelass04 · 18/07/2022 23:39

Also have you read the thread in AIBU about universities making accommodations and the general lack of fortitude and resilience amongst graduates?

It's not pretty reading. This feedback is from Russell group lecturers as well.

So again it's a question of value for money - I'd rather get someone in for £30k with no degree and more life experience.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 18/07/2022 23:39

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime Well no, that isn't the point we've been discussing at all. Grads vs non-grads-without-experience is a completely different topic. What you've been repeatedly saying is that the OP is doing these grads a favour by being willing to give them a job if they show suitable gratitude at interview. That's what I disagree with.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 18/07/2022 23:36

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 18/07/2022 23:29

Yorkshirelass04 You don't seem to be comprehending my posts at all.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime Yes, I interview and hire people.

We do! We’re saying the average graduate (who hasn’t done voluntary work or internships) isn’t any more equipped to the job than an 18 year old fresh from A-Levels or a 21 year old who went into work instead of university. There are a few degrees and professions this is not true for, but on the whole, it’s a pretty fair assumption.
Now, if you’ve got a certain amount of money to put into the training and salary of one of these young people to enter to working environment, why would you pay a lot more salary for someone who isn’t any better equipped to do the job?

Womencanlift · 18/07/2022 23:32

I think even starting to recruit grads in March, never mind now, is far too late. All the strong candidates will have been scooped up months ago

We interviewed and offered our grads roles last October and they will start in September after graduating this summer

Swipe left for the next trending thread