Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Go on fess up, who’s eating all the good graduates?

634 replies

Whatsyournameandwheredyoucomefrom · 18/07/2022 17:17

I am currently interviewing grads for an entry level role in the marketing industry and SWEETMARYANDJOSEPH it’s tough going.

I’ve been taking in cohorts of grads for 10 years and in past years they were always keen to learn, chatty, determined to show the best of themselves and keen to know more about the industry. I’ve found graduate hiring to be a really
lovely thing; starting people off on their careers is something I love to do.

This year is bloody horrendous. I’ve done 23 interviews so far (5 roles available) and bar 2, without exception there’s zero enthusiasm or ‘self selling’, it’s more like I’m asking them to do a household chore and they’re getting pocket money in return - it’s ‘well if I really must do this job, what’s in it for me’. For example today a 21 year old cut me off mid sentence as I was talking about possible career progression through the industry and said ‘yeah I’m probably not thinking about that right now, I’m just figuring out what industry I want to get into right now you know? Like what is it about XXXX (that industry I’ve been in my entire career) that you think is worth pursuing because I could do basically anything and be fine you know?’ - very nearly snapped ‘this is an interview not a careers fair’ but held my tongue. Another told me £22k was basically slavery (her exact words) and she couldn’t work for less than £30k - not even graduated yet ffs. Also, oop norf so no London premium either.

I’m not expecting gratitude for the interview, I don’t even expect them to know anything about the industry and I’ll pay them £22k for the privilege of being fairly useless for a year while they learn. They can be earning £30k in 2 years with the training they get at the early stages through this role and I’ve had some go one to £50k+ in that time and yet almost without exception, none of the grads this year have turned up to the interview with any indication that they actually want the job.

What is this?? Is someone sweeping up all the driven, good candidates and paying them megabucks? Or are universities setting mad expectations on salary and not teaching interview skills?

I’m 35 so it’s not like I’m totally out of touch and feel a bit daft saying it but is this a generational thing? Covid?? WHAT IS HAPPENING?

OP posts:
Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 19/07/2022 09:55

OooErr · 19/07/2022 09:53

I’m not going to comment on the OP’s post because with the full package It might actually be competitive.

But reading comprehension : the best graduates. It’s easy, for the best.

Why do you have to resort to insulting my intelligence?
I have a MA in Applied Linguistics.
The patronising really just demeans us both.

OooErr · 19/07/2022 09:53

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 19/07/2022 09:48

In which case, why even apply for a £22k job? If it’s so easy to get a higher paid job?

I’m not going to comment on the OP’s post because with the full package It might actually be competitive.

But reading comprehension : the best graduates. It’s easy, for the best.

ApplesandBunions · 19/07/2022 09:52

HaveringWavering · 19/07/2022 09:46

it can be an inherently frustrating and patronising thing to basically be told that the company will choose how part of your renumeration is spent.

Wow, talk about finding a way to put a negative spin on everything! Poor lambs feeling patronised by their generous benefits package!

If you can't see why this isn't optimum, despite a number of posts explaining the issue with benefits over cash and indeed the OP agreeing it would be a good idea to change things, the issue is your insistence on a positive spin.

People like spending money how they want to spend it, not on things their employer has chosen on their behalf. That's just how it is.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 19/07/2022 09:49

Also @Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime the amount of work that today’s graduates have to do for top jobs has also increased.
In my FIL’s generation they could cruise through drinking, get a third, and still walk into a graduate job (graduate = well paid).

This actually made me laugh out loud. So thanks

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 19/07/2022 09:48

OooErr · 19/07/2022 09:38

With jobs that actually pay well?
The best people have a choice
They’re not willing to put up with low pay to ‘get a foot’ on the ladder.

There’s also a larger exchange of information. Even as a graduate there are online forums, seniors in uni and LinkedIn, lots of avenues. It’s not hard to see what jobs actually pay and go for the more £££ ones.

In which case, why even apply for a £22k job? If it’s so easy to get a higher paid job?

DenholmElliot1 · 19/07/2022 09:47

It doesn't matter how much the benefits are worth when you are trying to get a mortgage you get 4 x salary - not 4 x salary plus benefits.

HaveringWavering · 19/07/2022 09:46

it can be an inherently frustrating and patronising thing to basically be told that the company will choose how part of your renumeration is spent.

Wow, talk about finding a way to put a negative spin on everything! Poor lambs feeling patronised by their generous benefits package!

OooErr · 19/07/2022 09:42

Also @Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime the amount of work that today’s graduates have to do for top jobs has also increased.
In my FIL’s generation they could cruise through drinking, get a third, and still walk into a graduate job (graduate = well paid).

Nowadays all sorts of jobs are labelled graduate jobs even if they’re not really. Graduates are expected to have done lots of relevant work experience alongside the degree. Not just work in a shop during the summer. Many have also had placements.

The standards are higher. People aren’t just joining with zero experience anymore.

OooErr · 19/07/2022 09:38

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 19/07/2022 09:29

So how are you paying rent, bills and buying food etc?

With jobs that actually pay well?
The best people have a choice
They’re not willing to put up with low pay to ‘get a foot’ on the ladder.

There’s also a larger exchange of information. Even as a graduate there are online forums, seniors in uni and LinkedIn, lots of avenues. It’s not hard to see what jobs actually pay and go for the more £££ ones.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 19/07/2022 09:29

rightonthyme · 19/07/2022 09:15

We want you to pay us our worth. We've learned how to not be taken for granted, we have learned to ask for more, and we've collectively decided not to sacrifice our precious lives for peanuts.

So how are you paying rent, bills and buying food etc?

ApplesandBunions · 19/07/2022 09:29

Blowscold · 19/07/2022 09:06

When we ask our team if they want benefits or cash - they choose cash every time - unless we can get a genuine discount for something they genuinely value - it's not worth it, choice in how to spend your salary is a bigger perk, they want the money up front!
We provide private health care - it's a compulsory benefit that benefits the business and the employee - we just can't rely on the NHS to get them well again. And saying full sick pay is not a benefit, just shows how unaware the posters on this thread are about half the workforce in the UK who only have access to statutory sick pay and would be very grateful for full sick pay.

Yeah I'm not surprised. Things like eg reimbursing train fares, that's all very well and some people will like it, but what if I already live close to the workplace and have plans to walk, or will get a lift, or there's no train stop near me or I just don't want to use it? Health related stuff is a bit different I agree.

ChuckBerrysBoots · 19/07/2022 09:28

Interesting article in the guardian today which touches on some of the things discussed here. People just want different things now, whether that be a result of covid or a generational thing https://www.theguardian.com/money/2022/jul/19/a-bigger-paycheck-id-rather-watch-the-sunset-is-this-the-end-of-ambition

I wonder if in your case people aren’t interested in where they’ll be in 5 years anymore!

OooErr · 19/07/2022 09:27

TheWayoftheLeaf · 18/07/2022 22:50

Well on TikTok I know there's lots of people basically saying this generation refuses to be corporate slaves, interviews are for both parties, not to be pressured to do too much work for not enough money by a company that will easily replace you. Etc.

I think they're trying to change the game and make it more of a buyers market.

Can't see it working but I respect the end goal.

It’s already a buyers market for the best grads, for in-demand fields.
I got 6+ offers after graduating from a top uni, and cancelled further interviewers. Most of my peers had multiple offers too.
Now as a software dev I regularly get lots of offers. Quick callbacks for stuff I apply for.

It’s a market like any other. Why would I put up with less than my worth?

dottiedodah · 19/07/2022 09:25

I think 22k is low .Maybe you think in the North it isnt ,but obv something is wrong or you wouldnt still be looking! Its very much an employees market right now and you are not attracting anyone.I think somewhere in the region of 26/28k would be more realistic

rightonthyme · 19/07/2022 09:15

We want you to pay us our worth. We've learned how to not be taken for granted, we have learned to ask for more, and we've collectively decided not to sacrifice our precious lives for peanuts.

prettybird · 19/07/2022 09:12

Ds (21) has just graduated in Politics and International Relations. He was at a Scottish Uni which means a 4 year degree, so at least he got a year and a half of "normal" Uni life for Covid hit. He also played decent level rugby outside of the Uni and got paid to coach rugby to two of the local schools, so he had a wider perspective than just Uni. (He'd been made redundant by Carphone Warehouse just before the Covid shutdown when they closed all their standalone stores).

He's been fortunate that he's got a job in the (fairly niche) field that he wanted - public affairs. And still in Scotland, so for the moment he's moved back home (he'll get settled in the job about 2,months and then put out feelers fir a flat). He's the most junior of junior of their account executives Wink

It was his 3rd interview in this field, so he was delighted to get it (interview only took place a few weeks ago). He's earning £23k per annum, mostly working from home. None of the fancy extras like gym or free food (it's a relatively small/new communications and public affairs agency) but he gets 30 days holiday plus his birthday (and statutory holidays) per annum plus he'll get an allowance for working from home (he's not sure how much that is yet, as the boss has been on holiday since he started last week and we're going to take it off him anyway while he's staying at home Wink).

He's earning more than his flat mate who also graduated in PIR and has got a 12 week internship with the Foreign Office Shock His flat mate is only on about £21 or £22k. And to make it worse, at the very last minute they moved it from a Scottish location to central London, with no help with accommodation Shock

He took all three interviews he'd had really seriously and was disappointed not to make it to the 2nd interview stage/be offered with the first two. But the one that he got is even more "public affairs" than the other two, so he's happy Smile

He didn't want to go to London just yet (that was a back up for him via the work that he does as Head of Politics for a volunteer pressure organisation - the founder works for a company that could've offered him an internship) although he does want to once he's more established. He is happy to spend a few years not earning "that" much while he gets experience.

So in my anecdotal experience of one, what you're offering "in the North" (given that Scotland is even further North Wink) seems ok and I can empathise with your frustrations. I hope you find the rest person soon Flowers

Blowscold · 19/07/2022 09:06

ApplesandBunions · 19/07/2022 08:33

This sounds like a good idea. It's a pretty benefits heavy package you're offering relative to the salary, and while I'm not saying there's no place for any of that, it can be an inherently frustrating and patronising thing to basically be told that the company will choose how part of your renumeration is spent. You will probably be better just upping the cash.

When we ask our team if they want benefits or cash - they choose cash every time - unless we can get a genuine discount for something they genuinely value - it's not worth it, choice in how to spend your salary is a bigger perk, they want the money up front!
We provide private health care - it's a compulsory benefit that benefits the business and the employee - we just can't rely on the NHS to get them well again. And saying full sick pay is not a benefit, just shows how unaware the posters on this thread are about half the workforce in the UK who only have access to statutory sick pay and would be very grateful for full sick pay.

GoodThinkingMax · 19/07/2022 09:04

The universities have made them stay in their rooms and do a lot online, placement opportunities all cancelled.

Er, no @49er that was government policy: compulsory lockdowns followed by work from home commands.

Not the choice of most universities who put in enormous resources with only a few weeks’ notice.

ApplesandBunions · 19/07/2022 08:33

Whatsyournameandwheredyoucomefrom · 18/07/2022 21:02

That might be a good point - the benefits are just blanket across everyone so maybe if we remove those for grads but you the salary that might be better? It would probably soften the blow for the business too.

This sounds like a good idea. It's a pretty benefits heavy package you're offering relative to the salary, and while I'm not saying there's no place for any of that, it can be an inherently frustrating and patronising thing to basically be told that the company will choose how part of your renumeration is spent. You will probably be better just upping the cash.

Blowscold · 19/07/2022 08:26

GrowlingManchego · 18/07/2022 23:53

I’m currently hiring for a charity role and I was discussing this with a friend’s teen daughter. The gist of her opinion was that most marketing jobs are ‘bullshit jobs’, which are promoting the consumerism that is wrecking the planet. She said that she would want a bigger salary than if she were in a more socially meaningful role, such as working for a cause she believed in.

at least she knows there’s a price in her principles 😂

HaveringWavering · 19/07/2022 08:21

@Whatsyournameandwheredyoucomefrom

45 days’ holiday? Wow. In my industry (professional services) 25 starting rising to 30 max 32 with long service is the norm, perhaps with the ability to buy another 2 or three. I thought that was not bad. Is 45 really standard in marketing?

HaveringWavering · 19/07/2022 08:14

GrowlingManchego · 18/07/2022 23:53

I’m currently hiring for a charity role and I was discussing this with a friend’s teen daughter. The gist of her opinion was that most marketing jobs are ‘bullshit jobs’, which are promoting the consumerism that is wrecking the planet. She said that she would want a bigger salary than if she were in a more socially meaningful role, such as working for a cause she believed in.

Tell her to read The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy.

Arthien · 19/07/2022 08:04

Whatsyournameandwheredyoucomefrom · 18/07/2022 20:46

Hilarious Grin

I love that you have an image in your head of the grads all shuffling their feet through the streets of Manchester, raiding the bins for scraps while we lash them into the workhouse for a pittance while Pankhurst watches on with a solitary tear rolling down her statue face HmmGrin

They work an average 35 hour week, 3-4 days from home, we pay for their annual train passes or parking so no travel costs to and from the office (fuel has just been subsidised as well), whichever they need. There’s free gym membership to a gym round the corner and they get breakfast and lunch for free when they’re in the office. They get 45 days annual leave as basic with an additional number of unlimited days if they need it. Private healthcare and access to private mental health services including CBT and psychotherapy for free. There’s also an excellent pension, bike to work, flat share schemes, a grant for at home working equipment, a monthly ‘top up’ for costs incurred from working from
home (towards energy bills, paid at the standard rate for electricity so it’s just gone up a lot).

For this we ask for zero experience, not even a degree now. We offer them a year of training in multiple disciplines so they can work out which branch of marketing suits them before they settle. They get a clear progression plan with milestones they know about from their first day, and unless they completely screw up they’re essentially on £30k 18 months in. From there, there’s a progression to £50k within 4-5 years.

This has been called exploitation, slavery and starvation wages on this thread. Mumsnet is WILD.

That said I do take the point that £22k isn’t what it used to be and needs an update - I’ll be feeding that back for sure. It might be we drop the train travel benefit (costs an absolute fortune, it’s worth about £3k a year) and up the salary or something.

I'm now wondering whether this sort of package is standard at all agencies, and/or wishing I lived closer to Manchester! I've been in-house for 5 years, but progression is now more or less only available when someone else leaves, which isn't particularly incentivising - especially as salary is banded, so no progression also means no salary increase. I like the idea of being loyal to a company, but if I'm missing out on that sort of salary and benefits package, then maybe I should be looking elsewhere. Thanks for the career inspiration OP!

Blowscold · 19/07/2022 07:43

YouCantSpellAmericaWithoutErica · 19/07/2022 05:41

I don’t know the answer to most of your questions OP, but my partner lectures in university, mainly those in their final year and he’s said similar to you about a fair few of them. The arrogance seems to piss him off most. Not just towards him, but the insinuation that anyone who employs them would be lucky to have them. This often the attitude before their grades are given to them. I’d like to say receiving a 2:2 or below would knock that attitude out of them but it doesn’t seem to 🤷‍♀️

I don't see the arrogance when I'm interviewing them - it's the arrogance in their applications that comes across very strongly - amongst the typos and bullshit. I'm never quite sure whether the problem is that they think they need to sound very confident of their own abilities - and it's good to be confident about things you have achieved but there are limits, they end up sounding naive and absolutely clueless. There's a curious mix of defiance, arrogance, insecurity and poor self-awareness - it's almost worth holding off for the Masters grads as they'll have gained some more maturity. Due to their age and their lack of track record, you can never be quite sure how much work you need to put in to get someone who can actually do the job well - grads are a risky hire, no one likes to sack anyone - despite what some might like to believe - we'd avoid hiring grads if we could but in this market we're forced to do the parenting (because that's what it often feels like).
I'm dreading the point where the actual parents get involved in the process - I'm sure it's not that far off!

HollyBollyBooBoo · 19/07/2022 06:25

V low salary, I started on £24k in retail 25 years ago as a grad.

Swipe left for the next trending thread