Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Go on fess up, who’s eating all the good graduates?

634 replies

Whatsyournameandwheredyoucomefrom · 18/07/2022 17:17

I am currently interviewing grads for an entry level role in the marketing industry and SWEETMARYANDJOSEPH it’s tough going.

I’ve been taking in cohorts of grads for 10 years and in past years they were always keen to learn, chatty, determined to show the best of themselves and keen to know more about the industry. I’ve found graduate hiring to be a really
lovely thing; starting people off on their careers is something I love to do.

This year is bloody horrendous. I’ve done 23 interviews so far (5 roles available) and bar 2, without exception there’s zero enthusiasm or ‘self selling’, it’s more like I’m asking them to do a household chore and they’re getting pocket money in return - it’s ‘well if I really must do this job, what’s in it for me’. For example today a 21 year old cut me off mid sentence as I was talking about possible career progression through the industry and said ‘yeah I’m probably not thinking about that right now, I’m just figuring out what industry I want to get into right now you know? Like what is it about XXXX (that industry I’ve been in my entire career) that you think is worth pursuing because I could do basically anything and be fine you know?’ - very nearly snapped ‘this is an interview not a careers fair’ but held my tongue. Another told me £22k was basically slavery (her exact words) and she couldn’t work for less than £30k - not even graduated yet ffs. Also, oop norf so no London premium either.

I’m not expecting gratitude for the interview, I don’t even expect them to know anything about the industry and I’ll pay them £22k for the privilege of being fairly useless for a year while they learn. They can be earning £30k in 2 years with the training they get at the early stages through this role and I’ve had some go one to £50k+ in that time and yet almost without exception, none of the grads this year have turned up to the interview with any indication that they actually want the job.

What is this?? Is someone sweeping up all the driven, good candidates and paying them megabucks? Or are universities setting mad expectations on salary and not teaching interview skills?

I’m 35 so it’s not like I’m totally out of touch and feel a bit daft saying it but is this a generational thing? Covid?? WHAT IS HAPPENING?

OP posts:
Holidaydreamingagain · 19/07/2022 11:25

To those saying 22k is”peanuts” - it’s not if there’s a clear progression and training path. I’d loved to have been able to see how I could double my salary and receive really useful training and mentoring within 5-6 years of starting my first job post graduation.

Correct and if it's a good company and you impress then you'll be moved on, it's a stepping stone. And good people get remembered, networking is so important. The skills learnt and the doors good training can open is how careers develop. Saying "our admin are on more than that" doesn't mean anything - do they have a career path? They probably have more work experience so their skills are in more demand, admin isn't easy, I'd be a shit administrator and coming in, showing willing and learning is the best experience one can get. OP the people you're getting through, sound crap and I'd be appalled if one of my children went into an interview with that attitude.

Tellhimno · 19/07/2022 11:22

Don’t their PARENTS model this sort of stuff?
This is a parenting site, but it seems to me, a lot of parents are complicit in the minority of young people who are overfull of entitlement.

I wish I could say that parents modeling this sort of stuff is enough!
Twins - the difference in their approach to work is remarkable and it has always been there.
You'd think having someone educate you on how to approach these things would help but dt1 is the I'm not working for peanuts type, I'm too good for them, pay me what I'm worth and it has not worked out well for him. Despite being academically bright, that youthful arrogance and delicate male ego does him no favours, it does not allow him to be agile and learn quickly in a practical sense - it's infuriating to watch but we can do little else, I assume he'll eventually figure it out whilst we are not watching.
Dt2 does not have that arrogance - listened to her parent's advice and is doing really well. Works hard, shows initiative and will enthusiastically do anything she is asked and more - one of her work colleagues wrote a note to me recently to tell me how amazing she was!

MerryChristmasToYou · 19/07/2022 11:10

Parents don’t need to do anything.

No, but it helps if they have brought up their offspring to be hard-working, resilient, co-operative, curious, and confident.l

OooErr · 19/07/2022 10:47

GoodThinkingMax · 19/07/2022 10:41

Don’t their PARENTS model this sort of stuff?

This is a parenting site, but it seems to me, a lot of parents are complicit in the minority of young people who are overfull of entitlement.

To those saying 22k is”peanuts” - it’s not if there’s a clear progression and training path. I’d loved to have been able to see how I could double my salary and receive really useful training and mentoring within 5-6 years of starting my first job post graduation.

I went for a PhD and worked 1.5 jobs + my PhD and thought I was well paid on £15k (probably around £30k now) in my first post-PhD lectureship. Took me about 10 years and a couple of (expensive) moves to double that.

Parents don’t need to do anything.
It’s the graduates themselves who should be talking to seniors, going to networking events.
A PhD doesn’t mean anything. You could do one in Art History which there really isn’t demand for - I wouldn’t tell a child who did that to expect a high salary unless they found a niche.

I personally based my salary expectations on what people were actually getting. There’s no need for guesswork

allgoodabc · 19/07/2022 10:47

MangyInseam · 19/07/2022 00:41

I think hiring non-grands, or reentries to the workforce, is the future in these kinds of jobs where a degree isn't actually useful in and of itself.

The degree in anything is just a cost that means the individuals are going to need a higher salary as they will likely have loan payments.

It's basically an apprenticeship, you could take anyone looking to get into the industry if they seem capable and talented.

This is a very good point actually, there is a lot of untapped value in the re-entry workforce, and depending on the age you get them at they could 20-30 years of career left in them. They might be a better match for the offer as well, and will likely be proactive about getting training to fill the gaps in their knowledge and skills too.

Blowscold · 19/07/2022 10:46

OooErr · 19/07/2022 10:38

It’s not my day job. But I work closely with early careers teams. Doing outreach events, interviews, giving input on the format of our assessments. This is to ensure we get the right talent.

A lot of our jobs, technical or otherwise don’t really need a degree.
We also hire a lot of apprentices, they get on-the-job training, professional qualifications. They can do a paid for degree if they wish as a top-up qualification, but it makes no difference to the job. By the time they’re 23 they’ve had 4+ years experience, relevant qualifications and have no issues getting promoted or jobs elsewhere.

Interesting - internships give very little extra for us on a CV for us. The experience is usually not relevant and even if it is in the same sector, the bad habits gained by poor experience are often more irritating and difficult to remove. The intern experience through covid seems particularly limited.

Hont1986 · 19/07/2022 10:44

But that’s not new? I was a grad, started on £16k in 2010 after gcse, a level and a degree. Not sure what minimum wage was back then, but I certainly couldn’t have bought a house, paid rent alone etc

OP, £16k in 2010 is equivalent to almost £25k today. You earned more then than these graduates you're trying to hire now, plus the cost of housing and rent for them is far, far higher than it was for you.

GoodThinkingMax · 19/07/2022 10:41

Don’t their PARENTS model this sort of stuff?

This is a parenting site, but it seems to me, a lot of parents are complicit in the minority of young people who are overfull of entitlement.

To those saying 22k is”peanuts” - it’s not if there’s a clear progression and training path. I’d loved to have been able to see how I could double my salary and receive really useful training and mentoring within 5-6 years of starting my first job post graduation.

I went for a PhD and worked 1.5 jobs + my PhD and thought I was well paid on £15k (probably around £30k now) in my first post-PhD lectureship. Took me about 10 years and a couple of (expensive) moves to double that.

Blowscold · 19/07/2022 10:41

marvellousmaple · 19/07/2022 10:30

I'm thinking salaries must be lower in the UK as my 27yo earns just over 100 $AUD which is about 58k pounds which I think is a good salary there? . It's hard to tell with the different prices of things.
OP if you aren't attracting any good candidates you need to change either
your ad
your job appeal
your salary offer
your expectations
your marketing strategy

Depends on the role, experience, talent and location - one of our 27 year olds is on more than £58k and one of our 27 year olds is on quite a bit less - both have a Master's degree.. give a piece of work to both and one will need a lot of hand holding, guidance and generally will use a lot of management's time to get there, the other will be able to run with something with minimal guidance, make valuable contributions and produce a quality piece of work. The lower-paid person is taking longer to develop - not helped by their refusal to come into the office more frequently.

blametheparents · 19/07/2022 10:39

Holidaydreamingagain · 19/07/2022 10:21

really? So did I on one of the top grad programmes and it was on 16500 with london weighting ending up at about 25 about 3 years later. The buying and merchandising jobs at the time in london was more like £12-14. The accountants at the big 5 as they were, weren't even on 24 when they started

@Holidaydreamingagain
Completely agree with you.
My DH started in an investment bank in 1993 (so 29 years ago) and that was on £20k a year - which was top dollar. None of his peers (graduates in comp sci from Warwick) earnt more than that.

OooErr · 19/07/2022 10:38

Blowscold · 19/07/2022 10:11

@OooErrAre you involved in grad recruitment?

Also, what is the difference between a grad job and a non-grad job?

It’s not my day job. But I work closely with early careers teams. Doing outreach events, interviews, giving input on the format of our assessments. This is to ensure we get the right talent.

A lot of our jobs, technical or otherwise don’t really need a degree.
We also hire a lot of apprentices, they get on-the-job training, professional qualifications. They can do a paid for degree if they wish as a top-up qualification, but it makes no difference to the job. By the time they’re 23 they’ve had 4+ years experience, relevant qualifications and have no issues getting promoted or jobs elsewhere.

MerryChristmasToYou · 19/07/2022 10:37

Many of them don't have the skills or fortitude for the workplace.
I speak as someone who didn't!!!

And yet school leavers would?

I think a school leaver would probably be a better prospect than a graduate who thought that their 2:1 or 'masters' made them better than someone else.

I have a young colleague with a Masters, who thinks they know everything, has a meltdown on any constructive criticism and flounces off on sick leave far too often. This colleague could be trained, although does lack some of the essential skills, but in reality they'd be better off doing something better suited to their temperament.

allgoodabc · 19/07/2022 10:37

Sorry @Whatsyournameandwheredyoucomefrom have to agree with so many previous posters, the pay is not enough to live on comfortably, and the prospects not that promising. I started on lower than 22k years ago (but not much lower) but I had plenty of money to rent a nice room in a house in a capital city, money for clothes, holidays and entertainment, nights out etc. wasn’t even a graduate at the time so no student debt. Worked 9-5. Graduates are probably no longer falling for the foot on the ladder fallacy, because the truth is there isn’t an obvious career pathway upwards to earning enough to achieve even the middle class basics in life in marketing generally (own home, car, children, holidays). There are some very senior roles that pay well enough sure, but not many and no guaranteed pathways to get there. It’s very easy to get stuck on a middling to poor income in marketing, and it’s a demanding career.

If I had to make my way now I would go directly to a profession like accountancy, maybe law, banking, or the really structured graduate programmes with the big 5. There are probably lots of would-be marketing geniuses out there quite sensibly deciding that a career in marketing is not a luxury they can afford, even if it would suit them better.

Now it’s no longer a recruiters market, but the recruitment is probably being carried out by people like yourself who came up in a world where graduates would be really competing for these roles, so there’s a mismatch. The sooner you and your colleagues accept that it’s now you who is competing for them, and adjust your offer and your pitch accordingly the better. And the whole “paying them 22k while they’re still not much use” perspective is probably unhelpful and slightly unrealistic, if you have a good training/mentorship programme you will be able to gain value from they bring to the table almost immediately.

marvellousmaple · 19/07/2022 10:30

I'm thinking salaries must be lower in the UK as my 27yo earns just over 100 $AUD which is about 58k pounds which I think is a good salary there? . It's hard to tell with the different prices of things.
OP if you aren't attracting any good candidates you need to change either
your ad
your job appeal
your salary offer
your expectations
your marketing strategy

chiffchaffchiff · 19/07/2022 10:28

The salary is uncompetitive. The good graduates won't be interviewing for you.

I'm outside of London and the administrators where I work get 23k as a starting salary. No degree or experience necessary. Our newest administrator is 18, has just left school and is out-earning your graduates. She's not spent a year being useless either, just a few months in and she's brilliant. I'm a level just above administrator, half of us have degrees, the other half progressed from administrator after a year or two. Starting salary is now around 28k.

marvellousmaple · 19/07/2022 10:21

I'm not sure what is going on over there in the UK, but you need my sons and their friends. We are in Australia , but everyone has just moved on. Uni was done remotely but that was the only concession I am aware of.My 21yo is already employed in his field, although he hasn't finished his degree yet ; as are most of his friends and my older son and his friends are all in high demand. They are hardworking and have travelled extensively before Covid . The 21yo's are planning their big trips now for next year when they finish uni or delaying a semester. They all have walked into great jobs where they work very hard .
I think you must be underpaying.
For example my 21yo is earning $37k AUD ( roughly 21 k pounds) but only works 3 days a week and has 18 months to go to graduation ( it is a double degree though).

Holidaydreamingagain · 19/07/2022 10:21

HollyBollyBooBoo · 19/07/2022 06:25

V low salary, I started on £24k in retail 25 years ago as a grad.

really? So did I on one of the top grad programmes and it was on 16500 with london weighting ending up at about 25 about 3 years later. The buying and merchandising jobs at the time in london was more like £12-14. The accountants at the big 5 as they were, weren't even on 24 when they started

RufusthefIoraImissingreindeer · 19/07/2022 10:21

My graduate son would be an absolute asset

He's currently in a 20k job with limited progression at the moment...but is a bit tied to where we live otherwise I'd send you his cv ...he'd love the holiday 😀 (partner is a teacher)

Holidaydreamingagain · 19/07/2022 10:18

People need to think more widely. Yes the 22k is quite low but it's a starting salary not a finishing salary. She has outlined the training plan which sounds excellent, she has also pointed out that they'll earn more money as they move along and will be earning close to £50k within about 3-4 years. you can't compare it to an admin or supermarket job, you're investing in short term lowish salary for an ability to maximise income at a later date.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 19/07/2022 10:15

MA in Linguistics indeed… then you really should know better.

Sorry, you’re going to need to elaborate on this. Me being so thick and old and all 😂

Blowscold · 19/07/2022 10:11

OooErr · 19/07/2022 09:42

Also @Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime the amount of work that today’s graduates have to do for top jobs has also increased.
In my FIL’s generation they could cruise through drinking, get a third, and still walk into a graduate job (graduate = well paid).

Nowadays all sorts of jobs are labelled graduate jobs even if they’re not really. Graduates are expected to have done lots of relevant work experience alongside the degree. Not just work in a shop during the summer. Many have also had placements.

The standards are higher. People aren’t just joining with zero experience anymore.

@OooErrAre you involved in grad recruitment?

Also, what is the difference between a grad job and a non-grad job?

LikeADogWithABone · 19/07/2022 10:11

My kids are grads in their 20s and I w have grad jobs. They got more starting wage than the OPs job but I still think the OPs job sounds good. The holiday leave thing is a massive massive benefit and the job sounds great. It's a proper grad job. It could be a few more thousand a year but it's ok. I like the fact that if employees are working excess hours it's flagged and looked at. One of my sons is doing a financial grad job and the culture is for grads to work ridiculously hard. The partners seem happy for them to do that 😡😡😡
I had a look at grad marketing job ads in Manchester and it doesn't stand out as being really badly paid. There are plenty lower.
However I wonder if it would be better for the company to pay more and attract better candidates.

I also think you might just have been unlucky with who you have interviewed.

OooErr · 19/07/2022 10:11

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 19/07/2022 09:55

Why do you have to resort to insulting my intelligence?
I have a MA in Applied Linguistics.
The patronising really just demeans us both.

You set the tone. No need to get upset when people respond in kind.
MA in Linguistics indeed… then you really should know better.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 19/07/2022 09:58

Blowscold · 19/07/2022 09:56

The difficulty is knowing and demonstrating your worth when you have no track record. Make yourself a superstar at work and people will trip over themselves to keep you - in this market especially. But a lackluster performance with a pay me what I'm worth attitude will have them showing you the door ASAP!

Totally agree.

Blowscold · 19/07/2022 09:56

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 19/07/2022 09:29

So how are you paying rent, bills and buying food etc?

The difficulty is knowing and demonstrating your worth when you have no track record. Make yourself a superstar at work and people will trip over themselves to keep you - in this market especially. But a lackluster performance with a pay me what I'm worth attitude will have them showing you the door ASAP!