Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Go on fess up, who’s eating all the good graduates?

634 replies

Whatsyournameandwheredyoucomefrom · 18/07/2022 17:17

I am currently interviewing grads for an entry level role in the marketing industry and SWEETMARYANDJOSEPH it’s tough going.

I’ve been taking in cohorts of grads for 10 years and in past years they were always keen to learn, chatty, determined to show the best of themselves and keen to know more about the industry. I’ve found graduate hiring to be a really
lovely thing; starting people off on their careers is something I love to do.

This year is bloody horrendous. I’ve done 23 interviews so far (5 roles available) and bar 2, without exception there’s zero enthusiasm or ‘self selling’, it’s more like I’m asking them to do a household chore and they’re getting pocket money in return - it’s ‘well if I really must do this job, what’s in it for me’. For example today a 21 year old cut me off mid sentence as I was talking about possible career progression through the industry and said ‘yeah I’m probably not thinking about that right now, I’m just figuring out what industry I want to get into right now you know? Like what is it about XXXX (that industry I’ve been in my entire career) that you think is worth pursuing because I could do basically anything and be fine you know?’ - very nearly snapped ‘this is an interview not a careers fair’ but held my tongue. Another told me £22k was basically slavery (her exact words) and she couldn’t work for less than £30k - not even graduated yet ffs. Also, oop norf so no London premium either.

I’m not expecting gratitude for the interview, I don’t even expect them to know anything about the industry and I’ll pay them £22k for the privilege of being fairly useless for a year while they learn. They can be earning £30k in 2 years with the training they get at the early stages through this role and I’ve had some go one to £50k+ in that time and yet almost without exception, none of the grads this year have turned up to the interview with any indication that they actually want the job.

What is this?? Is someone sweeping up all the driven, good candidates and paying them megabucks? Or are universities setting mad expectations on salary and not teaching interview skills?

I’m 35 so it’s not like I’m totally out of touch and feel a bit daft saying it but is this a generational thing? Covid?? WHAT IS HAPPENING?

OP posts:
lissie123 · 20/07/2022 10:31

@mathanxiety exactly!

I work with graduates and some are exceptional others less so. A diverse range much like any employee base.
in terms of his salary my DS worked bloody hard to secure his job and and has a first class honours degree.

Porridgeislife · 20/07/2022 10:17

Tellhimno · 20/07/2022 09:04

I’m always in two minds about being very impressed that a student secured an internship (or several) with companies - is not great practice to be impressed that someone has a big name on their cv, what does it say? - it isn’t always a positive - why didn’t that internship lead to a job - after all that’s why we offer them! Who got them the internship - was it Mummy or Daddy? What skills did they acquire in six weeks that another grad couldn’t acquire equally as quickly.

We take far more internships (about 3x) than grad jobs offered after the internship stage so I don’t think it’s unusual not to have been converted.

We have an apprentice scheme that runs concurrently with our graduate scheme. These young people are generally far more mature and practical than our grads - most have worked for a year or taken a non-traditional route to our industry, despite being usually 18 or 19 rather than 23.

I really like to see grads who have worked part-time in hospitality or retail before joining us. It shows ability to stick out something a bit uncomfortable and learn some practical people-based problem solving skills.

My most frustrating grad (rotational) last year flatly refused to ever turn her camera on, didn’t get in touch with me unless I reached out first & during Covid it was incredibly hard to get to know her. I wouldn’t be able to pick her out in the office now we’re back.

We didn’t end up extending a permanent offer (it was hers to lose) as I had no confidence in her.

Tellhimno · 20/07/2022 10:10

OooErr · 20/07/2022 09:57

Ah yes, that’s true!
We’re never as you said particularly impressed solely by internships. ‘Work experience’ includes clubs, hobbies etc basically anything where there are skills.

I cannot understand how ANYBODY can get away with not realising the importance of these as career advisors at prestigious unis talk about it fr day one. But maybe they’re too important to go to career fairs, or think big name degree = £££.

Another issue I have with internships is that they often are only offered for 6 weeks - a student from a lower socio-economic background couldn't afford to only work 6 weeks of their holiday and getting a job for the remainder would be very tricky, students from poorer backgrounds are also less likely to get an intern place through Mummy and Daddy contacts (although fewer students get internships through contacts now) - we are keen not to disadvantage poorer students - so anything we see as a potential barrier, we try to remove if possible.

We've given up on careers fairs - they don't bear much fruit - students reportedly see little value in them, and they are expensive to attend (in terms of staffing and expenses) again whilst we are London based we would like to reach Students from throughout the UK.

OooErr · 20/07/2022 09:57

Tellhimno · 20/07/2022 09:53

I agree that it's how they use their internship to answer competency questions but they can be answered using a wealth of other experience. The problem comes from grads who don't join Uni clubs, don't have hobbies and have never had any jobs - they have literally nothing to talk about, their biggest achievement is getting through Uni - just like everyone else on your list. Although some do try to make it up - even the big named Oxbridge kind.😏

Ah yes, that’s true!
We’re never as you said particularly impressed solely by internships. ‘Work experience’ includes clubs, hobbies etc basically anything where there are skills.

I cannot understand how ANYBODY can get away with not realising the importance of these as career advisors at prestigious unis talk about it fr day one. But maybe they’re too important to go to career fairs, or think big name degree = £££.

OooErr · 20/07/2022 09:54

justasking111 · 20/07/2022 09:20

Salary offers surely depends on the degrees taken, whether there's a glut or shortage in that area. Some careers are not well paid at different times. Some are never well paid.

Exactly. I find it strange that loads of people are responding referencing their own starting salaries/years of experience. It’s really irrelevant.
I only provided an illustrative example of what grads with any old degree ‘could’ earn in my company/field to show that higher salaries exist in the North West.

But I’m not In marketing. So I wouldn’t know whether 22K was appealing, to people who wanted a marketing job and career as opposed to just the highest paid, ‘any’ job.

Tellhimno · 20/07/2022 09:53

Holidaydreamingagain · 20/07/2022 07:47

Well there are graduates and graduates aren’t there. Just because someone has been to university doesn’t make them worthy of a high salary. It is always going to be the attitude and what there is about the person who will define how they get their foot through the door.

No 22 year old with next to no work experience is going to be in a position to get a job if they have an entitled attitude and think they know their worth before they’ve even set foot in a professional environment.

a smart savvy grad will look at what they will learn in their first job and how it will equip them to get where they eventually want. They might start on £22k but they’ll be the ones laughing when their attitude and experience takes them far beyond what the arrogant little fuss pots who won’t get out of bed for less than £30k with no experience ever manage to achieve

and those who talk about £35-40k starting salaries, do you really think they are going to the kids who can barely grunt in an interview? No theyre going to the ones who have done the work in the background: who have looked for work experience, who have done the online internships over covid, who have shown leadership and used their initiative on top of their degree through sports or running clubs or similar or taken on extra training etc in their own time.

if they want the big money they’ll still, even in this day and age need more than a degree certificate

I agree that it's how they use their internship to answer competency questions but they can be answered using a wealth of other experience. The problem comes from grads who don't join Uni clubs, don't have hobbies and have never had any jobs - they have literally nothing to talk about, their biggest achievement is getting through Uni - just like everyone else on your list. Although some do try to make it up - even the big named Oxbridge kind.😏

OooErr · 20/07/2022 09:45

Tellhimno · 20/07/2022 09:04

I’m always in two minds about being very impressed that a student secured an internship (or several) with companies - is not great practice to be impressed that someone has a big name on their cv, what does it say? - it isn’t always a positive - why didn’t that internship lead to a job - after all that’s why we offer them! Who got them the internship - was it Mummy or Daddy? What skills did they acquire in six weeks that another grad couldn’t acquire equally as quickly.

Well just ask them how they got it?
Finance/tech always have spring weeks, internships, It’s a thing.
When I was at a prestigious uni people who hadn’t been able to get a proper internship were told to write to various companies, asking for experience.
Usually look them up on LinkedIn, find a commonality and message them.
Did work for quite a few people!

The best people also don’t just take ‘any job’. They might want to try a few.

Also why no job offered. Sometimes they take more internet than there are places. All great, but they have to choose.

I’d look at the whole package and reasons

Also it’s not the internship per se but how they use it to answer competency questions.

mycatisannoying · 20/07/2022 09:36

And presumably they knew the salary before the interview took place!

mycatisannoying · 20/07/2022 09:35

Sign of the times I'm afraid.

justasking111 · 20/07/2022 09:20

Salary offers surely depends on the degrees taken, whether there's a glut or shortage in that area. Some careers are not well paid at different times. Some are never well paid.

PumpkinPiloter · 20/07/2022 09:07

My graduate position paid 21k 20 years ago. Considering how much the cost of living has gone up in this time 22k is a low wage.

Tellhimno · 20/07/2022 09:04

I’m always in two minds about being very impressed that a student secured an internship (or several) with companies - is not great practice to be impressed that someone has a big name on their cv, what does it say? - it isn’t always a positive - why didn’t that internship lead to a job - after all that’s why we offer them! Who got them the internship - was it Mummy or Daddy? What skills did they acquire in six weeks that another grad couldn’t acquire equally as quickly.

Holidaydreamingagain · 20/07/2022 07:47

Well there are graduates and graduates aren’t there. Just because someone has been to university doesn’t make them worthy of a high salary. It is always going to be the attitude and what there is about the person who will define how they get their foot through the door.

No 22 year old with next to no work experience is going to be in a position to get a job if they have an entitled attitude and think they know their worth before they’ve even set foot in a professional environment.

a smart savvy grad will look at what they will learn in their first job and how it will equip them to get where they eventually want. They might start on £22k but they’ll be the ones laughing when their attitude and experience takes them far beyond what the arrogant little fuss pots who won’t get out of bed for less than £30k with no experience ever manage to achieve

and those who talk about £35-40k starting salaries, do you really think they are going to the kids who can barely grunt in an interview? No theyre going to the ones who have done the work in the background: who have looked for work experience, who have done the online internships over covid, who have shown leadership and used their initiative on top of their degree through sports or running clubs or similar or taken on extra training etc in their own time.

if they want the big money they’ll still, even in this day and age need more than a degree certificate

summerin69 · 20/07/2022 07:47

I do a lot of research for HR and this is the trend. The tables have turned in favour of candidates rather than the other way round. There are so many jobs on offer, candidates can afford to be choosy - they have lots of jobs and offers to choose from so employers need to be competitive. Gone are the days of employers holding all the cards - in order to be competitive in hiring you need to really adapt and employers need to sell, not the other way round. Yes, there's more entitlement with candidates and they expect a lot, but in many cases they are getting what they ask for.

There are a lot of companies this candidate can choose from so now it's actually more about you selling your company and why this person would want to work there, not the other way round. Top draws for candidates are salary (more so now than ever because of rising cost of living) and career progression. Hybrid working or working from home is standard, not a luxury etc.

Do a google search about hiring and you'll see dozens of reports that will confirm this and what employers need to be doing to attract the top candidates.

I know it's demoralising - but candidates have had to put up being ghosted by employers, being made to jump through hoops etc to get a job for years - now it's the other way round.

vulvacious · 20/07/2022 07:14

I’m in the north and I work in the public sector and even we pay our graduate positions more than that. That’s really low.
There’s also a much healthier attitude emerging in younger generations around working to live and not living to work.

KatherineJaneway · 20/07/2022 06:17

We turned down a young man who failed the practical and his mother phoned to harangue us for turning down such a talented person!

We had a woman write in and complain her daughter didn't get a place on our graduate scheme. According to her, her daughter had a degree in the subject so couldn't fathom why she didn't get a place. Writing back I said we had 7000 applications for 30 odd places so the fact she had a degree in said subject wasn't going to set her apart. I then highlighted some of the things that would mean she would stand out and send the letter.

What I didn't say was there was no way her daughter was right for our grad scheme if her mum had to write letters on her behalf and she couldn't ask for feedback for herself.

mathanxiety · 20/07/2022 04:15

Nope the salary is not fine. It’s too low. That’s the whole reason you can’t recruit. My son has just been offered a graduate position for £37.5kpa. Not London.

That's much more like it.

Grads are able to talk to each other these days and compare the salaries they're being offered. It's a market which favours the employee. There's nothing entitled in their approach. They are smart enough to appreciate the position they are in.

Spaceshiphaslanded · 20/07/2022 01:56

I started on £22k as a grad…market research agency (the biggest one there is OP, you’ll know it). Wasn’t the London office, midlands.That was in 2008….
as others have said, realign expectations to salary offered. The world is quite different just now.

WyfOfBathe · 20/07/2022 00:56

DB has 1 more year of uni left and wants to go into marketing after he graduates. He's had a look on job sites recruiting this year's graduates, to get an idea of what might be available next year too. He commented that there's a real range of salaries for marketing grad schemes. Lots are around what you pay, but some are around £40k. You may be in line with lots of competitors but still losing the very best candidates.

DBro is very interested in companies with opportunities to transfer abroad, so I'll DM you if that's ok!

I'm a secondary school teacher and many of us have noticed that our students seem about 2 years less mature than students before covid, even where they're on track academically. I wouldn't be surprised if it's the same at universities.

Madcatgirl · 20/07/2022 00:44

I was a mature student and couldn’t get on any grad programme. Pointless doing a degree.

McClaire · 19/07/2022 23:30

In my opinion you are being a bit unreasonable by gossipping.
I think you should be respecting their confidentiality and keeping them private.

justasking111 · 19/07/2022 23:18

DanceItOut · 19/07/2022 22:17

I am in the graduating class of 2022 but as a mature student rather than in my 20s. From what I have seen there has been much less opportunity for this graduating class to actually grow up and get out in the world. So many of us ended up doing more than half of our degree online that those in student accommodation moved back home.

i started September 2019 and all was normal until January-February 2020 when the uni had strikes so classes cancelled and then covid hit and it was online only until my third year which became blended between online and in person but social activities etc were limited. for me this isn’t a huge issue in terms of life experience because I’m 33 I had a job working from apprentice to senior admin for 7 years before being a stay at home mum and I have my own life experiences and social life outside of uni. I just wanted a degree to help prove I could still learn new things after a few years of being a stay at home mum. But for these kids? That window of time where they leave the nest and get life experience didn’t really happen as it normally would.

Thanks from a mum with a DS who has just graduated. They really have had the strangest three years. I'm so sad for them

Mirw · 19/07/2022 23:17

So many graduates think they are worth at least £30k even with no experience. Such a, sense of entitlement. The last interview I was involved in was for an office manager. Like you, we had a young woman who told us we were paying peanuts and she would only take the job if we paid her £32k. My salary as a researcher with 40 years experience. Her experience... Studying for a BSc in sociology and a summer job picking fruit!!
We turned down a young man who failed the practical and his mother phoned to harangue us for turning down such a talented person!

Mirw · 19/07/2022 23:12

So many graduates have a sense of entitlement. Won't get out if bed

masterblaster · 19/07/2022 22:29

Because there is a massive shortage of labour.

Swipe left for the next trending thread