Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Go on fess up, who’s eating all the good graduates?

634 replies

Whatsyournameandwheredyoucomefrom · 18/07/2022 17:17

I am currently interviewing grads for an entry level role in the marketing industry and SWEETMARYANDJOSEPH it’s tough going.

I’ve been taking in cohorts of grads for 10 years and in past years they were always keen to learn, chatty, determined to show the best of themselves and keen to know more about the industry. I’ve found graduate hiring to be a really
lovely thing; starting people off on their careers is something I love to do.

This year is bloody horrendous. I’ve done 23 interviews so far (5 roles available) and bar 2, without exception there’s zero enthusiasm or ‘self selling’, it’s more like I’m asking them to do a household chore and they’re getting pocket money in return - it’s ‘well if I really must do this job, what’s in it for me’. For example today a 21 year old cut me off mid sentence as I was talking about possible career progression through the industry and said ‘yeah I’m probably not thinking about that right now, I’m just figuring out what industry I want to get into right now you know? Like what is it about XXXX (that industry I’ve been in my entire career) that you think is worth pursuing because I could do basically anything and be fine you know?’ - very nearly snapped ‘this is an interview not a careers fair’ but held my tongue. Another told me £22k was basically slavery (her exact words) and she couldn’t work for less than £30k - not even graduated yet ffs. Also, oop norf so no London premium either.

I’m not expecting gratitude for the interview, I don’t even expect them to know anything about the industry and I’ll pay them £22k for the privilege of being fairly useless for a year while they learn. They can be earning £30k in 2 years with the training they get at the early stages through this role and I’ve had some go one to £50k+ in that time and yet almost without exception, none of the grads this year have turned up to the interview with any indication that they actually want the job.

What is this?? Is someone sweeping up all the driven, good candidates and paying them megabucks? Or are universities setting mad expectations on salary and not teaching interview skills?

I’m 35 so it’s not like I’m totally out of touch and feel a bit daft saying it but is this a generational thing? Covid?? WHAT IS HAPPENING?

OP posts:
Florenz · 18/07/2022 19:38

What is the point of 45 days or unlimited annual leave when you only earn 22k a year and can't afford to go anywhere or do anything?

FinallyMrsE · 18/07/2022 19:37

My DS is in the cohort you talk about and he’s been offered a role (Yorkshire) for starting 27k with company car, his friend is working in London for 42k plus very good relocation package. They both came out of university with Firsts and some great experience working part time and their employers have recognised they are good candidates and committed to them early (around 3 months ago)

I think your timing for September starts is going to attract the less motivated who are behind the leaders and the salary is not great either.

Hutchy16 · 18/07/2022 19:37

LilyMarshall · 18/07/2022 17:26

£19k and a half is minimum wage. You are offering a graduate £2.5k above minimum wage.

it is a very low salary.

This isn’t right…you can’t come up with a calculation from thin air as you don’t know how many hours are expected.

my full time job is 35 hours…so based on minimum wage (not what I am on) it would be £16700, and then the OP is offering approx 1/3 more than minimum wage, for someone with zero experience at all.

you can’t just pluck figures from thin air…

Deafdonkey · 18/07/2022 19:37

KweenieBeanz · 18/07/2022 19:23

They won't get it. My employer has tried carrying on advertising jobs with similar and all that's happened is few/no applicants, certainly none of the standard they want.

But I'd do it. But the adverts are all so specific, they want a couple of years of industry experience. I'd work for minimum wage if a company was going to invest in me.

applecharlotte12 · 18/07/2022 19:36

I work in a RG careers service with humanities students who are often interested in marketing jobs.

I think this cohort has had a tough time - covid, remote learning, strikes, etc. This has impacted their ability to network, which means their understanding of the graduate world of work has been delayed/is nonexistent beyond part-time jobs. As a result, they aren't as confident speaking to employers and presenting themselves well. There has also been little opportunity to get work experience/internships during covid or develop the essential communication skills that

Mental health has taken a battering, and there was a drop in attendance this last semester in lectures/seminars. Likewise, attending careers workshops and appointments has been low priority because many students needed to just push through to the end of their degrees.

I spend a lot of time boosting confidence at the moment as many grads are overwhelmed and lost with the whole job-hunting process. The finalists who have engaged with the careers service and who I speak with in guidance sessions are great and motivated, but that is a small proportion of the overall student body. We try to offer lots of support and resources, but it’s hard to reach students due to the above. I hope you find some good candidates for your role, but I think employers have to accept that this cohort isn't going to be as 'polished' as previous ones.

Whatsyournameandwheredyoucomefrom · 18/07/2022 19:36

SoManyQuestionsHere · 18/07/2022 19:31

Professional Services exec here - we pay a lot more than you, OP, but I tend to agree on substance (albeit without the compensation complaints).

Recent grad we've just hired to me, last week (relevant: I'm the boss of his boss' boss): "I'm escalating this because I asked my supervisor and then my manager to be taken off duties that require me to be interacting with clients because it triggers my anxiety. They have both denied my request. This makes me feel disrespected! What are you going to do to address the situation?"

It's the entitlement and lack of sense of reality that kills me! This is a bloody consulting firm, FFS! Dealing with clients is, basically, what we do.

FWIW, I have put my boy the graduate on back-office duties - yes, in preparation for that chat with HR during which I will need to demonstrate I've been as accommodating as humanly possible. To absolutely nobody's surprise, he's now complaining that he doesn't find invoicing fulfilling and wishes to work on "actual consulting" work [you know, the one that involves clients ...].

He's extreme but far from the only one!

And, no, I don't blame the grads. I blame their parents, teachers, recruiters, and ourselves for not stating clearly what we expected!

I’ve got one similar at the moment - I’m his great great line manager and he asked me for a pay rise he’d been denied twice by his line manager grandma because ‘he felt he wasn’t listened to while decisions were being made’ - he was listened to, he was just told no!

OP posts:
spuddy56 · 18/07/2022 19:35

I don't think extra holiday would be that attractive to a grad who couldn't afford to go anywhere and is most likely living in a flatshare (plus probably no children so don't need it for childcare). Id have ended up using it to do a part time job just to be able to afford to live! At that age I'd have much preferred a better salary and less holiday.

TheMullerLightOwl · 18/07/2022 19:34

These benefits sound fantastic to me, who graduated in 2018 and got a job on 17k with 27 days annual leave. However, they probably won't sound amazing to someone who is used to having a 10 week summer holiday plus 4 weeks at Christmas and Easter and who has been told by their university that a graduate starting salary is 25-30k minimum.

If they're anything like I was then, by September, they'll have worked out that what you're offering is actually incredible.

ParsleySageRosemary · 18/07/2022 19:32

House prices, cost of living and the years of employers taking the piss.

Plus youngsters now, especially the middle class you’ll be interviewing, have been raised in the era of knowing your own worth. No more being whacked around the head and being told to get back in their place by any boomers, they’re well aware that only youth matters and that they are the centres of the universe. Interesting combination.

Eeksteek · 18/07/2022 19:32

I’m also coming across the idea more and more that we work for money, and shouldn’t have to pretend otherwise. Nobody actually goes to work for fun, and it shouldn’t be wrong to say so. Obviously that doesn’t mean you should act (or dress) like you left your surfboard outside, but corporations have much more of a reputation of expecting ‘enthusiastic and motivated employees to go above and beyond’ while being shafting employees as much as they can get away with and paying decidedly below average wages.

I’m not saying your company is, but that many companies do. It’s becoming the expected employee/employer relationship model, and if they’ve had minimal wage gigs through uni, that’s what they’ll have experienced so far, isn’t it?

SoManyQuestionsHere · 18/07/2022 19:31

Professional Services exec here - we pay a lot more than you, OP, but I tend to agree on substance (albeit without the compensation complaints).

Recent grad we've just hired to me, last week (relevant: I'm the boss of his boss' boss): "I'm escalating this because I asked my supervisor and then my manager to be taken off duties that require me to be interacting with clients because it triggers my anxiety. They have both denied my request. This makes me feel disrespected! What are you going to do to address the situation?"

It's the entitlement and lack of sense of reality that kills me! This is a bloody consulting firm, FFS! Dealing with clients is, basically, what we do.

FWIW, I have put my boy the graduate on back-office duties - yes, in preparation for that chat with HR during which I will need to demonstrate I've been as accommodating as humanly possible. To absolutely nobody's surprise, he's now complaining that he doesn't find invoicing fulfilling and wishes to work on "actual consulting" work [you know, the one that involves clients ...].

He's extreme but far from the only one!

And, no, I don't blame the grads. I blame their parents, teachers, recruiters, and ourselves for not stating clearly what we expected!

lookforthesun · 18/07/2022 19:30

@InChocolateWeTrust yep +1

junebirthdaygirl · 18/07/2022 19:28

My friend was recently interviewing graduates and her tip is this;
Look for the ones who don't go to the high flying school and who have worked part time to put themselves through college as you find those who are self starters and not bring propped up by parents They have a good work ethic and their ambition is their own and they have had to fight to get this far..
By the way my ds grad salary in lreland was 30,000 euro and his next job straight after was 55000.

CredibilityProblem · 18/07/2022 19:28

MidnightMeltdown · 18/07/2022 19:08

@Liebig

I was responding to a post which stated that the average salary is 31k and simply stating that it was incorrect. Whether the 'average' is meaningful or not is completely irrelevant to the post.

Science and chemical engineering are a minority of graduates. I didn't do these and started on 28k 15 years ago.

Granted some will be earning below the the median, but OP is offering almost a third less. That's an insult and a piss take.

Mean and median are both averages. Median is the appropriate measure of average to use for wage comparisons and mean is very rarely used for that purpose.

So while it would be preferable to specify "the median full-time wage is c.£31k" just to prevent people misunderstanding, it's certainly correct to say "the average full-time wage is c.£31K".

OooErr · 18/07/2022 19:27

Deafdonkey · 18/07/2022 19:21

Sadly not, I'm in the south and have just looked for graduate training jobs and the salary is around 22k. For 25k they not only want graduates but graduates with additional qualifications

At the risk of sounding snobbish - why is everyone going on about ‘graduate training jobs’? there’s no such thing.
Some jobs require specific skills. Specific degree, specific professional qualifications.
Some jobs require ‘graduates’, i.e People with demonstrable academic abilities.
the vast majority of jobs really don’t, and used to be done by school leavers/apprentices who learnt on the jobs The only reason why they specify ‘graduate’ is because of the sheer number of graduates, plenty with degrees of little academic rigour.

Young people are starting to realise that university isn’t always worth it

Wonderfulstuff · 18/07/2022 19:26

20 years ago as a graduate with decent work experience my starting salary in a marketing and comms role was £18k + 25 days holiday + bank holidays. I see so many roles offering only minimum wage plus just 20 days holiday and expecting the creme de la creme. Meanwhile I worked recently with a guy who was 2 years post grad and on £50k. I know what would have been more appealing to me as a fresh faced grad!

riesenrad · 18/07/2022 19:26

Herewegoagain84 · 18/07/2022 19:01

@DillAte as I pointed out in my follow up comment, I’m in the legal industry and the starting salaries are eye wateringly high. They need to impress. Year on year they’re getting worse - just my observation.

That's interesting because I've had the opposite experience - I think the quality of trainees and paralegals is improving and know I'd never have got a training contract these days. They are insanely bright and still not getting training contracts particularly easily. Quite a few work in paralegal roles for some years before getting a training contract. If I give them something to do, they do it, and they do it well. And it's proper work, not glorified photocopying.

AnotherAnxiousMess · 18/07/2022 19:25

@Yessha Why is it bad to be upfront about mental health problems? I didn't realise it was still a taboo topic... shouldn't employers be accommodating to any employees mental health problems, same as physical. And maybe interviewees want to know that you do have things in place if they do need that support?

MagratsDanglyCharms21 · 18/07/2022 19:23

Not exactly minimum wage though is it? Its actually 4k more than minimum wage, for people with NO actual experience in the sector despite their degree. As a starting rate its absolutely fine as long as there is a progression pathway and they know how long it will be before a significant raise (as long as they meet learning targets of course).

DomusAurea · 18/07/2022 19:23

JustFrustrated · 18/07/2022 19:15

There are some people a bit out of touch with reality IMO.

One) yes Aldi pays well, it also involves shift work/weekend work/BH work, which MANY MANY people want to avoid

Two) that annual leave entitlement is amazing, removing the "unlimited" aspect, 45 days is phenomenal. Don't care who disagrees with that, it's FAR BEYOND the realm of standard. 25 days is considered decent to most people outside of Mumsnet.

Three) if you can train a new staff member with no previous experience in 3 months, the job doesn't require much skill at all.

Four) free training is literally invaluable.

22k isn't amazing, but the package itself IS.

Just look on any jobsite, 22k seems to be bang in the middle for a lot of jobs, in the north.

Average, people REALLY need to understand what this means..it DOESNT mean "most common" FFS. It means some people will earn far far far above, and others below.

Also, this is for 35hours a week. That is a low low amount of work.

She's actually offering £13 an hour. £4 ABOVE NMW.

Welcome to late stage capitalism, where the lumpenproletariat incense a £22,000 per year wage as a favour given to them.

KweenieBeanz · 18/07/2022 19:23

Deafdonkey · 18/07/2022 19:21

Sadly not, I'm in the south and have just looked for graduate training jobs and the salary is around 22k. For 25k they not only want graduates but graduates with additional qualifications

They won't get it. My employer has tried carrying on advertising jobs with similar and all that's happened is few/no applicants, certainly none of the standard they want.

OooErr · 18/07/2022 19:22

Also OP you’re not competing in a regional market anymore. There are loads of hybrid roles, even for once a week in the office. Manchester is only 2 hours away from London by train. Not an issue for young people with no family commitments.

This obviously wasn’t an issue pre-pandemic but companies are having to rethink.

riesenrad · 18/07/2022 19:22

eggsandwich · 18/07/2022 18:51

My dd has just finished her first year Marketing degree and I would be seriously annoyed with her if she went to an interview with that attitude.

I would be annoyed if my son went to an interview with that attitude (on display). But I'd also tell him to avoid any employer who acted like they were doing him (or anyone) a favour by taking them on. Or investing in them. That's what good employers do.

KweenieBeanz · 18/07/2022 19:21

People need to stop thinking they can carry on paying these lousy salaries. £22k was a reasonable graduate starting salary when I finished my degree 16 years ago!!!! Cost of living has gone up 10% this year. £22k this year buys a graduate what £20k bought them last year, it's barely above minimum wage. Stop trying to suppress wage growth no wonder young people can barely afford to live

Deafdonkey · 18/07/2022 19:21

Sadly not, I'm in the south and have just looked for graduate training jobs and the salary is around 22k. For 25k they not only want graduates but graduates with additional qualifications