Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Go on fess up, who’s eating all the good graduates?

634 replies

Whatsyournameandwheredyoucomefrom · 18/07/2022 17:17

I am currently interviewing grads for an entry level role in the marketing industry and SWEETMARYANDJOSEPH it’s tough going.

I’ve been taking in cohorts of grads for 10 years and in past years they were always keen to learn, chatty, determined to show the best of themselves and keen to know more about the industry. I’ve found graduate hiring to be a really
lovely thing; starting people off on their careers is something I love to do.

This year is bloody horrendous. I’ve done 23 interviews so far (5 roles available) and bar 2, without exception there’s zero enthusiasm or ‘self selling’, it’s more like I’m asking them to do a household chore and they’re getting pocket money in return - it’s ‘well if I really must do this job, what’s in it for me’. For example today a 21 year old cut me off mid sentence as I was talking about possible career progression through the industry and said ‘yeah I’m probably not thinking about that right now, I’m just figuring out what industry I want to get into right now you know? Like what is it about XXXX (that industry I’ve been in my entire career) that you think is worth pursuing because I could do basically anything and be fine you know?’ - very nearly snapped ‘this is an interview not a careers fair’ but held my tongue. Another told me £22k was basically slavery (her exact words) and she couldn’t work for less than £30k - not even graduated yet ffs. Also, oop norf so no London premium either.

I’m not expecting gratitude for the interview, I don’t even expect them to know anything about the industry and I’ll pay them £22k for the privilege of being fairly useless for a year while they learn. They can be earning £30k in 2 years with the training they get at the early stages through this role and I’ve had some go one to £50k+ in that time and yet almost without exception, none of the grads this year have turned up to the interview with any indication that they actually want the job.

What is this?? Is someone sweeping up all the driven, good candidates and paying them megabucks? Or are universities setting mad expectations on salary and not teaching interview skills?

I’m 35 so it’s not like I’m totally out of touch and feel a bit daft saying it but is this a generational thing? Covid?? WHAT IS HAPPENING?

OP posts:
YellsiBabs · 18/07/2022 21:50

Good to see the tables have turned, I was doing “marketing internships” (free labour) as a graduate paying over £300 per month for a London travel card to work for free for a marketing agency. Glad these young ones have the gumption to speak up & be treated fairly for their contributions.

DottyLittleRainbow · 18/07/2022 21:50

millytint44 · 18/07/2022 20:56

Milennials are the most entitled generation ever. End of.

Millennials as a generation are typically those born 1981-1996, so not this time. Probably half the posters on this thread are millennials 😂

OooErr · 18/07/2022 21:50

Augend23 · 18/07/2022 21:37

I really agree with this - the benefits sound amazing but particularly things like healthcare I would hang on til the salaries are a bit higher. Rail fares is again great, but it is taxable so you might like to whack that on the base salary too.

The overall package does sound fab, and it sounds like the company is an amazing place to work so ironically I think it might be the marketing that's letting you down.

I'm fairly well paid but would be happy to take a reasonable pay cut for that work life balance - but that's easy for me to say because I own a house and am not trying to scrimp for a deposit while paying rent.

I think most people are sifting through millions of job options and the best grads will have plenty of choice. So unless your adverts have a table in that says:

Base salary £22k
5 Weeks holiday over and above statutory: worth £2.2k
Your train fare paid: worth up to £3k
Home working grant: £1k
Private healthcare: £1k
Gym: £400
Free lunch: £600
Pension @ 10%: £2.2k

Total package: £32.6k

Then it's really easy not to appreciate the value of all those benefits. And even then you're still going to be missing out on the graduates who filter the job websites (I seem to remember it went in bands of 2.5k when I was looking, worth checking what the ones you advertise on use - you don't want to be at the top of a filter band).

It sounds like you want quite a specific sort of grad - someone who recognises the importance of work life balance but is happy to work hard and efficiently in the time they are there for, and to maximise the benefits of the free training you give. That's different from the "earn as much money as I can as fast as possible" grads, it's different from the "get a professional qualification and keep on steadily up the ladder" grads, and it's different from the "give back to society at any cost to myself" grads. A job like the one you advertise is going to get a mixed bag of the "can't really be fucked" grads (which it sounds like there's an excess of) and some of the ones you want. I think it's worth having a think about how you could change your advertising to get the middle section of grads because actually with that good salary progression etc I think they might well be a fit but not necessarily assuming the role is for them? Obviously that's just my inference from this thread and you'll know much more than me about your own company!

That’s a great point!I also filter on salary. not that it works with the sheer amount of coy ‘competitive salary’ ads…

OooErr · 18/07/2022 21:49

ShaneTwane · 18/07/2022 21:30

The son who got a 1st in economics would not even consider a job for less than 30 k …why should he ? !!

What entitles him to it? Going to uni? There's many people on less than that with years more experience. Sounds like a shit attitude to have.

You don’t seem to understand how this works. It’s not the years of experience. It’s the skill set.
If he’s done the right kind of economics he can get a job close to 30K, easy. With professional exams passed increasing the pay until he ends up at 50K, 3 years in.

PeloAddict · 18/07/2022 21:47

Random two pages I picked off indeed of jobs near me
Maybe I'm just in a job wasteland!
P.S if anyone has careers suggestions I'm all ears, feel free to PM me/help

Go on fess up, who’s eating all the good graduates?
Go on fess up, who’s eating all the good graduates?
NoGonnaLie · 18/07/2022 21:46

luxxlisbon · 18/07/2022 21:34

@NoGonnaLie are 10 a penny these days - and with worthless degrees, many of them.

And yet here the OP is struggling to recruit one for the salary she is prepared to pay.

You’re right. OP seems to be interviewing all the crap ones because they are 10 a penny.

OP you need to sort your search out. There are plenty of grads that would be happy to have this role but you’re aiming too low.

OP change your search criteria. Where did you find your current applicants?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 18/07/2022 21:43

Have you considered not wasting the time and money on new graduates and giving older people, especially women, the training and opportunity to go on to earning 50k in a few years instead?

Augend23 · 18/07/2022 21:37

Whatsyournameandwheredyoucomefrom · 18/07/2022 21:02

That might be a good point - the benefits are just blanket across everyone so maybe if we remove those for grads but you the salary that might be better? It would probably soften the blow for the business too.

I really agree with this - the benefits sound amazing but particularly things like healthcare I would hang on til the salaries are a bit higher. Rail fares is again great, but it is taxable so you might like to whack that on the base salary too.

The overall package does sound fab, and it sounds like the company is an amazing place to work so ironically I think it might be the marketing that's letting you down.

I'm fairly well paid but would be happy to take a reasonable pay cut for that work life balance - but that's easy for me to say because I own a house and am not trying to scrimp for a deposit while paying rent.

I think most people are sifting through millions of job options and the best grads will have plenty of choice. So unless your adverts have a table in that says:

Base salary £22k
5 Weeks holiday over and above statutory: worth £2.2k
Your train fare paid: worth up to £3k
Home working grant: £1k
Private healthcare: £1k
Gym: £400
Free lunch: £600
Pension @ 10%: £2.2k

Total package: £32.6k

Then it's really easy not to appreciate the value of all those benefits. And even then you're still going to be missing out on the graduates who filter the job websites (I seem to remember it went in bands of 2.5k when I was looking, worth checking what the ones you advertise on use - you don't want to be at the top of a filter band).

It sounds like you want quite a specific sort of grad - someone who recognises the importance of work life balance but is happy to work hard and efficiently in the time they are there for, and to maximise the benefits of the free training you give. That's different from the "earn as much money as I can as fast as possible" grads, it's different from the "get a professional qualification and keep on steadily up the ladder" grads, and it's different from the "give back to society at any cost to myself" grads. A job like the one you advertise is going to get a mixed bag of the "can't really be fucked" grads (which it sounds like there's an excess of) and some of the ones you want. I think it's worth having a think about how you could change your advertising to get the middle section of grads because actually with that good salary progression etc I think they might well be a fit but not necessarily assuming the role is for them? Obviously that's just my inference from this thread and you'll know much more than me about your own company!

PeloAddict · 18/07/2022 21:34

DenholmElliot1 · 18/07/2022 18:21

£22k is a very small amount of money to actually live on. I'd hazard a guess that those people who think its doable are being topped up with benefits/universal credits/housing support.

I'm actually a bit shocked
I earn money wage so a bit under 20k plus commission (which isn't guaranteed) usually come out with about £1400pm which I live on (no benefits)
I'm 38 with a degree and can't find anything vaguely local paying much better that doesn't want experience/a million other qualifications/1hr commute. Small city in the NW

luxxlisbon · 18/07/2022 21:34

@NoGonnaLie are 10 a penny these days - and with worthless degrees, many of them.

And yet here the OP is struggling to recruit one for the salary she is prepared to pay.

PinaColadaSunset · 18/07/2022 21:33

YANBU.

TuftyMarmoset · 18/07/2022 21:31

Why should OP pay them more?

Because that’s how capitalism works? The labour market is very tight and that’s what you need to do to find employees.

ShaneTwane · 18/07/2022 21:30

The son who got a 1st in economics would not even consider a job for less than 30 k …why should he ? !!

What entitles him to it? Going to uni? There's many people on less than that with years more experience. Sounds like a shit attitude to have.

Iamcloey · 18/07/2022 21:30

Can I apply? 😂
I've got a good social media and marketing background but no degree and I'm in Scotland if you'd like a remote worker.

I get that £22k is fairly low but if there's the chance of earning £30k within a few year, I would think it would be a stepping stone.

QueenCamilla · 18/07/2022 21:29

I started as a graduate in Marketing. 22k really is low as it's the most stressful, ghastly career one can start in. I was underpaid, overworked and had your typical marketing burn-out by 25. Just like my predecessor in the role.

Marketing and media agencies are obsessed with graduate slave-labour. The young uns' haven't had kids yet and no one's waiting for them at home, so they're fair game for the "night shifts".

Ugh. Touched a nerve.

Lipsandlashes · 18/07/2022 21:27

Thatswhyimacat · 18/07/2022 18:01

Yeesh, when I graduated with my PhD 7 years ago my first job paid me 18k in London. Seems I undersold myself a bit...

I know! I can’t believe what I’m reading. I graduated in 2001 and my starting salary was £9,500. I’ve just checked the minimum wage back then, in case I’d been sold in to slavery but no, minimum wage was £3.60.

Hutchy16 · 18/07/2022 21:26

Whatsyournameandwheredyoucomefrom · 18/07/2022 20:46

Hilarious Grin

I love that you have an image in your head of the grads all shuffling their feet through the streets of Manchester, raiding the bins for scraps while we lash them into the workhouse for a pittance while Pankhurst watches on with a solitary tear rolling down her statue face HmmGrin

They work an average 35 hour week, 3-4 days from home, we pay for their annual train passes or parking so no travel costs to and from the office (fuel has just been subsidised as well), whichever they need. There’s free gym membership to a gym round the corner and they get breakfast and lunch for free when they’re in the office. They get 45 days annual leave as basic with an additional number of unlimited days if they need it. Private healthcare and access to private mental health services including CBT and psychotherapy for free. There’s also an excellent pension, bike to work, flat share schemes, a grant for at home working equipment, a monthly ‘top up’ for costs incurred from working from
home (towards energy bills, paid at the standard rate for electricity so it’s just gone up a lot).

For this we ask for zero experience, not even a degree now. We offer them a year of training in multiple disciplines so they can work out which branch of marketing suits them before they settle. They get a clear progression plan with milestones they know about from their first day, and unless they completely screw up they’re essentially on £30k 18 months in. From there, there’s a progression to £50k within 4-5 years.

This has been called exploitation, slavery and starvation wages on this thread. Mumsnet is WILD.

That said I do take the point that £22k isn’t what it used to be and needs an update - I’ll be feeding that back for sure. It might be we drop the train travel benefit (costs an absolute fortune, it’s worth about £3k a year) and up the salary or something.

Would you take a 35 year old applicant who didn’t complete their finance degree from Durham uni solely because they had a severely premature baby?

14 years of experience in the banking sector for a very large and reputable bank.

I’ll take the pay cut for the opportunity to actually go further in my life in a field that has always interested me.

I think your job sounds perfect for me. Especially with no transport costs, and I already have a home office

KingsArmy · 18/07/2022 21:25

I would also bite your hand off for this! Alas I'm near London.

NoGonnaLie · 18/07/2022 21:25

I think most people on here need to give their heads a good wobble.

More than £22k for a job they've never done, with no experience in? Whatever happened to working your way up and getting 2 good years of experience in? After that, you can earn so much more but why should you start at such a high salary, with no proof of your ability?

Why should OP pay them more? What have they done to prove they are worthy? Graduates are 10 a penny these days - and with worthless degrees, many of them.

Mums with heaps of marketing experience, I'm talking decades' worth I often see applying for roles offering £15 per hour in marketing and 'freelance' at that - that basically means no pension, no holiday pay, no NI, no sick pay. It's the same as minimum wage.

OP find yourself two hungry eager stay at home Mums who are gagging to get back into the industry.

Forget about graduates who all seem to come from the same 'wannabe-an-influencer' crowd.

I'd roll my eyes too with what you've described in your opening post.

Ohmydayssilleople · 18/07/2022 21:25

My three children worked bloody hard to get into decent Uni and two gain 2:1 and one a 1st . The only one who has accepted a low pay post grad course was the one really passionate about ecology..he still started on 20k five years ago …he is now on 30k .
The son who got a 1st in economics would not even consider a job for less than 30 k …why should he ? !!

eatingapie · 18/07/2022 21:21

Can I have this job please? I am sold on the unlimited annual leave whatever they say!

ShaneTwane · 18/07/2022 21:21

Even up north a £500 room gets you a shit hole. 10 years ago I was paying £450 up north for a house share and almost £400 for a shit student flat 15 years ago.

I've literally just moved into a 2bed flat that's pretty big and nicely done and that's £500 a month so not at all true it gets you a shit hole. And I'm in Liverpool so literally right next to Manchester.

FirstHusband · 18/07/2022 21:20

DC with science masters (and a successful year in industry doing dream role) has been told that £25k is a reasonable starting salary - niece, freshly out of sixth form is just about to start an apprenticeship on ... £25k.

bungaloid · 18/07/2022 21:20

I do think sometimes you forget about years of inflation and how things have moved on. 20 years ago as a graduate I was earning £22k. Therefore, from a knee-jerk response you might initially think £30k is a great salary. We recently benchmarked our graduate jobs and they are about £37k. That works out as 2.5% wage growth each year for 20 years from when I started, which seems about right.

XingMing · 18/07/2022 21:19

But it really isn't a salary or a job that needs degree level skills. I am 66, and loads of clever girls from my class (1974) took entry level jobs in professional legal and accountancy offices and qualified on the job while earning, and have great jobs and started businesses, earn well -- but not investment banking jobs. A handful of us went to university, and by and large, we were the top 5% of the population. In the days before CSE and O level were conflated, O levels were much more demanding, and A levels were equivalent to the first year of university today, perhaps less so in science subjects.