Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Go on fess up, who’s eating all the good graduates?

634 replies

Whatsyournameandwheredyoucomefrom · 18/07/2022 17:17

I am currently interviewing grads for an entry level role in the marketing industry and SWEETMARYANDJOSEPH it’s tough going.

I’ve been taking in cohorts of grads for 10 years and in past years they were always keen to learn, chatty, determined to show the best of themselves and keen to know more about the industry. I’ve found graduate hiring to be a really
lovely thing; starting people off on their careers is something I love to do.

This year is bloody horrendous. I’ve done 23 interviews so far (5 roles available) and bar 2, without exception there’s zero enthusiasm or ‘self selling’, it’s more like I’m asking them to do a household chore and they’re getting pocket money in return - it’s ‘well if I really must do this job, what’s in it for me’. For example today a 21 year old cut me off mid sentence as I was talking about possible career progression through the industry and said ‘yeah I’m probably not thinking about that right now, I’m just figuring out what industry I want to get into right now you know? Like what is it about XXXX (that industry I’ve been in my entire career) that you think is worth pursuing because I could do basically anything and be fine you know?’ - very nearly snapped ‘this is an interview not a careers fair’ but held my tongue. Another told me £22k was basically slavery (her exact words) and she couldn’t work for less than £30k - not even graduated yet ffs. Also, oop norf so no London premium either.

I’m not expecting gratitude for the interview, I don’t even expect them to know anything about the industry and I’ll pay them £22k for the privilege of being fairly useless for a year while they learn. They can be earning £30k in 2 years with the training they get at the early stages through this role and I’ve had some go one to £50k+ in that time and yet almost without exception, none of the grads this year have turned up to the interview with any indication that they actually want the job.

What is this?? Is someone sweeping up all the driven, good candidates and paying them megabucks? Or are universities setting mad expectations on salary and not teaching interview skills?

I’m 35 so it’s not like I’m totally out of touch and feel a bit daft saying it but is this a generational thing? Covid?? WHAT IS HAPPENING?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tellhimno · 23/07/2022 18:22

Crunchygrass · 23/07/2022 14:11

That seems like a good idea, school leavers feel they have something to prove so they are keen. Also, really do consider the return-to-workers as well, a lot of people on this forum are very well qualified but out of the workforce for a while due to caring duties etc. they might need a bit of training up but they have life experience and are keen to learn.

I feel sorry for graduates, a lot of them probably just need a bit of a break, they’ve been working towards this career since they were 5 years old often, exam pressure and pressure to get the best uni seems to have heightened. They have been told both that they can do anything, and also the economy’s screwed (since about 2008 anyways) and the best jobs are insanely competitive and still probably don’t pay enough to afford the things their parents and grandparents could afford in their 20s and early 30s- they must already feel a bit jaded.

I think if the graduates are feeling a bit jaded maybe they need to take a year out before they start their career and do something different. It's time they stopped blaming everyone else for being on the well-worn career path, they are there by choice and can depart from it at any moment. I know loads of people who traveled for a year before they started working on their careers and they didn't make a big who-ha about it - they'd just had enough for a while and came back ready to start working.

Crunchygrass · 23/07/2022 14:11

HappyGa · 23/07/2022 13:56

We've had similar issues with recruiting graduates, and we pay decently. It's all very - what are you going to do for me ( fair enough I suppose) and I won't be here for long anyways because my mum/dad says I'm GREAT so I'll be CEO in a minute, or working FT is a waste of time so I'll be looking for an out as soon as...

They're FULL of opinions on the way the world should be without actually wanted to do anything to change the world and I've had it up to my back teeth with 21/22 year olds offering life advice when they appear to have experienced fuck all of the world! Christ though, they've certainly seen a lot on TikTok and SM and on Insta so are happy to recommend places they've never been to or cities they've never visited or experiences they've never actually tried.

Have now persuaded HR to start looking at an apprenticeship scheme that tries to get school leavers with a year or 2 work behind them into our industry instead ( we typically ONLY hire those with degrees) because at least those kids seem to have a more realistic view of the world and the world of work. i.e. they need to actually work to support themselves...

That seems like a good idea, school leavers feel they have something to prove so they are keen. Also, really do consider the return-to-workers as well, a lot of people on this forum are very well qualified but out of the workforce for a while due to caring duties etc. they might need a bit of training up but they have life experience and are keen to learn.

I feel sorry for graduates, a lot of them probably just need a bit of a break, they’ve been working towards this career since they were 5 years old often, exam pressure and pressure to get the best uni seems to have heightened. They have been told both that they can do anything, and also the economy’s screwed (since about 2008 anyways) and the best jobs are insanely competitive and still probably don’t pay enough to afford the things their parents and grandparents could afford in their 20s and early 30s- they must already feel a bit jaded.

HappyGa · 23/07/2022 13:56

We've had similar issues with recruiting graduates, and we pay decently. It's all very - what are you going to do for me ( fair enough I suppose) and I won't be here for long anyways because my mum/dad says I'm GREAT so I'll be CEO in a minute, or working FT is a waste of time so I'll be looking for an out as soon as...

They're FULL of opinions on the way the world should be without actually wanted to do anything to change the world and I've had it up to my back teeth with 21/22 year olds offering life advice when they appear to have experienced fuck all of the world! Christ though, they've certainly seen a lot on TikTok and SM and on Insta so are happy to recommend places they've never been to or cities they've never visited or experiences they've never actually tried.

Have now persuaded HR to start looking at an apprenticeship scheme that tries to get school leavers with a year or 2 work behind them into our industry instead ( we typically ONLY hire those with degrees) because at least those kids seem to have a more realistic view of the world and the world of work. i.e. they need to actually work to support themselves...

OooErr · 23/07/2022 13:45

DadBodAlready · 23/07/2022 13:14

No shes not.
The average graduate salary in UK in 2022 is about £24k. In London it stretches to £28k, so £22k isn't too bad.
I think today's graduates are quite happy living off mum and dad and too lazy to get a job.

Sigh… once again… there’s no point in discussing an ‘average graduate salary’.


  • Some professions pay more.

  • Some have extra exams etc to pass with a guaranteed pay bump after each so the starting is irrelevant.

  • Some ‘graduate jobs’ aren’t really graduate level. They just put it as a filter to reduce the number of applicants but their degree doesn’t add any value.


Even say in the North West 22K is extremely low for the ‘best’ computer science graduates. Of course there are low paid jobs but they’re going to get the mediocre.

I don’t know about marketing so I can’t comment on this. It seemed to me however like the sort of glamour field which could get away with low salaries, as people were clamouring to break in. Same with journalism,publishing etc….

chilliesandspices · 23/07/2022 13:34

No shes not.
The average graduate salary in UK in 2022 is about £24k. In London it stretches to £28k, so £22k isn't too bad.
I think today's graduates are quite happy living off mum and dad and too lazy to get a job.

I think they're living with mum and dad because people like you think 22k "isn't too bad". They have to furnish and rent a property, pay utilities, pay council tax, feed themselves, get to work, buy appropriate clothes for work, have a social life... then try saving for a deposit on a property at the same time.

DadBodAlready · 23/07/2022 13:14

Labourious · 18/07/2022 17:26

YABU. You're paying well below graduate salary expectations during a labour shortage and expecting to get, not only graduates, but graduates who are enthusiastic and driven? Don't be ridiculous. They're absolutely right when they ask "what's in it for me?" - businesses have a shortage of staff and graduates don't have a shortage of job opportunities, of course they're going to be interviewing you and not the other way around.

No one is setting "mad expectations" at all - the one with mad expectations is you. You get what you pay for. Graduates who are driven, enthusiastic, and have good interview skills are walking into jobs that pay a hell of a lot more than what you're offering.

No shes not.
The average graduate salary in UK in 2022 is about £24k. In London it stretches to £28k, so £22k isn't too bad.
I think today's graduates are quite happy living off mum and dad and too lazy to get a job.

thing47 · 22/07/2022 18:27

I don't know about marketing, but I don't think a starting salary of £22K is that bad. DD2 is 8 months into her first job and started on that – it's quite low, but it has gone up fairly rapidly as she proved she could bring value to the role. FWIW she has a first-class MSc and is working in a field related to her degrees.

Also, just to address a point raised by a couple of PPs, it is possible that a student has studied all over the summer. DD2's Masters was a full 12 months so May through September was for writing up and finalising her dissertation, which also required further trips to the lab.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 22/07/2022 13:01

SpaceGoatFarm · 22/07/2022 11:48

Well that's how it works. Most generations are actually the same, however people complain about the younger generations as it suggests that they themselves were much better at the same things and people are a bit pathetic like that. Young people are being absolutely hammered from all sides these days.

I would agree with you but the difference between our young staff 10 years ago and our young staff now is startling.
I wasn’t even thinking about myself.

SpaceGoatFarm · 22/07/2022 11:48

Well that's how it works. Most generations are actually the same, however people complain about the younger generations as it suggests that they themselves were much better at the same things and people are a bit pathetic like that. Young people are being absolutely hammered from all sides these days.

dayslikethese1 · 22/07/2022 08:06

This is interesting, a few years ago everyone was complaining about millennials being entitled but we were mostly grateful for any job as we graduated in the recession. Sounds like Gen Z can afford to be pickier. I'd have been thrilled at that offer when I graduated.

justasking111 · 21/07/2022 23:09

mathanxiety · 21/07/2022 21:59

@Tellhimno

Demographic trends mean the pendulum has swung from employers dictating terms to a different sort of setup, one that favours the young graduate jobseeker.

The demographic trends are not going to change any time soon.

Tell me that after a winter of discontent across Europe with energy costs, food costs. We're in for a rough ride

Tellhimno · 21/07/2022 22:24

mathanxiety · 21/07/2022 21:59

@Tellhimno

Demographic trends mean the pendulum has swung from employers dictating terms to a different sort of setup, one that favours the young graduate jobseeker.

The demographic trends are not going to change any time soon.

Sure some industries are willing and able to bend over backwards to the American model (with different labour laws) - it might not do them any good in the long run when they look at productivity levels - and the pendulum will most swing back again...the recession will be challenging for everyone.

mathanxiety · 21/07/2022 21:59

@Tellhimno

Demographic trends mean the pendulum has swung from employers dictating terms to a different sort of setup, one that favours the young graduate jobseeker.

The demographic trends are not going to change any time soon.

prettybird · 21/07/2022 18:57

I can't remember who it was but someone once told the Institute of Directors (at a dinner or conference?) that in order of priority, third priority was the shareholders (Shock), second priority was the customers/clients and first and top priority was the staff.

The logic was that if the staff wasn't happy and looked after, then the customers wouldn't be happy. And if the customers weren't happy, then neither would the shareholders be.

My background was B2B marketing (so not FMCG) - and latterly sales (but still B2B - I was effectively selling to my company's competitors, so highly strategic as we also wanted them to sell to us if they were in areas that we weren't). My favourite definition of marketing was Malcolm McDonald's one, which (paraphrased) was the process of identifying and providing products and services profitably for mutual benefit I liked the definition because it made the point that there needed to be mutual benefit Smile: there was no point in screwing your supplier of widgets/services if they then went out of business and likewise if you overcharged your customer they may not continue in business or would find another supplier. Confused

That same principle also applies to the supply of new recruits Wink

LouisRenault · 21/07/2022 18:25

And in a corporate world, who is even more important than the employee?

The client or service user.

If the employee's happiness and fulfilment and flexibility means the client isn't getting the product or service he or she wants, or it's costing too much, the client will go elsewhere, or find they can do without it. And the happy fulfilled employees might find themselves looking at redundancy.

Tellhimno · 21/07/2022 17:24

Sellie555 · 21/07/2022 17:17

@summerin69 yes this! You wrote it much more articulately than me in an earlier response but you’re spot on

incredible to see so many comments from people on this thread about how entitled the grads are, how it’s their parents faults etc etc

young people are changing the shape of the world. They want a different work life to their parents as grandparents. They want to see much more fairness in society, including fairer distribution of profits from these multi million/billion pound companies to their employees, who are ultimately the ones who are making these companies huge profits.

they want purpose driven roles. They want ethical companies. They want to feel happy and fulfilled at work. They want full flexibility, flexible benefits.

they want control over their own lives and the freedom to make their own choices.

too many people on here still in the mindset that an employer owns you. No! An employee is a key asset to a company to make the company money! Without the employees, the company doesn’t hit its own financial objectives.

anyone who denies that an employee should expect all of the above as an absolute standard is a) way behind the times and b) forgets that life is for living and that gone are the days where people are happy to corporate slaves and c) that employees will just leave if they don’t get what they deserve and need

we should all expect much more in our lives !

And so it goes whilst it's an employee's market - there's a recession around the corner - we'll see how things pan out then. Nothing is set in stone and some employees are worth fighting for, some are not - best you know which group you fall into before you start producing your long list of demands and throwing your toys out of the pram.

Sellie555 · 21/07/2022 17:17

summerin69 · 20/07/2022 07:47

I do a lot of research for HR and this is the trend. The tables have turned in favour of candidates rather than the other way round. There are so many jobs on offer, candidates can afford to be choosy - they have lots of jobs and offers to choose from so employers need to be competitive. Gone are the days of employers holding all the cards - in order to be competitive in hiring you need to really adapt and employers need to sell, not the other way round. Yes, there's more entitlement with candidates and they expect a lot, but in many cases they are getting what they ask for.

There are a lot of companies this candidate can choose from so now it's actually more about you selling your company and why this person would want to work there, not the other way round. Top draws for candidates are salary (more so now than ever because of rising cost of living) and career progression. Hybrid working or working from home is standard, not a luxury etc.

Do a google search about hiring and you'll see dozens of reports that will confirm this and what employers need to be doing to attract the top candidates.

I know it's demoralising - but candidates have had to put up being ghosted by employers, being made to jump through hoops etc to get a job for years - now it's the other way round.

@summerin69 yes this! You wrote it much more articulately than me in an earlier response but you’re spot on

incredible to see so many comments from people on this thread about how entitled the grads are, how it’s their parents faults etc etc

young people are changing the shape of the world. They want a different work life to their parents as grandparents. They want to see much more fairness in society, including fairer distribution of profits from these multi million/billion pound companies to their employees, who are ultimately the ones who are making these companies huge profits.

they want purpose driven roles. They want ethical companies. They want to feel happy and fulfilled at work. They want full flexibility, flexible benefits.

they want control over their own lives and the freedom to make their own choices.

too many people on here still in the mindset that an employer owns you. No! An employee is a key asset to a company to make the company money! Without the employees, the company doesn’t hit its own financial objectives.

anyone who denies that an employee should expect all of the above as an absolute standard is a) way behind the times and b) forgets that life is for living and that gone are the days where people are happy to corporate slaves and c) that employees will just leave if they don’t get what they deserve and need

we should all expect much more in our lives !

Sellie555 · 21/07/2022 17:00

Hillary17 · 18/07/2022 18:33

It’s a employee led market and they know it. If you don’t want them - someone else does and probably for more money, better flexibility, stronger perks etc. there’s no panic about getting a job post uni anymore, they know they’ll get something! The tables really have turned on who’s trying to impress who!

@Hillary17 this!!! Can’t believe HR are posting about this and not realising that they are massively in competition against other companies offering similar roles for much better salary, benefits, flexibility, aligned values, purpose driven etc etc.

no corporate company has a hope in hell of hiring the cream of the crop unless they excel in every single aspect of what employees are asking for.

the best companies have researched, studied, consulted with experts, launched huge projects etc just to determine how they are going to tackle the talent shortage. They know they have to work extremely hard to get a look in from the best talent, that means throwing all the old rule books away about traditional job adverts, interviewing techniques, compensation etc. And even after all of that, when they make offers, some interviewees get huge counter offers from their existing employer to stay. It’s really really tough and competitive.

you want the best, my god you have to pay for it now.

employees market now, big time!!!

Tellhimno · 21/07/2022 16:09

Gwenhwyfar · 21/07/2022 15:25

But presumably you have some work experience.

Dd has a job paying the equivalent of £22k over the summer, very little training needed - she has very limited experience but the job has no career prospects and little training needed or required - unlike the OP's. They are like comparing apples and pears.

Gwenhwyfar · 21/07/2022 15:25

SpaceGoatFarm · 21/07/2022 15:15

The decent ones are going for a better salary than that, I could get that salary without years of doing a degree

But presumably you have some work experience.

Tellhimno · 21/07/2022 15:18

Porridgeislife · 20/07/2022 10:17

We take far more internships (about 3x) than grad jobs offered after the internship stage so I don’t think it’s unusual not to have been converted.

We have an apprentice scheme that runs concurrently with our graduate scheme. These young people are generally far more mature and practical than our grads - most have worked for a year or taken a non-traditional route to our industry, despite being usually 18 or 19 rather than 23.

I really like to see grads who have worked part-time in hospitality or retail before joining us. It shows ability to stick out something a bit uncomfortable and learn some practical people-based problem solving skills.

My most frustrating grad (rotational) last year flatly refused to ever turn her camera on, didn’t get in touch with me unless I reached out first & during Covid it was incredibly hard to get to know her. I wouldn’t be able to pick her out in the office now we’re back.

We didn’t end up extending a permanent offer (it was hers to lose) as I had no confidence in her.

According to the Institute of Student Employers Recruitment Survey 2021 - 60% of interns and placements went on to work for that employer and that percentage is apparently pretty constant. So in general more get converted to jobs than don't although I haven't seen the split in percentages between interns and placements.

And they report the satisfaction rating amongst employers who responded on the quality of hire amongst school leavers is quite a bit lower than grads.

SpaceGoatFarm · 21/07/2022 15:15

The decent ones are going for a better salary than that, I could get that salary without years of doing a degree

LouisRenault · 21/07/2022 15:11

I think spending so much time in their rooms gaming/on social media doesn't help. It might be how they interact with their friends these days, but they're not learning to interact with the real world, and they're not learning to interact with people outside their own chosen circle.

If you're out and about, sometimes you'll get lost when you visit somewhere new. Sometimes your train or bus will be cancelled, or terminate halfway there. Sometimes the shop or café will have run out of what you really fancied. Sometimes someone will jostle you out of the way when it's your turn to be served. Sometimes someone might speak to you a bit brusquely or even rudely if you're in their way or otherwise annoying them.

You interact with the shop assistant, the customer who asks if you can reach something for them that's on a high shelf, the bus driver, the elderly lady on the bus who is lonely and wants to chat....

It's all life experience.

ToastTheMost · 21/07/2022 12:28

Saladcreamormayo · 20/07/2022 23:20

totally agree.

Trigger probably more unpopular opinion!

I think it's almost the opposite of child led - I think it's adult-led on behalf of the child - over-bearing, over-controlling parenting styles and teaching styles has infantilised this generation who are not allowed to fail at anything they do and when they come close to failing there is a full scale intervention where it's always someone else's fault and someone else's responsibility to fix it. No freedom, always supervised, drove from A to B, lives are over-scheduled with activities.

They take no personal responsibility - there's no time for it. So employers are expected to behave like their parents taking responsibility for their welfare, their mental health, physical health, career development - they are the generation who have been spoon-fed their entire lives.

Told when to take a new page in their jotters at school, exercise book inspections in sixth form ffs, expected to rely on the teacher to tell them when they can remove a blazer - school and the education system has a lot to answer for - they are encouraged to make so very few decisions for themselves, the scxhool's league tables are the priority.
So they are entitled, of course they are - they get everything done for them and told that passing exams is their only value in life and they learn to do that very well...how could they be anything else but entitled.

Saladcreamormayo · 20/07/2022 23:20

InChocolateWeTrust · 18/07/2022 17:25

I think (trigger: unpopular opinion) a combo of Covid, social media and parenting/education styles that are very much "child led" or child centred, is leading to very entitled young people who think the world owes them everything.

totally agree.