Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The great Eggsperiment taking place on 19th July/ Aka EGG WARS

207 replies

Enigma2000 · 18/07/2022 16:51

Following on from my patio egg experiment. I have set up this thread ready for us all to take part in on 19th July.

Pick your surface and splat your egg between 10am - 6pm.

Let's do our egg science and save humanity.

I will be setting up my egg out front (as it is hotter than my back garden) on foil tomorrow.

Lets go! 😁😁

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
58
Blondeshavemorefun · 21/07/2022 20:28

Next time if ever get this hot again

then will leave pan outside to heat before cracking egg

i need the sizzle

Emotionalsupportviper · 21/07/2022 10:52

EggsyUnwin · 19/07/2022 22:27

I enlisted the support of the entire family for this one. One egg outside in full sunlight, the other inside the car on the dashboard. Both on lightly oiled silver plates (not real silver, the tinny ones you get in the supermarket to do naice veg sticks on for parties). Both plates left out for about 90 minutes before cracking the egg.

Results are in:

Egg 1, full sunlight outside. Began at an ambient 30C and swiftly climbed to 50 on the thermometer. Egg did not cook so much as shrivel, slowly, into a desiccated mess. The yolk cooked quite quickly, while the white just dried up. On recovery some hours later, crystalline egg white scattered from the plate like ovine dandruff.

Verdict: Effective in that the egg was no longer raw, but 0/10 for eatability.

Egg 2, inside car on dashboard. Thermometer gave up entirely and the needle vanished, so well over 50C. Cracked the egg about 90 minutes later. The white began to set instantly, which was quite impressive. The yolk cooked quickly but the white took another hour or so, but we did end up with a set white, and even a little curlicue of crispy brown at the edge. When I washed the bastard plate up and dislodged the egg yolk, it actually bounced off the sink.

Verdict: Better. It wasn't exactly appetising but it did look more or less like a fried egg. The yolk however was pustulous. 2/10 for eatability. You could, but you wouldn't want to.

Conclusions: the relatively flimsy silver plates were not the ideal base for the fried egg. Ideally we would have used a thicker piece of metal with more thermal mass, which would have retained more heat and cooked the egg from below using conduction heat as per a traditional frying pan, rather than relying on the heat of the sun to cook it from above, heating it with convection heat from the hot air which ultimately dried it out rather than cooking it.

However, the hypothesis, which was "it really is quite unusually hot outside" was proved.

Thank you for coming to my Egg Talk.

Superb account.

I particularly liked "crystalline egg white scattered from the plate like ovine dandruff.". I know you corrected it to "ovicular", but that image of a hot sheep in desperate need of "Head 'n' Shoulders" is one which will make me smile for a long time yet.

MightbeMaybe · 20/07/2022 10:58

Came back to check your results @Enigma2000 eggcellent eggsperiment write up, thank you!

dontdrinkanddriveok · 20/07/2022 10:38

This is amazing

SheldontheWonderSchlong · 20/07/2022 09:40

EggsyUnwin · 19/07/2022 22:27

I enlisted the support of the entire family for this one. One egg outside in full sunlight, the other inside the car on the dashboard. Both on lightly oiled silver plates (not real silver, the tinny ones you get in the supermarket to do naice veg sticks on for parties). Both plates left out for about 90 minutes before cracking the egg.

Results are in:

Egg 1, full sunlight outside. Began at an ambient 30C and swiftly climbed to 50 on the thermometer. Egg did not cook so much as shrivel, slowly, into a desiccated mess. The yolk cooked quite quickly, while the white just dried up. On recovery some hours later, crystalline egg white scattered from the plate like ovine dandruff.

Verdict: Effective in that the egg was no longer raw, but 0/10 for eatability.

Egg 2, inside car on dashboard. Thermometer gave up entirely and the needle vanished, so well over 50C. Cracked the egg about 90 minutes later. The white began to set instantly, which was quite impressive. The yolk cooked quickly but the white took another hour or so, but we did end up with a set white, and even a little curlicue of crispy brown at the edge. When I washed the bastard plate up and dislodged the egg yolk, it actually bounced off the sink.

Verdict: Better. It wasn't exactly appetising but it did look more or less like a fried egg. The yolk however was pustulous. 2/10 for eatability. You could, but you wouldn't want to.

Conclusions: the relatively flimsy silver plates were not the ideal base for the fried egg. Ideally we would have used a thicker piece of metal with more thermal mass, which would have retained more heat and cooked the egg from below using conduction heat as per a traditional frying pan, rather than relying on the heat of the sun to cook it from above, heating it with convection heat from the hot air which ultimately dried it out rather than cooking it.

However, the hypothesis, which was "it really is quite unusually hot outside" was proved.

Thank you for coming to my Egg Talk.

Very informative and enjoyable, thank you!

xmaswiththeinlaws · 20/07/2022 09:14

Very late to the party here. Would have loved to join in. Had a thought though all those fires yesterday, I hope none were caused by errant frying eggs, unlikely I think but imagine the headlines, the shame. When we were kids we used to burn holes in paper with a magnifying glass on a hot day.

kateandme · 20/07/2022 06:21

EggsyUnwin · 19/07/2022 22:27

I enlisted the support of the entire family for this one. One egg outside in full sunlight, the other inside the car on the dashboard. Both on lightly oiled silver plates (not real silver, the tinny ones you get in the supermarket to do naice veg sticks on for parties). Both plates left out for about 90 minutes before cracking the egg.

Results are in:

Egg 1, full sunlight outside. Began at an ambient 30C and swiftly climbed to 50 on the thermometer. Egg did not cook so much as shrivel, slowly, into a desiccated mess. The yolk cooked quite quickly, while the white just dried up. On recovery some hours later, crystalline egg white scattered from the plate like ovine dandruff.

Verdict: Effective in that the egg was no longer raw, but 0/10 for eatability.

Egg 2, inside car on dashboard. Thermometer gave up entirely and the needle vanished, so well over 50C. Cracked the egg about 90 minutes later. The white began to set instantly, which was quite impressive. The yolk cooked quickly but the white took another hour or so, but we did end up with a set white, and even a little curlicue of crispy brown at the edge. When I washed the bastard plate up and dislodged the egg yolk, it actually bounced off the sink.

Verdict: Better. It wasn't exactly appetising but it did look more or less like a fried egg. The yolk however was pustulous. 2/10 for eatability. You could, but you wouldn't want to.

Conclusions: the relatively flimsy silver plates were not the ideal base for the fried egg. Ideally we would have used a thicker piece of metal with more thermal mass, which would have retained more heat and cooked the egg from below using conduction heat as per a traditional frying pan, rather than relying on the heat of the sun to cook it from above, heating it with convection heat from the hot air which ultimately dried it out rather than cooking it.

However, the hypothesis, which was "it really is quite unusually hot outside" was proved.

Thank you for coming to my Egg Talk.

I liked your talk very much.

kateandme · 20/07/2022 06:19

TwoOwlSocks · 19/07/2022 17:22

Well, it looks remarkably like a fried egg. But it took 5 hours and the texture is what I can only describe as joke shop.

Yup this was my finding too.
It was deff cooked though people!
But cooked differently.is this the kind of slow cooked eggs people charge thousands for in restaurants maybe.haha.
So yes science experiment proves it can be done.but the timing and nature of said cooking method alters the end cooked result.
But I guess this is like meat when its slow cooked or fried ect the texture alters.

Sweetpea1532 · 20/07/2022 04:37

@EggsyUnwin
Any photos? I love your egg abstract!

EggsyUnwin · 19/07/2022 22:31

* Ovicular, FFS, not ovine. Far too hot out there for sheep.

EggsyUnwin · 19/07/2022 22:27

I enlisted the support of the entire family for this one. One egg outside in full sunlight, the other inside the car on the dashboard. Both on lightly oiled silver plates (not real silver, the tinny ones you get in the supermarket to do naice veg sticks on for parties). Both plates left out for about 90 minutes before cracking the egg.

Results are in:

Egg 1, full sunlight outside. Began at an ambient 30C and swiftly climbed to 50 on the thermometer. Egg did not cook so much as shrivel, slowly, into a desiccated mess. The yolk cooked quite quickly, while the white just dried up. On recovery some hours later, crystalline egg white scattered from the plate like ovine dandruff.

Verdict: Effective in that the egg was no longer raw, but 0/10 for eatability.

Egg 2, inside car on dashboard. Thermometer gave up entirely and the needle vanished, so well over 50C. Cracked the egg about 90 minutes later. The white began to set instantly, which was quite impressive. The yolk cooked quickly but the white took another hour or so, but we did end up with a set white, and even a little curlicue of crispy brown at the edge. When I washed the bastard plate up and dislodged the egg yolk, it actually bounced off the sink.

Verdict: Better. It wasn't exactly appetising but it did look more or less like a fried egg. The yolk however was pustulous. 2/10 for eatability. You could, but you wouldn't want to.

Conclusions: the relatively flimsy silver plates were not the ideal base for the fried egg. Ideally we would have used a thicker piece of metal with more thermal mass, which would have retained more heat and cooked the egg from below using conduction heat as per a traditional frying pan, rather than relying on the heat of the sun to cook it from above, heating it with convection heat from the hot air which ultimately dried it out rather than cooking it.

However, the hypothesis, which was "it really is quite unusually hot outside" was proved.

Thank you for coming to my Egg Talk.

frankie001 · 19/07/2022 21:58

Here is egg after I bought it in after 3 hours in the car. I did dip finger into yolk and can confirm it was edible. I did not double dip though. Once was enough.

The great Eggsperiment taking place on 19th July/ Aka EGG WARS
Emotionalsupportviper · 19/07/2022 21:56

This whole saga is thrilling.

THRILLING!!!

Heyisforhorses · 19/07/2022 21:09

Well done everyone althought some of those clear cooked eggs have me gipping 🤢

MrsReeves · 19/07/2022 20:53

Some of these eggs look like they belong in sporner corner 🤮

TugboatAnnie · 19/07/2022 20:25

Some of these look edible! Mine doesn't although I did try to put it on dp's plate without him realising

The great Eggsperiment taking place on 19th July/ Aka EGG WARS
Natsku · 19/07/2022 20:10

Yeah i think the covering made the difference.
I've left it out now uncovered in case any neighbourhood cat wants it

Changechangychange · 19/07/2022 20:08

Natsku · 19/07/2022 14:39

38 according to according to my phone, 35 in the shade now according to thermometer and over 50 in direct sun according to the same when I moved it next to the eggs

I wonder if it is because yours was covered, so it didn’t dry out? More steamed/coddled than dessicated

DoveOfPiss · 19/07/2022 19:24

Been enviously watching these eggsperiments yesterday and today.
The only thing I can remember from my 'O' level Home Economics class is that egg white coagulates at 68 degrees.

Well done all, I've really enjoyed seeing all the interesting places you have put your eggs 😁😁😁

beastlyslumber · 19/07/2022 18:59

Anyone brave enough to eat their egg?

Blondeshavemorefun · 19/07/2022 18:54

Well mine was def Cooked or singed

slid onto my hand

I won’t be eating it 😂

Natsku · 19/07/2022 18:43

Think it's done now. Had to move it to the table as the chair was shaded

The great Eggsperiment taking place on 19th July/ Aka EGG WARS
Eeksteek · 19/07/2022 18:24

elephantoverthehill · 19/07/2022 17:25

A bit of a failure here, half an hour after I cracked the egg, the clouds came over. There was a bit of bubbling and cooking of the yoke but the albumen stayed really quite clear. As pps have said I think most of the cooking was from above rather than below.

That’s not cooking, it’s just drying out. (Not singling you out, a lot of people have said it, I know)

also, I did actually add an egg. I put the before pic in, doh!

The great Eggsperiment taking place on 19th July/ Aka EGG WARS
Eeksteek · 19/07/2022 18:20

Thought a lid would work, but it was a smidge too late at 3.30. Reckon it would have done at 2pm.

The great Eggsperiment taking place on 19th July/ Aka EGG WARS