Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friends didn't "tip"....bit tight?

592 replies

tvsavec · 18/07/2022 15:39

Me and three friends went to a little family run Greek restaurant.
The bill came to around £80 for four of us.
At the end of the meal
Friend 1 put £2 on the table and I also put £2
Friend 3 said "is that for a tip"
We said yeah.....she shouts for the waiter and hands him the £4 and says thanks
They didn't bother to put a couple of pound in each

Aibu to think it's a bit tight?

OP posts:
Reallyreallyborednow · 21/07/2022 18:58

but she said she was a waitress between 1999-2002, in which case rent and tuition fees would have been much, much lower then. I don't know whether she's from the UK or not but if she was earning the amount of money she stated (up to £19,000 a year), I reckon she could have paid her rent and tuition fees

no, if she wasn’t eligible for loans as a UK national she will be have been paying international student rates. So probably comparable to tuition now.

for example, UCL fees for UK students for physics 21/22 was 9k a year. International students it’s around 31k.

so even allowing for inflation, 10-20k fees, plus london rent, plus bills, plus tube/bus fare, plus some sort of medical ins- if not classes as Uk resident nhs not free- plus food, plus books etc…

i reckon 20k was bare minimum for fees and rent.

TrashPandas · 21/07/2022 18:48

No, what she claims was nonsense in 1999 just as it's nonsense today. She's clearly only experienced American tipping culture.

restedbutexhausted · 21/07/2022 18:44

@TrashPandas but she said she was a waitress between 1999-2002, in which case rent and tuition fees would have been much, much lower then. I don't know whether she's from the UK or not but if she was earning the amount of money she stated (up to £19,000 a year), I reckon she could have paid her rent and tuition fees.

Sorry slightly off topic there I know.

TrashPandas · 21/07/2022 18:38

I live in the US now Panda and Ugly Bonnet who insist on denying anything I am saying as being truthful- what is that all about guys?

We know you're American. It was obvious from your posts which are completely inaccurate for the UK. But when it was pointed out, instead of saying "Oh okay things must be different there" you decided to pretend you'd also waitressed in the UK. You keep adding more and more bizarre claims (like you earned enough to pay for a degree) that make you look even sillier.

You're not alone. Babyjellyfish has never waitressed ("if I were a waitress...") but rather than admit she doesn't know what she's talking about, she then claimed to have been a waitress for 7 years. I don't know why neither of you can just admit you have strong views that are not supported by real waiting staff.

babyjellyfish · 21/07/2022 18:10

blebbleb · 21/07/2022 18:02

I don't understand people who leave such a mess in restaurants either. If my toddler starts hurling food and crayons everywhere I'll tidy up as best as I can

Something tells me that restaurant staff aren't likely to assume you'll be a lousy tipper or have any reason not to give you good service then!

babyjellyfish · 21/07/2022 18:08

Reallyreallyborednow · 21/07/2022 17:57

No, your repeat custom is not as valuable to the waiting staff as an actual tip, and at the end of the day, if the restaurant is full and your table could have been filled by someone who does tip, your presence means the waiting staff are going home with a bit less money in their pocket than they would have been if someone else had taken that table

but it is as valuable to the restaurants bottom line. If no one fills that table, perhaps because the wait staff can be arsey and only give very basic service to some people, then the restaurant loses covers and don’t make money.

this happens too often, restaurant doesn’t make money, you lose your job, and who tips is the least of your worries. You will be going home with a lot less money in your pocket.

i can’t believe someone would treat paying customers like they’re wasting your time.

The knots you are tying yourself in to justify not tipping are really quite extraordinary.

Whether a table of non tippers comes in or not is going to make zero difference to whether the restaurant is a commercial success or is forced to close.

From the point of view of the waiting staff, whose take home pay is based on their hourly wage plus their tips, if someone who is known not to tip comes in and takes a table, they're creating more work for what - to the waiting staff - will be the same amount of money. Obviously you'll be polite enough and take their order and clear their plates, but they just aren't worth giving gold star service to. The waiting staff would be better off focusing their energy on making sure the other customers have a really good time.

And that can easily affect the restaurant's bottom line too. When I was a waitress, the tables I had a great rapport with were not just more likely to leave a generous tip, they were also far more likely to order an extra bottle of wine or upgrade to a more expensive one, and order dessert, coffee or liqueurs. I can't tell you the number of times I had a spark with a certain table and I cheekily suggested another bottle of wine, or something they otherwise wouldn't have ordered, and they said, "oh, go on then".

Those customers are just more worth everybody's time.

blebbleb · 21/07/2022 18:02

I don't understand people who leave such a mess in restaurants either. If my toddler starts hurling food and crayons everywhere I'll tidy up as best as I can

babyjellyfish · 21/07/2022 18:00

blebbleb · 21/07/2022 17:39

I agree with that. Non tippers are always going to be more of an annoyance even if they're gracing them with their regular custom.

Especially because if they're coming back regularly, there are clearly no issues with the service and they are having a nice time.

For what it's worth, although I wasn't talking about pre-judging people based on whether you think they'll tip or not, there are certain things which are a pretty reliable indicator. But they have absolutely nothing to do with your clothes or your nails. It's all about their behaviour. Generally, if someone treats the waiting staff like something on the bottom of their shoe, it would be surprising if they turned out to be a generous tipper.

Customers who make a huge mess too - it goes one way or the other. If I had customers whose children made a mess with food or crayons or whatever, if they were hugely apologetic it was pretty likely they would leave a huge tip to compensate, and if they said nothing at all it was pretty likely they would leave a smaller than average tip, despite creating a lot more work than the average customer!

Reallyreallyborednow · 21/07/2022 17:58

I agree with that. Non tippers are always going to be more of an annoyance even if they're gracing them with their regular custom

if you are treating customers like an annoyance you’re in the wrong job. And you expect tips as well 😂😂

Reallyreallyborednow · 21/07/2022 17:57

No, your repeat custom is not as valuable to the waiting staff as an actual tip, and at the end of the day, if the restaurant is full and your table could have been filled by someone who does tip, your presence means the waiting staff are going home with a bit less money in their pocket than they would have been if someone else had taken that table

but it is as valuable to the restaurants bottom line. If no one fills that table, perhaps because the wait staff can be arsey and only give very basic service to some people, then the restaurant loses covers and don’t make money.

this happens too often, restaurant doesn’t make money, you lose your job, and who tips is the least of your worries. You will be going home with a lot less money in your pocket.

i can’t believe someone would treat paying customers like they’re wasting your time.

blebbleb · 21/07/2022 17:39

babyjellyfish · 21/07/2022 17:37

I was talking specifically about the scenario where a non tipper is a repeat customer and you already know they're going to tip.

No, your repeat custom is not as valuable to the waiting staff as an actual tip, and at the end of the day, if the restaurant is full and your table could have been filled by someone who does tip, your presence means the waiting staff are going home with a bit less money in their pocket than they would have been if someone else had taken that table.

I agree with that. Non tippers are always going to be more of an annoyance even if they're gracing them with their regular custom.

babyjellyfish · 21/07/2022 17:37

I was talking specifically about the scenario where a non tipper is a repeat customer and you already know they're going to tip.

No, your repeat custom is not as valuable to the waiting staff as an actual tip, and at the end of the day, if the restaurant is full and your table could have been filled by someone who does tip, your presence means the waiting staff are going home with a bit less money in their pocket than they would have been if someone else had taken that table.

Reallyreallyborednow · 21/07/2022 17:04

What a shitty attitude - “I’ll only do a good job if you give me extra money”

agreed. Someone with this attitude is not a good wait staff member.

i am not your typical “groomed” middle aged woman. I don’t wear make up, do my nails, hair clothes are for comfort. Dh isn’t much better.

we probably don’t present like a well off couple who will tip well. Like I said I do tip, because i’ve been there. But anyone giving “basic order taking and plate carrying” because they’ve judged tipping ability on my appearance isn’t getting a tip anyway.

so be careful who you judge to be non-tippers…

chiweenie · 21/07/2022 16:58

I live in the US now Panda and Ugly Bonnet who insist on denying anything I am saying as being truthful- what is that all about guys? Deny anything people say if it contradicts your point of view?

I was raised in the UK and yes I waitressed from the age of 13 actually and yes I funded my degree- having lived overseas a few years, I found I was screwed over in the UK despite being British when I applied for a loan as you are classified as a non-resident so no loans for me. It was horrible. I suddenly had to hold down a job and a full-time job with zero financial support from my parents since they had not been to university there were no handouts there( unlike 80% of the wealthy kids at the university I attended who had never done even a Saturday job in their privileged lives) ...it was extrememely hard but yes I did it.

I did extremely well on my degree too. Never got to go to parties or to socialise of course because when I wasn't studying, I was in a restaurant serving customers, 90% of whom tipped 8-12% typically meaning I worked 3, 8 hour shifts rather than 5-6 hour shifts which would have made it impossible for me to study for my degree. Tips make waitressing jobs one way people can study for a degree whilst working part-time. I cleared between 70 and 125 a shift back then and that money paid rent, food and tuition. In summers I worked 14 shifts by picking up shifts in every single branch of the chain I worked in when they needed coverage- I look back and yeah it was heroic thinking about it that I paid my way with no debt at all and no handouts from the bank of mum and dad and that was because my job with tips was earning me on average between 8 and 14 pounds an hour which is what I needed to make and that is why I chose the job back then in the situation I found myself in. I had my own station to work of 6 tables and I kept every penny of every tip apart from in branches where the bar made the drinks- then we gave them 10% at the end of the shift. The chefs maybe made 9-10 an hour and their work was typically less stressful than dealing with customers- the waiters earned every penny of their wage and tips.

I repeat thanks so much to the non-tight-arsed Londoners of 1999 to 2002 who came in that restaurant and tipped (as was custom then and is custom today) and enabled me to get by on 24 hours a week in a job and so get a university education so I could progress in life.When people did not tip, I let it roll over me because such is life, 10% of people are unable to be generous in those situations ia a universal truth in the UK, I discovered but I saw the response of my peers and know non-tippers that they have a strong response to non-tippers, they think you are cheap to spend that money on feeding your face but not leave a few quid tip and it does not have to be ten % but it needs to be something. If you can afford to eat out you can leave a tip. All this talk of logic about who we tip is a distraction. It gets you off tipping.

We all know if we sit down to have a meal in a restaurant and someone comes over and gets stuff for us, runs back and forth meeting our requests........ we are expected to tip and Macdonalds is not like that. 7%,8% 10% 12% 20%, you choose but for goodness sake do not be in that a tight- arsed little minority fight club of non-tippers called...The Ugly *

I have a wonderful life (enabled by having a degree) that happens to be in the US today. By the way, revealing yourself as a blanket 'everyone hates all Americans and the whole of America and all Americans only care about money ' tells me all I need to know about you Ugly Bonnet...talk about small-minded, tired cliched generalizations on a country as large as Europe and with a population significantly larger than that of England, but go ahead carry on with your little generalizations if they serve you to keep on keeping doing you...

LittleJules59 · 21/07/2022 15:29

restedbutexhausted · 21/07/2022 13:46

I've had times before where a group of, say, 10 were splitting the bill and had decided to add on a service charge. So you go around the table and everyone pays individually until you get to the last person who says "whatever's left" and only pays for the remainder of the bill. It's obviously not your place to tell them they agreed to pay more. That's a bit disheartening when you are told you will be getting a tip (and you're thinking about the rest of your team here, too) and then some stingy bastard ends up with an £8 bill subsidised by everyone else at the table.

Thankfully not a very common occurrence!

I've had this with group meals. Most of us got wise and kept our tips back until the bill had been paid. The CF ery of people thinking my tip should subsidise their meal.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 21/07/2022 15:21

babyjellyfish · 21/07/2022 14:57

You think the rude customers are the ones who tip well?

No. You entirely missed my point there.

My point is if your ’excellent’ service can ONLY be ‘bought’ then you can’t complain if good tippers are absolute bastards to you. You value tips over anything else and you can’t have it both ways.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 21/07/2022 15:18

babyjellyfish · 21/07/2022 13:37

Back on the topic of the OP, I went for lunch with a colleague once and we had great service from the waitress. We split the bill and I paid first, adding on something for a tip. He then paid the rest, not including anything, which meant not only had I subsidised his lunch, the lovely waitress didn't get a tip, because I had no cash on me.

I found it excruciatingly embarrassing, and the next time he suggested going out for lunch I made an excuse. I hate eating out with stingy people.

Now THAT is stingy.

Years ago I went out for lunch with work for someone leaving. 10 of us all had the happy hour menu and a soft drink so we all owed £9. This was when paying by card wasn’t common so we all stuck in a tenner. At least, 9 of us did. One woman, known for being a bit of a penny pincher (the type of you say you’re going out for a sandwich she gives you 50p and says “get me a prawn baguette” and you never see the extra money back) said “I’ll pay the whole thing on my card and keep the cash”. I noticed she didn’t add a tip - so effectively she got a free meal! She was v popular, and so when I pointed this out the other women told mw to ‘stop picking on her’ 🙄

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 21/07/2022 15:14

babyjellyfish · 21/07/2022 13:28

It's simple. Restaurants need people to walk through the doors irrespective of whether they tip or not. If people choose to restrict spending on luxuries then businesses that are already struggling will close. And people will be out of a job.

Your previous point was staff don't care about a share of profits - they want people tipping. But without customers they don't have a job.

That'll be a "no, there is no evidence", then.

What evidence do you expect there to be? A peer led study by Oxford on “Is tipping more beneficial to a business than not tipping”.

Sometimes it’s fine just to use common sense

OooErr · 21/07/2022 15:04

babyjellyfish · 21/07/2022 13:06

Is there any actual evidence of a link between people not tipping and restaurants being better able to stay afloat?

We're talking about the logic of it.
Many people have said they wouldn't eat out if they couldn't afford to tip and others should do the same.
Logically, this would lead to less people going out. I'm sure you can extrapolate.

Also 'eating out' covers a wide range of experiences.

I was on holiday in Cornwall recently and received excellent service. The staff had a nice chat with us, patiently explained the alcohol and specials, got some 'off-menu' items, cleared up between courses. Happily left a large tip. Same with a lot of 'proper' restaurants.

However in a lot of casual/chain (don't know the correct words!) restaurants in Manchester.. ordering and paying done via app. All they do is bring my food. Why does that deserve extra money?

babyjellyfish · 21/07/2022 15:04

But that's not what was being discussed. The point was that it was said that staff (interestingly only waiting staff were talked about) didn't care about the profits as they don't get a profit share - they care about tips. This was in response to someone saying that people coming through the doors was the important thing, irrespective of whether they tip or not.

This is true though.

On the assumption that the restaurant is in business and will continue to be in business, the individual waiter or waitress is going to appreciate the compliment of a nice tip much more than the "compliment" of a repeat customer who comes in regularly because they think the place is great but are too mean to tip. And if it's a choice between the warm fuzzy feelings of a customer who says how great the place is and keeps coming back, and a customer who only visits once and leaves a tip, it is the tip and not the repeat business that makes a difference to the person who served them, who does not get a share in the profits made by the business.

The obvious point here isn't about tipping despite you trying to make it about that.

But this thread is about tipping. And there is no evidence that tipping or not tipping is linked to businesses staying afloat or not.

It's pointing out that without customers walking through the doors there is no restaurant to work in. No job. No tips. The service industry is being hit really hard and that is only going to get worse. When people can no longer afford to heat their homes, or drive unless necessary miles etc then luxuries such as eating out are the first thing to be cut back.

What has that got to do with tipping?

So it's false to say staff don't care if their restaurant is doing well or not. Most will care as they grasp that if it's not their job is on the line. Most will worry if customer numbers drop.

Again, nothing to do with tipping, which is something the vast majority of customers do to show appreciation for the person who served them, and something most waiting staff rely on as a part of their income. Because the warm fuzzy feelings generated by a nice comment, or company profits which don't directly filter down to them, don't help pay the bills. Tips do.

SpotlessMind88 · 21/07/2022 15:00

BarbaraofSeville · 18/07/2022 15:46

No its not tight, tipping makes no sense and we need to stop judging people for not tipping a small subset of service workers.

No-one tips retail workers, fast food counter staff, cleaners or care workers. So why is considered 'tight' to not give extra money to waiting staff in restaurants who get paid a similar amount for doing similar work?

Completely agree!
its not America, not everyone Tips

babyjellyfish · 21/07/2022 14:57

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 21/07/2022 14:49

What a shitty attitude - “I’ll only do a good job if you give me extra money”.

Don’t complain then when people give you a shitty attitude but tip well.

You think the rude customers are the ones who tip well?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 21/07/2022 14:49

babyjellyfish · 21/07/2022 12:59

No, but you can pick and choose who you go above and beyond for. Someone who was already known to be a non-tipper wouldn't be getting anything more than the basic order taking and plate clearing.

What a shitty attitude - “I’ll only do a good job if you give me extra money”.

Don’t complain then when people give you a shitty attitude but tip well.

tigger1001 · 21/07/2022 14:14

"But there is absolutely no evidence that the restaurant will be any more or less likely to close or do well if people do or don't tip.

The two things are unconnected.

The point I made was that in my six or seven years of working as a waitress, non tippers were few and far between."

But that's not what was being discussed. The point was that it was said that staff (interestingly only waiting staff were talked about) didn't care about the profits as they don't get a profit share - they care about tips. This was in response to someone saying that people coming through the doors was the important thing, irrespective of whether they tip or not.

The obvious point here isn't about tipping despite you trying to make it about that. It's pointing out that without customers walking through the doors there is no restaurant to work in. No job. No tips. The service industry is being hit really hard and that is only going to get worse. When people can no longer afford to heat their homes, or drive unless necessary miles etc then luxuries such as eating out are the first thing to be cut back.

So it's false to say staff don't care if their restaurant is doing well or not. Most will care as they grasp that if it's not their job is on the line. Most will worry if customer numbers drop.

restedbutexhausted · 21/07/2022 14:07

@babyjellyfish yes they could be a pain! They were introduced when we reopened for outdoor only service after the third(?) lockdown. Very, very handy as you wouldn't hear the food bell from the garden. Beyond that, extremely irritating being badgered pointlessly whilst serving a table. Felt really rude having to stop the customer so you could passively aggressively reply to your manager ConfusedBlush

Swipe left for the next trending thread