Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friends didn't "tip"....bit tight?

592 replies

tvsavec · 18/07/2022 15:39

Me and three friends went to a little family run Greek restaurant.
The bill came to around £80 for four of us.
At the end of the meal
Friend 1 put £2 on the table and I also put £2
Friend 3 said "is that for a tip"
We said yeah.....she shouts for the waiter and hands him the £4 and says thanks
They didn't bother to put a couple of pound in each

Aibu to think it's a bit tight?

OP posts:
chiweenie · 19/07/2022 01:26

Uglybonnet: "why did you work for £4 .an hour?"

Standard hourly rate for the job back then.

That was the hourly rate back in 2000-2002 when I studied in London and worked in a London restaurant 3 evenings a week that enabled me to study for a degree I had to pay for myself since I had been traveling so was classified as nonresident- that meant no access to loans, no tuition, I had to pay every penny myself and I did it through being a waitress.
The tips took it to 7-12 pounds an hour which meant I could work 20-25 hours a week and get by in London whilst studying with no access to loans and pay my tuition.
I very much counted on the tips and luckily in the 4 years I did it the average was that yes 90 % of people in the UK tipped 10%. Americans tipped 18-20% and very grateful I was to them too.
I am not sure what kind of restaurants you have worked in but only the naffest places I have worked in at 13 had customers who did not tip frankly.

I have worked in over 10 restaurants and the norm is for people to tip.
People who do not tip stand out and yes servers will judge them as being cheap and yes I think they are unreasonable and cheap too.
In the US yes it is 18-20% and they will really let you know what they think of you if you dare not tip there.

These are cultural norms- question them all you like but they have been around my entire life and having worked in many restaurants as a young person to support myself in getting educated, now as an educated person I makes sure I follow those norms and when money is tight I do not eat out in those places.

As I said thanks to the generous customers not quibbling over a few quid whose tips supported my wage back then so I could get educated. I would have had to abandon my degree without that 8-12 quid an hour I was able to make twenty years ago so thank you!

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/07/2022 00:48

Ok so in the place I worked the chefs earned more than double what the servers earned.

So they should. It’s a skilled job.

If the shift was quiet I requested to go home because frankly I was not willing to work for 4 quid an hour- I depended on those tips to pay my rent and bills and college tuition at the time.

when did you work for £4 an hour?

Look I think people who don't tip 10% are unreasonable and cheap to boot and I will leave a tip on their behalf if I see they haven't because it is so utterly cringey to eat a meal and not leave 105 because the cultural norm is to tip waiting staff if they wait on you in the UK and US

You’re obviously from the US but I can assure you it’s NOT the cultural norm to tip 20% in the UK. Never has been. There’s no well-known rule that 10% is the minimum, like in America. and there’s no expectation either. I like the US, we pay the NWM to food service staff here.

not if it is a buffet that is different

Why is it different?

but is just a cultural norm so if you have not learned that norm then either you have not gone out much or you are a bit cheap and tight - so just own up to that.

Ive been eating out for 30 years, I’ve worked in restaurants and my parent ran restaurants before they retired. I promise you that I haven’t missed this so-called cultural norm. Not everywhere is like America.

Very off-putting in a person as it speaks about the generosity of their spirit full stop- so that is why people are getting offended because they are being called out on it here.

Ugh no one gives a monkey’s uncle about being ‘called out’. And that’s not what you’re doing BTW - you’re imposing a US cultural norm on the UK, I don’t know why but you think it’s the same. It’s not.

That’a a big problem I have with Americans - they can’t get their head around the fact that not everyone is the same as them.
.

in the UK where everyone know if you go out for dinner you leave as close to 10 % of the total of the bill

Never ever heard this. Why do you think this is the case?

chiweenie · 19/07/2022 00:35

Ok so in the place I worked the chefs earned more than double what the servers earned. The bar staff- we all tipped them 10% of what we made each shift to top them up. If the shift was quiet I requested to go home because frankly I was not willing to work for 4 quid an hour- I depended on those tips to pay my rent and bills and college tuition at the time.

Look I think people who don't tip 10% are unreasonable and cheap to boot and I will leave a tip on their behalf if I see they haven't because it is so utterly cringey to eat a meal and not leave 105 because the cultural norm is to tip waiting staff if they wait on you in the UK and US- not if it is a buffet that is different but is just a cultural norm so if you have not learned that norm then either you have not gone out much or you are a bit cheap and tight - so just own up to that.

Very off-putting in a person as it speaks about the generosity of their spirit full stop- so that is why people are getting offended because they are being called out on it here. Then they say it is their principles....yeah right. You just won't pony up unless you have to and you are about 10 % of the population.

To be fair to your friends the norm is Greece may be 5%( I am not sure so they may have innocently thought you guys covered it so I would hold back judgment on that situation unlike in the UK where everyone know if you go out for dinner you leave as close to 10 % of the total of the bill and if in the USA more like 18-20%)

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 18/07/2022 23:43

Why didn't you make sure the restaurant dish washers, cleaners, chef's assistants, etc got a tip? Bit tight, or you don't think it's your responsibility to top up everybody's wages?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 18/07/2022 23:40

I waitressed throughout Uni, I don’t remember so much contention around tipping, but I agree with a PP and it’s worth much more to staff if you’re pleasant and courteous. That’s worth more than a tip - at least it was to me when I worked in the industry

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 18/07/2022 23:39

19lottie82 · 18/07/2022 23:26

And?

I go to restaurants to enjoy the food and drink, not to keep random waiters and waitresses happy

And……..
the discussion is about tipping waiting staff. You said if a meal is good then you will go back with family or friends, which is “worth more”. Worth more to who?

it certainly isn’t worth more than tipping to the waiting staff! I’m pretty sure
think they’d rather you didn’t return, if you don’t tip.

It wasn’t me who made that comment

I did say I think tipping is propping g up employers who underpay their staff so I don’t tend to do it u less I’ve had exceptional service.

And I know we live in an age of having to consider the feelings and happiness of everyone who passes us on the street over our own, but I don’t really give the waiting staff, and what they think of me, a second thought

Ravenpuff93 · 18/07/2022 23:37

ThreeLittleDots · 18/07/2022 23:32

I’m pretty sure think they’d rather you didn’t return, if you don’t tip

This is a myth, in the main. Most people on this thread who have worked in the industry have said a tip isn't expected, a nice bonus, but not expected.

I know my colleagues and friends working in hospitality definitely judge someone who is rude, dismissive and seems to look down on staff, however. They would rather these people didn't return!

My Grandad is an embarrassment to go out with. Makes condescending comments to the poor staff, who have to bite their tongues and pretend they're grateful for his tip.

This is a great point, no one wants a tip as kind of “payment” for poor behaviour from customers

ThreeLittleDots · 18/07/2022 23:32

I’m pretty sure think they’d rather you didn’t return, if you don’t tip

This is a myth, in the main. Most people on this thread who have worked in the industry have said a tip isn't expected, a nice bonus, but not expected.

I know my colleagues and friends working in hospitality definitely judge someone who is rude, dismissive and seems to look down on staff, however. They would rather these people didn't return!

My Grandad is an embarrassment to go out with. Makes condescending comments to the poor staff, who have to bite their tongues and pretend they're grateful for his tip.

19lottie82 · 18/07/2022 23:26

And?

I go to restaurants to enjoy the food and drink, not to keep random waiters and waitresses happy

And……..
the discussion is about tipping waiting staff. You said if a meal is good then you will go back with family or friends, which is “worth more”. Worth more to who?

it certainly isn’t worth more than tipping to the waiting staff! I’m pretty sure
think they’d rather you didn’t return, if you don’t tip.

19lottie82 · 18/07/2022 23:20

What if you've only got a ten or twenty pound note? No way would I leave a £20
tip just from me!

then you give your server the note and ask for £x change, and tell them to take the rest as a tip, it’s hardly rocket science!

OooErr · 18/07/2022 23:17

Also @chiweenie you donrealise that even the non tipping people pay your wages right. In the price of the food

OooErr · 18/07/2022 23:17

chiweenie · 18/07/2022 22:31

It may sound discriminatory but it’s true. Certain cultural groups don’t tip in there culture and they don’t tip when they travel generally and when people are earning 4 pounds a hour that will affect how they behave towards those people when the bulk of their wages is coming from tips. I served who I got because I also saw it was not particularly pleasant but it was how it was and the waiters bolted when they heard specific accents at the door because they knew they would work those tables for no extra money to that 4 pounds an hour. So whatever you think about that this is how human nature is I’m afraid. When you are struggling to get by a table that will leave 0 versus one that will leave 10 to 15 pounds is very different and waiting staff get good at identifying who is who. So until serving staff get paid a fair hourly rate that’s not going to change. I don’t eat out when I can’t afford to tip 10 percent in the uk or 20 percent in the USA. I just get take out instead. Yes I judge people who don’t tip . It’s cheap. If you can afford to eat out you can afford to tip for service because it’s a cultural expectation in the uk and the USA the countries I eat out in. It’s fine don’t tip but expect people to judge you for sure and I expect people who don’t tip are perfectly fine with that.

The easy way to solve this issue would be to make the employer pay more, so you’re not subject to people’s ‘cultural expectations’.
It’s the culture in the U.S because it’s literally the law that servers make below min wage.
It’s not in the U.K.
Maybe your restaurant was one full of tourists and everyone expected extra £££ but you were paid min wage same as everyone else on a similar job.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 18/07/2022 23:15

19lottie82 · 18/07/2022 23:13

I don't tip but if I enjoy a meal, I go back and take my friends and family there,
which is worth much more.

maybe to the company that owns the restaurant, but not your serving staff, they’d definitely prefer the tip!

And?

I go to restaurants to enjoy the food and drink, not to keep random waiters and waitresses happy

19lottie82 · 18/07/2022 23:13

I don't tip but if I enjoy a meal, I go back and take my friends and family there,
which is worth much more.

maybe to the company that owns the restaurant, but not your serving staff, they’d definitely prefer the tip!

Kite22 · 18/07/2022 23:04

I don't tip in shops so I don't tip anyone is very strange logic

How so ?
If you are saying that customers should subsidise / top up the wages of staff who work in NMW or NLW jobs, then why don't you believe that should be the case for everyone you encounter across the week who works in similarly low paid employment ?
If you are going to trot out the next catchphrase of it being "a personal service", then do you stuff a fiver into the pocket of the EY practitioner you pick your child up from at the end of every day ? As I would say that is far more personal / important the person gets it right, than the person who carries some plates from the kitchen to the table.
Or, if you don't have a child in Nursery, do you rush over to your parents' house to tuck a note into the pocket of the carer who comes and gets them up and washes them each day and helps them to the toilet then later puts them to bed? As it doesn't get more personal than that, but I never see anyone on these threads saying they do that every day.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 18/07/2022 22:33

I’d rather judge the shitty employers paying their staff £4 an hour (apparently) and then pointing the finger at paying customers for why they’re not earning more money.

tipping only serves to prop up this culture of low pay. I’d rather pay more for food, knowing the staff are on a higher basic wage, and not tip at all

chiweenie · 18/07/2022 22:31

It may sound discriminatory but it’s true. Certain cultural groups don’t tip in there culture and they don’t tip when they travel generally and when people are earning 4 pounds a hour that will affect how they behave towards those people when the bulk of their wages is coming from tips. I served who I got because I also saw it was not particularly pleasant but it was how it was and the waiters bolted when they heard specific accents at the door because they knew they would work those tables for no extra money to that 4 pounds an hour. So whatever you think about that this is how human nature is I’m afraid. When you are struggling to get by a table that will leave 0 versus one that will leave 10 to 15 pounds is very different and waiting staff get good at identifying who is who. So until serving staff get paid a fair hourly rate that’s not going to change. I don’t eat out when I can’t afford to tip 10 percent in the uk or 20 percent in the USA. I just get take out instead. Yes I judge people who don’t tip . It’s cheap. If you can afford to eat out you can afford to tip for service because it’s a cultural expectation in the uk and the USA the countries I eat out in. It’s fine don’t tip but expect people to judge you for sure and I expect people who don’t tip are perfectly fine with that.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 18/07/2022 22:27

BarbaraofSeville · 18/07/2022 15:46

No its not tight, tipping makes no sense and we need to stop judging people for not tipping a small subset of service workers.

No-one tips retail workers, fast food counter staff, cleaners or care workers. So why is considered 'tight' to not give extra money to waiting staff in restaurants who get paid a similar amount for doing similar work?

This.

Tipping is such a polarised topic, there are people who have a COMPLETELY random list of those who must be tipped otherwise you’re a Bad Person. And those who wish to exercise common sense and refuse to subsidise pithy wages of the establishments we visit.

QueenCamilla · 18/07/2022 22:25

Lol at all these rumours of ever increasing staff wages!!
Must be the same source of information that gives pearls of wisdom like "those on Universal credit get their houses furnished for free didn't you know?"

The minimum wage is 9.50. Some places might be paying a tenner an hour. I'm not talking about Cornwall in summer obviously! But then with rents in Cornwall all waiting staff would be homeless (or just not there) on NMW only.

Dunno what the solution is but the cluster shaft of increasing cost of living plus tipping going "out of fashion" probably will end up with all uf us ordering food McDonald's style everywhere.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 18/07/2022 21:49

chiweenie you're back-tracking now.

Your tipping practice means nothing to me and who even knows what's the truth? You said you dodged customers. How would you know which ones were going to tip/not tip? I can't imagine you had repeat business if that was accepted practice and no, you didn't earn your wage.

Ravenpuff93 · 18/07/2022 21:48

OooErr · 18/07/2022 21:42

Well I also do tip sometimes, can I join the club? :D
Was in Cornwall recently and most pub/restaurant staff were brilliant. Patiently explaining the specials, alcohol choices , had a bit of good chat. A lovely atmosphere. Was happy to leave a big tip.

But in a lot of city restaurants recently all they do is bring the food. You order and pay on the app. Food and drink appears, put down without a word. You eat and leave.

I fail to see how that deserves a tip.

Haha of course. Yeah I see what you mean there. I also find that those places often add gratuity, which is a bit of a cheek! That frustrates me, when it is taken out of my hands completely and the service is poor.

I feel like this thread is getting a bit toxic. Someone said I have my “tribe” and they theirs, and I don’t view it that way and really wouldn’t like others too. So I’m sorry my comments were judgy, I had a knee jerk response to the question but I’m not looking down on people who can’t afford to tip. It’s just drilled into me to do it as standard. Let’s not all pretend there’s a huge divide here, because I don’t think there is. Seems like we all worry tips don’t reach the right people, none of us want to tip bad service, and all of us tip when the service is great.

OooErr · 18/07/2022 21:42

Ravenpuff93 · 18/07/2022 21:32

Well then it sounds like we agree more than I thought. Neither of us tips 100% of the time! Wait staff are paid minimum wage, so I’m not contributing to any problem when I do choose to tip

Well I also do tip sometimes, can I join the club? :D
Was in Cornwall recently and most pub/restaurant staff were brilliant. Patiently explaining the specials, alcohol choices , had a bit of good chat. A lovely atmosphere. Was happy to leave a big tip.

But in a lot of city restaurants recently all they do is bring the food. You order and pay on the app. Food and drink appears, put down without a word. You eat and leave.

I fail to see how that deserves a tip.

chiweenie · 18/07/2022 21:41

lyinwitch

I didn't say I avoided serving them did I?
I served them knowing they probably would not tip and you know it is disheartening when you are getting 4 quid an hour back then so yes I was happy when I did not get certain people who we could predict would not tip because yes 99 pc of the time we could predict which people would not tip because that is how it is- certain kinds of people don't tip and it is about 10 pc of customers so the people on this thread saying they don't tip are in that minority and you can defend your choie as much as you like but know that waiters hearts drop when they see you enter their restaurants and when they go to clear your mess up and find no tip.

Yes as a student unable to access loans I took the job that I was able to do around my full time during the day study, which was evening work in a restaurant as a waitress and that is the deal- you depend on tips and 90 pc of the population just understand that is how it is and now I as a customer understand that and I leave 20% when I eat out because of this.

Carry on not tipping and sticking to your I don't agree with tipping excuse principles that saves you a few measley quid. Go watch the opening scenes of Reservoir Dogs on Youtube whilst you are at it. Don't think the servers don't notice, they do and know that you are in a minority in the utterly devoid of generosity choice you are making so there you go. Most people tip, thanks to those 90 % you helped me get my degree 20 years ago.

Sweatingmytiitsoff · 18/07/2022 21:33

Darbs76 · 18/07/2022 20:41

Yes very tight. I tip 10% in the U.K. as standard, more if I’ve had excellent service so I’d have felt bad handing over less than that. These places are struggling to recover from covid. I went to the US with a friend and she really struggled with the 18% tip expectation. She’s not a tipper generally but she did in the end

Some people can't afford it. OP gave £2 she has utter cheek and so do you.

Lots of people will earn similar to a waitress or a food chain. It's a joke too because I went to a restaurant which was Lucia in York recently and I asked about how tips are given.... the manager/supervisor took a percent and the rest "allegedly" goes to staff.

I would rather give a staff member the money personally (I know some places won't allow this).

Ravenpuff93 · 18/07/2022 21:32

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 18/07/2022 20:59

You think I'm 'tight' when I do actually tip? The difference probably is that I tip really well but not for standard or indifferent service which is very much the norm in the UK.

Breakfast waiting staff are generally streets apart from lunch/dinner waiting staff. Guess which ones expect financial reward for basic performance? Clue: It's not the breakfast waiting staff.

You and your cohort are contributing to the problem. Previous posters have patiently explained and you're still too blind/deluded to see it.

I'm quite happy to be distinct from you and your silly 'lady bountiful' view. We do all have a 'tribe' and you'r'e welcome to yours.

Well then it sounds like we agree more than I thought. Neither of us tips 100% of the time! Wait staff are paid minimum wage, so I’m not contributing to any problem when I do choose to tip