Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Climate change: just how f***ed are we?

357 replies

obsessedwithsleep · 18/07/2022 14:28

Obviously it's on my mind at the moment and it seems that nothing of any significance is being done. Like we're just watching those juggernaut come down the road and not even trying to the move the car.

Anyway, as the title says: how awful will the future be? What is the most likely degree rise by 2100? What does this actually mean in reality?

Would love to hear people's thoughts and wisdom.

OP posts:
AtwilightRebellion · 18/07/2022 19:56

riesenrad · 18/07/2022 16:25

Denial like this isn't helpful. I think people stick their head in the sand because they can't bear the thought of giving up their SUVs or making an effort to recycle.

No that isn't it.

You reference SUV's because you are lazy or cant be arsed to educate yourself appropriately.

A tiny example of what I see as wanton consumerism is how you shop in the UK.

The supermarkets are obscene in supply - designed to make you change your coffee cups and dinner plates twice a year.

Whenever I come back to my native UK I am staggered by the supermarkets alone. Consumer porn. A repulsive level of unnecessary - on every level.

I wonder how many of you on this thread so horrified, take a look at your own consumerism and the spend culture around you.

It is so much more than buying an SUV that contributes.

Personally, I think it's game over. I won't curb my habits for something so utterly pointless.

WinterDeWinter · 18/07/2022 19:56

Gosh, I didn't say communism was state capitalism - literally the opposite, in fact: I said that the Soviet Union and China practice/d state capitalism. Leninism/Stalinism/Maoism* 'reformed' capitalism, it didn't abandon it. It simply isn't the proof that a non-capitalist system would fail that you pretend it is

'State capitalism' is a simplification, of course - that's usual in a generalist discussion, I think? In this case, the simplification might help those who don't have detailed knowledge to see both your Telegraph whataboutery and your cynicism.

I'm interested in whether there's anything in the forms of communism which move away from capitalism entirely which might help us un-fuck things. And I'd like people to know that there are other forms of communism, despite your narrative, in case they are interested too.

And I don't mind you sneering at me (or mischaracterising Bordiga), because you speak very clearly when you do so.

*simplification, for the avoidance of doubt

stuntbubbles · 18/07/2022 19:43

@crawdaddio You personally? Or in general? Yes, we need more renewables – but we also need more reliable storage on the grid. Imagine if we could harvest all the solar energy from this heatwave and actually store it and use it later, that’s the real infrastructure to be invested in.

crawdaddio · 18/07/2022 19:39

im someone’s who is pretty distracted by life to keep up with what’s going on. We’ve made some changes as a family in terms of investments and reusing things but I’m sure there’s lots more we could do.

shouldn’t we be building solar farms and wind power stations?

Planetearthisscrewed · 18/07/2022 19:38

Agree we absolutely do not have 150 years to deal with it

UnnecessaryFennel · 18/07/2022 19:17

'those who pen 'peer reviewed' papers'

Scientists, you mean?

'The problem is' that we don't have 150 years to sort the damage. Change absolutely does need to happen now.

But sure, carrying on sneering about 'you people' and 'clickbait'. It's a great look for you.

Pebble55 · 18/07/2022 19:05

The people who read a few Guardian articles and say 'we're doomed' are funny. If we're doomed, why bother doing anything? Just go out then and spend all your savings on a V8, eat meat every meal, fly everywhere, drive to work every day.

The truth is we are not doomed. Automobile technology has taken colossal steps toward fuel efficiency in the last three decades. Your average family sedan consumes less than half of what it used to. Electric cars will invariably become the norm in the next decade or so. Aviation is changing quickly and biofuel or electric planes are well advanced in their development. The era of coal will be over by the end of the decade. Awareness of the impact of meat consumption is growing. As for poorer countries (most have a much lower carbon footprint than the West anyway), well they will very quickly abandon expensive, clunky combustion-engine vehicles in favour of easy-maintenance, cheap once they start becoming affordable second-hand cast-offs from the US and Europe.

The problem is that you people and those who pen 'peer reviewed' papers and Guardian clickbait is that you want change now. It won't happen. It's taken us 150 years to inflict climate-change damage on the planet and so it goes that it will probably take us another 150 years to heal that damage, no?

MagicFox · 18/07/2022 18:45

@WaveyHair yes they're in it together, they've said as much. A friendship without limits. Russia, China and Iran are in a gross ménage a trois

Wishyfishy · 18/07/2022 18:43

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 18/07/2022 16:57

@frazzledmess they need to make caring more lucrative, for example, they will pay me £3 an hour more as a HCA to go and help people to get washed/dressed but won’t pay carers the same. I also think there needs to be serious conversations over keeping people alive at any cost, it’s ludicrous really I’d rather have quality of life than quantity

Yes on the NHS point we can’t keep going as we are, there need to be some tough conversations and sooner rather than later.
If to fund it properly means ever increasing taxation on a demographic that will be far more affected by climate change than the one we are subsidising, we should be clear on what it means. What is quality of life for a lot of those under NHS care long term? What should we be prioritising? I can see why politicians endlessly put it off.

Planetearthisscrewed · 18/07/2022 18:42

tttigress

2 days of hyped up heat, is it really that big a deal?

Are you really that thick or just trying to wind people up?

WaveyHair · 18/07/2022 18:42

MagicFox · 18/07/2022 18:22

I do wonder if China’s heatwaves might lead to a change in chinese government policy, which might be world changing.

That would be excellent. Maybe they could also think about the impact of war on climate change and have a word with Russia while reining in their own ambitions re Taiwan at the same time!

I do think there needs to be a huge high level change like this

Nah, my conspiracy theory is that Russia & China are in this together. China had the first pop at the world economy with Covid & just as that finished Russia picks a fight with Ukraine. I think this is a group effort to take over.

Pedallleur · 18/07/2022 18:24

tttigress · 18/07/2022 17:53

2 days of hyped up heat, is it really that big a deal?

But it's happening globally. Hot countries are getting hotter, water storage is failing. 2 days here this year, maybe 4 next year then a week the year after. At what point do we say enough.

MagicFox · 18/07/2022 18:22

I do wonder if China’s heatwaves might lead to a change in chinese government policy, which might be world changing.

That would be excellent. Maybe they could also think about the impact of war on climate change and have a word with Russia while reining in their own ambitions re Taiwan at the same time!

I do think there needs to be a huge high level change like this

Discovereads · 18/07/2022 18:22

WinterDeWinter · 18/07/2022 17:57

China calls itself communist, but isn't (I think that's probably obvious to most people but there are lots of great resources out there if not.)

And why the lol at the term state capitalism? It's a widely understood one which describes a state - of any political format - which undertakes business or commercial activities for profit . In doing so, it treats - must treat - the humans that are its primary resource just as democratic capitalism does: it mines their labour for profit. (Their market is usually external, ie other capitalist countries - though China's new internal market demonstrates capitalism's relentless drive to growth, even when that growth might bring about its host's ideological demise.)

Your post is exemplary. In the narrative of people like you, who usually have an investment of one kind or another in heading off any serious analysis of its overall utility, capitalism must be presented as simply "common sense". Alternatives - even the mere idea of serious people getting together to seriously consider alternative ways of living - become not just unnecessary but unthinkable. How we do things now is simply common sense.

But it's not. It's not 'common' anything, though that's its best lie.

Nor is it sense. When you look through the prism we are all looking through on this thread, it looks fucking insane, tbh.

“And why the lol at the term state capitalism?”

Because communism is not state capitalism. You don’t even know the basic definitions of capitalism or communism. Profit has fuck all to do with it.

I have no agenda, no narrative, but you obviously do have a narrative you are regurgitating with little to no understanding of the terminology you are employing.

CavernousScream · 18/07/2022 18:20

I think what’s interesting about this heatwave is that you can see the same people who were incapable of acting in the interest of the broader population also pretend that isn’t a symptom of climate change. A significant minority of people are simply unable to think and act in the interests of others. Those people will have to be forced into action and sadly some of them wield significant power across the world. The rest of us will have to do something. A very significant amount of climate change is now inevitable, but it’s not too late to change and adapt.

I do wonder if China’s heatwaves might lead to a change in chinese government policy, which might be world changing.

Discovereads · 18/07/2022 18:15

WinterDeWinter · 18/07/2022 18:05

Just before I fuck off, @Discovereads: my entire point is that the dominant systems of the present and the past are universally inhumane in that they are or were dependent upon - powered by - inequality. One of those systems - capitalism -is going to kill us all, quite soon. We need something which isn't how things have previously been done. I know you are finding that hard to compute.

If you are looking for a possible path forward, you could do worse than look at the writings of Bordiga.

Bordiga? and his proposed theory of legalising cartels…only he calls it “Trade Union Communes” where all the owners of the corporations in the same industry get to collude on self-regulation and fix prices instead of a competitive market. Such a proposed system would result in even faster/greater economic growth because the consumer and government would lose all their powers to reign in corporate power. This is a system based increasing inequality by empowering corporations to be ascendant over consumer demand and government regulation.

UnnecessaryFennel · 18/07/2022 18:05

tttigress · 18/07/2022 17:53

2 days of hyped up heat, is it really that big a deal?

Ah, critical thinking. As endangered as orangutans, these days.

WinterDeWinter · 18/07/2022 18:05

Just before I fuck off, @Discovereads: my entire point is that the dominant systems of the present and the past are universally inhumane in that they are or were dependent upon - powered by - inequality. One of those systems - capitalism -is going to kill us all, quite soon. We need something which isn't how things have previously been done. I know you are finding that hard to compute.

If you are looking for a possible path forward, you could do worse than look at the writings of Bordiga.

IGotItInTheSales · 18/07/2022 18:00

Scary that these deniers are likely to have kids!

I feel sorry for those poor kids

AlviarinAesSedai · 18/07/2022 17:59

Where has the free cavity wall insulation gone? We got free cavity wall in the 90’s. Also still have the rubbish energy efficient lightbulbs given free too.
There needs to be more done about built in obsolescence. Products needs to be repairable. There use to be businesses that repaired products.
Cars my DH use to be able to fix it, now everything is on a computer.

TuftyMarmoset · 18/07/2022 17:58

tttigress · 18/07/2022 17:53

2 days of hyped up heat, is it really that big a deal?

Seriously? It’s 2022 and there are actually still people in denial about climate change?

WinterDeWinter · 18/07/2022 17:57

China calls itself communist, but isn't (I think that's probably obvious to most people but there are lots of great resources out there if not.)

And why the lol at the term state capitalism? It's a widely understood one which describes a state - of any political format - which undertakes business or commercial activities for profit . In doing so, it treats - must treat - the humans that are its primary resource just as democratic capitalism does: it mines their labour for profit. (Their market is usually external, ie other capitalist countries - though China's new internal market demonstrates capitalism's relentless drive to growth, even when that growth might bring about its host's ideological demise.)

Your post is exemplary. In the narrative of people like you, who usually have an investment of one kind or another in heading off any serious analysis of its overall utility, capitalism must be presented as simply "common sense". Alternatives - even the mere idea of serious people getting together to seriously consider alternative ways of living - become not just unnecessary but unthinkable. How we do things now is simply common sense.

But it's not. It's not 'common' anything, though that's its best lie.

Nor is it sense. When you look through the prism we are all looking through on this thread, it looks fucking insane, tbh.

tttigress · 18/07/2022 17:53

2 days of hyped up heat, is it really that big a deal?

NoRegretsNoTearsGoodbye · 18/07/2022 17:51

@MagicFox, I totally agree about voting for change but all our electorate is obsessed with is fucking tax cuts. They can't see the wood for the burning trees unfortunately 😩

JanisMoplin · 18/07/2022 17:50

@mydogisthebest I think you were wise and prescient in not having DC. I probably should have done that too, but I think I just blotted out all talk of climate change some 20 years ago. My DC say they won't be having any children; we shall have to see.

Swipe left for the next trending thread