Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Climate change: just how f***ed are we?

357 replies

obsessedwithsleep · 18/07/2022 14:28

Obviously it's on my mind at the moment and it seems that nothing of any significance is being done. Like we're just watching those juggernaut come down the road and not even trying to the move the car.

Anyway, as the title says: how awful will the future be? What is the most likely degree rise by 2100? What does this actually mean in reality?

Would love to hear people's thoughts and wisdom.

OP posts:
thecatsthecats · 18/07/2022 22:20

restedbutexhausted · 18/07/2022 15:47

Overpopulation is a racist myth. It's not the people that are the issue, it's the corporations and governments who refuse to do anything about the problem whilst telling us to abandon plastic straws.

It's really not, and that's due to psychology, not resource availability. Because humans are demonstrably easy to manipulate, even more so with social media and booming populations.

The 7 going on 8 billion people in the world are not going to be able to collectively enact the changes needed, because most of us - quite reasonably, given our evolutionary background - not able to comprehend such scales.

And because we're too busy bickering about localised race issues that are fairly small fry compared to "we're making the continents where brown people live uninhabitable".

InconstantMoon · 18/07/2022 22:15

@Dashel

I think having kids is exactly what makes people start to think about climate change. Suddenly you care for something way more than yourself! If I'd been less ignorant of climate change before having mine (2) I'm not sure I would have had any. And I certainly wouldn't have any more. I spend my life now consumed with fear for their future and that's what makes me want to do whatever I can. I can't believe most parents don't wake up once they have children. Ps I don't fall into any of those other over-consuming categories listed, perhaps because I'm aware that's what they are now. I don't know if I was before tbh

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 18/07/2022 22:10

Yeah because just anyone can be a nurse or doctor. Quite honestly I like living rurally I don’t want to live in a rat race city and so would not like the living in a commune idea

Discovereads · 18/07/2022 22:10

onlythreenow · 18/07/2022 21:58

When really the only real way to ever solve this was always to have less. To tread more lightly.

This is what it comes down with - unfortunately most people in the western world want more, not less, and to hell with the consequences.

No, it’s not. That is a myth. Did you not read the report showing that the UKs total CO2 emissions are at 1945 levels….we have way better lifestyles and more than we did in 1945 post WWII Britain. In addition, on a per capita basis, our CO2 emissions are the same as they were in 1860- are we living like the overworked Victorian poor in the unsanitary slums without even a bed to sleep on? No.

And no, we didn’t reduce CO2 emissions by “outsourcing” most of the gains is due to eliminating coal. In other words greener energy sources has not only massively reduced CO2 emissions but also allowed us to have a hell of a lot more and better lifestyle at the same time.

Going back to medieval lifestyles is not necessary at all. The drastic changes needed are simply shifting off fossil fuels and on to green energy. It’s been happening since the 1960s. We are simply in a transition period where we are feeling the pain of our ancestors emissions.

Dashel · 18/07/2022 22:10

InconstantMoon · 18/07/2022 22:01

This is what it comes down with - unfortunately most people in the western world want more, not less, and to hell with the consequences.

I think that most parents would willingly sacrifice anything to save their children

How many posters on here where they are asking about whether to have a third child actually take climate change into account? If I had kids I would be a lot more careful.

How many families need to have a dog, 4x4, new every thing, foreign holidays? I can’t believe how bad dogs are for climate change yet how many people have them now?

we are screwed, people are too selfish and too lazy to do anything apart from fill up their recycling bin.

InconstantMoon · 18/07/2022 22:01

This is what it comes down with - unfortunately most people in the western world want more, not less, and to hell with the consequences.

I think that most parents would willingly sacrifice anything to save their children

onlythreenow · 18/07/2022 21:58

When really the only real way to ever solve this was always to have less. To tread more lightly.

This is what it comes down with - unfortunately most people in the western world want more, not less, and to hell with the consequences.

Discovereads · 18/07/2022 21:52

@gnilliwdog
We would work within our local communities, rotating jobs and covering all the necessary things such as care work, food growing, libraries, local councils.

This rotating jobs is a recipe for disaster if you mean that we’d all take turns doing a different job every month or whatever. Most jobs require skills you know…it’s not like anyone can decide to be a farmer for a month and actually successfully grow food. I wouldn’t want to live in a society where Bob the gardener was also my brain surgeon.

Discovereads · 18/07/2022 21:47

WinterDeWinter · 18/07/2022 19:56

Gosh, I didn't say communism was state capitalism - literally the opposite, in fact: I said that the Soviet Union and China practice/d state capitalism. Leninism/Stalinism/Maoism* 'reformed' capitalism, it didn't abandon it. It simply isn't the proof that a non-capitalist system would fail that you pretend it is

'State capitalism' is a simplification, of course - that's usual in a generalist discussion, I think? In this case, the simplification might help those who don't have detailed knowledge to see both your Telegraph whataboutery and your cynicism.

I'm interested in whether there's anything in the forms of communism which move away from capitalism entirely which might help us un-fuck things. And I'd like people to know that there are other forms of communism, despite your narrative, in case they are interested too.

And I don't mind you sneering at me (or mischaracterising Bordiga), because you speak very clearly when you do so.

*simplification, for the avoidance of doubt

Gosh, I didn't say communism was state capitalism - literally the opposite, in fact: I said that the Soviet Union and China practice/d state capitalism.

Yes you did say that communism was state capitalism, you even gave a BS definition of it that proved you don’t know what capitalism or communism is:

It's true that Iron Curtain countries did not have a good environmental record (though we cannot know how they would be responding to the crisis now). But their 'communism' was simply state capitalism - a perversion which shifted ownership of the market from corporations to the state.

I'm interested in whether there's anything in the forms of communism which move away from capitalism entirely which might help us un-fuck things

FFS, no there isn’t because all the forms of communism which “move away from capitalism” implemented IRL historically have proven to be far worse for the environment than capitalism. I’m not saying capitalism isn’t perfect, but it’s the best we have to date. Communism is worse. You mentioned several times there are “other systems” and I’ve asked what are these other systems better than capitalism and you’ve dodged the question every time.

stuntbubbles · 18/07/2022 21:42

Whatsonmymindgrapes · 18/07/2022 21:37

It’s hot in summer…

What’s your point?

onlywhenidream · 18/07/2022 21:38

Reducing population is a daft idea

What matters is the number of people multiplied by emissions per person

Birth rates are falling especially amongst polluters , but it takes decades to impact population size and we need change now so it's emissions per person that needs to change

Unless you think government should propose a 50% instant population cull

Vikinga · 18/07/2022 21:37

It's not all or nothing though. The longer we leave it the worse it will get. We can do something now to change things and not let it get too much worse but it has to be pretty soon. And what we have to do is stop burning fossil fuels.

Whatsonmymindgrapes · 18/07/2022 21:37

It’s hot in summer…

gnilliwdog · 18/07/2022 21:37

@WinterDeWinter Yes, I am interested. In my ideal world we would work in small, local economies as much as possible. Housing would be allocated and restricted to one per person. We would work within our local communities, rotating jobs and covering all the necessary things such as care work, food growing, libraries, local councils. Public transport would be green and either free, or very cheap. There could be a number of electric vehicles on a shared scheme as well. I have many other ideas I would like to see happen, but I don't know if these are socialist ideas or more like benign anarchy. People would resist such ideas and call them dictatorship, but I feel I live under a dictatorship already - I am forced to participate in the capitalist system if I don't want to starve. My planet is being destroyed, without my consent. We are going to have a new prime minister but I don't get to vote etc.

RelativePitch · 18/07/2022 21:35

Lots of people have mentioned reducing the population and having fewer children and of course that is key, but no Western government is ever going to incentivise that because we need lots of future tax payers and public sector workers to support a huge ageing population. Italy has the fastest declining population in the world. Is the government there celebrating? No. They are very scared, to the extent that they wheel out the Pope to tell people to stop buying pets and have children instead. I don't know how we undo this massive pyramid scheme we've all got ourselves into.

InconstanMoon · 18/07/2022 21:28

To be fair, if we end up in a world war climate change will be the least of our worries

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 18/07/2022 21:12

Very fucked.

To combat it, you'd need to stop holidays abroad, limit the amount of children people have, stop all production of unnecessary items (this would be a very very long list), reduce food shipments and use what is in the country more, stop car usage completely, and a lot of other harsh changes that will affect people's lives majorly.

People on MN get upset if they can't water their grass. You tell me if they'd agree to the above without complaint. 😂

UnnecessaryFennel · 18/07/2022 21:11

I struggle to imagine anyone on this thread has properly railed against CC

What does that mean?

Ithinkimightbebroken · 18/07/2022 21:09

I do want to be more sustainable but the sustainable choices are so bloody expensive. Even simple things like biodegradable bags are fortunes more.

I drive a battered 12 year old Land Rover, it’s worth 5k at the most. I need a big car for work purposes. I can’t afford finance, I scrape by as it is.

A large electric car would be £30k or £400pm on finance. How are normal people finding that sort of money per month?!

AtwilightRebellion · 18/07/2022 21:05

SleeplessInEngland · 18/07/2022 20:09

“The planet’s heating up beyond repair but some people online were hypocrites so bring it on. I am very intelligent.”

Ok Love.

ShriekingShack · 18/07/2022 21:00

*emissions not transmissions!

ShriekingShack · 18/07/2022 20:59

Guilty of not RTFT.

I heard on the radio earlier we need to half current transmissions to keep within the 1.5 degree increase by 2030, which apparently will still mean very hot summers.

problem is, we each can (and should) do our bit but have no control at a country level. Developing countries are also suggesting the West take a bigger hit on emission reductions as we’ve already been through our industrial revolutions and created a shit ton of the problem. Hard to argue with to be fair, although there are alternatives nowadays.

The pandemic showed how adaptable peoples behaviour can be. Personally I think this will only come from big leaps in technical advancements though.

let’s hope Scotland doesn’t become independent as we’re all gonna want to move there.

Notanotherwindow · 18/07/2022 20:44

I'm forcing myself to forget about it. There's nothing I can do, it's too late to prevent it, we're looking at damage control now and until the big players change, there's nothing us little people can do.

I don't have any children, never fly, recycle what I can and don't throw stuff away just for the sake of having new. My car is a petrol as electric just won't work for me but it is low emission and 12 years old and I plan to run it until it is no longer financially or mechanically viable. I figure I'm doing all I can so I won't worry about it. Hopefully the shit won't really hit the fan until I'm dead.

SleeplessInEngland · 18/07/2022 20:09

AtwilightRebellion · 18/07/2022 20:03

Maybe they are fed up with the hypocrisy.

I struggle to imagine anyone on this thread has properly railed against CC.

These threads are pathetic.

Pointless, and designed to make the original poster feel some sort of moral superiority in temps without AC.

“The planet’s heating up beyond repair but some people online were hypocrites so bring it on. I am very intelligent.”

AtwilightRebellion · 18/07/2022 20:03

Planetearthisscrewed · 18/07/2022 18:42

tttigress

2 days of hyped up heat, is it really that big a deal?

Are you really that thick or just trying to wind people up?

Maybe they are fed up with the hypocrisy.

I struggle to imagine anyone on this thread has properly railed against CC.

These threads are pathetic.

Pointless, and designed to make the original poster feel some sort of moral superiority in temps without AC.