Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed with MIL

290 replies

LeafHunter · 18/07/2022 13:45

DHs family always go away each year. It’s him, his four siblings and everyone’s partners and children. We’re going on 2nd august.

MIL had just text to say she’s tested positive for Covid and so has cancelled the family holiday. She said she can’t guarantee she will be testing negative by then. FIL is negative currently.

Im annoyed as we’ve booked all flights, car hire etc. PIL pay for the villa and we all pay for the rest. This is widely out of character for them.

OP posts:
Sweatinglikeabitch · 21/07/2022 14:17

No way on earth would I secretly take FILs money. Can you imagine if she found out and 1. Demanded the money back and 2. Told the whole family that you had blackmailed money off FIL and then lied to everyone and pretended it was your generosity. You'd be lucky if you didn't end up cut off from the whole family.

I'd just get what holiday you can over there and never agree to another holiday again.

NumberTheory · 21/07/2022 14:08

Blossomtoes · 21/07/2022 12:39

Pathetic that FIL would rather OP and her husband lied to the entire family than stand up to MIL

I thought one of the fundamental tenets of MN is that men should support their wives. Is there an age limit for that?

Even if MN were as one note as you imply (and it’s not quite that bad) lying to his wife and encouraging her son to do style same isn’t supporting her.

Blossomtoes · 21/07/2022 14:07

There's absolutely no way MIL wouldn't find out eventually

Isn’t there? If they have separate finances, how would she find out unless someone told her?

MrsMontyD · 21/07/2022 14:04

Blossomtoes · 21/07/2022 12:39

Pathetic that FIL would rather OP and her husband lied to the entire family than stand up to MIL

I thought one of the fundamental tenets of MN is that men should support their wives. Is there an age limit for that?

He's only supporting her to her face though, he's actually undermining her by going behind her back and plotting with his son. There's absolutely no way MIL wouldn't find out eventually, can you imagine the fallout?

His role as a supportive husband includes telling her when she's being unreasonable, in a constructive, private way.

rookiemere · 21/07/2022 14:02

It may be nothing to do with age, MIL may not be thinking clearly because she has Covid.

Liorae · 21/07/2022 14:00

Blossomtoes · 21/07/2022 12:39

Pathetic that FIL would rather OP and her husband lied to the entire family than stand up to MIL

I thought one of the fundamental tenets of MN is that men should support their wives. Is there an age limit for that?

You forget, on MN the MIL is always evil and nobody, not even her husband, is allowed to support her.

MrsMontyD · 21/07/2022 13:56

strawberrybubblegum · 18/07/2022 15:26

When people get elderly, they become more reactive, and worry about things more. They also become more narrowly focused on their own perspective, and less able to imagine the impact on other people, especially where the impact would be different for them. Eg they haven't realised that you can't afford another holiday if you lose the money from these flights, because they would have enough money to rebook something else. It seems to be a normal part of aging, and will happen to us all (if we're lucky enough to reach that age!)

Best let DH talk it through with her - and spell out the impact on you, and that you'd really like the holiday to go ahead even if there's a risk they can't come. And maybe suggest a local get-together with the ILs later in the year if they can't come (paid for by the kids). Hopefully you can un-cancel the holiday (and with luck she'll be well enough to come anyway and this will all blow over!)

Late 60s is definitely not elderly, the state retirement age is 67.

Blossomtoes · 21/07/2022 12:39

Pathetic that FIL would rather OP and her husband lied to the entire family than stand up to MIL

I thought one of the fundamental tenets of MN is that men should support their wives. Is there an age limit for that?

AllNightDiner · 21/07/2022 12:15

Pathetic that FIL would rather OP and her husband lied to the entire family than stand up to MIL and be seen to be standing up to her. I think that explains everything you need to know about the character of MIL and what this is all about. Like a pp, I'd be tempted to accept the offer and then blow the gaffe to the others and get all the crap out into the open. As time passes, it must be decreasingly likely the original booking can be salvaged though. I would try and look for silver linings. At least the whole family now has a clearer idea of what dynamics are at play here, and maybe the less well off sibling might come to see the umbilical cord of funding for the control that it most likely is.

Chilmark79 · 21/07/2022 11:48

@LeafHunter Is it possible your PIL are using Covid as a pretext, that they have other reasons for wanting or needing to cancel but are pulling the Covid card? There’s something in the way you describe this- a narrative that doesn’t hold water being stuck to even as it unravels- that sounds like a No10 damage limitation operation.
I am sorry about the stress all of this is causing to you and your extended family, it does sound exhausting and unnecessary.

godmum56 · 21/07/2022 10:47

ThePumpkinPatch · 20/07/2022 14:42

@LeafHunter I must admit though, I'm very shocked that you'd willingly turn down FIL's offer and forfeit everyone's holiday (inc. 5 children who some of, or possibly all, will have been counting down the sleeps to and been very excited for) just because you don't want to tell a little white lie about who paid.

You mentioned earlier that there's at least two couples who will almost certainly not be able to afford a holiday otherwise, so what about them? Surely telling a small, ultimately meaningless lie in order to reinstate holidays for 5 children and 2+ couples on a low income, is a small price to pay? Is it not?

Don't get me wrong, I admire principles and despise lying at the best of times but this is one of those times where it needs to be done for the greater good of all.

Its not a white lie. That kind of thing has a way of coming back and biting you on the bum. Its a lot of money to say that you suddenly found from nowhere, also Mil has only got to get the truth out of fil for the shit to hit the fan. I honestly don't see why fil cannot just man up and say that he will be paying anyway, they are sorry to miss the holiday but there will be other times yadda yadda.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 21/07/2022 09:55

You MIL cancelled becuase she doesn't want you all to go on the holiday without her, and for her to miss out. She's being incredibly selfish.
Go, pay for a villa just for your family, and enjoy the holiday. I wouldn't be booking with them again.

Affyhuss · 21/07/2022 09:53

Hi could you not ring the villa and revoke the cancellation

MrsMontyD · 21/07/2022 09:25

My exMIL likes to be the matriarch, always trying to be in charge, even at events she hasn't organised, which would have been done right in the first place if she had - you get the picture.

She would never have done this, if she couldn't go she'd have cried the whole time we were away and been on the phone constantly (amazed adults were coping without her) but she would 100% still have paid for the villa. Her grandchildren getting a holiday would be the main priority.

This is extreme, narcissistic actually thinking the whole thing revolves around her.

Lobelia123 · 21/07/2022 08:54

Yeah this is a controlling tantrum on your MILs part....the arrogance is breathtaking - if she cant go....no one can go. Its a power play for sure. Stuff all your airline tickets, car rental hire and leave booked etc! i dont think its an answer to go the route your FIL suggested either as then you'll draw her anger by allowing the holiday to go ahead without her. If it were me, Id try to rebook somewhere close where your tickets etc will still get you - those who can join you are welcome. I would also probably be very wary of ever accepting a holiday invitation from her again. She's gotten very used to calling the shots and seems absolutely oblivious to the losses her children will sustain because of her selfishness.

PrincessNutella · 21/07/2022 08:53

Very selfish of her!

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 20/07/2022 15:43

Blossomtoes · 20/07/2022 10:33

Yes, incredibly selfless accepting free holidays in a villa with a pool for ten years.

Well that's not the ops fault is it seeing as this would have been her first holiday with them

rookiemere · 20/07/2022 15:08

@ThePumpkinPatch I can totally see why OP
And her DH wouldn't get involved in FILs lie.

MIL isn't thinking straight. Even if he did handover the money, who's to say MIL wouldn't ask for it back.

It's a messy situation and no way would I be picking up the reins on it.

Best thing OP can do is salvage their own holiday.

ChimChimeny · 20/07/2022 15:03

If you read the thread you will see that PIL paid for those flights.

Paid for the (single parent?) SIL with DC under 5 flights, there is another low income sibling who presumably will still be out of pocket

Meraas · 20/07/2022 15:00

ThePumpkinPatch · 20/07/2022 14:46

Oh and the 2+ low income couples will no doubt have paid for flights which won't be refundable under these circumstances! That loss will be a HELL of a lot more devastating for them than (by your own admission) it is for you

If you read the thread you will see that PIL paid for those flights.

ThePumpkinPatch · 20/07/2022 14:46

Oh and the 2+ low income couples will no doubt have paid for flights which won't be refundable under these circumstances! That loss will be a HELL of a lot more devastating for them than (by your own admission) it is for you

ThePumpkinPatch · 20/07/2022 14:42

@LeafHunter I must admit though, I'm very shocked that you'd willingly turn down FIL's offer and forfeit everyone's holiday (inc. 5 children who some of, or possibly all, will have been counting down the sleeps to and been very excited for) just because you don't want to tell a little white lie about who paid.

You mentioned earlier that there's at least two couples who will almost certainly not be able to afford a holiday otherwise, so what about them? Surely telling a small, ultimately meaningless lie in order to reinstate holidays for 5 children and 2+ couples on a low income, is a small price to pay? Is it not?

Don't get me wrong, I admire principles and despise lying at the best of times but this is one of those times where it needs to be done for the greater good of all.

eastegg · 20/07/2022 14:19

I haven’t rtft OP, but all this talk of not being able to guarantee she’ll test negative really annoys me! I mean her annoying me, not you!

She needs to take a deep breath. This notion of having to test negative in order to be able to do stuff is causing confusion. Back in the mists of time when I had Covid (2020), you were specifically told not to test for 3 months afterwards because you were likely to be shedding virus and therefore test positive even though you were way past being infectious. For situations where you had to prove you were safe ie Covid pass events etc, showing that you had tested positive in the last 6 months was deemed sufficient.

Then testing on day 5 and 6 to get released from isolation came in. Some people seem to have got hold of the idea that you have to test negative to show you haven’t ‘got it’ anymore. It riles me to a surprising degree!

I’m pretty sure that MIL would not need to test negative in order to go on this holiday. Either there will be no testing, or she will get round it by showing that she has tested positive more than 10 days ago. If that weren’t the case, then I think that would mean the regime is more restrictive than it was 2 years ago! She needs to get a grip and look at what the rules for the airline actually say, or at least she should have done! Ridiculous to cancel everything.

ThePumpkinPatch · 20/07/2022 14:13

Yeah, I'd be going NC with them over this. Utterly, utterly unacceptable and selfish

MargotChateau · 20/07/2022 14:03

@Blossomtoes my in laws could offer me a holiday to the moon and it would still be a chore because they are bloody hard going. The mil doesn’t have to martyr herself and pay for these holidays, she is paying for them because rather than the humble U.K. holiday the children could afford ( and would rather do) she’d rather go somewhere posh and as such she pays for it.

However her children, spouses and grandchildren are all out a holiday because they can’t get a refund on their flights like the PILs, have now wasted their annual leave, and now have no holiday as a result.

It was the Mils choice to take over and control the holidays and pay for something grander than the others can afford themselves, she should have let everyone go on without her since the others can’t get their money back or change their annual leave.
I’d never go on holiday with her again and seriously cut down on contact after this chaos if she were my mil.

Swipe left for the next trending thread