Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed by the 'in my day' comments

116 replies

Citycat1 · 18/07/2022 13:42

I'm 40, and it seems I am encountering more and more comments from people above 60 saying life was so different 'in their day'

Examples:
L.A issue a heat warning on FB. Relative starts a rather negative reply about how in their day, in the summer of '76 they used common sense. Yes, I get it, and I LOVE the heat, but there are many vulnerable people that may suffer or end up in a&e and the NHS is put under strain. I'm thinking frail elderly as one example group. So I cab see why warnings are in place.

My DD currently has chicken pox. I ask a lady (staff in boots) for some zinc oxide cream. She says there's no calamine lotion. I explain politely that actually that's not recommended anymore as it dries the skin and makes itching worse. I get 'in my day it was fine' and a roll of the eyes.

My mum regularly tells me how things in the 70's were so much better. I'm sure some things were....but some were not. And to berate my whole generation because you don't understand the next one is belittling.

I'm sure it happens in each generation but it just irks me. Or AIBU and things really were better 'in their day ?

OP posts:
RollerPolarBear · 18/07/2022 15:15

Interesting thought though - if it was easier for the “boomer” generation as is often claimed on here then does that mean they have more justification to say things overall were better in their day?

SherwoodForest · 18/07/2022 15:15

I'm one of the older people here and lots of things are definitely better now, though there are a few things that are worse.
Politics is worse - when I was young we were going into the EU and now we have sadly left it.

StopStartStop · 18/07/2022 15:11

@sweeneytoddsrazor
Any application of the term 'boomer' is unacceptable.

StopStartStop · 18/07/2022 15:10

In my day, cheeky whippersnappers were sent to their room without supper. Off you go. No arguments.

You're the age of my dd. And five years younger than my love-interest. Am I supposed to take you seriously? 😂

sweeneytoddsrazor · 18/07/2022 15:09

I see many many comments on here about how easy it was for the boomer generation? Are they acceptable?

TheGraceFace · 18/07/2022 15:08

Harridance · 18/07/2022 13:45

Or when people say music was better, bollocks, there's good music in every decade

There really isn’t.

Of course things were better for them, they had their youth & nothing will beat that feeling.

MarshaMelrose · 18/07/2022 15:07

Lucienandjean · 18/07/2022 14:53

I'm going to keep my lip zipped and just wait for the OP to turn into a "daft gammon" in a couple of decades' time.

Every generation of parents does their best for their children. They follow the up to date advice. That advice changes over time; sometimes it even changes back again.

I remember the days of go to work on an egg. Eggs were regarded as a good food. Then they became the devils food. They'll give you cholesterol and kill you. Now were back to they're great and actually a healthy power-pack.

Low fat diets were de rigueur. Now, the wheel is turning and scientists are moving against that. Carbs were healthy for diabetes sufferers, now the advice is to cut carbs. It's very confusing to know what to believe.

RollerPolarBear · 18/07/2022 15:06

Same shit but different really, it’s not ok to call someone a “snowflake” or a “gammon”. On bonfire night, DD’s guide troup made them wear gloves and stick their sparkler in a carrot, would have preferred it if the guide leader had been able to make an assumption they’d all seen a safety advert.

Amandamandamoo · 18/07/2022 15:03

I don’t know. It’s daft to think no times could ever be better than others. I mean on this thread we have people saying music today is just as good as it’s ever been. Really? The two decades in which Justin Bieber, Taylor Swift, Cardi B and One direction have been the most popular groups were better than the two decades that brought you the birth of Rocknroll, Elvis, The Beatles, Chuck Berry, The stones, Hendrix as well as old guys like Sinatra? I mean cmon, the old times were obviously much better in that regard. That’s true in many instances.

Then there’s changes that some like and others don’t. For instance when I used to work in a supermarket If often here older (not that old though) ladies complain about women in managerial positions or else someone’s daughter working too much etc, for them the new times were a drag because they enjoyed that kind of family life so probably so many broken families and two parents working does seem much worse. Then there are the other women of their generation who weren’t fulfilled in that time who probably wish they were born later.

Its not as simple as all generations say that about the next at all.

SirChenjins · 18/07/2022 15:01

Citycat1 · 18/07/2022 14:59

@AnybodyAnywhere thank you. It's not that any generation is better or worse. Just things are different. I can already see how different things are for my children. I need to educate myself on some things eg social media. No idea about tik tok for example. But I'm not thinking 'well in my day we didn't have this' I'm just thinking 'well this is different, let's get clued up on it'

You might be surprised to know that many people over 60 think just the same way as you Wink

Citycat1 · 18/07/2022 14:59

@AnybodyAnywhere thank you. It's not that any generation is better or worse. Just things are different. I can already see how different things are for my children. I need to educate myself on some things eg social media. No idea about tik tok for example. But I'm not thinking 'well in my day we didn't have this' I'm just thinking 'well this is different, let's get clued up on it'

OP posts:
Butteryflakycrust83 · 18/07/2022 14:59

My favourite tweet this week:

'Anyone around from the 1976 heatwave who can tell us how they coped with it? I bet it was probably by catching nits, playing on train tracks and drinking mercury or something? They could just deal with it then. Not like kids these days who have vegan smartphones for hands.'

MarshaMelrose · 18/07/2022 14:58

There was still poverty and people did things we now know not to do - like sunbathing while sitting on tinfoil in the park, or dunking the baby's dummy in advocaat to make it sleep. Although that last one might have just been my nan!

😂😂😂

There's still poverty and people still sunbathe even though now they know not to. Although I'm not sure how many of them slather the homemade mixture of olive oil and vinegar over their legs to make them fry like my school mates and I used to do!

Silverswirl · 18/07/2022 14:58

Totally annoys me too- I get the ‘I put you and your siblings on your side and you rolled around the car with no car seat and you turned out ok’
BUT
I wonder what the next generation will be looking back with horror at us for and will you be able to resist the ‘we did it in my day’ comments when you are 70.
Imagine if putting your baby in a sling is a complete health risk and no one would ever do it, You never take a child under 1 swimming due to health issues, it’s dangerous to put babies to sleep on their backs and now side sleeping is best, pregnant women should never drink milk or eat wheat, sleeping bags / gro bags are a total no, disposable nappies are completely banned and people 30 years on from now simply can’t comprehend that we ever used them, babies were fed on a strict schedule as new research shows feeding on demand is actually not the best for baby long term at all. Young children should never be baby led weaned and what the hell were we all thinking giving them non mushed / puréed foods before the age of 1.
Just could be anything. Let’s see if you resist in 30 years. I hope I do!

AnybodyAnywhere · 18/07/2022 14:55

I’m 67 and I agree with you OP.

I belong to several ‘older People’s’ FB groups and am always pointing out that the World has moved on and things are different now…..not better, not worse, just different. We used to get the same old bollocks from our elders in the 1960/70s and we should have learned from that 🤷🏻‍♀️

Lucienandjean · 18/07/2022 14:53

I'm going to keep my lip zipped and just wait for the OP to turn into a "daft gammon" in a couple of decades' time.

Every generation of parents does their best for their children. They follow the up to date advice. That advice changes over time; sometimes it even changes back again.

ImAvingOops · 18/07/2022 14:44

Calamine was okay when it first went on but I don't recall it doing much for my itching when I was a kid and had chicken pox. Antihistamine is probably more use, along with lots of cool showers. Zinc oxide is for nappy rash so probably would be quite good too.

Some things were better in the past - we had less of a consumer, wasteful culture, chocolate was better, you didn't need 2 salaries just to pay a mortgage but many things were worse. There was still poverty and people did things we now know not to do - like sunbathing while sitting on tinfoil in the park, or dunking the baby's dummy in advocaat to make it sleep. Although that last one might have just been my nan!

MarshaMelrose · 18/07/2022 14:44

Citycat1 · 18/07/2022 13:58

@sirchenjins because many things were bloody awful. Shipping kids to Australia, sexual abuse to children, stiff upper lip sentiment, ignorance to so much, not as much medical advances, strikes, power cuts, war etc. It wasn't 'better' just as hard as it is now. Just the next generation is handling things differently. Yet that seems to get eyes rolling from certain people. Why? I don't understand.

I'm an over 60 and I can assure you that no one ever thought that sexual abuse was OK.
During covid a bit more stiff upper lip and just get on with it rather than the hysteria I saw on MN might actually have helped people more.
Of course there were medical advances. The life my mum had as a young mother was totally different to what her mother had had. The services available to me as a child were infinitely better than those she'd had before the nhs was formed. Would I rather have medical treatment available now to that of the 60s. 100% yes. But would I rather have had what was available in the 60s to wait was in the 30s? Too right I would. The only reason we have so many medical advances now is because of the medical advances in the past to build on. Standing on the shoulders of giants and all that.
Strikes? True, we did have rail strikes - I mean, that could never happen today.
War? That's right zippo wars today. (Psst, don't mention Ukraine)

I grew up in the 60s and 70s. It wasn't some sort of dark ages. Cue roll of eyes. 🙄

Citycat1 · 18/07/2022 14:44

I didn’t say it’s what all over 60’s do. Not at all, and I don’t think that at all. But the comments do come from the over 60’s that I receive. Not my age. I work in a hospital, I love to sit and chat to all generations. Many don’t have the blinkers on about ‘in my day’ but those that do just come across as belittling and I think it’s annoying and sad too.

OP posts:
SpeckofDustUponMySoul · 18/07/2022 14:41

OP, bookmark this post and come back when you are 60+.
Maybe you will feel differently.
I have different world views at 43 than I did at 23. I imagine I'll be thinking (if not saying "in my day").
🤷

dannydyerismydad · 18/07/2022 14:41

DH claims the music was better in the 90's.

After forcing him to sit through several classic episodes of Top of the Pops he agrees he was wrong. The indie bands he remains fond of were a tiny part of the music scene.

Speedweed · 18/07/2022 14:40

A lot of it is silly (comparing today's temp to 1976 for example), but sometimes it's useful to remind myself when I'm stressing about some aspect of baby care and getting it right, that some crazy, unsafe stuff was done by previous generations and babies still survived, so I can cut myself some slack.

FunnysInLaJardin · 18/07/2022 14:40

oviraptor21 · 18/07/2022 14:33

I'd argue it's a whole load worse now for teenagers.
I'm so glad mine have navigated through the teenage years just about unscathed.
I blame social media.

'social media' has been great for my boys. It meant that in particular during lockdown they could chat to their mates and play games together.

They would have been very lonely without it.

Perfumbaby · 18/07/2022 14:40

What makes me laugh is the 60yr+ eye rolling about any heatwave thesedays and talk about '76 where 'people got on with it'.

.......except they didn't get on with it did they? I've heard about the 1976 heatwave every single summer - from as old as I can remember. So for nearly 50yrs that generation has been dining out on that 'hot' summer story, which is the exact opposite of 'getting on with it'!

Cookie79 · 18/07/2022 14:39

I had an “in my day” comment from one of DH’s relatives from DD was tiny and had just horrendous reflux.

I said well Aunty [name] thank goodness it’s my day and parents are listened to when they know there’s something wrong with their child. It just have been awful for you back then. Took her aback a bit and then she agreed.

I’m not usually so quick witted.