Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm shocked at this picture in the news..

186 replies

AppelFrench · 18/07/2022 13:38

A Queen's guard being given water. Can you imagine wearing a wool jacket & bearskin hat in this heat? This uniform needs rethinking for extreme heat.

I'm shocked at this picture in the news..
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
antelopevalley · 20/07/2022 11:52

Black tights are ridiculous. PPE is different as that has a practical reason.

mybiggestfan · 20/07/2022 11:04

MY friend district nurse has to wear full uniform including black tights not allowed to go bare legged. This and wearing a mask too.

antelopevalley · 20/07/2022 10:18

Snaketime · 20/07/2022 09:32

I have to ask how many of you went out for a meal at a pub or restaurant or ordered a take away during this weather?

This is not the gotcha you think it is.
This guard was performing essentially for the tourists. There was zero practical reason to have him wearing this hat in a heatwave. If it was just about security he could stand there with the hat off. But he had to keep his hat on so tourists could take photos.
That is what is inhuman.

Blossomtoes · 20/07/2022 10:12

I know what it means, thanks

In which case you’ll also know you used it incorrectly.

The monarchy is supposed to be represent our values and our morales

How is that even possible when everyone’s are different? As to consequences in the Queen’s lifetime - you do know she’s 96, don’t you? Are you seriously suggesting putting a nonagenarian up against the wall? 😂

Snaketime · 20/07/2022 09:32

I have to ask how many of you went out for a meal at a pub or restaurant or ordered a take away during this weather?

fyn · 20/07/2022 09:21

@cakeorwine I think you miss the point though. Soldiers go out and do their duty whatever the conditions. They’d be no use if they turned up in Mali or Somalia and hadn’t got the endurance to be there. They’d put themselves and others in danger.

All of our neighbours on the patch were out running with their weighted day sacks yesterday. They go out whatever the weather.

Darlingx · 20/07/2022 08:17

The Queen having her money invested offshore for tax avoidance purposes all perfectly legal would have been legal advice for further wealth enrichment even to one representing their Commonwealth

but when I saw the
The Storyville Documentary -Dark Secrets of a Trillion Dollar Island – Garenne

It put a whole new perspective on all the Pomp and Ceremony to add Grandeur to Power and that someone actually tried to honestly do his job as an MP representing his community . It was all the Ceremonies and costumes that united those above questioning that just swept any casualties under the rug. Those needing to be questioned were literally dressed in Ermine robes and Gold Medallions representing the Crown by that costume as being beyond reproach . So to me such costumes are to dehumanise or idolise false narratives. See the human beyond the costume. All the gold and the fur it’s an outdated fetish of power. It’s all Ceremony and symbolic though I suppose to wear a Bear’s skin. I don’t think wearing a mono fibre version is the answer or unquestioning duty.

Dark Secrets of a Trillion Dollar Island – Garenne
10pm, BBC Four

The complex story of Jersey’s historical child sexual abuse claims is unpicked in this fascinating documentary. In 2007, a media frenzy was caused by the discovery of abuse on the island, drawing attention to its status as a possession of the crown and offshore tax haven. The scandal split the community into those who wanted to preserve Jersey’s reputation for investment purposes and those wishing to uncover the truth.

cakeorwine · 20/07/2022 08:03

summerin69 · 20/07/2022 07:55

Aren't they meant to be in the armed forces? Wouldn't they be expected to tolerate much worse than this in war conditions? I would imagine they have measures in place for dealing with this and have briefed their guards. The optics don't look good I agree - but neither do photos of hundreds of people crowded on a beach, with nowhere to pee, frying under a baking sun.

Difference between having to tolerate it in war conditions and having to tolerate it because of tradition?

Maybe they do have precautions in place?
Maybe they have carried out a full health and safety assessment and taken appropriate steps to reduce the risk to the individual.

summerin69 · 20/07/2022 07:55

Aren't they meant to be in the armed forces? Wouldn't they be expected to tolerate much worse than this in war conditions? I would imagine they have measures in place for dealing with this and have briefed their guards. The optics don't look good I agree - but neither do photos of hundreds of people crowded on a beach, with nowhere to pee, frying under a baking sun.

cakeorwine · 20/07/2022 07:36

Softplayhooray · 20/07/2022 06:51

Making that man stand in the heat in that get up risked his health for no good reason, whatsoever. Honestly the pomp and ceremony around the Royals is ludicrous. And Charles the other day saying he'd warned everyone for years already about climate change and kind of bitterly laughing as he said it. The arrogance that it might not have occurred to millions of us, too is staggering. The monarchy needs to be wound up and their massive wealth put to better use.

No good reason
Exactly

Fighting in Afghanistan - a good reason to risk your health

But standing on guard in full uniform. Not a good reason. I am sure few people would have objected if a different more appopriate uniform was worn on hot days.

But a soldier's lot is not to reason why? Just to obey without questioning orders.

As Sergeant Wilson would say "Is this wise. Sir?"

Softplayhooray · 20/07/2022 06:51

AppelFrench · 18/07/2022 13:38

A Queen's guard being given water. Can you imagine wearing a wool jacket & bearskin hat in this heat? This uniform needs rethinking for extreme heat.

Making that man stand in the heat in that get up risked his health for no good reason, whatsoever. Honestly the pomp and ceremony around the Royals is ludicrous. And Charles the other day saying he'd warned everyone for years already about climate change and kind of bitterly laughing as he said it. The arrogance that it might not have occurred to millions of us, too is staggering. The monarchy needs to be wound up and their massive wealth put to better use.

Givemethereins · 20/07/2022 06:30

Absolutely!

The monarchy is supposed to be represent our values and our morales. They are supposed to represent civil service and holding their country before themselves.

Yet the Queen herself has been found to be hoarding and hiding huge wealth, goong back generations!
Demanding that her and all her estates are left out of important laws and regulations meant to bring buildings upto energy standards and hundreds of other laws!?

Wtf. And now most recently, getting away with wildlife killings of endangered animals fully assuming they have a right to live outside the law.

They have zero morales, zero duty to country and the Queen herself is lawless and rebranding it all as somehow acceptable for them. It's all been a bunch of lies.

They're has to be consequences for this family for these outrages 😠
And preferably in the Queen's lifetime.

sashh · 20/07/2022 06:13

MrsLargeEmbodied · 18/07/2022 14:10

i doubt it is bear skin nowadays

It is. They have tried synthetic fur and it doesn't work for some reason.

I hope he has slowly melting ice under the hat.

I think a faux fur hat would be much hotter.

Darlingx · 20/07/2022 04:43

Something that surprised me The Prince of Wales cannot understand Welsh. Wouldn’t it be more fitting if he had bothered. I was listening to a programme on Welsh Independence he couldn’t understand what the protesters were uttering as he couldn’t understand Welsh.
Personally the Guards are in a status position I knew someone who rode exercised their horses in the early hours each day and its quite an Elite fixture they have balls as in society dances and mingle with a certain strata so that hat represents as bizarre as it looks rather like Ermine Cloaks and Crowns and bending the knee a certain standing .
Rather like waving from carriages I feel all the fairytale princesses ended up miserable with their Princes anyway yet they still fell for that Disney story. It’s all a golden cage rather like all the illusions of glamour if you can be bothered with all the pomp.
Diana walking through an area of landmines that must have been a thorn and I had never realised we are not a nation of shopkeepers we are Arms dealers . It’s our largest export . Not finance Arms that’s why this little Island has it’s power which is currently waning .
So as Arms dealers we need all the illusions of heraldic romance

Mothership4two · 20/07/2022 01:40

If they have to continue wearing the full get up, then they should only be out there for minutes to prevent heat-stroke. Like the full costumed staff at Disneyland and Disneyworld US.

Outsideswimbabe · 19/07/2022 23:49

You are right. Also Armed Forces train to be able to withstand all kinds of unpleasant discomforts to protect this country.

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 19/07/2022 23:38

Yanbu. Those hats are made from actual dead bear as well. Illegal for anyone else to import but a special exemption allows it for this purpose. Horrible.

McClaire · 19/07/2022 23:34

Do you never have leather?

Chocolatehamper · 19/07/2022 21:28

ihatethefuckingmuffin · 18/07/2022 14:04

I hit this moment a long time ago when learning more about the potato famine in Ireland. People in dire poverty and the then Queen pops over, not to help them, but to lift their spirits.

There was never a ‘famine’ - the rich, prosperous land was taken from Irish landowners and given to the British landowners or rich Irish families loyal to the crown. The Irish were left to feed their families on a meagre few square feet of land and when the crop failed, as it was the mainstay and normally most productive crop to feed many, they starved. The rich landowners still expected their rents for land that couldn’t sustain people.

Unfortunately, the truth behind the ‘Irish problem’ is not taught in English schools so the vast majority see the issue in Northern Ireland etc as terrorists but don’t know the hundreds of years of hurt and history behind it.

As they say, ignorance is bliss!

Pleezgivemestrength · 19/07/2022 21:15

Hmmm. Just think president Putin, or would you prefer Macron. Both disasters. You want to sweep our history under the carpet, because of jealousy of anyone in this country who has more money than you. That's not being gullible, that's realising what an asset the royal family is to this country. For those young men, guarding our Queen in traditions that go back centuries is a great honour.

dudsville · 19/07/2022 21:05

GreenManalishi · 18/07/2022 13:44

This is what you can get people to do when you've got all the money.

Yup

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 19/07/2022 21:03

Blossomtoes · 19/07/2022 20:25

I don’t think you understand what draconian means. Or that the sentries are members of the British Army and would still be there regardless of whether we had a monarchy or were a republic.

I know what it means, thanks

cakeorwine · 19/07/2022 20:30

I wonder if there is no culture of complaining.

Would they go back in and tell their CO that it was really hot under there and he almost fainted?

Or do they just have to take it?

Because that's what you do in the Army...

I know that there have been heatstroke deaths during training in other regiments.

Still, looks good and of course, we have tradition.

Being in a war zone is different. It does matter if you can't do your job in the heat as you have a vital job to do.

In a heatwave - the job can still get done but some accommodation could be made as it's not a matter of life or death that they wear such a uniform in the heat.

StoneofDestiny · 19/07/2022 20:30

If you want us to get rid of royal family. Who btw is a bargain at a couple of pounds per person to maintain

Cant believe anyone actually believes that. Shame on you for being so gullible!.

Blossomtoes · 19/07/2022 20:25

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 19/07/2022 20:08

The whole system is outdated and draconian, monarchy needs to go.

I don’t think you understand what draconian means. Or that the sentries are members of the British Army and would still be there regardless of whether we had a monarchy or were a republic.