Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The NHS is not living with COVID, it's dying from it

118 replies

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 18/07/2022 13:26

Most people (including many in the NHS) are so tired of it that they are wilfully pushing it to the back of their minds, but now is the time to face the fact that the nation’s attempt to “live with covid” is the straw that is breaking the NHS’s back.

In 2020 and 2021 the NHS coped with pandemic peaks by stopping or slowing much of its routine work. 2022 was meant to be the year of full speed recovery, when we would build back better and fairer, when record waiting lists in elective care, cancer diagnosis and treatment, and mental health would begin to reduce, and the workload on primary care would begin to ease.
…
Above all, the government must stop gaslighting the public and be honest about the threat the pandemic still poses to them and the NHS. Being honest with the public will have two positive results, it will encourage the public to modify behaviour and, we hope, provoke urgent reflection about how the NHS is in such a mess so soon after the nation was applauding it on their doorsteps.

Joint editorial from major Health Services journal and the BMJ. Free to read: www.hsj.co.uk/coronavirus/the-nhs-is-not-living-with-covid-its-dying-from-it/7032824.article

What measures would you be prepared to support to get the NHS back to some form of functioning for everyone who needs it for non-COVID reasons?

OP posts:
munchbunch12 · 19/07/2022 10:04

110APiccadilly · 19/07/2022 07:01

The NHS exists to help us, not the other way round. If it can't deal with us living normal lives, it has to be changed, not our lives. That's the bottom line.

This, 100%! We should be able to do normal, not particularly dangerous things, like work, go to school, shopping, hell, maybe even do something fun like go to a pub or the theatre without the NHS buckling under the pressure!

TheSummerPalace · 19/07/2022 09:56

*Exactly how is the Government supposed to increase pay and working conditions for social care to try and encourage more people to work in the area ?

It is predominantly a privatised industry, so surely the only thing the Government could do at the moment, would be to raise the minimum wage ?*

They could give more ring fenced funding to local authorities for Social Services. It’s Social Services that impose discounted fees on care homes, by virtue of their mass purchasing power. If Social Services were willing to allow care homes to charge reasonable amounts, to cover costs and some, then they could pay their staff more.

IMO, there should be no profit in the provision of care, because all it does is take taxpayers’ money out of the care system, to pay dividends to shareholders. There needs to be a national system of care, to enable more planning to meet needs - it shouldn’t be left to the vagaries of the private sector. A national care service could ensure decent pay and training for care staff.

I would look at how the German system works, with an additional social care levy on wages. It’s probably not perfect, but it sounds better than what we have!

ApplesandBunions · 19/07/2022 09:25

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 19/07/2022 09:14

So they're no worse than everyone else who strangely can't quite cost up options for what must seem like simple decisions, especially if you have no constructive or practical options either, only at best partially informed basic level questions.

I consider that the editors of both journals, and the Chief Editor of the BMJ Group in particular, have access to a wide range of expertise and would be better placed than most to provide a starter for 10.

They've requested discussion and reflection that involves the public. This is a discussion that involves the public. There are obviously several contributors here who work within the NHS and who provide their perspective and that's helpful. I'll be interested to see if there are emerging themes both about their suggested measures and COVID-19 and their wider points about the NHS.

Additionally, nobody is forcing anyone to write articles in the BMJ and most people in this discussion are not doing so. Recommending a return to measures that have already failed and suggesting they're actually going to do anything to assist the situation in the NHS now, providing no evidence at all and not even deigning to acknowledge that restrictions have downsides too, is a choice.

MsFrenchie · 19/07/2022 09:25

Topgub · 18/07/2022 13:33

Massively increasing funding and staffing levels and pay.

Massively increasing funding for social care and staffing levels and pay for those in social care

That's what we need to fix the nhs.

The covid response exacerbated an existing problem.

What tax changes would you propose to cover this? Complete removal of the personal allowance and raising the basic rate to 30%?

Or maybe we pick only one of these and knock 20% off the state pension, and stop all in-work benefits.

We spend £140 billion a year now, and the country is getting further into debt every year, borrowing ever more to fund it.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 19/07/2022 09:14

So they're no worse than everyone else who strangely can't quite cost up options for what must seem like simple decisions, especially if you have no constructive or practical options either, only at best partially informed basic level questions.

I consider that the editors of both journals, and the Chief Editor of the BMJ Group in particular, have access to a wide range of expertise and would be better placed than most to provide a starter for 10.

They've requested discussion and reflection that involves the public. This is a discussion that involves the public. There are obviously several contributors here who work within the NHS and who provide their perspective and that's helpful. I'll be interested to see if there are emerging themes both about their suggested measures and COVID-19 and their wider points about the NHS.

OP posts:
EllisActon · 19/07/2022 09:03

I have just spent weeks in NHS hospital following a brain bleed then stroke.....I was not overweight or anything...o had blood pressure taken once a day not even basic teeth cleaning and NO therapy. Was sent home with no care plan or therapy in place and it took me over an hour to write this

NHS is not only broken it does not work!

ApplesandBunions · 19/07/2022 08:29

GabriellaMontez · 19/07/2022 08:22

The health, social and economic consequences of restrictions are not even mentioned. Let alone explored thoroughly.

Pretending they don't exist. This is as bad as what they accused the government of. The writers have no credibility in my eyes.

Yes, it's an inherently untrustworthy take.

BirmaBrite · 19/07/2022 08:24

Exactly how is the Government supposed to increase pay and working conditions for social care to try and encourage more people to work in the area ?
It is predominantly a privatised industry, so surely the only thing the Government could do at the moment, would be to raise the minimum wage ?

Social care provision or the distinct lack of it at present, is having a huge knock on effect on the NHS's ability to function.

GabriellaMontez · 19/07/2022 08:22

The health, social and economic consequences of restrictions are not even mentioned. Let alone explored thoroughly.

Pretending they don't exist. This is as bad as what they accused the government of. The writers have no credibility in my eyes.

TheKeatingFive · 19/07/2022 07:40

Well unlike you I have no fear whatsoever of the BMJ and HSJ getting any airspace or headspace with the Govt.

Well there is that. It's still pretty presumptuous however.

Incidentally the NHS is not the BMJ or HSJ any more than you are whatever your trade rag is.

I for one never said it was

Do you find that rattling the bars of an open cage gets exhausting?

Its a discussion forum. I'm reacting to a post. If I found it exhausting I wouldn't be here.

Icedbannoffee · 19/07/2022 07:29

110APiccadilly · 19/07/2022 07:01

The NHS exists to help us, not the other way round. If it can't deal with us living normal lives, it has to be changed, not our lives. That's the bottom line.

Surely it should be both, people should also take some responsibility for their health instead of expecting the health service to pick up the pieces. I know it's not always that easy so think preventative initiatives and support in the community should be more heavily invested in.

110APiccadilly · 19/07/2022 07:01

The NHS exists to help us, not the other way round. If it can't deal with us living normal lives, it has to be changed, not our lives. That's the bottom line.

Justrealised · 19/07/2022 06:48

There is too much bureaucracy in the nhs. Too many high paid posts that aren't really needed.

I'd rather bring restrictions in than limit service to those deserving or who qualify. I'm conscious that if the nhs isn't free at point of access or people start being shamed then others will not go and won't get the help they need. I don't think there are enough covid restrictions that could be brought in now to save the nhs.

I would wear a mask again if it helped and i would/ do vaccinate. Other than that I'm not sure what else could be done without seeing some businesses go under and people lose their jobs. I'd happily test also but unsure as to how this would be funded.

user1477391263 · 19/07/2022 05:40

The NHS is struggling because it's not a very well run institution, and the British population is aging every year and is increasingly fat and in poor shape.

www.hsj.co.uk/coronavirus/the-nhs-is-not-living-with-covid-its-dying-from-it/7032824.article#.YtVLStk6bv8.twitter
Going through this article:

Existing public health advice to wear masks in crowded places,
People won't do this, and masks don't seem to very effective against the highly infectious latest varients

ensure good ventilation
How, short of retrofitting every damn building? With fuel bills going the way they will this winter, there is no way you will get the public to keep the windows open all the time

and test regularly need to be communicated much more powerfully and widely.
Who's going to pay for all these free tests in the current economy?

This should include a return to mask wearing in healthcare settings and on public transport,
Go ahead then. But most spread has always happened in indoor socializing, workplaces and the home. You won't get people to wear masks there. There's never been much spread on trains and buses in the UK, probably because most Brits don't talk much there. I agree masks in hospitals are a good idea.

as well as the re-introduction of free tests for the public.
How can we possibly afford this in the present economy?

Vaccination is the fourth pillar of action. Large sections of the population, particularly ethnic minorities and younger age groups, are still not fully vaccinated.
Sure, I agree with continuing to push the vaccine. Flu vaccines too.

Other measures might include working from home when possible
People are already working from home loads--it's one of the few things that has stuck around long-term from COVID. We're probably at the practical limits of how much and what kind of work can be done remotely.

and restrictions on some types and sizes of gathering.
People aren't going to go along with this. We're facing a cost of living crisis and incredibly high levels of stress and anxiety. People NEED friends and fun right now, especially after the last two years of misery.

maryso · 18/07/2022 23:14

I disagree that wanting to implementing restrictions on other peoples businesses and livelihoods in this way is having an honest conversation. That's beyond their remit.
Well unlike you I have no fear whatsoever of the BMJ and HSJ getting any airspace or headspace with the Govt. Nobody is going back to lockdown, and even if the kill rate were to increase with another mutation, it'll take a while. Incidentally the NHS is not the BMJ or HSJ any more than you are whatever your trade rag is. Do you find that rattling the bars of an open cage gets exhausting?

It is 70 years out of date and needs to be changed.
No point banging the door of the NHS when the person you want is the Health Secretary or maybe try the PM. You'd think someone in Govt would have done something about it sometime in the last 70 years! It'd be different if they were elected... oops they have been, every single Gov for at least 70-years.

Tadpoll · 18/07/2022 23:11

Worldgonecrazy · 18/07/2022 13:58

Okay would like to see much greater emphasis on prevention. That would require massive societal changes though, including focus on not only poverty, but mental health, and modern messaging from on-high.

The government were very willing to use manipulation to manage behaviour in lockdown. They should apply the same expertise to make positive societal changes and encourage self care where possible, freeing up the NHS resource for non preventable illness and injury.

Yes, this.

Even the Dept of Health nutrition messaging is totally out of date. They need to prioritise prevention.

Also, until health professionals are adequately trained to look at patients holistically the NHS will always fail.

It is NOT about money.

Hbh17 · 18/07/2022 23:00

I think Covid may have simply exposed what has been happening for decades. Absolutely the last thing the NHS needs is more funding - it would be like pouring water into a bucket with a hole in the bottom, and many NHS staff will tell you this. It is badly managed and wasteful, and nobody takes any responsibility. It is not about individual staff, most of whom work hard, but the whole culture of the organisation.

What is needed is a Royal Commission to look at healthcare in comparable countries (France, Germany, Holland, Australia etc) and to come up with a better structure - preferably one where the population have to make some sort of contribution so that they stop taking the p**s and misusing the service. And politicians from all parties need to accept this and support this - at the moment, they are just too scared and hide behind the lie that the NHS is wonderful and must be "protected". No. It is 70 years out of date and needs to be changed.

TheKeatingFive · 18/07/2022 22:54

Like you, the editors want an honest discussion about how to proceed in the current situation. Frankly their editorial is less likely to get a response than if you raised a campaign to review the NHS.

I disagree that wanting to implementing restrictions on other peoples businesses and livelihoods in this way is having an honest conversation. That's beyond their remit.

The nhs is a public service, one among many. Like all the others we need to clarify what it should deliver and how it should be funded. Covid has put additional strains on the service, yes, and we need to figure out how that's handled, but it is up to the nhs to handle it, rather than the rest of society to restrict their enterprise so the nhs doesn't have to.

That may involve massively more funding, or it may involve scaling down services, but it's not clear at all what people want the future of the nhs to look like. None of the political parties will tackle it head on either.

JohnPrescottsPyjamas · 18/07/2022 22:49

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 18/07/2022 18:03

We need to stop keeping people with no quality of life alive just because we can.

We need to only treat people over the age of 80 if they are otherwise fit.

Hasn't Covid sort of been doing this anyway? Don’t forget, at the beginning, there was a view that we had to save absolutely everybody - even if they were very, very poorly with major underlying conditions. Even if it meant putting them in total isolation from their families for their last few months, they had to be protected.

Yes, I agree with other posters; the NHS hasn’t been fit for purpose for years. We’ve been living with covid for nearly 2.5 years now so that’s no longer an excuse. It’s definitely a combination of many factors. If it’s free, so it’s open to abuse. We’re all living longer, so more of a burden on it. Mismanagement at the top. Poor cost control, money wasted on duff computer systems etc and dire record keeping. I’ve had several instances with both DH, DM and MIL where details of diagnosises/medications issued were not even on file which resulted in wasted resources and unnecessary retesting.

maryso · 18/07/2022 22:39

We do need to talk about the nhs. But in honest terms about what we can expect it to deliver for the funding we're prepared to put into it.

Like you, the editors want an honest discussion about how to proceed in the current situation. Frankly their editorial is less likely to get a response than if you raised a campaign to review the NHS.

Tolerance has been beaten into HCPs, so pandemic controls or not, all we will do is to control hospital infection. Those who use public transport will have much higher risks, but once they're in we can control their infection risk better.

maryso · 18/07/2022 22:32

You've summed it up @endlesscraziness All we can do is maintain infection control, by being extraordinarily rigorous about turning away covid positive electives, while the fires burn outside. There'll be many more of these with the transmission rates, however patients who have restricted themselves to lower their risk should get treatment they're due.

Reinfections occur every 3 months because up to 12 weeks they don't count as reinfections! With BA5's immune escape and replication, it's like measles plus morphed with the cold, so no immunity. Very helpful for people to accelerate mutations for the greater good, but I dread to think how many tiny clots are circulating in those who are unlucky enough to succumb. Still, they're happy with the trade-off, so fair enough.

TheKeatingFive · 18/07/2022 22:25

Sure, you're asking for what they are, aren't you? To open up the box?

Is that directed at me? I'm not quite sure what you mean if so.

endlesscraziness · 18/07/2022 22:20

We're in a weird no mans land at the moment where the rest of the country is pretending COVID is no longer here but the NHS has to test staff and patients and isolate both. In order for us to properly ignore it we would have to accept it's virus that isn't seasonal and mutates like a cold so is circulating perpetually. We would have to accept that patients will get sick and die from it but that's the cost of life returning to normal. Those dying are mostly sick with other things but probably would have had a while left.

maryso · 18/07/2022 22:09

Sure, you're asking for what they are, aren't you? To open up the box?

The NHS isn't there to cheat taxpayers, it serves using what it's given, and for most of us what it's not given, too. As long as it's understood that changes resulting can be less for more or the same for more and less for the same, and not just more for less/the same. We're already substituting shortage HCPs with nurse practitioners, AI, so change isn't new.

The real blockers for you are the paymasters, not the NHS. Get them to open up, and if you find that you can reduce service levels to match the funding you're prepared to put into it, that'd be a win all round. It does seem odd that repeated Govts some extremely keen to simply cut any part of the service possible find that options range from bad to fantasy. Shame they haven't got the Gov Econ Service or the Finance Service to work it out yet. Go for it!

TheKeatingFive · 18/07/2022 21:51

Firstly they're not economists or accountants.

Well this is exactly the point.

They're not.

But they're asking for measures that will impact a wide range of businesses ability to function, require significant additional amounts of tax payers money beyond medical care, ask the impossible of workers with much worse employment rights than their own, impact people's ability to live their lives as they always have.

Massively overstepping their remit basically.

Unprecedented measures were taken in a global health emergency. These were acceptable to most in a short term situation. But as a semi permanent way of living, to hold up a service that wasn't fit for purpose to begin with. No goddamn way.

We do need to talk about the nhs. But in honest terms about what we can expect it to deliver for the funding we're prepared to put into it. It's there to serve the people, not the other way around.

Swipe left for the next trending thread