Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what will happen to food banks when

144 replies

dottypotter · 18/07/2022 12:11

Nobody has anything left to donate because they are all feeling the squeeze themselves.

It's tight for everyone and as they only rely on donations what would happen?

OP posts:
WhiteFire · 18/07/2022 22:37

oviraptor21 · 18/07/2022 15:25

I would like to see the online supermarkets set up a food donation option. I tweeted it to the Tesco twitter account who said that's a great idea - please give us your email address and phone number. Why couldn't they just pass on the feedback and get something actioned? Hasn't happened yet 🙄

You can donate with Sainsbury's, they are in partnership with Fair share. It was originally a COVID / lockdown thing but thankfully they have continued it. You can donate [as little as] a £1.

Lincslady53 · 18/07/2022 20:21

My Rotary Club, and most others in this area, have been supporting local food banks more than in previous years, since the start if lockdown when it became apparent that there was going to he an increase in food bank usage. It has been difficult as we haven't been able to hold our usual fund raising events, but we have done what we can, and will continue to help too. There are also Lion Clubs, Probus, WI, Round Table and other service associations in all towns in the country.

XenoBitch · 18/07/2022 20:13

JinCocktail · 18/07/2022 19:45

Tbf people have plenty of notice to increase their hours to pay their bills. Unemployment is very low and there are plenty of vacancies recruiting. Don't work part time and expect the government or food banks to pick up the tab.

If someone is full time and still needs FB then fair enough. I'm a single parent FT worker and can afford my bills.

Some people are unable to work and can't just increase their hours to get more pay.

TooBigForMyBoots · 18/07/2022 20:10

Mrsjayy · 18/07/2022 19:59

What about a single parent who works a 20 hour contract in the Co op because she can't get childcare or her ours increased is that a "choice "

We have more food banks than McDonalds in this country.🤯 It's a fucking travesty and is the fault of 12 years of corruption and incompetence by our Tory government.

Them and their mates are richer, the banks, despite their recklessness are fine, but some Mnetters prefer to blame the poor, mentally ill, destitute and hard working families who've been shafted.

Dicks.😡

WilmaFlintstone1 · 18/07/2022 20:08

It didn’t take long for the fake “I work in a food bank and all the users have x, y or z luxury item” to come crawling out of the woodwork did it?

Most food bank “workers” are volunteers and most users from my experience tend to be those who are vulnerable in some way. Many elderly, disabled or learning difficulties with the occasional family thrown in.

But if it suits your narrow minded agenda to think it’s all feckless shysters then rock on.

pointythings · 18/07/2022 20:01

@JinCocktail but it isn't as simple as 'get more hours', is it? And you probably know that too. People on low pay are often also on ZHC, and if they take additional work and become less available to their first employer, that employer is likely to give them fewer hours and they're no further forward. Then there's childcare - we all know how astronomically expensive that is! And lastly there is the shitshow that is UC - a system which doesn't understand that some months have two payrolls in them and therefore views the claimant as 'earning too much, cuts them off UC and they have to start a fresh claim.

It's very easy to look at it from a comfortable position of working FT and earning enough, even as a single parent (I am one too) - but a little empathy for those less fortunate goes a long way.

Mrsjayy · 18/07/2022 19:59

What about a single parent who works a 20 hour contract in the Co op because she can't get childcare or her ours increased is that a "choice "

JinCocktail · 18/07/2022 19:55

@pointythings I did say 'if someone is FT and still needs a FB then fair enough'. If someone chooses to work PT and then use a FB then yes, I am critical of that decision.

pointythings · 18/07/2022 19:52

@JinCocktail and you don't give a shiny shit about FT workers who are on low wages and paying high rents, do you? There are full time qualified nurses needing to use food banks!

Mrsjayy · 18/07/2022 19:51

I can't decide if some of these posts are taking the piss or not ! I mean just work harder seems to be the Mantra !

JinCocktail · 18/07/2022 19:45

Tbf people have plenty of notice to increase their hours to pay their bills. Unemployment is very low and there are plenty of vacancies recruiting. Don't work part time and expect the government or food banks to pick up the tab.

If someone is full time and still needs FB then fair enough. I'm a single parent FT worker and can afford my bills.

Ponderingwindow · 18/07/2022 19:41

I suspect at some point the government will step in, not necessarily because it is the right thing to do. Just to be clear, I don’t support what I am about to say, I am just pragmatic enough to recognize reality.

You can have two versions of extreme deprivation in a country. In one, the remaining wealth is extremely concentrated within a very small group. In that scenario, order is often maintained with draconian military policies and even targeted deprivation.

in a place like the uk, while there is some extreme wealth, there is also going to be a large economic upper class. To allow that group to maintain their freedoms and privilege, the economic lower classes have to be placated enough to not rebel.

Ragwort · 18/07/2022 19:35

user interesting comments ... I am involved in an independent FB and we intend to stay that way... Trussel Trust actually came to visit us and tried to get us to 'join' their network ( for a fee !) - we declined. I am sure there are lots of very well meaning volunteers at Trussel Trust but it is not a model we wish to be part of.

Ragwort · 18/07/2022 19:33

I don't think that FB volunteers are the least caring although I can appreciate it seems that way. There are so many factors as to why people use FBs and to be perfectly blunt, at least where I live, in many cases it's not because they can't afford food. We have been supporting someone at our local FB for over 12 years ... he clearly needs a lot more than a weekly food parcel but it is so hard for untrained volunteers to know exactly what to do .. there is very, very little support from Social Service and other 'agencies'. The default seems to be 'give someone a voucher for the FB' and let someone else pick up the pieces Sad

TooBigForMyBoots · 18/07/2022 19:30

What's "funny" is some of the posters on this thread are giving off about the horrendous abuse of children in Telford. Many abused children grow up to have serious MH and addiction problems.

But fuck them "junkies" at the food bank.🤔

user1471453601 · 18/07/2022 19:29

I'm not worried for tressel trust apart from wondering where exactly they are coming from.

I've had a direct debit to them for a couple of months. Recently I was told to expect their brand new news letter shortly. As well as getting an electronic version of said letter, bigging up Tressell Trust, I also got a copy through the post.

I emailed them, about a month ago. I asked how much the production of the letter cost, and what they hoped to gain from it.

I've had no response at all.

My take on the situation is that they prefer to spend money on telling those of us who already contribute to them, how wonderful they are, than to actually feed people in dire need.

I'm now about to cancel the direct debit and have sourced a local independent food bank who seem to be doing what I intend my donation to d o, feed desperate people

Blossomtoes · 18/07/2022 19:20

Isn’t it funny that the people who apparently have worked in the foodbanks are the most uncaring

It’s more shocking than funny. This thread’s just awful.

TabithaTittlemouse · 18/07/2022 19:13

Isn’t it funny that the people who apparently have worked in the foodbanks are the most uncaring.

If you don’t want to give or can’t then don’t but don’t judge those that do. That could be you in the future.

As for the poster who said about ‘junkies’, do you know their story? Do you know how they ended up where they are?

XenoBitch · 18/07/2022 19:08

Insidelaurashead · 18/07/2022 17:55

Hey, poor people, we know if you're earning below a certain amount you'll probably get Universal Credit, which you need to deal with online, and that often the phone you've had for years with its £10 a month, 12GB data is much cheaper than a laptop and broadband but HOW DARE YOU have a phone. Sure school need to contact you if DC is ill but you should sell that phone for the £20 it'll make you. I know that means you can't take that phone call about that interview for that better paid job you're trying to get but you're POOR, don't get ideas above your station.

My god. Is this attitude towards people really what we've come to. Do you think people who can afford to buy whatever they fancy for tea in Tesco are really glind to food banks?

I am on UC (have been for nearly 5 years), and the worst bit is seeing the judgemental comments from people who have no fucking clue what it is like.
Of course I have a phone... you need one to claim UC to start with. Mine is a smartphone that a relative gave me, and it has a PAYG sim in it. Other people might be tied to contracts that they had before they fell on hard times.
Of course I have flat screen TV.... that is the only TV you can buy now. Am I meant to be watching just four channels on a CRT from the 80s?
Everyone things that can comment on what you spend your money on, as it is "my tax", yet they wont reserve the same comments for other people who are also paid by taxpayers such as anyone who works for the NHS. Or the MPs who claim what I get a month on UC for their weekly expenses.

According to a lot of people that feel the need to pass judgement online... I should have sold everything I own before being allowed to claim (or the Job Centre should come and value everything in my house), that benefits are not meant to go on pet food/vet bills, that anyone on UC is not allowed on holiday ever, that I should be paid in food and energy vouchers only, that if I can budget and afford something nice for myself then it means I am getting too much money and it should be reduced.

People who come out with crap like that, and work in foodbanks, should give their damn heads a wobble. Like a PP said, they are working in such an environment to give themselves a sense of superiority.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 18/07/2022 19:03

Councils are suffering from huge deficits at the moment though.
There's much less of that kind of funding around just now.

My local council just announced another half million to local food banks while waiting for funding from central government. And I know from a friend who manages a food bank that although they do appeal for public donations, it is the money they receive from council and other sources that really keeps them afloat. They are less vulnerable to the people putting two cans of beans in the trolley at Tesco than it might appear.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 18/07/2022 18:58

you are unlikely to notice the squeeze amongst your friends if you have a high household income

That's the thing - I don't. Very average, and although I have friends who earn way more, my colleagues don't. And the other parents at DS's bog standard state primary in East London also don't. And yet they are getting new kitchens and loft extensions and going on holiday... because in reality life is ticking along just fine for most people. Ordinary people.

Ragwort · 18/07/2022 18:42

Agree TheYear - you only have to look at some of the threads on here about holidays, style and beauty etc to know that not everyone is struggling... the media likes to portray the picture that everyone is finding life extremely tough financially at the moment but that is clearly just not true. There are still lots of people able (maybe not willing) to donate to FBs.

Trainfromredhill · 18/07/2022 18:33

@TheYearOfSmallThings I think it does depend on the circles you move in. I think most people hang out with people with similar household incomes, so you are unlikely to notice the squeeze amongst your friends if you have a high household income. We were chatting to friends recently who said they may cut down eating out by 1 time a month…..that’s not exactly ‘squeezing’. I have only 1 friend who I know is struggling. I have many colleagues whom I know will struggle, but they are colleagues, not friends.

Pinotpleasure · 18/07/2022 18:30

I used to live in New Jersey and the ShopRite and Kings supermarket chains had/have an excellent scheme: when paying at the till you could ask the cashier for a (printed) token for the food bank. They were in various amounts eg. $1, $5, $10 etc. The token once paid for went directly into the till.

The food bank managers could then choose whatever was needed. Personally I found it really convenient as I didn’t have to think about what products to buy and the money went directly to the food bank.

I assume it can be used if you use a hand held device too (which I didn’t when I lived there).

TooTightFit · 18/07/2022 18:29

I don’t donate to my local FB, but I do in my original home town. Where I live now is one of the most affluent areas in the country, and I worked for a charity which dished out food bank vouchers. I met a lot of people taking the piss, whilst also slogging their local Homestart helper to exhaustion. I’m my town they can’t find staff for love nor money, and there is London 45 mins south and other bustling employment centres north, east and west.

I left my local town due to lack of work and education opportunities and I’ll happily donate to there, but not where I live because there are some seriously work shy chancers here.