Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

High school for DD 11 - private vs state

37 replies

tattyteddy · 17/07/2022 23:03

I’m probably being unreasonable but her goes….

my daughter is going to high school in September. I really want her to go to private school, however my husband is dead set on the idea she goes to the local secondary school.

my work means I have a good knowledge of the local school, they are all massive academies. They are focused on discipline, for example sending kid home if they’ve forgotten planner etc. I think the emphasis should be on nurturing. If a kid is in school that’s surely a win? My DD is good at school so not worried she will get disciplined for bad behaviour. However, the local schools are so focused on discipline that even good kids get negative points. I’ve also heard that there is a gang issue at the school.

my dh states we can’t afford it. It will be a little tight but my parents have agreed to pay half the fees. They only have two gc and want them to have the best opportunities. I just can’t seem to get over the fact she will be going yo the local state academy. She has been offered a place at local private school too. Please help me

OP posts:
tattyteddy · 17/07/2022 23:24

I agree, but I think the most important thing is for the child to be at school.

OP posts:
Lolliepoppie · 17/07/2022 23:23

I don’t see how discipline in school is a bad thing; especially in schools with bigger classes.

Its not a win to have a DC in school habitually minus the proper equipment. It often means class time is taken up sorting them out and finding them the books/pens/paper they need; impacting everyone. Encouraging personal responsibly and organisation is a vital life lesson.

tattyteddy · 17/07/2022 23:19

Paying half would mean about £7500 a year for me. I probably have about a £1000 left each month for savings etc. at present I don’t worry about going out for dinner etc or booking a holiday. Obviously, if she went to private school then of have to be more careful.

OP posts:
tattyteddy · 17/07/2022 23:15

Yes do have second child, but he’s only six. So got a few years to go. My parents could afford it and are happy to help.

OP posts:
Testina · 17/07/2022 23:14

tattyteddy · 17/07/2022 23:13

Also the job I do now is permanent, but I could earn more if I went supply. To bed honest I’m not very worried about the financial side of it.

You’re not, we know. He is. What’s not clear is if he’s being reasonable.

Testina · 17/07/2022 23:14

tattyteddy · 17/07/2022 23:11

Thanks fir the reply. when I say little tight I mean less money for holidays, treats etc.

That still doesn’t really tell us anything.
So at your usual level of saving, with your usual holidays and treats spending, how much do you save a month? And how much would your 50% of the school fees be?

Blizzardbeach · 17/07/2022 23:13

To be honest, I think you need to try and separate the wants of you and your DH, and really weigh up your DDs personality and what it is she needs.
If the disciplinarian way that your local school uses, is going to upset DD, and hinder her chances of success, then obviously the more nurturing school is going to be a better fit. DDs school was chosen because it was a nurturing school, had most of the intake from her primary, and also rivalled the private schools in the area in terms of academic prospects. They start their GCSES early in DDs school and a few of the teachers have scared the life out of her with threats to the whole class. What I'm trying to say is the approach of a school can really make or break the success of its students if they don't cope with the hard line approach.

As a side note, the privately educated people I know had better opportunities, we're taught in a different way it seemed, but aren't necessarily any more successful than the people I know who are state educated, but they do tend to have better connections stemming from their private school days.

I can see the for and against arguments, but the deciding factor really needs to be your DD

tattyteddy · 17/07/2022 23:13

Also the job I do now is permanent, but I could earn more if I went supply. To bed honest I’m not very worried about the financial side of it.

OP posts:
Testina · 17/07/2022 23:12

Do you have a second child?

tattyteddy · 17/07/2022 23:11

Thanks fir the reply. when I say little tight I mean less money for holidays, treats etc.

OP posts:
FuchsAndMöhr · 17/07/2022 23:11

You really need to think about the financial side of this for the next 7 years.

That’s not just school fees either. My youngest starts y7 at indi in September and the uniform is £400. That’s before trips, extras etc.

Testina · 17/07/2022 23:08

Being offered a place is neither here nor there - you’ll always find somewhere to take your money 🤷🏻‍♀️

Can your parents afford this and sustain that for 7 years?
Can your family afford the other 50%?
”a little tight” doesn’t really tell us anything.

If his objection is financial rather than philosophical though, I’m inclined to side with him.

What does “a little tight” really mean?

Swipe left for the next trending thread