Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

High school for DD 11 - private vs state

37 replies

tattyteddy · 17/07/2022 23:03

I’m probably being unreasonable but her goes….

my daughter is going to high school in September. I really want her to go to private school, however my husband is dead set on the idea she goes to the local secondary school.

my work means I have a good knowledge of the local school, they are all massive academies. They are focused on discipline, for example sending kid home if they’ve forgotten planner etc. I think the emphasis should be on nurturing. If a kid is in school that’s surely a win? My DD is good at school so not worried she will get disciplined for bad behaviour. However, the local schools are so focused on discipline that even good kids get negative points. I’ve also heard that there is a gang issue at the school.

my dh states we can’t afford it. It will be a little tight but my parents have agreed to pay half the fees. They only have two gc and want them to have the best opportunities. I just can’t seem to get over the fact she will be going yo the local state academy. She has been offered a place at local private school too. Please help me

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Chazx · 19/07/2022 10:44

Actually, school pick up bus was a 7.10 am but would have had to leave house 7.00 to get to collection point!

Appleblum · 19/07/2022 10:41

Have you researched the private school? Is it good and suitable for your daughter? There are good and bad private schools and it's very important to find one that fits you

In general I would always pick a good private school over a good state school.

However it doesn't sound like you can afford private school. Your parents are willing to pay now, but what about in the future? Private school fees increase yearly and it would be a shame if at some point it is no longer palatable. You also have to make provision for your younger child.

Chazx · 19/07/2022 10:24

honestly, is it a status thing? My in'laws only have two grand kids - our two! They offered private school from 4-18 years and we said no, it's now in trust for the kids!

We said no because in our situation, we did not feel it represented a good use of a resource (capital ££), our local schools are fine and we support our children at home. The local independent school didn't get massively better results and isn't a "top tier" school - very ordinary local people send their kids there.

The private school further away (in my opinion more prestigious, well known and "famous" alumni) was a 24 mile trip one-way and school bus left at 7.30 am. Transport costs added up for two kids!!

What is better about the private school and why do you think a state school is not a good fit?

Doesn't sound like it's very affordable and will both children be given the same opportunity? Can you affords ski trips, the extra expenses: sports clubs, trips to Europe, music lessons and can you also save for their future uni, deposit on first home etc

What is your DDs personality - is she resilient, sensitive, does she tend to get on well/mix well? is she good academically without too much pushing? Is she strong, determined etc?

Our eldest is going to a state secondary and it is regarded as fine locally, there is another less popular and another one very popular (get a few % better GSCE results,. all three high schools are OFSTED good. All three have a massive focus on building up life skills, team working, doing presentations in lessons in front of peers etc.

Is it really worth it the money and what are you really expecting from school? Honestly, is it connections and better environment?

RedHelenB · 19/07/2022 10:10

Yabu. Nowhere have you mentioned where your dd wants to go. Presumably sgws done the taster days at the comp, has in her head that she going there?

VestaTilley · 19/07/2022 09:58

It’s not just the discipline issue that matters - what are both school’s results like? You send your child to school to get an education - that has to be the primary concern.

If the state school gets better results then that is a major win. A lot of local independent day schools aren’t actually that good. The only private schools I’d ever consider are the top public schools, but we can’t afford it and DH is dead against it anyway.

If you don’t like your local state schools are there others near you?

FlatWhiteLover · 19/07/2022 09:52

My secondary education was at the local private school. It was massively focused on discipline - strong uniform rules (no make up, nail polish, wear your tie, top button done up etc) - I was once told off for wearing a pink bra. Marked if you broke uniform rules and after a couple of warnings you were on detention.

Strict homework rules too, expected to have completed homework, you needed a note from a parent explaining why (and it had to big family circumstances), depending on the lenecy of the teacher you might get a free pass if its a one off, repeat offenders had to stay in at lunch time.

BanjoVio · 19/07/2022 09:29

Hoppinggreen · 19/07/2022 09:23

Not all Private schools are like this.
Mine wasnt and the one my DC are at isnt either

I completely agree. Most of the parents at the private schools I went to and work at have normal houses and normal jobs like administrators, teachers, taxi drivers, etc. Many kids wear tatty uniforms and go on UK holidays. Yes we have one child of an MP and some children of doctors and lawyers, but they don’t typically have millionaire lifestyles.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 19/07/2022 09:28

On the financial side, I would worry about relying on a regular income from your parents. Where is the money coming from, is it guaranteed, what if one of them can't work or needs care? And also, five years ago I would not have been so worried about this but we have rising inflation now and school fees typically run ahead of inflation, will your parents income or reserves keep up? Will your own income keep up?

the most important thing is for the child to be at school.

Are you saying that your DD is likely to refuse to go to school? Does she have issues that need an especially nurturing environment? If so then that's where I would start from, making sure she has support and understanding wherever she goes.

That aside, I wouldn't worry about petty rules unless your DD tends to be either defiant or unusually anxious. Insisting everyone sticks to convention can maintain a calm atmosphere which is often good for quieter or more nervous children. I would worry more about what happens when a child has real difficulties. How do they support kids with ADD who wont remember their jotters without help? What are they like over bullying? "Strict but kind" is probably the vibe you want.

Gang issues are also a serious concern but what matters is how big the problem really is, how the school deals with it and whether most of the children feel safe.

You haven't said, where do your DD's friends expect to go? We got suckered because I thought it was an even split but it turned out all DS's primary school friend circle ended up at the local private school. We could have afforded private but chose (very excellent and well matched to DSs needs) state, and DS had a rough couple of years til he found his own circle. It turned out well for him in the end but if I'd known he'd have no-one I would probably have ponied up for private.

MintJulia · 19/07/2022 09:25

My ds went to a tiny state primary (120 people in total) and was due to go to a state comp (1600 people). He went to three taster days there and didn't like it, as well as taster days at another state school and two private schools.

He chose one of the private schools. It isn't particularly smart or selective, but is generally good quality and small (about 600 pupils). It is calm, friendly and well organised (lots of ex-army staff). I'm a single mum so a big stretch for me, but my DS is happy and engaged. He was bored at primary school. Plenty of families stretch to attend his school so no worries about rich classmates and feeling poor.

I visited all the schools. The big state school was impersonal and felt 'off'. Good sports facilities but their maths GCSE pass rate for boys was 41% which is poor. It seemed chaotic and at the end of one taster day they turned 400 10yos loose without any of them knowing where they were going, couldn't find their lifts home etc. Three years later it has just been put in special measures.

The smaller state school - they couldn't provide a french teacher for years 7-9. They offered German as a MFL or nothing. And they didn't have a library. 😯 My DS reads constantly.

I'd say visit the schools on offer, arrange taster days for your child, and go with your and her instinct. If you can afford it, forget how they are funded and choose on what will suit your child best.

Hoppinggreen · 19/07/2022 09:23

FarmGirl78 · 18/07/2022 19:24

My friend went to a private school when her parents were in a similar situation to you. They lived in an average house and went on average holidays abroad, but she says she always always felt like the outcast at school, because she wasn't wildly rich like all the other kids. They'd all go abroad to the house in Colorado for summer, or stay at the ski-lodge in South of France for half term, whereas my friend would stay in very nice hotels in very nice holidays, but was always poor in comparison. Over 20 years later and she still feels the sting of it. If you have to make cutbacks, or cross your fingers it'll all be ok when it's your Son's turn, then you're not realistically in a position to give your Daughter the financial support she would need to FULLY fit in with her peers.

I think you'd be doing her a disservice by sending her.

Not all Private schools are like this.
Mine wasnt and the one my DC are at isnt either

Hoppinggreen · 19/07/2022 09:20

Bluntly, you cant afford it.
I would never rely on anyone else to pay school fees and it sounds like even with your parents help you will struggle.
If the fact that the schools are hot on discipline is your main concern then I dont think thats enough of a reason for you to choose Private if you cant actually afford the fees
I am not anti Private school, my DC go at Secondary but firstly we can easily afford it and secondly the State school is awful, it could actually do with a bit more discipline

BuanoKubiamVej · 19/07/2022 09:15

I am confused that you are asking this now. The decision needed to be made back in April as you have either accepted the private school place (in which case you are going to be liable for the first term's fees whether she goes there or not) or you rejected it.

We have DC at a private school and yes money is a bit tight eg we are having no full scale holiday this year, just having an airbnb for a long weekend within the uk and some days off at home. But financially it feels worth it for our particular DC. But there's no single solution that's always right for these dilemmas, it depends on the school and on the child. There are plenty of kids who really thrive in state education and there's nothing wrong with a rigorous system of discipline and rules if it is clearly explained and fairly enforced. School doesn't need to be a total joyful experience, there's lots of different needs to balance up. But if you would otherwise be spending the money on luxuries and holidays and you can cover your bills and food then money shouldn't be the reason not to go for it if it is otherwise the best school for the child.

Seeline · 19/07/2022 08:58

Apart from your views on discipline, what makes the private school better for your daughter?

Size, facilities, range of subjects, options at GSCE/A level, results, opportunities for sport/music/drama etc?

IS it in a good position financially - have you checked the accounts to see if it will survive the 7 years of your DDs education?

And beware, even the most nurturing of private schools have no qualms at asking DCs to leave for certain misdemeanors. And IME discipline is pretty strict as most parents don't appreciate forking out thousands for their DC to have their education disrupted by others misbehaving.

BanjoVio · 19/07/2022 08:57

I’ve taught in both state and private secondary schools and to be honest I’m convinced that private is the way to go if you can manage it. Ultimately, the three private schools I have first hand experience of are a much calmer, more studious environment where the culture is that you listen to teachers and get on with learning. There are minimal behavioural issues (not none, obviously) and it’s this that allows students to do their best. There also tend to be more extracurricular opportunities and a bigger emphasis on educating the “whole person”. Yes, academics are important, but so are mental and physical health, opportunities for music, art, etc. There will be several state schools that do this brilliantly, too. But the private sector has a bigger budget and teachers with more time on their hands to provide these things. I do a much better job for my students with class sizes of <25 than >32 and a dozen free lessons a fortnight, not five.

StripyHorse · 19/07/2022 08:48

tattyteddy · 17/07/2022 23:13

Also the job I do now is permanent, but I could earn more if I went supply. To bed honest I’m not very worried about the financial side of it.

Do you mean supply teaching?

Have you spoken to agencies to find out how much you would earn, or just believed the myth that supply teachers are well paid.

At best, if you work through the LA, your daily rate could be 1/195 of your annual rate (so you get paid the same as perm teacher if you work every day).

In Wales, the Framework Agreement means agencies that have signed up to the agreement should pay teachers 1/195 of the M1 rate (ie lowest qualified teacher rate). You won't have access to Teachers' Pension Scheme. They will offer Nest or similar.

Elsewhere, you may not get that - it will depend on local demand and your specialism. £100 - £120 per day is not uncommon.

Also as a supply teacher, you don't get paid sickness etc. September and the last couple of weeks of term are traditionally quiet.

If you are fully aware of this and you can still earn more - great.

notanothertakeaway · 19/07/2022 08:38

It's not just about whether you can afford fees. It's also about whether it's a good use of the money

We could have afforded private school, but I would prefer to save the money and help our DS buy a flat in future. I recognise were in a fortunate position, especially as our local state high school is excellent (and better exam results than local private school, although exams aren't everything)

RockandRollsuicide · 19/07/2022 08:31

Farm girl! What a strange way of looking at things! Your friend would have been better of being emotionally shored up ,and realising not all that glitters is gold!

There will always be richer/poorer/happier/sadder etx

jeaux90 · 19/07/2022 07:12

@FarmGirl78 this may well have been an experience but so many private schools are different.

The one my DD13 goes to isn't overly expensive and the majority of parents both work and are just in professional jobs. Not stupidly rich.

FarmGirl78 · 18/07/2022 19:24

My friend went to a private school when her parents were in a similar situation to you. They lived in an average house and went on average holidays abroad, but she says she always always felt like the outcast at school, because she wasn't wildly rich like all the other kids. They'd all go abroad to the house in Colorado for summer, or stay at the ski-lodge in South of France for half term, whereas my friend would stay in very nice hotels in very nice holidays, but was always poor in comparison. Over 20 years later and she still feels the sting of it. If you have to make cutbacks, or cross your fingers it'll all be ok when it's your Son's turn, then you're not realistically in a position to give your Daughter the financial support she would need to FULLY fit in with her peers.

I think you'd be doing her a disservice by sending her.

creamwitheverything · 18/07/2022 17:16

HI OP
I think well I know that public school is an amazing thing to do but I would urge you to take into consideration your child in totality,What I mean is that it doesnt suit every child,The reason I know this is because my son went to an all boys public school from 11 yrs to 18 and he loved it and thrived,but some of his classmates were miserable and dropped out over the years, My son was highly academic and the pace of school suited him but my dd is 10 and is so not the same child,I know she would struggle and it wouldnt be for her,I am not saying she doesnt deserve to go she does but I know it would be a wasted investment in terms of her,She is flighty,lovely, adorable but has no interest in academia,sports or musical ability,she would struggle just to plod on in public school. Would your dd keep up with the school day?these are often extended due to commitments the children are expected to attend,,My son often went to school at 8am and returned at 6,30 sometimes even 9 or 10 pm depending on what was happening, The work load is alot more too as expected plus sometimes the weekend is taken up by clubs or activities, It is about way more than money entering into public school. I also think whist the education is very good would it be fair for the whole family to have to make sacrifices too? If this is the case then I would advise against it, I wish you well on whatever you decide to do but even for us it was financially chalenging at times and the world is a very different place now than it was when my son went,I would think most parents now are concerned about job security and the cost of living etc and making a big commitment like that? Would you feel happy to pull her out if you couldnt afford it ?I doubt it, I dont want to put you off if your daughter could benefit from it its a wonderful thing but its a big step to take,Take your time all be on the same page its a long time 7 yrs for you all, Be sure 100% its right for all of you as a family is my advice,Many second rate public schools are loosing numbers left right and center and will take pupils who can pay gladly this too is never a good thing but they need to survice this could drive down standards and thats no good for anyone either,

FrodisCapering · 18/07/2022 16:48

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

jeaux90 · 18/07/2022 15:56

I sent my DD13 to a private all girls school. I'm a single mum with a decent career so can afford it but it's a little tight.

Girls statistically do better in single sex schools, I'm certain this helped me personally too.

Mine is quiet, has ASD so the small class sizes and better facilities etc means she is thriving. She would have absolutely sunk in the massive but very good local secondary.

I also have very big concerns about the number of sexual assaults/mixed sex facilities in mixed secondary schools.

This comes down to your child, what is she like and what does she need. Also what are your priorities.

Testina · 18/07/2022 14:59

Sorry, that’s £12K a year, but my point stands. There’s a reason why he doesn’t think it’s affordable when you do, and who’s to say he isn’t right on the detail you’ve given?

Testina · 18/07/2022 14:58

tattyteddy · 17/07/2022 23:19

Paying half would mean about £7500 a year for me. I probably have about a £1000 left each month for savings etc. at present I don’t worry about going out for dinner etc or booking a holiday. Obviously, if she went to private school then of have to be more careful.

And your husband?
If you have £10K a year for holidays and treats as a couple, then £2.5K “only” is a big hit to lifestyle.
But if he is also saving each month, then perhaps you can afford it.

solarbirdscalm · 17/07/2022 23:40

You haven't said anything good about the private school. Private does not automatically equal better than state and if you can only just afford it then you are potentially putting your DD in a very difficult situation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread