Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think living in the Channel Islands must be miserable in winter?

80 replies

writemyricebun · 17/07/2022 18:24

By that I mean having to fly or get the ferry just to visit the mainland if you live in one of the Channel Islands, how often do you visit the mainland? Is it expensive?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
thetombliboo · 19/07/2022 09:22

DH and I went to Jersey a couple of weeks ago. Fabulous place, we had no idea what to expect either. I couldn't imagine being miserable living there at all quite the opposite.

Constantcrayfish · 18/07/2022 22:52

We left Jersey recently after several years. The weather in the winter is no worse than the UK, definitely milder.

We left because:

It became too expensive. We couldn’t buy and the rents were shooting up. We earned decent salaries compared to the UK but were just on a treadmill to keep afloat.

The costs of leaving the island to visit grandparents and go on holiday has rocketed after Covid. Routes are fewer, and EasyJet charging for bags adds hundreds to the costs of a family trip away. Day trips to France are very difficult as Condor has really cut down its schedules and the costs are up.

There was very little for our kids to do as they got older. It’s really lovely to bring up small kids there, low crime rate, lovely beaches etc, but things have closed before and during Covid and my kids were just so bored. Every single winter weekend was a challenge.

The relentless rhetoric about non-islanders; we were immigrants and a certain vocal section of society would not forget it. DH’s employers discriminated against him because of it, and it just got too much.

The cost of living is rising; tax is now charged on most goods ordered online, and the main on-island producer of fruit and vegetables has closed, so food security is less. The lack of choice and the fact that fewer suppliers will deliver to the Channel
Islands post-Brexit was making life more complicated.

On the plus side, we had amazing friends, and being on a small island through Covid was intensely bonding as we were cut off for months on end, and right now, I’d absolutely love to be able to jump into the lovely clear sea. We miss our friends and doubt we’ll find the same sense of community anywhere else. I go over frequently for work and love walking down King Street and being greeted by every third person, whereas I know virtually no one where we’ve moved to. You can’t have everything.

But there’s no way I would move back. And I know quite a few people, including friends who were born and grew up on the island, who are leaving for some of the same
reasons as us, primarily housing.

Sideorderofchips · 18/07/2022 22:41

Honestly I go out and rarely lock the back door. I've had a car thst wouldn't lock and no one pinched it off the drive. It's safe enough for my 15 year old to go out with friends and to the beach and walk home without me worrying all the time

I grew up on the mainland and never had that

Yes you can walk through town and know at least 3 people. But it's good

Iwantcollarbones · 18/07/2022 22:25

My dd lives in jersey. She’s only been back a few times. She loves it. The safety aspect someone mentioned up thread is a massive bonus. She went out drinking one evening and FaceTimed me the next day as she had woken up without her bag, phone, passport, keys and money. But randomly with someone else’s phone. We were able to track her phone to her boyfriends house but her bag and contents weren’t there. Someone called the phone she had and she was able to hand that back. After retracing her steps she tried to register her bag and contents as missing with the police who refused to file the report as ‘these things have a habit of turning up’. Indeed a few days later she got a call from a nightclub to come and collect her bag. Every penny (and it was a few hundred pounds in her purse) was there. Someone had just taken home by mistake.

Im hoping to move there once I finish my degree. Jersey winters are beautiful. It’s such a colourful island but the colours change with each season. I have never had better food then the food in Guernsey. I love the Channel Islands.

FettleOfKish · 18/07/2022 22:04

Fair enough on the actual definition Smile

You're right about phases of people coming, but in addition to those you mentioned I've also met people from all corners of the earth, and had some amazing opportunities in terms of being able to visit them in their home countries, and made some (hopefully!) lifelong friends, brought together by being away from home, and often becoming each other's second family.

I'm not sure I'd have found that same diversity in small town Yorkshire.

FindingMeno · 18/07/2022 20:31

I spent a few months on Jersey and couldn't wait to get back to England.
I felt suffocated. Hemmed in.
Not for me I'm afraid.

UnreasonabIe · 18/07/2022 20:17

I think it depends on how you approach the situation.

If you're an islander, or you are prepared to assimilate and make friends with us, your winters will be full of social events - meals out, visiting friends, walking on some of the most spectacular cliff paths and watching the sea jump to amazing height as it hits the sea walls.

Some people come and never experience the full island life because they just can't get used to the close community and everyone knowing your business- some embrace this as a caring community experience and jump in feet first, some just cannot.

TeenDivided · 18/07/2022 19:39

The Watersplash seems a pretty lively place at a weekend evening.
And the surfing.
Depends what a teen is into I suppose.

SleeplessInEngland · 18/07/2022 19:36

I grew up in the Channel Islands. It’s definitely a better place to retire than be a teenager.

Plantstrees · 18/07/2022 19:30

I have many happy memories of living in the Channel Islands and have often considered going back. I think on balance I prefer living in England but do miss quite a few aspects including the healthcare system and lovely doctors who had time for you, lack of crime, and short commute are the main ones I can think of. I also had a great set of friends and enjoyed the lifestyle but I think maybe that was also because of the age I was when I was there and perhaps it would be a little different now I'm older. When I was there I missed English pubs and the miles of beautiful empty countryside most. Sometimes it could be difficult to get away from people, especially in the summer when the tourists descended. I came back to the UK regularly for work when I was there so the cost of travel didn't bother me but going anywhere other than the UK or a few places in Europe involved more than one flight which was annoying.

BobinogBobbleHat · 18/07/2022 19:10

It's expensive, but a few years ago I had a weekend away with friends and the woman travelling from the Channel Islands got to the UK city we were in (Midlands) a lot quicker than I did, from rural Wales.

longcoffeebreak · 18/07/2022 19:01

oreo2020 · 18/07/2022 17:45

It sounds like a fab life in the islands, but no I couldn't live there. Why? I am a keen cyclist and cycling options would be limited there.

There are LOADS of cycling clubs and high level competing in things like triathlon but yes you road ride round and round and up and down. The Zealand has a 50mile perimeter. Lots of cliff paths for fearless l black or diamond level mountain bikers but VERY limited gravel

longcoffeebreak · 18/07/2022 18:58

TeenDivided · 18/07/2022 15:19

@MathsRocksMathsRocks Great user name.

Can you please answer the question I have that never gets answered?

There is a tree on the St Johns->St Marys road that seems to contain an ever changing soft toy. Have you seen it? Do you know what is going on?

Just came back from you on Saturday. Bit hot for me this year, but relaxing.

I heard it was rubbish lorry guys who rescue soft toys people throw out and pop them in the tree hole 😀

aquatastics · 18/07/2022 18:56

Anyway, never mind Jersey OP. Imagine living in the Scottish islands in winter! That would finish me off.

aquatastics · 18/07/2022 18:52

Jersey is not hotter in summer than Southern
England because its an island, so always a wind. Nor is it drier than SE England because they'll get whatever comes straight off the sea. Winters would be milder though, like Cornwall. Though probably more wet than Eastetn England.

I suppose it's no different to living anywhere else in terms of travel - eg. If you live in Nottingham, how many times do you actually go into London? I live in London and if I go anywhere, it's abroad.

Fizbosshoes · 18/07/2022 18:42

My mum lived in Jersey for a few years in her early 20s. She met several older people who had never left the Island.

TeenDivided · 18/07/2022 18:33

insular
/ˈɪnsjʊlə/
Origin
mid 16th century (as a noun denoting an islander): from late Latin insularis, from insula ‘island’.

Jersey has its turnover of people from different parts of the world. It was Portuguese, then Easter European, and this year seemed to be Caribbean?

FettleOfKish · 18/07/2022 18:17

Yes I forgot to mention the safety aspect. Very blasé about locking cars / doors here. I've had my car windows rolled right down the last couple of days when I know I need to use it in the afternoon (parked both at home and at work) and not a second thought about anyone stealing it, or anything in it.

Friends live in Guernsey and I once called to let them know I was going to be there for a work trip in case they were around. They were away on holiday but the response was 'stay at ours if you want, you know where the house it is, it's unlocked, help yourself'. Pretty standard Guernsey Grin

I'd argue with insular, in that I don't think I'd have met and become friends with so many people from so many varied nationalities & backgrounds if I'd stayed in the North. It's a bit of a melting pot of people travelling here to work in hospitality or finance.

I also feel bad for people who don't have easy access to amazing Portuguese food SmileSmileWink

CounsellorTroi · 18/07/2022 18:15

We've been on holiday twice to Jersey and on both occasions the weather was shit.

GemmaEdKitten · 18/07/2022 18:00

TeenDivided · 18/07/2022 17:57

It's fairly insular

I think as an island, Jersey is the epitome of insular. Smile

I was being polite! Teehee.

TeenDivided · 18/07/2022 17:57

It's fairly insular

I think as an island, Jersey is the epitome of insular. Smile

GemmaEdKitten · 18/07/2022 17:55

BrieAndChilli · 17/07/2022 20:28

My issue is the healthcare side - people on guernsey have to travel to the mainland for lots of specialist appointments. It’s paid for my the government but you have to fly or get a ferry to the U.K. mainland for lots of treatments.

I grew up in Jersey and was sick as a child and this was fine - I thought it exciting going to London! Maybe my parents felt differently! It's lovely; we had sea days, there's beach walks, loads to do in terms of touristy stuff. I learnt (then forgot) French. I do think (I left in my young teens) it might have got a bit dull as I got older. It's fairly insular and, of course, there's limited scope to visit other parts of Britain easily.

HTH1 · 18/07/2022 17:49

I’d much rather live here than in London (or much of the U.K.!)

oreo2020 · 18/07/2022 17:45

It sounds like a fab life in the islands, but no I couldn't live there. Why? I am a keen cyclist and cycling options would be limited there.

Riapia · 18/07/2022 17:18

It must be awful.
No electricity, running water or mains drainage.
Running sewer down the Main Street.
Living in rags.
we should start a collection for them immediately. They’ll be in tears of gratitude.