Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not sleep train my baby?

157 replies

MD1803 · 16/07/2022 21:06

So, the internet is full of advice how to sleep train your baby.

Are there many / any people out there who never bothered and just allowed things to happen (and how did that go)?

My DD is 4 months old (in two days). We are now about two weeks in into the 4 month sleep regression. In general, it takes fair amount of rocking to get her fall asleep for her naps or at bedtime. I never put her down drowsy but awake. In fact I always wait about 20mins when she is normally in deep sleep and doesn’t wake up once I put her in her cot.

From about 2 months old until the regression started she would sleep from 9:00 and later 8:00pm to first wake up around 3:00 / 4:00 am.

Since the regression I started to take her to bed with me after her midnight / 1:00am wake up. Frankly I get better sleep that way. I never took her to bed with me before.

I’m thinking she will just naturally develop sleeping habits where she will get over the regression and eventually learn how to fall asleep on her own.

Am I being delusional?

OP posts:
MonkeyPuddle · 17/07/2022 12:41

Play it by ear. Get the sleep while you can. DD hit the 4 month regression and woke after no longer than 45 mins of sleep, I would feed her back to sleep, took her ages to get to sleep and then, PING! Awake after 45 minutes. I thought I was going to lose my mind. I waited til she was 6 months, She was sleep trained.

WhiteFire · 17/07/2022 12:39

She absolutely hated the cot too. Her day naps were in the buggy. Even if she fell asleep on me I couldn't then put her down in the cot.

WhiteFire · 17/07/2022 12:36

I had one sleep through at 6 weeks and another at 4.5 years. The youngest pretty much broke me. I did short spells of sleep training, it was that or walk out the house and she totally messed up my sleep pattern.

Ultimately she got there, but it was tough going. The middle was just over 1. I guess some will easily, some won't and some just need a little help to get there.

You don't have to but neither is it dreadful if you reach the point that you need to.

oh and I did nothing with my first, she would have slept on a washing line. She is also a back sleeper whilst the middle is a front sleeper so was never happy until he could consistently roll over (which was later for him)

Duttercup · 17/07/2022 12:31

I didn't and she's always been a great napper and sleeps through the night from about 22 months. She was never a terrible sleeper so I've never been on my knees with tiredness (or at least not for long periods) so it never felt necessary. The wake ups she did do in the night were very manageable.

I used to worry about it all a lot and then around 6 months I decided to shut out all the noise of what she should be doing, what I should be doing, whatever IG wanted to make money by me doing and followed my instinct. That broadly meant never letting her cry when she was small and letting a bit of whinging happen as she got bigger.

I don't judge anyone for sleep training if they have a lunatic sleeper. She went through a phase of waking up 3-5 times a night and it was only a week or two and I was ready to sleep train, but then she just got over it on her own. I couldn't have sustained it much longer.

I do think there's a lot of pressure from people selling things on Instagram though. It feels like an American import based on their shit maternity leave. So I do judge influencers saying they're sleep training their tiny babies/advertising sleep consultants and then spending a lot of time on stories complaining about their baby not sleeping (Chessie King, I'm looking at you).

AnxietyLevelMax · 17/07/2022 12:16

Tried many many time, actually 5 months since he was 1…he was a bad sleeper since he was born, extremely attached to me. Used to wake up 4-5 times always crying, took forever to go back to sleep. Paid for sleep consultants and was really on point with training. Gave up about a month ago. He goes to sleep in his room and always wakes up and comes to me, no chance to put him back there if I dont want hours of hysterical crying. Now i just let him sleep with me. We both have much better sleep. Dont want to go through my sleep deprivation ever again. Husband sleeps in the guest bedroom🤷🏻‍♀️

Topgub · 17/07/2022 11:35

People do all sorts, depending on what's right for them.

Telling people not to sleep train or that they aren't natural is as bad as telling them they absolutely must sleep train.

I 'sleep trained' ds in various ways from birth.

I didnt with dd as she didn't need it.

That all changed from 18 months when she became a terrible sleeper. She was a terrible sleeper for the next 6 years because dh didn't want to st her.

It all works out in the end (mostly, as I said lots of adults have terrible sleep habits) but I know which route I found easiest

TheKeatingFive · 17/07/2022 11:26

Perhaps on some subconscious level, to be honest I don’t know, but the main question is what did various people do.

Anything and everything. Depending on their circs.

DS1 we sleep trained at 9 months, controlled crying, it was wonderful, worked in a night, everyone was much better for it.

DS2 has terrible eczema. Sleep training wasn't an option, we had to co sleep for the guts of 4 years and I absolutely hated it. We're only now getting on top of the sleeping because we're getting on top of the eczema.

Do what's right for you, don't worry about what anyone else is doing. Sleep training done right can be an amazing tool, equally no one's forcing you to do it, it is entirely up to you.

alphapie · 17/07/2022 11:21

MD1803 · 17/07/2022 11:19

Perhaps on some subconscious level, to be honest I don’t know, but the main question is what did various people do.

The internet can be a good place but also a bad place. There can be a lot of advice about what to do and what not to do but what do people actually do do and how did it work for them is a different topic.

Keeping in mind that every baby is different of course.

Your baby is tiny, honestly it's silly to try and make plans at this stage, come back when you have an 8 month old not sleeping then you'll understand why some need to train.

It's like the people who say before kids they wouldn't let them have a dummy etc. just wait until you need to decide whether to train or not before making decisions

MD1803 · 17/07/2022 11:19

Perhaps on some subconscious level, to be honest I don’t know, but the main question is what did various people do.

The internet can be a good place but also a bad place. There can be a lot of advice about what to do and what not to do but what do people actually do do and how did it work for them is a different topic.

Keeping in mind that every baby is different of course.

OP posts:
alphapie · 17/07/2022 11:10

I always operated on until 6 months I'll do what baby needs, if that's holding to sleep, sleeping on me and nothing else, sleeping on DH, in a carrier etc. and never trained.

After 6 months some form of schedule could begin as they were moving to solids, hunger becoming less of a factor for overnight waking etc. and did gentle sleep training at his 8 month regression and it worked brilliantly.

Only took 2 nights and he got used to it

Topgub · 17/07/2022 10:50

@ReeseWitherfork

Have dads been wiped from existence in your world?

What came naturally to me as a mother was teaching them how to go to sleep on their own

I had zero interest or desire for 5 am cuddles

Topgub · 17/07/2022 10:48

@MD1803

Ah.

So really you just wanted to post to get reinforcement that you're right?

🙄

Cakeandslippers · 17/07/2022 09:21

Just see how it goes. I haven't sleep trained mine, at times I've wanted to, and we did try a bit with the oldest as a toddler but she was trying to self injure and I couldn't let that happen. You might find it all sorts out very soon. You might find it doesn't in which case you can make a decision then.

My eldest started reliably sleeping through around the time she turned 3. My 2yo has slept through the night twice but normally wakes up quite a bit still. It's really hard but we have survived somehow.

TheGoogleMum · 17/07/2022 09:13

With sleep always do whatever works best for you. It's not wrong to not do it, plenty if people don't. I find generally people are more judgemental of those who do sleep train. We did sleep train, I had some insomnia issues so sleep at night became important as I found day sleep impossible. It was hard and its not for everyone.

Porcupineintherough · 17/07/2022 08:59

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 16/07/2022 21:08

I think 4 months is too soon to know anything. Not delusional but it also might not happen. Only fine will tell.

^^This. Im sure they do learn, eventually but if its when they are 3 you may not be able to stay the course. Either way, it's your choice and there's isn't a right answer.

SouperNoodle · 17/07/2022 08:58

I always rocked DD2 to sleep. She's 3 now and still needs to be rocked to sleep 😑🤦‍♀️ 😅

MD1803 · 17/07/2022 08:55

Thanks for all your comments. Yes, I didn’t really think about using controlled crying or any crying at 4 months. I couldn’t do that and can’t see how it would go anywhere.

It’s more the talk on the internet about bad habits. We do have regular bedtime, regular naps to avoid over-tiredness so I think overall we do have a good routine and create good ‘general’ habits. But the way how to get to sleep and stay asleep is always with lot of support, the support that is often described as bad habits.

However, I can’t see how she would actually sleep otherwise and I don’t feel added aggregation would help anybody, least her.

I did wonder whether the fact I started to take her to bed with me is creating a new ‘bad’ habit but if just seems to work as she gets a better sleep that way and so do I.

It’s reassuring to hear how lot of people feel about the ‘sleep training’ industry / approach.

OP posts:
Rumplestrumpet · 17/07/2022 07:20

Sleep training at 4 months would be ridiculous. So keep going as you are and if you need a new approach later then look at options. I never left mine to cry but did try to encourage them to sleep more independently from around 6months

Good luck

Ginfilledcats · 17/07/2022 07:15

I did a lite version of the Ferber method (adapted so wasn’t quite as long, but general principles the same) so I suppose I did an element of sleep training.
but at 9 months, not at 4. At 4 months you just have to roll with the punches I’m afraid!! It does get better, honestly!

for my experience, I bf mine to sleep and she would wake up once or twice in the night by 9m at the exact same time every night, have a small suckle and go off. I was confident it was just habit, she was eating 3 meals a day and lots of bf so I KNEW it wasn’t hunger. We had 1 bad night doing the leave for 1 min, 3 min, 5 for a couple of hours, but she’s slept through every night ever since and is 2.5 now! Luck? Maybe? Is she scarred and we have a terrible relationship now? Absolutely not!

you do what’s best for you, and your sanity!

Thehonestbadger · 17/07/2022 06:27

They’re your child so you can do what you want RE sleep training.

Mine have both slept through since 8-10 months and I did gently sleep train them at that point because I couldn’t take more bed sharing, constant breast feeding…etc it was a really bad situation and none of us were getting enough sleep. That being said both my kids were different and I approached sleep training differently with them. I would never be able to just let them scream endlessly but I found that giving them 5 minutes to cry and crash when they were just really over tired and over stimulated worked wonders

ReeseWitherfork · 17/07/2022 05:35

JudgeJ · 16/07/2022 22:12

Oh I love these trendy terms like regression and sleep 'training'! Our babies were put into their cots and went to sleep, no 'training' involved, it does seem that a lot of the jargon attached to such a normal thing as having a baby is there to make parents even more worried!

…. Worried parents fork out cash!

Like a PP said, there’s an entire industry out there telling new mums that their babies (perfectly normal!!!) sleep habits are BAD and need FIXING. And that babies will never learn to fall asleep without their “pRoVeN aNd ReSeArCh DrIvEn MaGiC mEtOhD!!!”. Fucking criminal.

Lets normalise how crap babies are at sleeping, and how eventually by doing everything that comes naturally to a mother, they will sleep. And the mother will sleep. And the mother will miss the 5am cuddles (which I’m having now long after she’s fallen asleep, even though the eldest will be awake soon because overnight calm cuddles are actually the best.)

ReeseWitherfork · 17/07/2022 05:28

Topgub · 16/07/2022 21:40

@Selinna

Eventually can be a long time.

And of course its not a myth that we form sleep habits. Most adults have them too.

I'm sure your kid didn't move from feeding to sleep to not with no intervention whatsoever

Mine did. And I know you’re going to come at me claiming I intervened even the smallest amount, but really not the case. Fed back to sleep overnight every single time and he gradually woke less and then finally didn’t wake at all. Humans don’t need to learn to fall asleep, they do it when they’re developmentally ready to do so.

Vikinga · 16/07/2022 23:16

I ded mine to sleep and at 4 months they were with me all the time. They would sleep in my arms/bouncy chair and then I'd take them up to bed with me. 3 out of 4 of mine coslept with me. Never had any problems.

Fupoffyagrasshole · 16/07/2022 23:11

fyi I didn’t just leave her to cry alone in the dark either - why do people always assume this is the case 🙃

husband sat in the room reassuring her and patting her - and saying goodnight and walking out for short bursts of time and coming back for reassurance - gradually waiting another minute or so each time!

by 8 months old I could tell the difference between property upset crying and giving out crying

even now at 16 months she’ll cry when I leave the room after I put her in the cot.

Flubadubba · 16/07/2022 22:47

I didn't, but my daughter was never one to cry etc without reason, and her sleep naturally extended until she started to sleep through at around at 10 months.

Like allthinhs baby related, it depends on your approach, tolerance and your baby!