Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not sleep train my baby?

157 replies

MD1803 · 16/07/2022 21:06

So, the internet is full of advice how to sleep train your baby.

Are there many / any people out there who never bothered and just allowed things to happen (and how did that go)?

My DD is 4 months old (in two days). We are now about two weeks in into the 4 month sleep regression. In general, it takes fair amount of rocking to get her fall asleep for her naps or at bedtime. I never put her down drowsy but awake. In fact I always wait about 20mins when she is normally in deep sleep and doesn’t wake up once I put her in her cot.

From about 2 months old until the regression started she would sleep from 9:00 and later 8:00pm to first wake up around 3:00 / 4:00 am.

Since the regression I started to take her to bed with me after her midnight / 1:00am wake up. Frankly I get better sleep that way. I never took her to bed with me before.

I’m thinking she will just naturally develop sleeping habits where she will get over the regression and eventually learn how to fall asleep on her own.

Am I being delusional?

OP posts:
ThreeLittleDots · 17/07/2022 20:39

DC breastfed and bedshared until 3yo, waking a few times very briefly in the nights (I didn't care as super easily soothed), then easily transitioned to their own bed when they chose to at 3.5yrs, no probs. Milk dried up.

FlyingPandas · 17/07/2022 20:35

I didn't do cry it out sleep training but did it very gently between 3 and 6 months (pick up put down, use of white noise etc, DC never left to cry) and they were all self-settling by 6m.

Many DC do grow out of needing to be rocked/cuddled/boobed/back rubbed etc etc to sleep, very naturally, without parents needing to formally sleep train.

Many DC don't.

And only at that point will you know whether you're the kind of parent to just go with the flow and wait to see if they do it on their own, for years if necessary. Or whether you're the kind who can't stand one more night of having to sit in a DC's room for hours having no evening to yourself whilst they fall asleep, and then repeat the process through the night because they can't re-settle themselves back to sleep.

Many parents are happy to do it, for years - I know of 9yos who cannot fall asleep unless a parent lies down with them for 2 hours + and that is fine, if that's what works for you, as a family.

But if it doesn't work for you, that's the point at which you might need to think about something else. And if you need to consider sleep training then that is fine too.

yellow13 · 17/07/2022 20:15

I didn't
At 11 months she started putting herself to sleep.
She makes noise for 4 or 5 mins (moaning not crying, babbling, etc) and then is out for the night, Before this we were rocking / feeding her to sleep. It's been a gamechanger and I've no idea how it worked, but grateful it did.

IF she ramps up from moans to wails of course we go and see if she's ok - but I feel like it's just her decompressing and then settling for the night.

Topgub · 17/07/2022 19:46

@MD1803

If you're not happy to rock forever then I'd say St now.

You can do it 'gently'

There are lots of methods that claim to be 'no cry'

I posted a bit of my experience with my own children earlier

luxxlisbon · 17/07/2022 19:46

pimlicoanna · 17/07/2022 19:30

@luxxlisbon of course they do as I go to them when they cry. Just as I do at night Smile

And yet by your logic shouldn’t they have learned they don’t need to cry because you are in fact still there?

MD1803 · 17/07/2022 19:44

@Topgub yes, everyone is free to express their opinion. And people will, whether that is in answer to the question posted by the original poster (in this case me) or then opinions regarding the evolving thread.

Some will be more objective some more subjective.

Sometimes we try to read between the lines of what someone posted. And sometimes these ‘between the lines’ do exist and other times they don’t. I would say it doesn’t really matter either way.

Some comments might come across provocative and they are not intended to be (just the nature of social media and not having a face to face conversation) and other times people do like a little argument.

We are all different, like our babies (😁😁😉)

In my case I wouldn’t be happy to rock forever. So, and I do apologise in advance as this is me being a little argumentative, what would be your advice how to try to tackle my situation with my 4 month old. I don’t know if you have children and if so how old they are and what is your experience with them.

OP posts:
Penfelyn · 17/07/2022 19:41

Should mention that the friends referenced above are not sleep training in any way as can't cope with the crying. If that's what works for them that's fine. I couldn't do it though.

Penfelyn · 17/07/2022 19:40

It's partly a question of what you're willing /able to put up with.

I'm a single parent so waking up every 2h every night for potentially years just wasn't an option. I got my dc used to sleeping in their cot (age-appropriate cot) alone and I always put them down still awake so they get used to falling asleep on their own.

They slept through the night relatively early, 3 months for my eldest and maybe a bit later for my youngest. There has been some crying at times but this is what my sanity demanded.

Conversely I have friends whose 2.5yo son still wakes up multiples times a night. I couldn't deal with that.

The fact is that if you reward night waking with attention, feeding, etc, you're basically encouraging the child to keep waking up. By all means go in, pat, hug, whatever, but then leave again.

If you don't want to sleep train (which as stated above does not necessarily mean leaving child to cry for hours on end), that's fine too, but be aware that they may keep waking up through the night for many years. Or not. That'd be a matter of luck.

ShirleyPhallus · 17/07/2022 19:37

pimlicoanna · 17/07/2022 19:30

@luxxlisbon of course they do as I go to them when they cry. Just as I do at night Smile

But do you think sleep trained babies jusy never cry again because they “think no one will come”?

pimlicoanna · 17/07/2022 19:30

@luxxlisbon of course they do as I go to them when they cry. Just as I do at night Smile

luxxlisbon · 17/07/2022 19:18

pimlicoanna · 17/07/2022 19:05

I didn't do it with mine. Why would you want to teach your baby to stop crying because they've given up all hope of you coming in to them. I think it sucks

Do sleep trained babies stop crying in the day?
Pretty sure they are still conveying their needs by crying.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 17/07/2022 19:15

I did but when they were a little older. Best thing we ever did, both very settled happy kids who thrived on routine and regular bedtimes. It also made such to my well-being as I was physically and emotionally drained from the bedtime settling sagas.

FamilyStrifeIsHard2Bear · 17/07/2022 19:09

Can highly recommend 'the beyond sleep training project', they have a website and a group on facebook you can ask for advice. Free with no payment required, they are a charitable service to support children and parents

Topgub · 17/07/2022 19:08

@pimlicoanna

🙄

Wouldloveanother · 17/07/2022 19:06

pimlicoanna · 17/07/2022 19:05

I didn't do it with mine. Why would you want to teach your baby to stop crying because they've given up all hope of you coming in to them. I think it sucks

But that’s not what sleep training is?

pimlicoanna · 17/07/2022 19:05

I didn't do it with mine. Why would you want to teach your baby to stop crying because they've given up all hope of you coming in to them. I think it sucks

Wouldloveanother · 17/07/2022 19:00

TheKeatingFive · 17/07/2022 16:43

I know someone who crashed the car with two small children in it because of being very sleep deprived.

Thankfully they were okay, but it was a scary wake up call.

Parental sleep is very important, this is sometimes not properly acknowledged in these discussions.

I think mums are somewhat conned into believing that if older babies and toddlers wake up many times a night (usually for breastfeeding) that they ‘must need it’ and that it’s natural development. When really, like dummies or drinking from a bottle, it’s just a habit which needs gentle encouragement to stop. Good quality sleep matters just as much as good quality food, particularly when the brain is developing so much.

ivykaty44 · 17/07/2022 18:55

@TwinMumStruggling such a sensible post

ivykaty44 · 17/07/2022 18:52

mine both slept, were both bottle feed and back in the day the 4 month sleep regression wasn't a thing - but then weaning was at 4 months not 6 so maybe those things are connected or not

they used to fall asleep on their evening bottle about an hour after their tea and sleep till the next bottle - popped them in their cot upstairs and had a baby listener

all dc are different and you do what works for you

I went away with friend on holiday who's daughter wouldn't sleep without her, so at 7 years old she had her mum in bed each night by 8.30/9pm - but now she is in her 20s and is fine sleeping alone

Topgub · 17/07/2022 18:16

@MD1803

i literally said if you want to keep rocking her, you should.

If you wanted your choice reinforced and not disagreed with you should have posted some where that would have happened or been more clear in your op.

@TwinMumStruggling

You seem to have missed the point of my post.

And yes, those things are all normal. As is sleep training

ihavenocats · 17/07/2022 18:12

I slept with my baby until age 2 because sleep deprivation is not my thing. Used bed rail and big double and single bed with just me and her.

She went in own room at age 2 when we could explain things to her.

A new baby or young baby can't train themselves or be trained to sleep alone. They will be upset and scared and think you are just gone. There's no way around it. If they stop crying it doesn't mean they suddenly realised they have to sleep alone, they just realise it's pointless as no one's coming.

But do what you have to. If you have to balance baby in own room with your sanity then your sanity has to win. When my daughter went into her own room it was not the best thing for her. It was the best thing for me. Children would happily sleep with their parents until they start wanting alone time at night, and there would be absolutely nothing wrong in that.

But as parents that's not practical for us, and that's okay too.

Topgub · 17/07/2022 18:12

@SmallPrawnEnergy

Not really, I havent said anyone should listen to me. I'm just posting opinions asked to. Feel free to ignore

I'm not selling any books.

I'm not criticising one form of sleep industry whole posting another

Monoandsix · 17/07/2022 18:01

Topgub · 16/07/2022 21:23

Its unlikely

Youve created a sleep crutch/habit by rocking.

Its unlikely she'll learn how to fall asleep in a different way by luck.

But if you're happy to keep rocking her, keep rocking her

Bullshit.

My eldest was rocked to sleep. Slept through from 3 months. Never had any of the so called sleep regressions. At six months we started cuddling him to sleep at night. At 12 months we put him in bed to sleep awake by himself. He slept through the entire time.

Every child is different. There is no guaranteed formula that works for every child. Sleep training works for the families it works for and doesn't for others.

MD1803 · 17/07/2022 17:54

TwinMumStruggling · 17/07/2022 17:36

Because the bulk of what she talks about is how normal things are. Normal to wake frequently overnight, normal to feed to sleep, normal to rock to sleep, normal to only sleep in prams or cars, normal to cosleep, normal for toddlers to wake at the crack of dawn, normal for bed times to be different, normal for wake windows to differ from the standard. She often says that if you child does anything of these things then they’re not a “terrible sleeper”, they’re just doing what every child everywhere does. She’s such a breath of fresh air compared to the swathes of “rod for your own back” and “bad habits” people. But she also says, if things aren’t working for you then you can try and change them.

And you can look up her credentials yourself if you’re interested.

You don’t need to care what she thinks. But OP, who is panicking she is doing something wrong (with help from you!!) should definitely go and have a read.

Very well put.

OP posts:
TwinMumStruggling · 17/07/2022 17:36

Topgub · 17/07/2022 15:48

Who the fuck is lyndsey hooksay and why should I care what they think?

And how is her selling her book and Instagram any different to the sleep training industry you were criticising earlier?

Peddling the natural bollocks is as much of an industry and st is

Because the bulk of what she talks about is how normal things are. Normal to wake frequently overnight, normal to feed to sleep, normal to rock to sleep, normal to only sleep in prams or cars, normal to cosleep, normal for toddlers to wake at the crack of dawn, normal for bed times to be different, normal for wake windows to differ from the standard. She often says that if you child does anything of these things then they’re not a “terrible sleeper”, they’re just doing what every child everywhere does. She’s such a breath of fresh air compared to the swathes of “rod for your own back” and “bad habits” people. But she also says, if things aren’t working for you then you can try and change them.

And you can look up her credentials yourself if you’re interested.

You don’t need to care what she thinks. But OP, who is panicking she is doing something wrong (with help from you!!) should definitely go and have a read.

Swipe left for the next trending thread