Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not sleep train my baby?

157 replies

MD1803 · 16/07/2022 21:06

So, the internet is full of advice how to sleep train your baby.

Are there many / any people out there who never bothered and just allowed things to happen (and how did that go)?

My DD is 4 months old (in two days). We are now about two weeks in into the 4 month sleep regression. In general, it takes fair amount of rocking to get her fall asleep for her naps or at bedtime. I never put her down drowsy but awake. In fact I always wait about 20mins when she is normally in deep sleep and doesn’t wake up once I put her in her cot.

From about 2 months old until the regression started she would sleep from 9:00 and later 8:00pm to first wake up around 3:00 / 4:00 am.

Since the regression I started to take her to bed with me after her midnight / 1:00am wake up. Frankly I get better sleep that way. I never took her to bed with me before.

I’m thinking she will just naturally develop sleeping habits where she will get over the regression and eventually learn how to fall asleep on her own.

Am I being delusional?

OP posts:
ladydoris · 18/07/2022 03:10

What worked for us :


  • Rocking : Pb, we only had a King of Rock in the house no Queen. I was dismissed.

  • Sleep soother

  • Swaddle then later hoodie pyjama with hands and feets covered. That was my magic trick.

  • limited space to sleep : cosydream style bed in the baby's bed.

  • Feed, change if needed, burp and lie the BB almost asleep but not quite.

  • the dreaded dummy (ye I have written it down as I am being truthful, it's not a good idea, it's not needed, I regretted it)

  • Ultra dim lights at night when changing.

  • Just you, no moving no nothing, just you. Actually only method that never fails...Clever clogs.

Is it sleep training? I doubt it, the outcome wad wildy different depending on the kid.
Anyone else ? I am taking notes here. The wider the arsenal the better. Mine is quite limited TBH.
At that particular stage if I have a 3/3/3 hours of sleeps or 3/4 that's bliss. You have to rush to bed yourself. Half a hour more sleep is worth it's carat.
It's still the raw phase to me.
(gases, teething, the joys...)

Galileu · 18/07/2022 00:20

I tried to sleep train DD1 on the advice of everything/everyone. Dreadful for us and I regret it so much.

With my other children, I had so much more confidence and didn't sleep train at all - my other DC settled into a routine much more easily. I can't remember at what age, so I guess not terribly late.

My otherwise logical and sensible sibling sleep trained from 2 weeks old. Absolute bloody nightmare for everyone involved.

Scottishskifun · 18/07/2022 00:16

Parents should do what is best for them and their babies and not judge others on their own situations frankly.

I sleep trained my eldest as he woke every 45 mins from birth, by 4 months I had severe sleep deprivation as would get 10 mins sleep per sleep cycle with him if I was lucky and frankly it was dangerous for me to be looking after a baby in that state let alone driving. There is a big difference between being tired and severe sleep deprivation.
I have been told on more then 1 occasion that I was cruel, I tortured my baby etc etc except we never did the CIO method. We did stay and support with patting, sushhing and within a few days he was sleeping in 3 hour blocks. By 7 months he slept through til 5am and through the night from 9 months.

DS2 was a far better sleeper and would only wake every 4 hours and be fed to sleep but that has gone backwards at 4.5 months to every hour so again we do a combo of feed to sleep and stay and support depending on the times that he wakes up.

Do what works best for you but know that might need to change and also understand sleep training is not CIO method alone!

Topgub · 18/07/2022 00:11

@Milkthistle55 and @LarryTrotter

You'd think a child psychologist would know that huh?

Milkthistle55 · 18/07/2022 00:05

There's quite a misconception that if you ST it means you've left your baby to scream for hours. Which for me personally i would never do.

Sleep Training is anything from cry it out to sitting next to them, patting their bum and shushing them.

4 months is young, but a good bedtime routine will help build healthy sleeping habits.

It's up to each parent to decide what works for them and their baby.

LarryTrotter · 17/07/2022 23:59

Most people see "sleep training" and jump to "leaving them to cry all night".

I'm surprised no one has mentioned cortisol yet 🙄 (although maybe they have - I've skimmed)

There's nothing wrong with teaching your child that they are loved and safe and they can soothe themselves to sleep. But that if they need you, you'll be there to comfort them.

I don't understand what the issue is.

LadyLucksters · 17/07/2022 23:40

People also forget that the primary stress response of a baby is to sleep.

LadyLucksters · 17/07/2022 23:39

I didn’t. I’m a child psychologist, so would never consider it based on the research (*cue a whole load of angry mum’s asking for peer reviewed studies…). The truth is, their obviously aren’t any studies looking at exactly this topic, as it would be completely unethical to research something that you suspect could be harmful to an infant. Despite this, taking everything we now know about brain development, attachment, the neurological impact of developmental trauma, etc, etc., I feel it is pretty safe to conclude that it is NOT good practice for infants/young children, and flies in the face of their basic biology. Leaving a child to cry certainly does get the behavioural response people want (for them to be quiet and sleep), but on a neurological level, and certainly from an attachment perspective, I believe it to be harmful. After all, the behaviourist movement in itself was developed with rats and pigeons - animals that don’t even have the same brain structures as human babies!!

My two didn’t sleep through all night until they were around 18 months. I was prepared for that though and now they sleep beautifully.

The only advice I can give you is to trust your own judgement on this.

RosyappleA · 17/07/2022 23:33

I tried and failed so I gave up. Some kids just won’t adjust. Not every day is the same some days they are more tired etc and the routine goes out the window. Finally getting somewhere with DD aged 3 now. Next child I will go with the flow. Too much being told what to do online and too much assuming every child is textbook and every life as a parent is the same!

Topgub · 17/07/2022 23:08

@Selinna

I never said it was bad?

You said they learned to sleep with no intervention from you.

Thats obviously not true

That was me point.

Almost all children need taught how to sleep, one way or another

Some need less intervention than others

Some need none

Some need lots

Neither way is bad

AlwaysLatte · 17/07/2022 22:33

We never did it. We always rocked them to sleep then when older stayed with them until they fell asleep, right up to about age 6/7 when they were happy for us to leave them still awake after their story.

Jackie246 · 17/07/2022 22:22

Nope, not even slightly delusional. My sister and I both swear sleep training is yet another tool used to exploit parent’s exhaustion and guilt, and to make them feel even crapper about themselves. My son is 10 months, and sleeps through (7pm-6am) on average 5 out of 7 nights a week (will have an occasional night of waking once here and there). I never sleep trained him, and on paper he has the WORST experiences. 4 months spent in hospital with constant night observations waking him up, noisy wards, nasty procedures etc, you name it he’s had it. He has never once slept through in hospital, but does at home. By ‘sleep training’ logic, he should be a crap sleeper, but he isn’t, he’s fab. My sister’s baby on the other hand has had the best of the best in terms of sleep hygiene, sleep support etc, and he is now 2.5 and still doesn’t sleep through. Have a good bedtime routine, and go with the flow. And block out all the noise of people pressuring to sleep train!

Selinna · 17/07/2022 22:17

Topgub · 17/07/2022 22:08

@Selinna

Doesn't matter if you consciously decided to do it or not.

Its still an intervention. You still replaced one sleep gaining method with an other

@pimlicoanna

You're not making any sense

What's bad about this 'intervention' then? Like I say, in my experience the DC outgrew all of the 'interventions' in their own time anyway. It required no training on my part

Barrawarra · 17/07/2022 22:09

SparklingPeach · 16/07/2022 21:22

I didn't sleep train DS, but be warned he was 3yo before he slept well!

Same. With kid 2 I did gradual withdrawal sleep training at 9/10 months as I knew I couldn’t do waking 5/6 times a night for another couple of years. I wouldn’t have been a good parent in any way so I had to sleep train which wasn’t in my parenting ideology, so to speak. Being in a relationship with kids isn’t always what we imagine! Hopefully he will settle for you though and you won’t need to consider it, it does happen for some not jealous at all

Topgub · 17/07/2022 22:08

@Selinna

Doesn't matter if you consciously decided to do it or not.

Its still an intervention. You still replaced one sleep gaining method with an other

@pimlicoanna

You're not making any sense

ShirleyPhallus · 17/07/2022 22:04

pimlicoanna · 17/07/2022 21:53

@ShirleyPhallus that's people imposing something on to my post. It's literally got nothing to do with what I said. Of course babies cry. It's how you respond to it that I commented on. People who sleep train always get overly defensive- I know why. Grin I'm off to enjoy my evening cheers Wine

I think people are confused rather than defensive, given you’re the one who said that sleep training teaches babies to stop crying because they learn no one comes 🤷‍♀️

deathofastrawberry · 17/07/2022 22:04

I've always rocked my baby to sleep and never attempted sleep training, as much as I've looked into every possible strategy during those awful regressions I've never been able to try it as I just can't do it! In my experience the regressions are temporary and things go back to normal after a couple of weeks.

My little boy is 1 now and I don't really rock him anymore as I don't need to, for his 1 nap a day I sit with him in my arms and he falls asleep then I put him down. At bedtime he has his bottle then falls asleep in my arms with his dummy in and again I put him down asleep. I have no intention to stop doing this.. he sleeps from 7-7 and has a decent 2 hour nap in the day too. It's what works for us and naturally his sleep has got better as he's got older.. just because I hold him and he has his dummy when he falls asleep doesn't mean he wakes in the night needing it again.. he puts himself back to sleep. I was so worried when he was a few months old that I was making a rod for my own back with what I was reading online regarding sleep training and sleep crutches etc. I say just keep giving your baby what she needs and take things as they come! And enjoy it Smile

Selinna · 17/07/2022 22:03

SnackSizeRaisin · 17/07/2022 21:54

People generally only sleep train when they are desperate. People who don't get desperate like to think they are morally superior because they didn't need to sleep train, when actually it is more that their child slept better, they are able to cope with less sleep themselves, have more family support, dont work, or some other reason.
Whatever you end up doing, know that sleep training is there as an option if lack of sleep is causing you serious problems. And don't judge people who do it.

I do agree with this. I think it is a problem then though, when people say these things like 'You have to teach your child this vital skill of self soothing' (as if that was possible and the child didn't start to self soothe in their own time when developmentally able to) or 'Youre making a rod for your own back' (not true at all, things naturally evolve over time) or 'Youre creating all these bad habits' (suggesting they can then never be changed anymore, which isn't true at all). All of these statements conversely shame or intimidate those who do not want to sleep train into thinking they ought to. That's not right either

Selinna · 17/07/2022 21:58

Topgub · 17/07/2022 15:06

@Selinna

Lullabies and sitting next to them are an intervention

What I meant was that I didn't make the decision or put any effort into stopping feeding to sleep. It just naturally ran its course. When DC no longer fell asleep while feeding, the logical next step to me was that I still stayed with them, just without feeding. I didn't think to myself 'From now on I'll get them to stop feeding to sleep and instead I'll sing a lullaby' - I just always naturally did whatever worked and was least effort for me. Then at some point they started to go to sleep by themselves entirely.

The point was that in my experience it just naturally develops towards more independent sleep, no matter how many bad habits and rods for my back I had made previously.

SnackSizeRaisin · 17/07/2022 21:54

People generally only sleep train when they are desperate. People who don't get desperate like to think they are morally superior because they didn't need to sleep train, when actually it is more that their child slept better, they are able to cope with less sleep themselves, have more family support, dont work, or some other reason.
Whatever you end up doing, know that sleep training is there as an option if lack of sleep is causing you serious problems. And don't judge people who do it.

pimlicoanna · 17/07/2022 21:53

@ShirleyPhallus that's people imposing something on to my post. It's literally got nothing to do with what I said. Of course babies cry. It's how you respond to it that I commented on. People who sleep train always get overly defensive- I know why. Grin I'm off to enjoy my evening cheers Wine

ShirleyPhallus · 17/07/2022 21:47

pimlicoanna · 17/07/2022 21:42

@luxxlisbon I'm not sitting poised over them all day and night. But as soon as they cry I get them and comfort them. And guess what. They stop crying

Yeah that’s not what people are responding to and asking

You said:
”Why would you want to teach your baby to stop crying because they've given up all hope of you coming in to them. I think it sucks”

My question and that of the PP is - do you think sleep trained babies never cry even during the day then as they think you’ll never come for them?

It has nothing to do with your own children - do you think sleep trained babies will never cry again?

Topgub · 17/07/2022 21:45

@pimlicoanna

It seems to be you who is missing the point.

You weren't asked about your kids

pimlicoanna · 17/07/2022 21:42

@luxxlisbon I'm not sitting poised over them all day and night. But as soon as they cry I get them and comfort them. And guess what. They stop crying

pimlicoanna · 17/07/2022 21:40

@luxxlisbon .you are missing the point. They stop as soon as I PICK THEM UP.