Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not sleep train my baby?

157 replies

MD1803 · 16/07/2022 21:06

So, the internet is full of advice how to sleep train your baby.

Are there many / any people out there who never bothered and just allowed things to happen (and how did that go)?

My DD is 4 months old (in two days). We are now about two weeks in into the 4 month sleep regression. In general, it takes fair amount of rocking to get her fall asleep for her naps or at bedtime. I never put her down drowsy but awake. In fact I always wait about 20mins when she is normally in deep sleep and doesn’t wake up once I put her in her cot.

From about 2 months old until the regression started she would sleep from 9:00 and later 8:00pm to first wake up around 3:00 / 4:00 am.

Since the regression I started to take her to bed with me after her midnight / 1:00am wake up. Frankly I get better sleep that way. I never took her to bed with me before.

I’m thinking she will just naturally develop sleeping habits where she will get over the regression and eventually learn how to fall asleep on her own.

Am I being delusional?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bumpsadaisie · 25/09/2022 17:52

I didn't sleep train either of mine.

They're 13 and 11 now and go to sleep fine!

I would say that each of them were between 2 and 3 years old at the point when they they'd go to bed at 1930 and wake at 0700, pretty reliably. It was linked too to when they had their big girl/boy bed and we ditched the cot. Plus when they were at nursery a few sessions a week so were very stimulated and tired.

But even tho they didn't sleep through reliably until they were 2.5 to 3 yrs, their sleep was not all that bad before then either. Just more that they might wake up and need resettling, a few nights a week.

There were bursts of sleep misery. Dd at around 12 months seemed to be wide awake between 2 and 4 in the morning! She just used to come in my bed and I would desperately put in the night garden on. Eventually she'd drop off again. I wouldn't be asleep but I used to think well at least you are resting and lying flat 🤣 this prob am went only 3-4 weeks but felt like forever.

DS had a grim few weeks at around 18mths when molars were coming through and I was trying to stop feeding him at night.

Again it probably didn't last all that long. Ur it felt like it did.

They've been great about sleeping for many years and we haven't had any issues.

Thistleinthenight · 25/09/2022 17:34

I think just do what you want. No need for a performance. I sleep trained eventually, but it doesn't suit everyone.

Mangogogogo · 25/09/2022 17:31

I went with the flow on everything with my children including sleep.

dd didn’t sleep through til 6 up and ds 2 yo so take that how you will 🤣

Wouldloveanother · 25/09/2022 17:28

It all just reads a bit smug and like you weren’t really asking for help, you just wanted to put down mums who do sleep train. But okay.

MD1803 · 25/09/2022 17:22

Wouldloveanother · 25/09/2022 14:14

Or maybe it’s just because she’s a little older.

@Wouldloveanother I believe you are referring to my update post. To make it clear, if people feel that any form of sleep training is right for them and they are happy with their choices I personally think no-one is to judge them.Everyone’s circumstance and baby is different.

But I think that’s exactly the point. She is getting better at sleeping because she is older. So there was no need to rush to push something too early, when perhaps the baby isn’t actually ready. No need to worry about bad habits as they naturally get there as they get older.

I was coming as someone who didn’t see for my personal circumstance how avoiding any of the bad habits would benefit me or my baby at 4 months but given this is my first and all that is found on the internet I was confused if by not doing something more interventional she will NEVER learn to fall back to sleep during the night on her own.

OP posts:
MD1803 · 25/09/2022 16:49

@MissHavershamReturns thank you 😊

OP posts:
Onceuponatimethen · 25/09/2022 15:52

Op I’m so pleased you are feeling happier. So much to be said for going with your gut

Onceuponatimethen · 25/09/2022 15:51

@Wouldloveanother I didn’t drive when exhausted when I had newborns

Wouldloveanother · 25/09/2022 14:46

Rowen32 · 25/09/2022 14:40

I fed to sleep, rocked to sleep, ssshed to sleep, held to sleep, sang to sleep with no issues - f all this rod and crutch for your back. They need to feel safe enough to go to sleep so make sleep a safe space - you won't regret anything you do from love.

Until you’re so exhausted you fall asleep at the wheel. Safety first.

Rowen32 · 25/09/2022 14:40

MD1803 · 17/07/2022 17:54

Very well put.

I fed to sleep, rocked to sleep, ssshed to sleep, held to sleep, sang to sleep with no issues - f all this rod and crutch for your back. They need to feel safe enough to go to sleep so make sleep a safe space - you won't regret anything you do from love.

User14379 · 25/09/2022 14:18

I use the term baby loosely he is two atm

User14379 · 25/09/2022 14:16

I really regret not doing mine. It is absolutely exhausting where as my friends who did do sleep training are able to enjoy their life again. I am in a black hole atm with a baby that absolutely can’t soothe themselves to sleep

roarfeckingroarr · 25/09/2022 14:15

Never sleep trained mine. He started sleeping through in his cot at around 14 months.

Wouldloveanother · 25/09/2022 14:14

Or maybe it’s just because she’s a little older.

MD1803 · 25/09/2022 14:10

Update on my post should other people wondering about the same thing come across it.
After a few weeks of taking my baby to bed with me after the second then first wake up she became impossible to put her to bed at bedtime. She would wake up immediately after I put her down. However, she would stay asleep if I put her down in the bed with me next to her for a moment.

Then one night she woke up and turned on her tummy. She was like that for a while with her eyes open and then just went to sleep without any intervention from me.

I also stopped having to rock her to sleep at bedtime. She is bottle fed and then breast fed and then rolls on the bed for a while with me next to her. Only very rarely she won’t settle and I need to rock her to help her fall asleep but then once she sleeps in my arms she actually starts wriggling and crying in sleep but settles as soon as I put her down.

Now she sleeps in her cot next to the bed (she falls asleep in my bed and I move her in her cot once I go to sleep) and I wake up when she wakes up in the night. There is a lot of tossing and bushing but she just goes back to sleep on her own, unless she is hungry or did a dirty nappy.

She still needs a lot of help at nap times and bedtime is still with help (I lie next to her and she takes the breast as well as she keeps turning on her tummy with her head moving side to side) but it did feel like just by following her lead and reacting to her / trying to work out what her resistance / fussiness at bedtime was caused by she is naturally slowly developing new habits. So I now do feel confident that just by tuning into her needs and adjusting slowly as she is capable she will become an independent sleeper. It does actually feel like creating those bad habits such as rocking to sleep and taking her to bed with me was beneficial as we both got better sleep during the regression period.

She is now just over 6 months.
Btw I also use the huckleberry app and the sweet spot is rather accurate.

OP posts:
MD1803 · 18/07/2022 16:09

LookAtThatCritter · 18/07/2022 15:50

Not in the UK! No maternity leave, so returning to work isn't a choice. I think MD1803 is right, I guess different people see sleep training as different things. Sleep training at 2 weeks isn't about sleeping throughout the whole night, it's just about routine management and getting the baby to fall asleep by themselves or in a certain set of circumstances. To some extent, I think the majority of people sleep train but don't think of it that way. It's only when you get into the extinction and ferber methods that it becomes an obvious training and not everyone is comfortable with doing those.

Can you take one more week as holiday or unpaid leave (if you can afford it) or something to have at least one other week off? I’m assuming this is your first one.

I’m in the UK but didn’t qualify for statutory maternity pay either as I got pregnant before starting my job. Originally I was going to go back after the mandatory two weeks at home but then I thought try to extend it and I used my holiday pay for part of the 8 weeks, the rest was the minimum Matt allowance paid by the government.

Everyone’s birth is different but I thought I was really lucky I ended up taking a bit more time (albeit taking a financial hit) as I didn’t appreciate the recovery your body needs to go through post delivery.

OP posts:
MrsJBaptiste · 18/07/2022 16:02

I didn't sleep train as early as 4 months but did do it at 8 months which worked after 3 nights. I'd much rather a few nights of crying and whimpering than disrupted nights for years. A colleague still get woken a couple of times a night by her three year old - ridiculous!

LookAtThatCritter · 18/07/2022 15:50

Not in the UK! No maternity leave, so returning to work isn't a choice. I think MD1803 is right, I guess different people see sleep training as different things. Sleep training at 2 weeks isn't about sleeping throughout the whole night, it's just about routine management and getting the baby to fall asleep by themselves or in a certain set of circumstances. To some extent, I think the majority of people sleep train but don't think of it that way. It's only when you get into the extinction and ferber methods that it becomes an obvious training and not everyone is comfortable with doing those.

MD1803 · 18/07/2022 15:04

MiniMoosey · 18/07/2022 14:38

How do you sleep train a baby that needs feeding every 3 hours though?

Obviously I can’t speak for @LookAtThatCritter but this probably comes back to the question what do we mean by sleep training.

We in the first two weeks (when my husband took paternity leave) just went with the flow. Had baby with us in the room watching the TV until we went to sleep (baby sleeping on us or in the cot).

When my husband went to work and I had to do for 6 weeks the whole night and whole day I got strict about 9:00pm being the bedtime. E.g. nappy change, feed (wake baby up from the nap and feed if necessary), lights out and quite (and I went to sleep at 9:00 as well). The evening become more predictable that way and the wake up times during the night as well. I wouldn’t call that sleep training, more routine management…. though.

OP posts:
MiniMoosey · 18/07/2022 14:38

LookAtThatCritter · 18/07/2022 11:48

I’ll be starting sleep training around 2 weeks. But I’m also back at work a week after baby is born so I need sleep to function

How do you sleep train a baby that needs feeding every 3 hours though?

MD1803 · 18/07/2022 12:47

LookAtThatCritter · 18/07/2022 11:48

I’ll be starting sleep training around 2 weeks. But I’m also back at work a week after baby is born so I need sleep to function

Oh, wow. That’s tough. Are you in the UK, I believe here you actually only can go back to work 2 weeks after the baby was born at the earliest? I don’t know if going back to work after one week is your choice or you are ‘forced’ but if it’s the latter maybe worth looking into? Even one extra week in terms of recovery post birth will be very useful.

I went back to work after 8 weeks but until she is 6 months I can work 5 days a week from home. My husband is on shared parental leave so he takes over early in the morning and I have a nap before starting work.

Somehow it worked out well, and neither of us are sleep deprived (at the moment) and so far we were not forced to do any intervention.

We thought we would need to, mainly my husband. I wasn’t against it but I couldn’t see how would we stop her from waking up at night if she needs feeding (in the early days) Then literally as I I was to start work again at the 8 weeks she started sleeping from 9:00pm till first wake up at 3:00am (we are mix feeding from birth as I had issues with breast feeding and milk supply).

Lot of luck to you and your baby what ever you end up doing.

OP posts:
LookAtThatCritter · 18/07/2022 11:48

I’ll be starting sleep training around 2 weeks. But I’m also back at work a week after baby is born so I need sleep to function

Selinna · 18/07/2022 11:20

Otherwise they will never get there

See, I think this is exactly the kind of lie that sleep consultants spread to essentially scare parents into sleep training. I almost started to believe too that I would be doing my DC a disservice by not doing this to them! Ridiculous. I was just in a vulnerable and anxiously place.

OP, they will naturally get there in their own time. Like they also start to be interested in solid foods in their own time and learn to crawl and walk and talk in their own time. Your baby's sleep will naturally change over time, sometimes it will be easier, sometimes harder (for you I mean), but over time it will naturally develop towards longer and more independent sleep stretches. Please don't let these harmful discourses intimidate you or scare you into doing something to your baby that you didn't really want to do.

ReeseWitherfork · 18/07/2022 09:46

@MD1803 your current setup sounds exactly like mine. First feed back in cot, second feed stays in bed. And if this was my first, I too would be panicking that I needed to make a change before it became a bad habit that was hard to break. I wish I’d not spent so long of my firsts’ time as a baby panicking about such things. But alas, I think every first time mum has to go through it.

Kids eventually sleep through the night. But the question is… did they do that on their own or at some point did there have to be some strict intervention? I reckon the first will happen in almost every scenario, but the second happens if the parent hits a wall where they need to intervene (and fair enough if they do). So if your current set up works, keep at it. Enjoy those early morning cuddles (before they can roll about and kick you in the head).

MD1803 · 18/07/2022 09:23

I didn’t realise that this can be such a polarising issue.

In general I imagine what is on the internet is well meaning but I think it is such a fine balance about how to intervene and when, specific to each individual’s situation and each baby.

What I took out of it all, and hence was worried that I’m doing things wrong, was that we must start encouraging the baby to fall asleep in the cot on their own and to teach them how to self sooth in the night. Otherwise they will never get there.

At the moment, now that she started waking more regularly in the night, it works for us that I offer her breast, she does go immediately back to sleep (although I do need to hold her again for a while otherwise she wakes up if I put her down too early). I do that once and after second waking I do the same but keep her in bed with me as it is less interruption for me and her. I can just offer her the breast in the bed and we both go back to sleep relatively quickly. Before I put her down for the night there is always some element of rocking or bottle / breastfeeding to sleep.

So in my mind that works well at the moment, but to keep repeating myself, reading advice and views on the internet and also some advice and views here, one is led to believe that by doing this I’m creating problems.

Albeit it’s only anecdotal, but it sounds like there are people out there who did a similar thing and didn’t create a problem for themselves, so that is reassuring.

Equally, I believe people shouldn’t be judged if they try out different methods relevant to their circumstances. The only concern I would have if someone ends up doing something where it’s ill-advised for their specific situation, but are led to believe it is the right thing and that they should persist with it.

OP posts: