Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher and student hit

160 replies

Sixpencefaux · 16/07/2022 21:00

Has anybody seen the footage from a Leeds secondary school where a student attacks another student. When the teacher steps in, the student then repeatedly punched the teacher in the face. It really is shocking.

OP posts:
slowquickstep · 17/07/2022 15:29

sst1234 · 16/07/2022 21:58

I’m sure there will be a million and excuses why it’s ‘understandable’ for the pupil to do this. The usual ones being disadvantaged background, SEN, some kind of mental health issue. I mean never the mind the teacher, who simply comes to work to teach but has to manage feral kids behaviour.

How dare children be disciplined and how dare their parents be held to account for their childrens behaviour. Everyone’s a victim nowadays, except the real victims.

Well said

MissyB1 · 17/07/2022 15:20

I have just left my job as a TA, one of the reasons was the expectation that children are just allowed to physically attack staff and if they do it must be the staff member’s fault. When one of my colleagues was left covered in bite marks and bruises after one attack, she was told by the head that perhaps she should repeat her de escalation training 😡
I won’t be going back to work in a school again.

GCHeretic · 17/07/2022 15:19

girlmom21 · 17/07/2022 15:15

@GCHeretic I initially wrote 'reasonable' then thought they shouldn't have to think about what they're doing before they try to defend themselves. When I said necessary I meant they should be allowed to defend themselves or others in any way necessary - ie the necessary force may not normally be deemed as reasonable force, if that makes sense

Yes, I agree with you, it’s just splitting hairs really.

I think any pupil who’s violent should be excluded the first time that it happens, to reduce as far as possible risk to staff and other pupils.

If a teacher ends up seriously hurting a child who was in the process off attacking someone they should suffer no consequences.

MmeMeursault · 17/07/2022 15:18

I had to physically intervene to break up a fight between two hefty Yr 11s in the dinner queue once....on the day Ofsted was in. I sustained bruises and had to go on and teach (and was observed) straight afterwards.

It's not an uncommon experience, sadly.

girlmom21 · 17/07/2022 15:15

@GCHeretic I initially wrote 'reasonable' then thought they shouldn't have to think about what they're doing before they try to defend themselves. When I said necessary I meant they should be allowed to defend themselves or others in any way necessary - ie the necessary force may not normally be deemed as reasonable force, if that makes sense

GCHeretic · 17/07/2022 15:14

DogsAndGin · 17/07/2022 15:09

I’m 5 months pregnant. You think I should physically intervene if my 11 year olds get into a fight? Of course no teacher should have to get physically involved - the kids are bigger than us! There are no male adults in our school.

Yes, if a child is on the ground being beaten I think that you should.

If you are the sort of person who will just watch as someone dies that then you shouldn’t be employed in teaching.

GCHeretic · 17/07/2022 15:12

girlmom21 · 17/07/2022 15:08

There are instances where teachers should be allowed to use the necessary force to defend themselves. This is one of them.

I’d remove the word “necessary” from that. If the safest way to intervene is to crack the back of their head with a chair then needs must.

HeleenaHandcart · 17/07/2022 15:10

As an ex teacher it’s still scary even if it’s a primary child or if there’s un met SEN. I once had an 8 yr old go for me from behind when I wasn’t aware they were in a classroom I walked in to. I was left with significant bruising to my ribs, back and a swollen upper ear. It got to me mentally quite a bit. Even a 6 yr old with scissors can be hard to deal with when you are trying not to actually hurt them back (unlike you would with adults).
I think I was teaching 10-15 years before I was offered restraint/ de-escalation training.
In high schools I’ve had just accidental blows defending children that have winded me too hard to get up and carry. A colleague was hit in the face with an air gun purely for fun during a lesson.
Im so much less jumpy and more confident 5 years post leaving teaching and being expected to have a magic wand to prevent harm when ever other professional and parent can’t manage either. One boy I had for an entire year, had to physically intervene for regularly was in an incident where the police got involved. The two officers called for back up when he used a chair against them in a corridor. Whilst I really felt for him, he had difficulties, I was very pissed off id been expected to manage him alone as a female 2/3 of their body weights all year.

DogsAndGin · 17/07/2022 15:09

GCHeretic · 17/07/2022 15:05

No, no adult should stand by if a child is being assaulted.

I’m 5 months pregnant. You think I should physically intervene if my 11 year olds get into a fight? Of course no teacher should have to get physically involved - the kids are bigger than us! There are no male adults in our school.

girlmom21 · 17/07/2022 15:08

There are instances where teachers should be allowed to use the necessary force to defend themselves. This is one of them.

DogsAndGin · 17/07/2022 15:07

Florenz · 17/07/2022 01:51

Maybe it was the students first offence but I doubt it. "Inclusion" has a lot to answer for. Schools would be better off taking a "one strike and your out approach". There's no reason to put teachers and other students lives at risk on the one in a million chance that a violent psychopathic kid suddenly reforms.

Absolutely! We were told last week to give detentions for XYZ behaviour, but to alter the punishment after consideration of SEN or pastoral triggers. Every single person has something going on which could trigger them! It’s ludicrous.

We have children in our school who are violent every single day. It’s only when they get to KS2, and they’re big enough to do serious damage, that anyone realises what a huge problem we have on our hands.

GCHeretic · 17/07/2022 15:05

ConsuelaHammock · 17/07/2022 14:21

Fuck me! No teacher should have to get involved in that. Let them fight to the death!

No, no adult should stand by if a child is being assaulted.

ScreamingInfidelities · 17/07/2022 15:04

CanaryShoulderedThorn · 17/07/2022 14:38

My (huge, rugby playing) DS got into trouble at school for retaliating against the class bully. School repeatedly said it was six of one and half a dozen of the other.
Yeah right.
Until the day that the bully started to beat up a pregnant female teacher in front of the class and it was DS who dragged him off, whilst another teacher who could have helped, fled.
The teacher was off for 6 months whilst DS was expected back at school the next day, even though he had experienced months of incidents from this lad, who was and still is a total thug. He is now in prison for stabbing a woman whilst our DS is a nurse.

Your DS is a good lad ❤️

sunshnesall · 17/07/2022 15:00

ConsuelaHammock · 17/07/2022 14:21

Fuck me! No teacher should have to get involved in that. Let them fight to the death!

They weren't fighting. A child was being physically attacked and not fighting back. Any normal human being would jump in to defend a child being punched. If your child was being attacked you would want some one to do the same for them.

seven201 · 17/07/2022 14:39

In my old school I physically got between two massive year 11 boys as one of them was choking the other and I thought he might kill him. It was terrifying. I'm only a small woman and was mid 20s. Luckily they didn't go for me in any way. It was down the dead end of a long corridor with no other staff about. One of the leadership had had her arm broken trying to break up a fight too. I left.

CanaryShoulderedThorn · 17/07/2022 14:38

My (huge, rugby playing) DS got into trouble at school for retaliating against the class bully. School repeatedly said it was six of one and half a dozen of the other.
Yeah right.
Until the day that the bully started to beat up a pregnant female teacher in front of the class and it was DS who dragged him off, whilst another teacher who could have helped, fled.
The teacher was off for 6 months whilst DS was expected back at school the next day, even though he had experienced months of incidents from this lad, who was and still is a total thug. He is now in prison for stabbing a woman whilst our DS is a nurse.

ConsuelaHammock · 17/07/2022 14:29

I wouldn’t put myself in between two fighting teenagers! I hope the kid gets a criminal record for assault.

jetadore · 17/07/2022 14:25

ConsuelaHammock · 17/07/2022 14:21

Fuck me! No teacher should have to get involved in that. Let them fight to the death!

Lol yeh, look forward to outrage over a vid of the teacher standing by watching while one kid’s getting whaled on. Literally damned if they do damned if they don’t.

ConsuelaHammock · 17/07/2022 14:21

Fuck me! No teacher should have to get involved in that. Let them fight to the death!

Threetulips · 17/07/2022 11:26

Or there are special units that are almost too late for some kids.

Jellycatspyjamas · 17/07/2022 09:46

Inclusion" has a lot to answer for.

I agree with this to some extent, the drive to mainstream pupils and the utter lack of specialist provision for kids with mild to moderate additional support needs means kids are continuously put in learning environments not suitable for them. And teachers end up trying to support kids who just can’t cope with the school environment and who end up withdrawing, lashing out or running.

My DD has complex needs, she just about functions in primary school because the school make adjustments for her but she goes to high school next year. She’s right on the cusp of the criteria for specialist provision - if there’s not space for her she’ll be placed in a mainstream school where she will struggle to cope.

Its not the schools fault, they need to accept the kids placed there, it’s not the teachers fault, they can’t accommodate all
of her needs, but it’s not her fault either. When it all inevitably goes wrong though there will be blame all round depending on perspective. The blame actually lies with whoever decided to reduce specialist provision.

Threetulips · 17/07/2022 09:22

Apparently it is the staffs fault for not de-escalating situations

Or it’s your fault for not anticipating the flying chair would catch you on the head as you didn’t duck quick enough.

Threetulips · 17/07/2022 09:20

There’s a huge difference between a parent working with the school and a parent of a child who clearly has no self control, often like the parent or if not, the parent is struggling with the same thing at home.

And there should be more support for teachers who face this everyday and then find the child hasn’t so much as a exclusion, because being sent home is seen as the ‘worst option’ for the child and they are considered safer in school.

And there’s a lack of parents making complaints that would help build a case for the child to get help.

rongon · 17/07/2022 09:18

. In nicer schools it doesn't happen often at all, but in many it happens often and in a hefty chunk it'll happen weekly or so.

I teach in a nice, outstanding primary school in a very middle class area with a supportive SLT. It is a weekly occurrence in our school. Mostly children with additional needs attacking staff. Apparently it is the staffs fault for not de-escalating situations.

Mumofsend · 17/07/2022 09:09

There's a difference between a horrible attack like this, where the child absolutely should never step foot back in the school again and a much much younger child struggling to adapt to school and lashing out.

My now 7.5year old (Y2) had a miserable first 2 years of school. She has multiple diagnosises and two years of covid hit schooling. We had a few physical incidents where she very clearly had zero clue what had just happened after, let alone any control during. Her teacher described it as "she just isn't there anymore". A lot of work closely with the school and she hasn't had a single incident this entire school year other than a push of a child who pinched her first.

There is a clear difference between that sort of situation and the one in the video and it should never be about making a child untouchable. Children like my DD shouldn't have been slung out like some in this thread have suggested so to some extent there needs to be protection against that but when it's like the child in the video they clearly need a different setting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread