Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher and student hit

160 replies

Sixpencefaux · 16/07/2022 21:00

Has anybody seen the footage from a Leeds secondary school where a student attacks another student. When the teacher steps in, the student then repeatedly punched the teacher in the face. It really is shocking.

OP posts:
woodhill · 18/07/2022 10:52

Or any other dcs obviously

woodhill · 18/07/2022 10:50

Perhaps they need to bring borstals back

The current approach isn't working

Why should adults be hurt by these dc

Morph22010 · 18/07/2022 09:54

Purplepeoniesdroppingpetals · 18/07/2022 09:41

I ended up on the floor with an injured arm trying to separate two teens (one of whom was trying to strangle the other). Wasn’t the worst I’ve seen either. Not many consequences for them; not even an ‘are you ok?’ for me. When a student, high on something, nearly shut my face in a door as I was trying to eject him, I got asked after a half term if I’d have him back in my class.

I don’t get how the kids aren’t excluded for stuff like this. I’ve got a child with asd and when he was in mainstream primary he had ehcp with full time 1-1 (in practise he didn’t get the 1-1 all the time) but he was excluded loads of times for far less incidents like running out of the classroom without permission for example which whilst tough at the time ultimately did us a favour as it was all evidence of school not being able to meet needs and he’s now in a specialist since year 4. The specialist is asd specific so does alot of work on managing emotions, social skills etc. He still struggles with emotions but they can recognise when he needs a break to calm down so send him to walk round the field for example. Ultimately they want him to recognise himself and to give himself a break to calm down, ultimately this is going to help him more in life than keeping him in a primary school where he couldn’t manage in the name of inclusion

saraclara · 18/07/2022 09:44

I've broken up several fights between teenaged pupils. We're told not to intervene, but how can you not? These were lads with emotional and behavioural issues in a specialist school, and they had no 'off button'. I honestly thought that in one case one of them was going to be killed. I don't believe anyone could just stand by and watch while one repeatedly bashed the other's head against the playground tarmac.

Fortunately in each case my intervention helped. The time that I fell trying to do so, stopped the fight fastest, as the lads genuinely liked me and were worried that I was hurt.

De-escalation really shouldn't be written off though. It absolutely can work. But it's far harder to achieve in a mainstream classroom.

I also don't think people realise how much damage a five year old with no off button can do, either. My late job was with primary children in another special school, and one very disturbed five year old (who was really lovely much of the time) put one of my TAs in hospital, and I was black and blue for most of the year that I taught him.

Purplepeoniesdroppingpetals · 18/07/2022 09:41

I ended up on the floor with an injured arm trying to separate two teens (one of whom was trying to strangle the other). Wasn’t the worst I’ve seen either. Not many consequences for them; not even an ‘are you ok?’ for me. When a student, high on something, nearly shut my face in a door as I was trying to eject him, I got asked after a half term if I’d have him back in my class.

sandgrown · 18/07/2022 09:40

My son’s high school was not in a particularly bad area but they had security guards who responded to incidents and supervised exclusion.

NewNamePrivacyneeded · 18/07/2022 09:36

@CanaryShoulderedThorn

You have a wonderful son. The thug he dragged off the teacher is where he should be now.

NewNamePrivacyneeded · 18/07/2022 09:34

It's quite sick. The poor child was repeatedly hit and then the teacher intervened and was repeatedly punched in the face, calls for help and the bully hits the child around the head again.

Vile individual, slap on the wrist but eventually this type of bully will end up doing some serious damage and go to prison - how many people does he have to assault in the process though.

angstridden2 · 18/07/2022 09:18

I decided to retire when a child kicked and shattered the glass door when he walked out of my small group (primary).My Head asked what I had done to,provoke him.

TheFallenMadonna · 18/07/2022 09:01

They not only have a right to an education, but also to try to put in place some interventions that will put them on a different path. Because ultimately, as another poster said, those behaviours will just move with them into their family lives and into wider society if not addressed. That's why we need the joined up thinking around alternative provision as part of the wider school system. And post 16, where it falls off a cliff.

TheFallenMadonna · 18/07/2022 08:58

I'm also in a PRU and while there is a level of aggression from some, actual violence is fairly uncommon.

CustardCreamsAndMintTea · 18/07/2022 08:47

Icedbannoffee · 17/07/2022 15:36

I wouldn't have intervened when pregnant either. If you think that makes me a crap teacher then that's up to you, I couldn't care less.

Also, as a single mum teacher with 3 young kids of my own, I can't afford to be seriously injured by fighting teens, so I won't get involved physically if I can avoid it. There is nobody to take over care of my own children if I am seriously hurt.

I am an excellent teacher and regularly go over and above. Its interesting that parents think we shouldn't be teachers if we are not prepared to put ourselves at physical risk.

SeekingBalance · 18/07/2022 08:38

I work in early years, we are seeing this more and more due to lack of family support and sen provision pre primary in our area...do day dream about working in tesco for more money and less bruises.

maddy68 · 18/07/2022 08:30

Sadly my life as a UK teacher came to an end when I was dealing with many incidents such as these. (I haven't seen this particular footage ). On top of that all the teacher bashing in the press and social media really got to me people honestly have no idea what it's like to teaching in England right now.

paddingtonstares · 18/07/2022 08:28

DD lasted one and a half terms as a TA, after being punched and kicked by a 7 year old every day. No consequences for the child whatsoever. If one teacher said he lost playtime another teacher would just let him go rather than deal with the tantrum.

The classroom was frequently evacuated to protect the kids on the class. DD got told off for blocking his punch on one occasion as his immediately started looking for a new job.
This was a school in a nice area boasting a 'kind and caring' ethos. Regardless of age, no one should ever have to put up with attacked.

A 7 year old with no consequences will become a 17 year old who thinks he can do what he wants and then a 27 year old beating up his partner. Then we wonder why men as a class are violent.

indecisivewoman81 · 18/07/2022 08:28

I work in a pupil referral unit (where permanently excluded students go).

We have excessive training on de -escalating violent situations, we can on occasions use "necessary force" to remove a student and we always break up fights that often lead to the staff being hurt

The violence I see on a weekly/sometimes daily basis is terrifying!

The problem is, these students have a right to education. And in a PRU type setting there are a lot of the same sort of students displaying the same sort of violent, impulsive and aggressive behaviour

EinsteinaGogo · 18/07/2022 08:27

CanaryShoulderedThorn · 17/07/2022 14:38

My (huge, rugby playing) DS got into trouble at school for retaliating against the class bully. School repeatedly said it was six of one and half a dozen of the other.
Yeah right.
Until the day that the bully started to beat up a pregnant female teacher in front of the class and it was DS who dragged him off, whilst another teacher who could have helped, fled.
The teacher was off for 6 months whilst DS was expected back at school the next day, even though he had experienced months of incidents from this lad, who was and still is a total thug. He is now in prison for stabbing a woman whilst our DS is a nurse.

How bloody awful, @CanaryShoulderedThorn

Your DS sounds wonderful. I bet that teacher was very, very grateful he was there x

ItsSnowJokes · 18/07/2022 08:21

whataloadabullocks · 17/07/2022 16:36

I suspect fights are very unlikely in grammar schools.
The issue is our educational system doesn't cater to non-academic pupils. We're trying to push square pegs into round holes, it won't work, and bored, disillusioned kids is going to result in fisty cuffs.
I'm not saying the behaviour is acceptable, it's obviously never okay, but governments educational minister really needs to look at what's going on in state schools....of course most MPs don't give a fig coz their kids go to private schools.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

I used to work in a grammar school. They still have fights just like other schools. We still had drug issues, we still had students bringing knives into school. It is not only an academic issue.

Legrandsophie · 18/07/2022 08:06

Morph22010 · 18/07/2022 08:02

Children with Sen can be permanently excluded, ive known children be excluded for far far less than what you’ve described

Yes, but not immediately. He has had some fixed term exclusions but parents are fighting us every inch of the way to keep him here. The amount of evidence you need for a permanent exclusion for a kid with a full EHCP is huge. Parents are currently saying we haven’t adjusted enough for his needs.

I’m sure they are somewhere on the SEN boards getting all sorts of legal advice about how to make us keep him.

Legrandsophie · 18/07/2022 08:04

@ParsleySageRosemary

Sone of those kids are a foot taller than me and can swipe me aside as if I were made of air.

The sad truth is that there are is an increasing number of kids (especially boys) who are badly socialised (allowed to spend almost every waking hour at home online) or have complex emotional issues that have gone unaddressed during lockdown.

When we just shoved them all back into school this all boiled over in the form of increasingly violent fights and toxic online behaviour. What we really need to happen is that part of the money for catch up tutoring needs to be spent on group and individual counselling sessions for these kids and their families. There isn’t enough space in the PRUs and not enough staff in main school to deal with them.

Morph22010 · 18/07/2022 08:02

Legrandsophie · 18/07/2022 07:55

YANBU- it is actually terrifying sometimes at the moment. I was being stalked around school by a pupil who had a grudge against me and I knew to be carrying a knife. Luckily he’s been moved on but I still worry that he’s going to come back to find me.

We also have to do lockdown drills because a kid threatened to come in to shoot up the school and we know he has access to his dad’s firearms.

A child recently removed broken the leg of another child, the jaw of a second child and the fingers of a third child. We cannot expel him because he has significant SEN needs and parents are refusing a managed move.

Children with Sen can be permanently excluded, ive known children be excluded for far far less than what you’ve described

Legrandsophie · 18/07/2022 07:55

YANBU- it is actually terrifying sometimes at the moment. I was being stalked around school by a pupil who had a grudge against me and I knew to be carrying a knife. Luckily he’s been moved on but I still worry that he’s going to come back to find me.

We also have to do lockdown drills because a kid threatened to come in to shoot up the school and we know he has access to his dad’s firearms.

A child recently removed broken the leg of another child, the jaw of a second child and the fingers of a third child. We cannot expel him because he has significant SEN needs and parents are refusing a managed move.

Morph22010 · 18/07/2022 07:44

Florenz · 17/07/2022 01:51

Maybe it was the students first offence but I doubt it. "Inclusion" has a lot to answer for. Schools would be better off taking a "one strike and your out approach". There's no reason to put teachers and other students lives at risk on the one in a million chance that a violent psychopathic kid suddenly reforms.

Inclusion in schools isn’t inclusion though, it’s doing things on the cheap dressed up as being inclusion. True inclusion would require significant investment. My child has Sen and unless you’ve been though it I don’t think people have any comprehension about how hard it is to get any level of support (I didn’t before Ds)

Threetulips · 18/07/2022 07:33

Whoops … sorry

dontyoubother · 17/07/2022 22:52

I'm a teacher and have been seriously assaulted at work more than once. In my experience teachers are very poorly supported. After the worst incident I was advised that if I wanted anything to be done about it I'd need to go to the police. I told my boss I was considering it and she told me not to then didn't speak to me for weeks, even ignoring me in tears one day telling her the incident was having an impact on my mental health.

Swipe left for the next trending thread