Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher and student hit

160 replies

Sixpencefaux · 16/07/2022 21:00

Has anybody seen the footage from a Leeds secondary school where a student attacks another student. When the teacher steps in, the student then repeatedly punched the teacher in the face. It really is shocking.

OP posts:
JudgeJ · 18/07/2022 16:14

I once had to grab a 15 years old girl from behind to prevent her from attacking another girl with a pencil sharpener blade, I held her arms from behind her until another teacher came along. I had a badly pulled shoulder and an internal enquiry to see if I had, according to the breeder of the girl, used too much force! She could see a nice little claim on the horizon no doubt.

MikkiMouse1969 · 18/07/2022 13:33

I'm so sorry that you were physically injured while simply doing your job; and that you were not supported by your employer. Having to buy yourself a laptop so that you can continue to work is ridiculous. Hopefully you can claim the purchase back as employment-related at tax time!
It also sounds like you have great instincts, considering that that same young person allegedly committed a stabbing not long after the incident with you!

woodhill · 18/07/2022 13:29

MikkiMouse1969 · 18/07/2022 13:25

Sadly this also occurs here in Australia. More often than not, the children's parents verbally attack the teachers for "daring to speak"* *to the children about their poor choices and bad behaviour!
I really feel for all of the teachers who really try their best to deal with disrespectful children and their ungrateful & disrespectful parents!!

It's ridiculous isn't it.

Doesn't get the dc anywhere in life

MikkiMouse1969 · 18/07/2022 13:25

Sadly this also occurs here in Australia. More often than not, the children's parents verbally attack the teachers for "daring to speak"* *to the children about their poor choices and bad behaviour!
I really feel for all of the teachers who really try their best to deal with disrespectful children and their ungrateful & disrespectful parents!!

tttigress · 18/07/2022 13:17

Why don't unions put an emphasis on this?

If I were a teacher I would prefer a robust response against bad behaviour from a school rather than having a pay rise.

sparky1038474 · 18/07/2022 13:01

@GCHeretic
'No, it’s all about you isn’t it.'

Nope, it's about her unborn child. And quite rightly.

Smokealarmwakeup · 18/07/2022 13:00

Smokealarmwakeup · 18/07/2022 13:00

I once got pushed over by a student that had been working perfectly 30 seconds before. All of my side was bruised and my school laptop was smashed as a result. A couple of kids screamed and one cried as it happened out of shock. He was put in isolation for an hour. Nobody contacted home (I didn’t because I assumed exclusion which is above me). As a result he didn’t even get a detention.

Two days later I asked where he would be for my lesson, SLT couldn’t understand why he wouldn’t be in my lesson, I’m a food teacher so have knives around etc. I was told if I refused to teach him it would count as strike action on my part and I wouldn’t be paid.

At my next PMR meeting I was given the target to build good relationships with students and increase contact with home when needed, I didn’t move up the pay scale because of this. I also had to buy myself a laptop to complete work on because school wasn’t willing to replace the one that I apparently broke.

He was arrested less than 6 months later for an unprovoked stabbing.

Just to add, I’m 5 foot, he was at least 6 foot.

Smokealarmwakeup · 18/07/2022 13:00

I once got pushed over by a student that had been working perfectly 30 seconds before. All of my side was bruised and my school laptop was smashed as a result. A couple of kids screamed and one cried as it happened out of shock. He was put in isolation for an hour. Nobody contacted home (I didn’t because I assumed exclusion which is above me). As a result he didn’t even get a detention.

Two days later I asked where he would be for my lesson, SLT couldn’t understand why he wouldn’t be in my lesson, I’m a food teacher so have knives around etc. I was told if I refused to teach him it would count as strike action on my part and I wouldn’t be paid.

At my next PMR meeting I was given the target to build good relationships with students and increase contact with home when needed, I didn’t move up the pay scale because of this. I also had to buy myself a laptop to complete work on because school wasn’t willing to replace the one that I apparently broke.

He was arrested less than 6 months later for an unprovoked stabbing.

Spikeyball · 18/07/2022 12:58

My friends child wasn't as severe as that. She wanted special school but was told because her child could speak, he couldn't have it. He was permanently excluded in yr1 and spent a year out of education until an imminent tribunal hearing and the prospect of spending £100k a year at a specialist independent meant the LA magically found a place in one of their own schools.
That's the reality of parents being able to choose special school.

Spikeyball · 18/07/2022 12:49

"If I were any of those things then I expect my parents would send me to a specialist school, not try to include me in mainstream education. Children who do have that level of disability are rare."

You may find that your parents would be told that there aren't enough special school places and you will be fine in mainstream. If your parents wanted a special school place they would have to join thousands of others going to tribunal to secure a suitable place for their child.

TheMoth · 18/07/2022 12:47

Legrandsophie · 18/07/2022 08:06

Yes, but not immediately. He has had some fixed term exclusions but parents are fighting us every inch of the way to keep him here. The amount of evidence you need for a permanent exclusion for a kid with a full EHCP is huge. Parents are currently saying we haven’t adjusted enough for his needs.

I’m sure they are somewhere on the SEN boards getting all sorts of legal advice about how to make us keep him.

Yy to this. It's shit all round. Shit for the kid with needs; shit for the kids whose learning is constantly interrupted; shit for the random kids drawn into their orbit; shit for the school, because other kids see all this and start behaving the same way.

And surely, surely, if a kid has so many needs that a mainstream school isn't capable of dealing, then they shouldn't be in Ms.

Mumofsend · 18/07/2022 12:39

Morph22010 · 18/07/2022 12:16

That’s what my sons 1-1 was for too, but school would use them to assist other kids saying he was fine at that time, then when he’d kick off they’d exclude. I could have fought it but decided it was going to be a constant battle and never any better than mediocre so decided to put my energy into fighting for specialist instead

And that is exactly the issue. The school should have been perfectly able to do that, they don't want to. Child behaves as a result of it and gets excluded. If child had been supported in the first place then incident prevented.

woodhill · 18/07/2022 12:35

This is the problem

Not enough staff to meet the needs of EHCP dc at times.

Saragossa · 18/07/2022 12:34

Spikeyball · 18/07/2022 12:00

"As it is there are far too many excuses for children. SEN, autism, whatever. In my (probably unpopular) view, none of these conditions is a reason for violence towards other people. I get fed up of hearing 'they can't help it."

Imagine you were non verbal, couldn't communicate your needs, couldn't understand ordinary speech, didn't understand what was going on around you and found noise and movement around you so distressing you bit yourself. I would you would behave towards other people.

If I were any of those things then I expect my parents would send me to a specialist school, not try to include me in mainstream education. Children who do have that level of disability are rare.

I'm talking about the children who disrupt the learning of others because their parents say they have ODD and they can't help being violent towards other people.

Morph22010 · 18/07/2022 12:16

Mumofsend · 18/07/2022 11:28

That is what they should have been doing in the mainstream too. You don't need a specialist setting when a child has 1-1 to recognise for them when they need a break and gradually teach them to recognise it themselves. That is a school not wanting to, not being unable to. My daughter's mainstream with 1-1 and this is literally what their job is.

That’s what my sons 1-1 was for too, but school would use them to assist other kids saying he was fine at that time, then when he’d kick off they’d exclude. I could have fought it but decided it was going to be a constant battle and never any better than mediocre so decided to put my energy into fighting for specialist instead

LaChatte · 18/07/2022 12:12

I've been injured twice when intervening in situations like this, once was a dislocated jaw and the other was a nasty bruise on the side of my face. I've also had to pin a child up against a wall to prevent them from hurting another child. In all three cases the offending child was expelled. I have no idea what they all went on to become though. Feels very much like we were just passing the problem on for another school to deal with rather than actually help the kids/families.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/07/2022 12:11

They should be able to refuse to teach a class until the violent pupil is removed

I sometimes wonder if this isn't the only thing which would make a difference, though it would need every teacher to be on the same page

Obviously it's not ideal, not least because it disadvantages the other pupils, but then constant disruption's hardly good for their education either

Spikeyball · 18/07/2022 12:00

"As it is there are far too many excuses for children. SEN, autism, whatever. In my (probably unpopular) view, none of these conditions is a reason for violence towards other people. I get fed up of hearing 'they can't help it."

Imagine you were non verbal, couldn't communicate your needs, couldn't understand ordinary speech, didn't understand what was going on around you and found noise and movement around you so distressing you bit yourself. I would you would behave towards other people.

Namenic · 18/07/2022 11:38

I’d rather my child was in a zero tolerance school.

teachers forced to manage violent pupils should sue the school as this is the only way things will improve. They should be able to refuse to teach a class until the violent pupil is removed. Hospital staff do not have to tolerate violent behaviour. Neither should staff or pupils.

Mumofsend · 18/07/2022 11:28

Morph22010 · 18/07/2022 09:54

I don’t get how the kids aren’t excluded for stuff like this. I’ve got a child with asd and when he was in mainstream primary he had ehcp with full time 1-1 (in practise he didn’t get the 1-1 all the time) but he was excluded loads of times for far less incidents like running out of the classroom without permission for example which whilst tough at the time ultimately did us a favour as it was all evidence of school not being able to meet needs and he’s now in a specialist since year 4. The specialist is asd specific so does alot of work on managing emotions, social skills etc. He still struggles with emotions but they can recognise when he needs a break to calm down so send him to walk round the field for example. Ultimately they want him to recognise himself and to give himself a break to calm down, ultimately this is going to help him more in life than keeping him in a primary school where he couldn’t manage in the name of inclusion

That is what they should have been doing in the mainstream too. You don't need a specialist setting when a child has 1-1 to recognise for them when they need a break and gradually teach them to recognise it themselves. That is a school not wanting to, not being unable to. My daughter's mainstream with 1-1 and this is literally what their job is.

Saragossa · 18/07/2022 11:25

TheFallenMadonna · 17/07/2022 16:12

Exclude them to where?

Just exclude them. If they are violent and disruptive then they should forfeit their education. It then becomes the parents' problem. If more children learned that they would be excluded permanently for acts of aggression against other pupils or staff then perhaps behaviour might improve.

As it is there are far too many excuses for children. SEN, autism, whatever. In my (probably unpopular) view, none of these conditions is a reason for violence towards other people. I get fed up of hearing 'they can't help it.'

There are children in other parts of the world who walk miles to access a school.

Education in the UK should not be seen as an entitlement, but a privilege.

As long as universal education for all is seen as a right, and as long as specialist schools for children with SEN are underfunded, nothing will change.

lizziesiddal79 · 18/07/2022 11:17

The answer to the question of who reduced specialist provision in the name of inclusion is David Blunkett c.2000

KnittingNeedles · 18/07/2022 11:08

Not a teacher but I have three teenagers at a very good state school in Scotland. There have been violence incidents for a couple of children through primary and secondary. Latest incident was just before summer when a 14 year old was swinging a hammer round his head in d&t after being repeatedly told not to , it slipped or he threw it depending on who’s telling the story, and knocked the teacher out cold.

Scotland doesn’t really have expulsion, they seem to just shunt problem children between schools in a “we’ll take Jimmy and Bob if you have Mike and Charlie” sort of way.

i’m a very average 5 ft 5 tall and my 14 year old towers over me, and he’s heavy and strong, physically restraining these large “children” is impossible.

woodhill · 18/07/2022 10:55

Absolutely

Morph22010 · 18/07/2022 10:53

woodhill · 18/07/2022 10:50

Perhaps they need to bring borstals back

The current approach isn't working

Why should adults be hurt by these dc

Lack of funding, cheaper to keep in mainstream under the guise of it being inclusion

Swipe left for the next trending thread